Hospitals have long dominated the realms of infection control and antibiotic overuse. Ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs), which typically release patients the same day of a procedure, use antibiotics less frequently than other facilities, and most do not have an antimicrobial stewardship program. However, some ASC leaders and organizations are encouraging stewardship by adopting infection prevention awareness programs.
ASCs are usually the last to adopt new procedures in healthcare settings, says Beverly Kirchner, BSN, RN, CNOR, CASC, chief compliance officer at SurgeryDirect, LLC, in Highland Village, Texas. Hospitals had quality indicators (QI) for years before ASCs were required to adopt QIs as well, she notes.
The same was true for value-based purchasing with third-party payers, Kirchner adds. Now, ASC leaders are being told that they don’t have to comply with stewardship as long as they’re maintaining infection control at their facilities.
That isn’t good enough, Kirchner says. Her advice to ASCs is to invest in stewardship regardless of whether or not a federal or accrediting body tells them to do so.
ASCs are required to report surgical site infections (SSIs) to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s (CDC) National Healthcare Safety Network, and to some state websites. Although ASCs need to follow antibiotic protocols for prevention of SSIs, Kirchner says, “we do not have to send the patient home with a prescription for postop antibiotics.”
SSI rates in ASCs are generally low, but she notes, “we still hear of the outliers who do not follow infection control practices and therefore harm patients and make the news.”
Guidance has varied among the major national organizations. “We’ve gotten mixed messages on this topic,” notes Kirchner.
The Joint Commission, which issued a new antibiotic stewardship standard in January, says its provisions do not apply to ASCs or office-based surgery programs. For ambulatory facilities, the requirement applies only to those accredited centers that routinely use antibiotics, such as medical or dental services, episodic care, occupational/worksite health, urgent/immediate care, or convenient care.
But depending on who you talk to at the Joint Commission, the answer might be “yes” or “no” on ASC inclusion, Kirchner adds.
The Leapfrog Group, AORN, and the Association for Professionals in Infection Control and Epidemiology (APIC) see the merit of engaging ASCs in stewardship practices. AORN offers advice on usage of antimicrobials in its Guidelines for Perioperative Practice, whereas APIC supports ASC stewardship programs as an important infection control and prevention measure.
“APIC doesn’t specifically point out ASCs, but as of now, all healthcare entities are being addressed to manage the issue and set up programs,” Kirchner says.
Regardless of what the federal agencies, APIC, the Joint Commission, and other groups advise, ASCs should question the necessity of giving antibiotics to every patient they treat, Kirchner says. “When you read what the CDC says, you need to evaluate the patient and how the staff contribute to surgical site infections.”
For the past 20 years, the Leapfrog Group has been surveying hospitals on infection and other quality metrics. In 2019, it launched a similar survey for ASCs and hospital outpatient departments. Results showed that very few of the 300-plus ASCs had adopted an antimicrobial stewardship program (sidebar at right).
The survey includes the Health Services Advisory Group’s (HSAG) antimicrobial stewardship checklist program, which suggests steps ASCs can take to improve stewardship, says Erica Mobley, Leapfrog’s vice president of administration.
Andrews Institute Ambulatory Surgery Center in Gulf Breeze, Florida, an ASC that participated in the Leapfrog survey, has been using HSAG’s checklist as a guide. ASCs may not use antibiotics as frequently as hospitals do, but they still administer certain types, which usually include cefazolin, clindamycin, and vancomycin, says Barbara J. Holder, BSN, RN, CAPA, CAIP, the center’s QI/IC safety/regulatory officer. As part of its stewardship efforts, Andrews audits charts for each surgeon and type of surgery performed, as well as antibiotics administered during the preoperative, intraoperative, and postoperative phases. This provides the center with a baseline metric on antibiotic usage, she explains.
Holder says the facility has adopted more prudent antibiotic prescribing and infection control practices. As an example, hand surgeons order intravenous antibiotics (IV ATB) for some, but not all, procedures. Total joint surgeons are no longer ordering home health care with IV ATB administration.
Leapfrog also recommends 200 observed hand washings per hospital unit/ASC facility. At Andrews, every department has gotten on board with this recommendation. Each employee is responsible for observing three hand washings per month. Overall, “our employees’ adoption of this program has helped to improve our safety culture,” Holder says.
Engaging staffSurgeryDirect decided to engage its physicians and partnering pharmacies in conversations about the necessity of antibiotics before and after surgery. What were the criteria for doing so after an implant, for instance, or a procedure around the bone and joint? Delving deeper, they expanded their stewardship efforts to staff, educating them on the basics of infection prevention. Hand hygiene was the number one target, Kirchner says.
The facility already had a sound record on infection control; no wound infections have occurred in the past 3 years. This is a solid achievement for an institution that does some very high-risk procedures such as neurosurgery, deep brain stems, and generator packs (batteries connected to the stems in the brain), in addition to orthopedics and implants, Kirchner notes—adding that education on stewardship is needed nonetheless.
SurgeryDirect took other steps to strengthen its infection controls:
• reviewed policies and procedures on SSIs
• reviewed and incorporated CDC and APIC data on antimicrobial stewardship
• rewrote its infection control plan to include antibiotic stewardship.
“We’ve been working with our surgeons to develop education for them and our staff so they understand what it means to give antibiotics,” explains Kirchner. They must ask: Does this patient really need this antibiotic order? The general consensus is no, they don’t need it. Being treated in an ASC is very different than in a nursing home, for example, where risk of infection is much higher. A patient who goes home after an outpatient procedure and comes into contact with normal flora in the home may not need an antibiotic.
SurgeryDirect’s initiative began last fall, with a full rollout anticipated in the spring. “We’re not where we want to be yet,” Kirchner says. Physicians have insisted that the center complete its research and come back with recommendations based on patient health issues in the ASC.
“We need to analyze our sicker, higher-risk patients to see if they still need antibiotics following an implant, for example,” says Kirchner.
Patient education also factors into stewardship—they must learn the importance of presurgical skin preparation and postoperative practices such as hand washing vigilance. “There are a lot of pieces to put into place to change practices,” she says.
At Capital City Surgery Center, a multispecialty ASC in Raleigh, North Carolina, a systemwide quality improvement study led to changes in antimicrobial stewardship practices. In the third quarter of 2019, its management company, Compass Surgical Partners, did quality improvement (QI) benchmarking across nine centers in different states, looking at the timing of antibiotic administration, adequacy of choice of antibiotic, and dosage based on patient weight. Although antibiotic timing was at 99% compliance, “dosages across the board were incorrect at least 26% of the time,” says Jamie Ridout, MSN, MBA, RN, administrator at Capital City Surgery Center.
The challenge was choosing the right antibiotic with the right dose. The study was beneficial in that it “got us to examine our own practices, while the benchmarking across other ASCs allowed us to see where we were in relation to other centers,” Ridout says.
Armed with this information, Capital City began examining its surgical orders and total joint preoperative medication protocol. “We looked at CDC guidelines on antibiotic stewardship, and found that we had some opportunities to clarify specific antibiotic choices with respect to a patient’s weight,” says Ridout. The ASC took steps to ensure language consistency across the two order sets.
Essentially, all options were eliminated except for the correct antibiotic dosages and choices for certain patients. This way, the surgeon has no choice but to select the right method, she explains. “If a physician chooses the wrong dose based on weight, for example, we would immediately flag that.” Thus far, physicians are embracing these new changes.
“We have a very engaged medical staff that, for the most part, are supportive of practical changes,” Ridout says.
The facility’s pre- and postoperative supervisor and quality improvement coordinators have been proactive in driving these key changes, says Ridout, who tries to keep everyone informed via newsletters, regular staff meetings, and quarterly QI meetings. “People get accustomed to old order sets, so we try to keep staff informed, letting them know about the changes in forms and our rationale for the changes,” she says. As extra insurance, all staff are required to sign off on staff meeting minutes, “so that no one can say, ‘I never got this information.’”
Capital City is still in the early phases of changing its stewardship program. They planned to remeasure the outcomes data at end of the first quarter of 2020, to see if their performance improvement initiatives were effective, Ridout says.
External guidance aside, what ASCs do inside their facilities is what really matters, Kirchner believes. Administering antibiotics as a rote procedure is the easy way out, she says. “We need to look at what’s best for the patient.” ✥
–Jennifer Lubell is a healthcare writer based in Rockville, Maryland.
Health Services Advisory Group. Antimicrobial Stewardship Checklist For Ambulatory Surgery Centers (ASCs). https://www.hsag.com/contentassets/98d1e68f70bc4240832eb3545b6050f6/rbrndcdchsagaschecklistforascs.pdf.
Leapfrog Group. Same Day Surgery in the US: Findings of Two Inaugural Leapfrog Surveys. 2019. https://www.leapfroggroup.org/sites/default/files/Files/NationalReport_Final.pdf.
Joint Commission. R3 Report Issue 23: Antimicrobial Stewardship in Ambulatory Health Care. 2020. https://www.jointcommission.org/standards/r3-report/r3-report-issue-23-antimicrobial-stewardship-in-ambulatory-health-care/.