March 5, 2025

Capital funding crunch spurs creative hospital financing

By: Anne Wainscott-Sargent
Share

Health systems are fundamentally capital intensive. They are regulated; depend on highly educated, high-cost employees; and operate under complex reimbursement structures. Investing in new technologies and infrastructure upgrades is imperative to keeping up with the latest medical advances. But what happens when capital funds are insufficient or no longer available?

Stephen Spring

“For the last few years, it’s been pretty hard to make money or have positive margin even in larger hospital systems,” says Stephen Spring, director of finance at Massachusetts General Hospital.

The news is not all bad, Spring says. Leaders continue to find creative ways to finance capital expenditures. In fact, this was the subject of Spring’s presentation at the 2024 OR Manager Conference, where he explored the pros and cons of different financing options. A recent series of follow-up conversations with Spring and other sources provided fresh perspective on these ideas and capital investment challenges.

 

Funding challenges

Since the COVID-19 pandemic, the healthcare sector has faced rising interest rates and frequent supply chain disruptions. Meanwhile, hospitals could face significant federal funding cuts affecting Medicaid and state-directed payments this year, according to a recent report from Chief Healthcare Executive.

Greg Flicek

Given these realities, it is no surprise that costs are rising. “Hospitals are getting hit on multiple fronts,” says Greg Flicek, a consultant at Ascedient Healthcare Advisors, Chapel Hill, North Carolina, who works primarily with rural hospital systems. “The cost of fixed assets such as facilities and equipment has risen dramatically, making them much more expensive. On top of that, when hospitals need financing, they’re facing much steeper interest rates.”

In fact, CBRE data show construction costs have increased by about 35% between 2020 and 2023. Interest rates also have increased significantly. Compared to 2020, hospitals issuing bonds to fund construction receive $14–20 million less in usable funds for every $40 million in bonds issued. The net result? A new facility costing $40 million in 2020 effectively would cost between $68 and $79 million at 2023 rates, Flicek says.

Other stakeholders expressed similar views. “I don’t think I’ve ever seen the finance end of things in this market be so stressful; it’s the toughest budgetary environment I’ve witnessed in 30 years in the healthcare industry,” says Nunzio Leo, a senior district sales manager with medical device maker Medtronic. “I don’t know one finance person who says they’re doing great. Reimbursements are less, so they’re asking you to do more with less.”

Staff shortages compound the problem, particularly in the OR (sidebar, Staff shortages). “At the hospital level, if you don’t have enough nursing staff or enough materials people, it all ties into the capital,” Leo says. “Do I buy that capital piece of equipment, or do I hire two more OR techs?”

Meanwhile, medical technology is constantly changing, Spring says. And although ORs are capital intensive, the budget must spread across departments, including radiology, general care, pharmacy, and labs. “It’s just impossible to afford it all at the same time. We have to make priority decisions and decide where that capital is going.”


Staff shortages

Hospital staff shortages, especially in ORs, are well documented:

• A new study by the Mercer consultancy and its partner Lightcast projects a shortage of about 100,000 critical healthcare workers by 2028. The Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) forecasts a deficit of 78,610 full-time registered nurses (RNs) in 2025 alone.

• A 2024 integrative review of perioperative nursing shortages cited annual surveys from AORN, which found the percentage of vacancies of full-time perioperative nursing positions rose from 3.1% to 18% from 2013 to 2023.

• The annual OR Manager Salary/Career Survey reveals consistent staffing challenges from year to year. The most recent edition, 2024, showed slight improvements in some parameters, but these gains were often offset by other factors. For example, the percentage of respondents reporting an increase in open positions for STs fell slightly, but more than a third of respondents still reported high vacancies. Additionally, most respondents reported increased surgical volume.

References

Future of the US Healthcare Industry: Healthcare Labor Market Projections by 2028. Mercer. 2025.

Nurse Workforce Projections, 2020-2035. National Center for Health Workforce Analysis. November 2022.

Saver C. Survey: Staffing woes ease slightly, but challenges remain. OR Manager. 2024;40(9):1,12–15.

U.S. Real Estate Market Outlook 2023, Chapter 11: Construction Costs. CBRE. December 13, 2022.

Xie A, Duff J, Munday J. Perioperative Nursing Shortages: An Integrative Review of Their Impact, Causal Factors, and Mitigation Strategies. Journal of Nursing Management. August 19, 2024.


Financing options

From the latest imaging technology to robotic-assisted surgical systems and drills, pricey medical devices are always on surgeons’ wish lists. However, hospitals and health systems do not always have to buy the equipment outright, Spring says. Alternatives to purchasing can help modernize technology and facilities without breaking budgets.

The most common options, renting and leasing, require no capital and offer a set term and price, with no commitment to buy consumables if they are part of the capital purchase. “There are various durations on this—from 12 months to 48 months all the way up to 72 months. The longer the term, the smaller the monthly payment is,” Spring says.

Which option to choose depends on the level of acceptable risk. “Leasing by default is a long-term option, while renting can be as short as 3 months or as long as 3 to 4 years,” Spring says.

Medical equipment leasing continues to gain traction as a means for budget-constrained hospitals and healthcare systems to preserve capital for other investments. However, a recent blog post from equipment financer National Funding notes the total cost over time may be higher than buying.

Spring also notes the short- and long-term contracting payment terms associated with renting or leasing could significantly impact an organization’s operating budget. Sometimes there is a path to ownership, such as an end-of-lease buyout option.

Regardless, Spring emphasizes that renting and leasing are not the only options. Others include:

• Rent to own. Like renting or leasing, this funding scenario requires no capital and no commitment, and it includes a set term and price.

• Placed for product. The vendor places the capital equipment in the facility, and the organization commits to purchasing consumables on a monthly or annual multi-year commitment. Failing to meet spending commitments results in a penalty, and the vendor retains ownership of the device.

• Per-use agreement. The vendor places the device in the institution, and the organization commits to a minimum number of procedures. This pay-by-procedure for use of the device also includes paying for the use of consumables.

• Place for product and per-use agreement. In this combination of the previous two options, the hospital or health system commits to a minimum volume of procedures, then pays by procedure for the use of the device and any consumables. This option presents no pathway to ownership.

The direction hospitals go via spending or leasing depends on a given healthcare facility’s finances and the philosophy of their institution. “Some people want to own equipment, others prefer to lease or rent it, and some people do a mix because they can’t afford to buy it all,” Spring says.

At Mass General, Spring says he approaches capital investments with a mindset of “buy first, and lease second,” with built-in upgrade options. If he knows the technology for a given device is moving quicker, then he builds an upgrade opportunity into the lease. “So, if in 2 years, something new comes out, I give the equipment I’m leasing back and start a new lease agreement,” he explains.

 

Technological evolution

Technology advancements pose a significant challenge for financial teams who are constantly being asked by surgeons and other influential stakeholders to upgrade the equipment to ensure their institution can provide the best, most modern medical care. “Is the technology changing every 2 years, every 4 years, or is it changing every couple of months? It’s really important to understand the speed of advancement of a particular technology, and whether you want to upgrade it,” Spring says.

For example, OR tables are not being reinvented every few years. However, imaging equipment changes all the time. “There’s always new software, and safer, lower-radiation image taking,” Spring says. “You often want the opportunity to upgrade without having to buy something every couple of years. A lease allows you to swap out your equipment.”

Surgical waste systems, such as Stryker’s Neptune system, also tend to evolve quickly. “Three years ago, there was Neptune Two,” Spring says. “Now there’s Neptune Three. Is it better? There’s this constant increase in technology on the capital side and on the product side in what we use on patients.”

Spring suggests consulting with engineering or technology teams who can help finance managers understand what the technology is and where it’s going from an engineering perspective. He also advises talking to vendors, who can point to where a particular technology is headed in the near and long terms.

 

Vendor consolidation

“There is no magic in this,” Spring says, noting that data are king, and surgeon support is vital. “Committing volume and spend to a smaller number of vendors” generally improves pricing.

He adds that a hospital’s spend data allow finance personnel to see where the money is going. “You can use that data to determine if your organization is purchasing many products that do the same thing. Using that data to consolidate to two vendors allows for a better negotiation on pricing.”

From a vendor perspective, Medtronic’s Leo agrees. He says hospitals are increasingly streamlining and standardizing procurement, including working with a smaller number of vendors, to manage costs. Bringing some procurement in-house can also increase control, flexibility, and cost savings in capital equipment purchasing. The IV solution shortage, a result of severe damage to Baxter Healthcare’s manufacturing plant in western North Carolina during Hurricane Helene, prompted some hospitals to open their own warehouses, eliminating the need for a distributor. Working with fewer vendors and bringing some procurement in-house could give hospitals greater control, flexibility, and cost savings in their capital equipment purchasing, Leo observes.

 

Communication, collaboration

Today’s funding realities are pushing hospital finance leaders to embrace a more collaborative and less transactional relationships with vendors, Leo adds. “Building strategic relationships—where you share ideas and collaborate versus being transactional—is more effective in the long run for finance teams tasked with managing capital expenditures.”

Spring elaborates on the importance of connecting with clinicians, noting, “Better understanding the needs and wants of the clinical team and the impact that new devices have on patients, patient flow, costs, outcomes and finances is critical to establishing a best practice for prioritizing and using capital funds. The goal should be to get the most out of the funds you have. Engaging in these types of discussions and relationships with providers is the best way to achieve this goal.”

 

Holistic thinking

Finance teams and surgeons need to think broader than simply upgrading a piece of equipment that benefits the OR, Spring says. They also must assess whether it can also benefit a larger group of patients and ultimately drive their healthcare organization forward financially.

The sweet spot is technology that benefits both the patient and the hospital’s margins, Spring says. For example, new devices that enable minimally invasive surgery (MIS), such as laser therapy for brain tumors, provide a win-win by allowing more patients to be seen. These MIS approaches can reduce recovery time in the postanesthesia care unit and recovery time as an inpatient,” he says. “In this way, an expensive device for the OR might actually be good for the institution.”

 

—Anne Wainscott-Sargent is a freelance technology and science journalist with a diverse healthcare writing background, covering topics ranging from infection control to biopharma/life sciences.

References

Flicek G. Hospital Finance: Capital Expenditure Costs Are Up Nearly 2x. Ascendient Healthcare Advisors. Accessed January 2025.

Rodeck D. Medical Equipment Leasing: Should You Lease or Buy? National Funding. March 19, 2020.

Southwick R. How Donald Trump’s return affects hospitals: Medicaid, the Affordable Care Act and tariffs. Chief Healthcare Executive. January 20, 2025.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat