April 19, 2024

ASC staffing woes persist in era of increased surgical volume

The past 10 years of data from the OR Manager Salary/Career Survey reflects many challenges in the healthcare environment, particularly those associated with the COVID-19 pandemic. ASC leader respondents report that staffing difficulties have become particularly challenging.

For example, only 15% of respondents to the 2014 survey reported increased RN turnover in the past year. This percentage then ranged from 22% to 30% until the pandemic year of 2021, when it jumped to 49%. In the post-pandemic environment of 2023, the percentage remained high at 35%.

Staffing woes are not limited to RNs. The percentage of ASC leaders reporting an increase in open positions for surgical technologists (STs) compared to the previous 12 months was only 6% in 2014. Subsequently, the percentage generally trended upward until it reached a high of 39% in 2023.

Amid surging surgical volumes, these patterns are particularly troubling. In 2022 and 2023, 56% of respondents reported increased volume—the highest percentage of the survey years included in this article (2014-2023).

Here are additional trends, divided into categories. Note: The public health emergency for the pandemic was issued in March 2020 and ended in May 2023. Data collection for the annual survey typically ends in May.

 

Surgical volume

Question: In the past 12 months, has the volume of surgical procedures in your ASC increased, decreased, or remained about the same?

Comments: Most ASC leaders reported increased surgical volume in every year except 2019, 2020, and 2021. Note the surge in volume in the past 2 years. In 2023, only 16% of respondents reported volume stayed the same, the lowest figure of the decade.

 

Staffing levels

Question: Has the turnover rate for RNs and STs increased, decreased, or stayed the same over the past 12 months?

Comments: Turnover rates have been consistently higher for RNs than STs, although the gap between the two has varied. In 2014, the percentage of ASC leaders reporting an increased turnover rate was 15% for RNs and 6% for STs, a gap of 9 percentage points. In 2018, only two percentage points separated the two groups, but by the pandemic year of 2021, the gap was 24 points, dropping to 9 in 2022. The smallest difference (4 percentage points) between RNs and STs came in 2023. More significantly, 2023 marked the first time in the survey that more ASC leaders reported a higher percentage of increased turnover for STs compared to RNs (39% vs. 35%).

 

Question: Compared with 12 months ago, has the percentage of open positions for RNs and STs increased, decreased, or stayed the same?

Comments: Reported changes in the percentage of open positions for the past 12 months followed a similar trend for STs and RNs. The lowest percentages for an increase in open positions came in the first year of the survey (9% RNs, 6% STs). In subsequent years, the percentage ranged from 26% to 32% for RNs, before rising to 40% in 2020 and 50% in 2022. The percentage for STs ranged from 16% to 26% before hitting 28% in 2021 and 42% for 2022. In 2023, the figures were 39% for RNs and 43% for STs, the first time in the decade that STs surpassed RNs.

The percentage of ASC leaders reporting five or more currently open RN positions peaked at 13% in 2023. The percentage reporting five or more currently open ST positions was the highest in 2021 and 2023 (6%). The lowest percentage for RNs was 2% in 2018; for STs, it was zero in 2014.

 

Recruitment

Question: Has recruiting for RNs become easier, more difficult, or neither over the past 12 months?

Comments: Recruiting experienced RNs has remained consistently difficult for ASC leaders. The lowest percentage of respondents reporting that recruiting was more difficult in the past year came in 2014 and 2020, when half were struggling. The percentage of those reporting an easier time recruiting experienced RNs has never risen above 9%. Last year, 68% reported more difficult recruitment, the highest figure since 2017’s 67%.

 

Question: Has recruiting for STs become easier, more difficult, or neither over the past 12 months?

Comments: For many years, respondents found it more difficult to recruit RNs than STs. The 2023 survey showed the percentage climbing higher for STs for the first time, although the difference was only a single percentage point (69% vs 68%). The gap also narrowed to two points in 2020 (50% for RNs, 48% for STs). The largest gap came in 2015 (53% for RNs, 29% for STs, a difference of 24 points).

In recent years, percentages of respondents reporting increased recruiting difficulty have risen sharply, from 2021’s 39% to 58% in 2022 and 69% in 2023. The lowest percentages came early in the past decade: 33% in 2014 and 29% in 2015.

 

Compensation and benefits

Respondents were first asked in 2015 to report their salary by choosing from a list of categories. Since then, the most frequently chosen category has been either $100,000 to $119,999 (2015 to 2017 and 2021 to 2023) or $120,000 to $149,000 (2018 to 2020). The percentage of those earning $100,000 or more has consistently been in the 50s, spiking to 77% in 2023.

Since 2017 (the first year ranges were used for the compensation question), $120,000 to $149,999 has been the most popular category among ASC leaders. The exception was 2021, when the $100,000 to $119,999 category topped the list by one percentage point over $120,000 to $149,999.

As was the case for most workers, ASC leaders’ compensation suffered as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. From 2014 through 2021, respondents’ average raise was higher than the consumer price index for all urban consumers (CPI-U). That trend reversed in 2022, when the average raise was 4.2%, much lower than the 7% CPI-U. ASC leaders saw some improvement in 2023, but compensation still fell short of CPI-U (5% vs. 6.5%).

Responsibilities

In 2023, ASC leaders reported the highest number of employees supervised since 2017: 32 clinical and 8 nonclinical for a total of 40. After 27 in 2014, all other totals were in the 30s.

The number of ORs that ASC leaders manage has remained relatively unchanged, with most supervising two, three, or four.

Starting in 2018, ASC leaders were asked to provide their operating budgets by category. Each year since, most respondents did not know their center’s budget. Among those who did know, the budgets have trended slightly higher. For example, in 2019, only 9% had an operating budget of $10 million or more, compared to 17% in 2023. Conversely, 25% had a budget of $1.9 million or less in 2019, compared to 9% in 2023.

 

Job satisfaction

Since 2015, participants have been asked to rate satisfaction with their role, support from boss, top leadership, and total compensation on a scale of 1 to 5, with 1 being not at all satisfied and 5 being completely satisfied. When reporting the results, scores of 4 and 5 are consider favorable, while scores of 1 or 2 are considered unfavorable.

ASC leaders have consistently been most satisfied with their current role: The percentage of favorable ratings has ranged from a high of 83% in 2017 to a low of 70% in 2023. ASC leaders are much less satisfied with their total compensation. The percentage of responses deemed favorable has hovered in the mid- to upper-50s; the peak (in 2017) was only 60%.

Most respondents are satisfied with the support they receive from their boss. In 2022 and 2023, the percentage reporting favorable boss satisfaction scores reached a high of 70%, matching 2016’s results. Percentages of respondents reporting favorable scores for top leadership in an organization have consistently been lower than percentages reporting favorable boss support scores, with the former ranging from a low of 57% in 2021 to a high of 68% in 2016. In both 2022 and 2023, the percentage reporting favorable scores for top leadership support was 62%.

The favorable job satisfaction is reflected in the percentage of those planning to leave their employers within the next year. In 2021, when the question was first asked, 69% planned to stay (58% in 2022 and 62% in 2023). In 2022 and 2023, when the question was first asked, many respondents planned to stay with their current employer 5 years or more (55% in 2022, 50% in 2023). Those who planned to leave most commonly cited burnout as the reason (participants could choose more than one answer).

Another first with the 2021 survey was asking participants to choose what benefits they would like to add to those they already receive. In all 3 years, the top choices were financially related: profit sharing, bonus, and tuition reimbursement.

 

ASC leader profile

The average age of ASC leaders who responded to the survey has been fairly consistent in the 50s except for 2022, when it was 49. In 2023, the average age was 51 years, compared to 55 in 2014, the oldest average over the past decade. The highest (53 years) came in 2017 and the lowest (48 years) in 2022. In all instances, the average was higher than that for RNs in general; the 2022 National Nursing Workforce Survey reported a median age of 46 years.

In recent years, there has been a slight uptick in the percentage of ASC leaders with 5 years of experience or less. In 2023, a quarter of respondents fell into this category, compared to 21% in 2020. On the other side of the spectrum, 23% had at least 21 years of experience in 2023, compared to 34% in 2020.

 

In each of the past 10 years, most respondents worked for a physician-owned ASC. The percentages ranged from 36% in 2014 and 2017 to 48% in 2022; in 2023, it was 40%. The second most common setting for most years was joint venture, with hospital claiming second place in 2018 and 2020.

Over the past decade, more respondents have worked in a multispecialty rather than single specialty ASC, although the percentage of single specialty centers has increased in recent years (28% in 202, 32% in 2021, 41% in 2022, and 40% in 2023).

Ophthalmology has been the most common single specialty for most years, ranging from 31% to 40% of respondents. The exceptions came in 2015 and 2020, when orthopedics took the top spot. An outlier occurred in 2018, when gastroenterology was first.

The most common specialties in multispecialty ASCs have tended to be orthopedics, general surgery, and pain management, but the categories have changed somewhat over the years, making comparisons more difficult. Interestingly, 44% of 2014 respondents reported that the number of specialties they offered in the past 12 months had increased; by the time the question was dropped, the percentage was only 26% (2020).

Education preparation has remained stable over the past decade. Most ASC leaders report a baccalaureate in nursing as their highest level of education. The lowest percentage (22%) came in 2014. By 2021, the percentage had risen to 42% before dropping slightly to 34% in 2022 and 35% in 2023. The percentage of those with a master’s degree remains low; the highest percentage (in 2016) was only 19%. The highest percentage (21%) of those with an associate degree in nursing was in 2016, and the lowest was 16% in 2015 and 2016.

The past 10 years have brought little change in diversity. Since 2014, most (77% to 87%) of respondents have been female. Participants were asked their race or ethnicity starting in 2021. Most identified as White (88% in 2021, 84% in 2022, and 86% in 2023), with all other categories either 0 or in the single digits.

Data collection for OR Manager’s next annual survey is now open. Your participation will help in continuing to identify trends of interest to OR leaders. Results of the 2024 survey will be published in September and October.

 

—Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.

Reference

Smiley R A, Allgeyer R L, Shobo Y, et al. The 2022 national nursing workforce survey. J Nurs Reg. 2023;14(1):S1-S90.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat