July 26, 2022

A team approach to reducing instrumentation, costs during the age of COVID-19

By: Jennifer Lubell
Share

ORs rebounding from the financial impact of COVID-19 are looking for ways to reduce expenses. With rising costs coming from all angles of the economy, some have adopted systemwide processes to reduce, streamline, and improve surgical instrumentation sets.

Two major health systems, the Cleveland Clinic and Thomas Jefferson University Hospital in Center City, Philadelphia, found a way to engage their staff, examine trays and instruments at the ground level, and implement changes to reduce tray load. Representatives for both health systems reported their successes at the 2021 OR Manager conference (ORMC 2021) and provided updates to OR Manager for this article.

Rebecca Urban, MEd

Even before COVID-19 was a household name, Cleveland Clinic in 2019 set its tray standardization strategy into motion, implementing campus-wide changes across its 11 affiliated hospitals. The strategy impacted its ORs, research and education departments, family health centers, capital allocation, block strategy, and supply chain. The result: a new strategy that led to $5 million in cost avoidances.

“We were already done with the project by the time COVID started. During the pandemic, we were able to reap the sustainability of it,” says Rebecca Urban, MEd, former project manager for the duration of the project. Urban is currently department administrator for the GYN subspecialty in the Women’s Health Institute at Cleveland Clinic.

 

Sources of waste, duplication in trays

Both health systems had been struggling with instrumentation duplication and waste issues stemming in part from poor communication among surgeons and staff.

Instrumentation build-up can happen over time, increasing the size of the tray and strain on the OR and the sterile processing department (SPD), says Urban. Some instruments are added in for “just in case” circumstances. New surgeons may also have a list of instruments they want added to the trays.

Thomas Jefferson, which includes 18 hospitals and 50+ outpatient and urgent care locations, had no guidance on tray build and maintenance. Surgeon requests to add items to trays were being processed without any checks and balances, and there was no monitoring of instrument utilization or technicians to track underutilized instruments.

Erin Kini, MSN, RN, CNOR

Instrument processing is expensive, amounting to $58 a tray, says Erin Kini, MSN, RN, CNOR, former case carts/project manager SPCC at Thomas Jefferson. Kini currently works at Medical-Legal Consulting, LLC in East Norriton, Pennsylvania.

The hospital was also grappling with waste issues. Some unopened trays were not being used, and there were reports of tray assembly errors. Some trays were overweight and difficult to carry. Excessive instrumentation leads to risk of bioburden and wet load, impacts processing time and costs, and impairs the ability to meet demand, intraoperative setup, and count time, Kini explained during her presentation at ORMC 2021.

Surgeons had limited free time for input, and it was difficult to schedule in-person meetings.

 

Pandemic a catalyst for change

An example of a standardized general instrumentation set at Cleveland Clinic. Used with permission.

Shutdown of elective surgeries and added social distancing restrictions inspired the team at Thomas Jefferson to create innovative solutions to reduce costs.

Prior to COVID-19, Monica Young, MBA, RN, DNP, FACHE, CNOR, CASC, NEA-BC, Thomas Jefferson’s vice president of perioperative services and a member of OR Manager’s editorial board, had enlisted Kini to investigate problems related to instrumentation tray costs and production. Digital collaboration is not usually the normal protocol at hospitals. “We had Microsoft Teams in place for a while, but did not use it that much,” says Kini.

The pandemic set in motion an optimal setting for a virtual platform: people working from home; decreased revenue; underutilized nurses and surgeons; technicians available for virtual projects; and trays available for evaluation. As elective case volumes dropped, a need arose to rapidly deploy nurses to alternative assignments with a return on investment.

“We thought: there’s certainly things we can do with this time,” says Kini. An idea arose to create a virtual communication platform to invite feedback on instruments. Kini saw this as a useful tool to leverage surgeons. “I thought I could pop open a tray, take photos, talk to physician staff individually, find out what they’re not using in these trays, and make a list,” she says.

Kini would upload photos and invite surgeons through virtual meeting rooms to meet with different teams. There was a channel space for each service. Surgeons could view pictures of trays online and provide feedback in the chat section. A messaging option facilitated quick responses and dialogue, and feedback was integrated into recommendations to gain surgeon buy-in for instrumentation reduction.

The hospital also collected data through polls and surveys to form recommendations on instrumentation reduction, allowing for easy sharing of results through the platform. All teams were regularly informed of the reduction project’s progress and successes as well as projected savings.

Kini and her team also appointed surgeon “champions” to assist physicians who were not that “tech savvy” and hesitant to jump on the virtual platform. The surgeon leaders walked things through with them, encouraging them to take part in conversations and offer opinions.

Through these changes, Thomas Jefferson estimated it could save about $190,000 annually, based on per instrument processing, labor, and volume costs. As of 2021, Thomas Jefferson managed to remove 463 instruments across 42 tray types, reducing on average 11.9 instruments per tray.

Looking at things closer, a previous spine setup required four trays at an annual cost of $157,000. The new spine setup only uses two trays at an annual cost of $119,000.

Thomas Jefferson is looking at other creative ways to achieve reduction, such as tray combination and slimmer alternative trays. There have also been discussions to develop a review committee and formal process, says Kini.

 

The standardization challenge

At Cleveland Clinic the challenge was: could teams standardize surgical sets of instruments by procedure across the enterprise? The goals were multi-fold: to decrease variability, eliminate waste; reprocess 25–30% of non-utilized surgical instruments per date; and store underutilized sets, improving quality control.

Similar to Thomas Jefferson, Cleveland Clinic used a teams approach, bringing nurses, physicians, surgical technicians, and SPD together to determine what should be in their trays and how to standardize their sets, says Urban. These staff utilize these trays every day, so they are the best experts to provide feedback, she adds.

Each institute at Cleveland Clinic evaluated their trays as a group. Urban’s team worked with them to determine how to reduce instrumentation on trays. The goal was to standardize trays for specific procedures, such as chronic ear and major/minors, as well as reducing waste in trays. The teams approach was all about reconciliation—to choose and keep instruments used in the majority of cases, and group other instruments in the “as needed” pile.

In a creative move, the clinic developed an “instrument depot” for housing instruments removed from trays. “This helped us reduce expenses by not having to purchase instruments,” explains Urban. Cleveland Clinic also standardized to a primary vendor to reduce the variances of instruments in its trays.

 

$5 million in savings

Cleveland Clinic managed to save $5.1 million under this strategy. To date, the health system has removed more than 51,000 instruments and 672 unique trays, reducing tray size by 30%, reported Urban and Carol Pehotsky, DNP, RN, CPAN, ACNS-BC, NEA-BC, associate chief nursing officer, surgical services at Cleveland Clinic, at ORMC 2021.

The changes elicited positive feedback across staff. One lead surgical technician said the project streamlined efficiency and productivity. OR staff had fewer instruments to open, and SPD had fewer instruments to manage.

“It’s a win for patients and caregivers,” says an OR nurse on the team who asked to stay anonymous. “It decreased instruments used and risk of retained foreign bodies.”

A case study involving gynecology dilation and curettage (D&C) illustrates the returns. In a change that spanned 13 regional hospitals and 14 ambulatory surgery centers, the teams standardized to one surgical instrument set per enterprise. This standardized 13 variations of D&C sets from 13 unique trays comprising 27–56 surgical instruments at 17 different locations to a standard set with 27 instruments. Overall, this strategy removed 1,594 instruments, reducing variation in care.

Standardizing instruments at each site made things easier during the pandemic, when physicians moved from one location to another. “They could transition on a dime for those services because each site had the same trays. We could best utilize our OR footprint,” says Urban.

The main goal was to standardize trays, not save money, but that is what happened, adds Urban. “Clinical institutes will say they want to grow a location, grow service lines. And they will invest millions of dollars in equipment.” By pressing “pause” on this impulse and having those internal conversations, the clinic was able to move instruments from one location to another instead of spending money on new equipment.

Urban says the changes have made her own job easier. “In my current role, I’m always trying to move my surgeons around and recruit new surgeons. So, I have an appreciation of understanding what barriers are in play and the importance of building relationships back to the OR from the clinical institutes.”

Urban says she is in constant communication with OR directors and nursing managers regarding new recruitment, making sure her team knows what instrumentation trays are being used and what is available.

This is what prevents project derailment or scope creep, she continues. “If clinical teams aren’t communicating with their new physicians on instruments, those trays just become heavier over the years.”

—Jennifer Lubell is a freelance medical and health policy writer based in Rockville, Maryland


Breaking down the Silos: An ASC success story

Faced with delayed transport times and a lack of communication among its ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) and clinics, Ann & Robert H. Lurie Children’s Hospital in Chicago decided it was time for a makeover of its supply chain.

W. Zeh Wellington, DNP, RN, NE-BC

The main hospital, located in downtown Chicago, faced traffic constraints as it tried to supply its suburban locations with instrumentation trays and other equipment needs, says W. Zeh Wellington, DNP, RN, NE-BC, director of procedural care and surgical services. Sometimes the turnaround took as much as 8 hours.

Adopting a model used by the airline industry, Lurie Children’s created a streamlined approach that resulted in safer surgeries, quicker turnaround of trays, and a happier staff. “We wanted to ensure that the ambulatory sites were not in silos—that they could rely on each other instead of the main unit to supply all their needs,” explains Wellington.

 

Boosting education

Lurie Children’s began its journey looking at what the ambulatory sites needed, what types of cases they worked on, and what types of trays they relied on daily to see how all the sites could work as one cohesive team.

“It was so important for us to make sure ASCs were safely staffed—that they had the tools to do their job and the capability to reprocess their equipment if an instrument was dropped or a tray wasn’t sterile,” says Wellington.

To accomplish this, all personnel, including those in the sterile processing department (SPD), received training at the main hospital site. “Our educator, who looks after all the sites, made sure we were doing all of the competencies and that everyone was well trained, not only for trays but for processing scopes, to make sure everything was done safely and correctly,” says Wellington.

Lurie Children’s educator continues to do rounding at every SPD processing site to ensure that instructions for use, competencies, and other requirements are up to date.

 

Streamlining transport pathways

Charles Williams, CSPDT

Lurie Children’s leveraged this training toward a path of independence for its satellite sites. Instead of relying on the main hub for supplies, the health system adopted a model like the airline industry, which ensures a seamless transport between all sites. ASCs and clinics began communicating with each other to process and house trays. “We looked at travel times and zones to see how far these locations were from downtown,” says Charles Williams, CSPDT, Lurie Children’s manager of SPD. Previously, it took 8 hours to transport equipment from Lurie Children’s to a clinic in New Lenox, Illinois. Because New Lenox was located near one of Lurie Children’s ASCs in Westchester, it made more sense for the clinic to get its items from that ASC. “We made sure Westchester had all of the functions of the main hospital so they could support New Lenox instead of everything coming down to Lurie,” says Williams. Redirecting transport routes meant that surgeons could get what they needed much faster, whether it was a scope or a tray.

 

Savings achieved through efficiency

Revising transport routes cut down on travel costs and resulted in fewer equipment drop-offs, says Williams. Staff members at ambulatory sites added technicians to support the staff. By establishing these localized support systems, staff became more familiar with the instruments and other items transported between sites.

 

Reorganizing trays

Lurie Children’s also revised some of its trays to customize them for certain ambulatory sites. This involved the input of nurses, physicians, and SPD personnel. “A multidisciplinary team looked at all of our trays to ensure that they had all the equipment they needed in case they fell into a dangerous situation,” says Wellington. A new color-coding system made it easier to identify and prioritize trays. A tray with a red top for example signifies a tray that needs processing of certain instruments. “When we see a purple top, that’s a transplant, so we know those trays are a top priority,” says Williams.

 

Improving staff and patient morale

Surgeons seem much happier, now that they have readier access to the tools they need, says Wellington. “I believe that our patients and families can rest assured that they are receiving a very safe surgery with properly processed equipment in a timely fashion. There’s no canceling of cases or waiting because we’re waiting to transfer instruments to an outside ambulatory center.” The changes have also boosted the morale of SPD staff. “They’ve challenged themselves to learn, do more, and be responsible for trays and scopes. They’re keeping their skills up,” adds Wellington.

Lurie Children’s has worked hard to break down its silos with education and team meetings. “We want our ASCs to be successful, and we want every patient to have a safe surgery and experience. It took time, but I think we’re succeeding,” says Wellington.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat