May 14, 2015

Analytics: A powerful tool for OR process improvements

By: OR Manager
Share

Analytics is a buzzword in today’s healthcare world, but behind the buzz is a very real tool. If used appropriately, analytics can help OR managers achieve improvements in stubborn problems such as turnover time. But OR leaders must first understand analytics principles before applying them in their management practice.

Analytics as a tool

“Analytics is a discovery tool that allows you to access data and transform it into knowledge you can act on,” says Andi Dewes, BSN, RN, director of clinical solutions for Surgical Information Systems (SIS), Alpharetta, Georgia.

“It merges many related data points to tell a story about what’s going on in your business,” adds Amy Smith, MSN, RN, NEA-BC, president of Accelerate Healthcare Management, Martinsville, New Jersey. Smith is a former vice president of perioperative services at Robert Wood Johnson (RWJ) University Hospital, New Brunswick, New Jersey, where she used SIS software programs.

That story can be challenging for OR managers to write. “A lot of managers get frustrated because they don’t have good tools for analytics—tools that give them the data points they need,” Smith says.

Dewes adds that managers may not use tools to their full extent because they think they are more rooted in information technology (IT).

However, newer tools are more user-friendly to OR managers. “You no longer have to find someone to write a special report when you want information,” Dewes says. “It’s a new day.”

Most analytics software has built-in capabilities to produce easy-to-read graphs and charts that visually tell the tale.

“At a quick glance you know what you’re looking at,” Smith says.

Such tools meet the desire of managers to be able to visualize data; a survey in MIT Sloan Management Review found managers expected that “the ability to visualize data differently will be the most valuable technique in 2 years.” Well-developed analytics tools also make it easy for users to adjust parameters as progress points toward the goal are met.

Analytics software may be integrated into the overall documentation system for the organization. If not, OR managers can work with their IT departments to purchase a third-party add-on.

Smith says the more user-friendly tools help OR managers “own” the analytics and quickly obtain information.

“Instead of relying on IT to generate reports, you have the ability to have data in near real time,” she says.

Once the tool is in place, how is it best used? Dewes and Smith say that analytics should be embedded into projects.


 

Keeping focused

Amy Smith, MSN, RN, NEA-BC, president of Accelerate Healthcare Management, Martinsville, New Jersey, says using the format below helps a project team keep focused on the goal, rather than the metrics.

“Instead of starting with the metrics and working in reverse to the goal, the idea is to start with the goal, develop objectives, and then decide what factors or drivers are interfering with the ability to meet the goal,” she says. “Then you know what information or metrics need to be captured.”

The slide tool can be adjusted as progress toward goals is made. All images courtesy of Surgical Information Systems. Used with permission.The guage provides a quick visual of progress made.This chart shows the percentage of overtime for total OR productive hours. Note the downward trend.

1


 

Creating a project charter

While at RWJ, Smith used the organization’s structured method for defining a project—problem statement, objective (including goals and metrics), and project scope (sidebar at bottom). “That was our charter for the project,” she says. “It’s a great management tool.”

Project scope is particularly important when navigating the project. “When you head down the path and hit three options, having a defined scope helps you decide which decision is appropriate,” Smith explains.

Project leaders report every 2 weeks on the charter, including what was accomplished, what wasn’t accomplished, and what additional resources might be needed.

Here’s how a project charter and analytics helped the team at RWJ address common problems OR managers face—on-time first case starts, overtime, and OR utilization—as part of an overall goal to improve operational efficiency.

 

Culture change

“We didn’t have robust operational practices to support building a culture of accountability,” Smith says, so the first step was to change the culture. The team revamped the daily 9 am huddles already in place so that specific issues were assigned to individuals who reported back the next day on progress.

“It helped people understand that the expectation was follow-through,” Smith says. “It also opened up the lines of communication and created transparency.” Management and clinical staff shared hurdles to solving problems. Metrics also were reviewed weekly during three existing meetings (directors planning, OR staff, and service line), with recurring themes addressed in regularly occurring meetings involving stakeholders on staff.

 

Late case starts

For late case starts, the problem statement was, “Late cases are running at about 37%, which is over the target of around 20%.” The goal was to return to the target, and the metrics were to measure total on-time starts weekly. The project scope consisted of:

• Basic process information—reasons for case delays. Cases are considered late if the start time is 15 minutes or later than the scheduled start time.

• Key milestones—80% compliance with late-case documentation

• Constraints—number and type of add-on cases. All add-on cases were assigned an arbitrary time to be scheduled, which increased the number of late cases.

Smith chose two analytics tools to measure progress: a slide tool (see image above) and a gauge chart (see image above). “The slide tool allowed me to change late criteria as we made progress,” she says. “Once we hit our 15-minute initial definition of ‘late,’ I moved it to 10 minutes.”

The gauge chart, similar in look to a gas gauge, displayed the percentage of on-time case starts. This quick visual made it easy for surgeons and staff to see progress. “Red meant you’re in trouble, yellow meant you were making headway, and green meant you were doing a good job,” Smith says.

Although not all analytics software programs have these exact visuals, OR managers can use similar ones or even create their own visuals in their analytics or software programs.

Collecting reasons for delays proved challenging because staff nurses believed the initial codes didn’t capture all the reasons for delays. Smith and her leadership team worked with staff nurses to identify nearly 60 codes that were then added to the system. For example, reasons for anesthesia delays were categorized as:

• anesthesia delay—intraop

• anesthesia delay—postop

• anesthesia delay—preop

• anesthesia delay—unavailable

• anesthesia delay—holding

• patient risk—intubation

• patient risk—IV access

• patient risk—reintubation.

Other categories included delays related to scheduling, preoperative area, surgeon, turnover, transport, equipment, housekeeping, personnel, and central sterile processing.

Despite the additional categories, staff nurses often still failed to document the reason for the delay. To correct the problem, missing documentation reports that showed the name of the circulator who failed to enter a reason were discussed in the daily huddle so individuals could be held accountable, Smith says.

As a result, documentation subsequently improved from 32% to 80%, which helped her to identify anesthesia delays as a significant issue. After that issue was addressed, on-time case starts improved from 75% to 85% over 8 months.

2

Overtime and room utilization

The problem statement for overtime was, “Overtime is currently averaging between 6% to 7% a month, resulting in higher than expected labor costs.” The goal was to reduce overtime to an average of 5%, and the metrics were to measure overtime by pay period and report a quarterly percentage. This was the project scope:

• In scope—review of case volume and staffing plan to determine where staffing does not meet case demand, resulting in the use of on-call/overtime

• Basic process information—staff needs have been matched to meet caseload demands

• Constraints—unpredictability of surgical volume (add-on and emergency) and staff scheduling changes protected by current union contract.

Smith says a challenge with this problem was trying to convert extensive—and not user-friendly—financial data into a format she could use to make decisions. SIS staff helped her create a dashboard to organize the data.

“It gave me productive hours by pay period and by job codes, and productive versus unproductive time,” Smith says. “I could even break it down to the level of job title.”

The data showed that although RN overtime was 40% of hours worked, clinical care technicians (CCTs), or OR assistants, accounted for nearly half (47%) of the overtime. Although the lower pay scale for CCTs meant RN overtime costs were still higher, it was something Smith needed to investigate.

She found that a monthly average of 25% to 30% of hours worked by CCTs was overtime and that this group had a high rate of leave of absences. Smith was able to hire two per-diem positions to remove this built-in overtime.

The task of tackling RN overtime took Smith down the road of investigating room utilization because, as she says, “My staffing plan has to mirror my case volume.”

She analyzed room use by hour of day, focusing particularly on 3 pm to 5 pm because of excessive on-call usage. Her analysis showed she needed 34 RNs during that time frame, but only 28 were normally scheduled.

Smith had been turning to on-call staff, who had to be paid a minimum of 4 hours, to fill the gap. “We looked into when staff were coming in and how we could better accommodate volume later in the day,” she says.

Because several rooms were still in use at 3 pm, she created new shifts of 9 am to 5 pm and 9 am to 7 pm.

Although initially Smith was concerned about whether staff would be willing to work those hours, she found they suited staff who wanted to be home to see their children off to school in the morning. She also rearranged staff schedules to provide more coverage during peak times and hired a few new staff members.

Smith also revised OR block and scheduling policies, which increased utilization by 7%. Improvement in staffing and efficiency meant that most add-cases didn’t have to be scheduled for the end of the day, when resources were lower.

“It built capacity in the OR so we could accommodate an increase in volume of 247 cases over 1 year, and we added an additional $3.5 million to the bottom line,” Smith says (sidebar, p 15).

Overtime decreased by $500,000 even as case volume increased.

This chart shows the percentage of overtime for total OR productive hours. Note the downward trend.

This chart shows the percentage of overtime for total OR productive hours. Note the downward trend.

Avoiding pitfalls

“Just because you have analytics doesn’t mean you’re going to be able to change your OR,” Smith says. Senior leadership support is essential.

“There needs to be an organizational commitment to using data to run your business,” she says. That commitment helped her have difficult conversations with surgeons, such as the need to change block time based on current utilization.

“The relationship between the two [OR manager and surgeon] is very important, too,” Smith says. “The data has to be perfect. Surgeons are scientists, so they will analyze and scrutinize where the data is coming from and how it’s calculated, particularly if the data doesn’t say what they want it to say.” OR managers need to ensure accuracy before meeting with the surgeon.

Failure to share data and project goals with staff is another possible pitfall to successfully applying analytics.

“Most staff want their environment to improve and their hospital to thrive,” Smith says. “You have to spend a lot of time communicating to staff, including sharing analytics reports and engaging staff.”

 

Sustaining change

Smith says her experience at RWJ showed her that good analytics tools are easy to learn, easy to use, and easy for merging data from other sources. “I got the data I wanted in a usable format. That allowed me to make the business decisions I needed to make for my OR, and we were able to make real sustainable changes,” she says.

“OR management is hard work, but discipline and execution—combined with today’s analytics tools—can get you the data you need,” Dewes notes. ✥

Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc., Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.

 

Reference

LaValle S, Lesser E, Shockley R, et al. Big data, analytics and the path from insights to value. MIT Sloan Management Review. 2011; 52(2): 21-31.

 

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat