Unexpected benefits can arise from unexpected circumstances. Relatively new nurse leaders at two different facilities have found this to be true, for different reasons. Both have faced sudden changes that made their jobs more difficult but also gave them opportunities for growth.
When the director of ambulatory care at Brigham and Women’s Faulkner Hospital went on leave in late summer 2020, there was an immediate need to fill that person’s shoes—creating a disruption but also a chance for a new manager to shine.
Robin Kaufman, DNP, APRN, FNP-C, NEA-BC, had been nurse director of perioperative services for a little over 2 years at the hospital when the absence occurred. Kaufman, who oversees the preoperative area, preoperative evaluation, and postanesthesia care unit (PACU), added the endoscopy area and the radiology/nephrology suites to her plate—temporarily managing about 40 to 50 staff on top of the 100 she normally supervises. The OR director took charge of the remaining ambulatory care areas: cardiac rehabilitation, pain management, and the infusion clinic.
This shared oversight of ambulatory care lasted for an 8-week period at the 171-bed nonprofit community teaching facility in Jamaica Plain, Massachusetts. The normal case volume of 40 to 60 cases per day includes general surgical procedures as well as bariatric, ENT, orthopedics, surgical oncology, and urology, Kaufman says.
For Patrel Nobles, MSN, RN, CNOR, trying to unite a divided cardiac surgery team at Inova Fairfax Medical Campus in Falls Church, Virginia, only got harder with the arrival of COVID-19. When she joined Inova Fairfax in October 2019 as clinical director of the CVOR, she inherited a fractured staff and a culture lacking in trust and accountability. Within months of trying to turn things around, she found herself confronting the first surge of COVID-19 cases at her facility.
Nobles oversees the OR suites, preoperative area, and PACU. Her staff of 50 performs an average of 2,100 cases annually. She reports to Paula Graling, DNP, RN, CNOR, NEA-BC, FAAN, vice president, nursing, Inova surgical services and perioperative services at Inova Fairfax. Graling, an AORN past president, has been an important mentor for Nobles, who attributes her success as a leader to lessons learned from Graling. “Being vulnerable, transparent, and accessible were the things she portrayed that I mimic,” Nobles says.
“I’m new to the director role, coming from a clinically focused role,” Kaufman told OR Manager. “I had taken a lot of classes on leadership, but the nurse director role is bigger than anything I’ve previously done.” Before taking on the nurse director role, she had served as the chief nurse practitioner for preoperative evaluation and as a thoracic nurse in a stepdown unit, she says.
Adapting quickly to change is something everyone has experienced in the COVID-19 era, and Kaufman is no exception. “We are an acute care hospital, and many PACU staff were deployed to the ICU or emergency department during the first surge, when we reduced OR volume almost to nothing. Since returning, we’ve had to reimagine everything we do. It’s been a lot of learning to adapt—a lot of changes and challenges,” she says.
Kaufman flexed into supporting the nurse supervisors and worked with colleagues to stand up a patient COVID-19 swabbing tent, among other things. “I had to quickly learn things that weren’t previously part of my wheelhouse,” she notes.
When Inova Fairfax got its first surge of COVID-19 cases in the spring of 2020, Nobles says, there were other fairly new leaders in the perioperative department, but all of them had come from within the system. “I was the lone ranger who had come from outside, and I had been here 4 months when all elective surgeries were shut down,” she says. “I was still trying to develop rapport with a new team and evaluate what was going on with them.”
The cardiac surgery team at that time was characterized by divisiveness and a lack of collegial working relationships, Nobles says. “They felt like they didn’t have a voice. The nurses were being controlled by physician leadership rather than nursing leadership.”
The emergence of COVID-19 galvanized much-needed change. Inova Fairfax was inundated with new information as cases mounted, and huddles were held every morning and some afternoons, with information that was shared in the morning changing by the afternoon, Nobles says.
Elective surgery at Inova Fairfax was shut down for 3 months beginning in March 2020, and some cardiac team members were redeployed, but no one was furloughed, Nobles says. Even before the shutdown, surgical case volumes were decreasing, and Nobles knew she needed to do something to give team members a sense of hope and belonging. Nobles and the nurse educator collaborated on ways the cardiac team might help, she says.
“We did a lot of training because these CVOR team members had to learn skills they had never used before,” she says. “We are the masters at positioning, so the CVOR staff did a lot of assisting with proning of patients, central line dressing changes, trachea care, and IV insertions.”
Everyone in the early days of the pandemic worried about exposure to SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19. “We didn’t know if the PPE [personal protective equipment] we were using was even the right PPE. We never went without appropriate PPE, but it was a concern,” she says.
“Inova was one of the leading organizations to use ECMO [extracorporeal membrane oxygenation] in the treatment of COVID-19 patients, and that fell 100% on the shoulders of this department,” Nobles says, adding that it was hard to manage PPE expectations and reassure staff of safety when so much information was changing throughout each day.
Leadership was very supportive, she notes. She credits leaders with working with infectious disease experts to come up with different kinds of respirators in addition to N95 masks—in particular, a device that wasn’t initially approved for use in the OR because of the exhalation valve and concerns about proper filtering in a sterile environment. “The CVOR was the first OR within Inova that got access to those respirators,” she says.
At Brigham and Women’s Faulkner Hospital, filling in for the absent ambulatory care colleague was a good learning experience, Kaufman says. “It forced me to think about the portfolio of work my team is responsible for and to realize I didn’t have to be the one who was owning every meeting and initiative,” she says, adding that some of her clinical leaders took on additional responsibilities.
This experience contributed to Kaufman’s idea for mini-sabbaticals. “One of the reasons sabbaticals don’t take hold in healthcare is that it’s potentially disruptive to have someone gone for a year,” Kaufman says. During a year-long absence, a substitute leader might make programmatic changes, whereas that’s less likely to occur during a mini-sabbatical of several weeks, she says.
“Time management is a huge challenge for any leader,” Kaufman notes. She had to get up to speed quickly, and she says support from the chief nursing officer and senior director of surgical and procedural services was instrumental to her success. “Luckily, the work is adjacent enough to other areas in my history; it wasn’t completely new to me,” she says. The bigger challenge was getting to know some of the physicians and staff that she hadn’t worked with previously, in order to support the work they were doing, she notes.
“Part of the concept for the mini-sabbatical is that it would be even shorter than 8 weeks, to provide an opportunity for people to step into day-to-day operations and to support bigger strategic or programmatic work that was in progress,” she says. In her view, a mini-sabbatical should be long enough to allow the person on leave to recharge and have time to focus more deeply on strategic work without the constant attention required for daily operations, but short enough that the person doesn’t return to a whole different strategy in his or her department.
Of course, much can happen even in an 8-week period. Kaufman’s oversight coincided with the beginning of a construction project in the endoscopy area that included a different means of storing endoscopes, as well as major workflow changes. She helped staff navigate those changes while also preparing for a Joint Commission survey.
Kaufman had not previously been through a survey as a director, and she felt proud as she guided the inspectors through the facility. “It wasn’t enjoyable, exactly, but it was an exciting and inspiring experience,” she says.
Hospital leaders at Brigham and Women’s Faulkner Hospital are exploring how the mini-sabbatical concept could be formalized, Kaufman says. Since 2019, when the hospital achieved Magnet status, leaders have emphasized the importance of evidence-based projects, and Kaufman sees opportunities there. “People are taking advantage of participating more in that work than they used to,” she says, adding that she sees coaching as another area for potential growth.
The mini-sabbatical, Kaufman believes, could be a case study for succession planning. “What I was able to experience as the director of these areas is something I wouldn’t otherwise have had the opportunity to do,” she says. “If it’s set up in advance, that gives people an opportunity to grow into roles and to think through solutions.”
She adds that it’s imperative to have the support of leadership. “That’s part of the culture we have here. That’s one reason it worked the way it did.”
Like Kaufman, Nobles sees how a difficult challenge gave her an opportunity to grow as a leader and strengthen her team. She created empathy by sharing some of her personal concerns about COVID-19 with her team, and she took on non-manager roles, working side by side with staff. “I helped move patients, did chest compressions, opened rooms—I walked the walk with them,” she says—a practice that continues to this day.
Nobles also found non-clinical ways to connect with staff. For example, she knew that some family members of the team had lost their jobs in the pandemic, and she told them this had happened to her husband. “To try to create a culture of sensitivity, we had team members offering to get gift cards at the grocery store. We didn’t know who was impacted, but team members said they were willing to help in any way possible, anonymously,” she says.
In addition, she says, team members who worried about older staff getting COVID-19 stepped up efforts to protect them.
“COVID-19 helped pull the team together,” she says. “We could have just shut down and not continued our journey. We didn’t. We really started to develop unit-based councils, we enhanced recruitment and hiring, and we engaged team members to be involved in the interview process and to think about performance improvement.”
In the past, she says, this team was often upset about things and vocal about their concerns. Nobles says the administrative vice president of the cardiac service line recently told her she noticed the improved relations during a town hall. “When I walked in and people were laughing, I knew it was a different place,” she told Nobles.
“I feel like I’m a better leader for having gone through this experience,” Nobles says. “Sometimes we were winging it because we didn’t have a playbook to go by.” She believes that being transparent about her own vulnerability helped to develop trust with the team. “They supported me as much as I supported them,” she says.
“To successfully lead the Inova CVOR team through a cultural transformation compounded by a global pandemic, I know that my passion was my purpose,” Nobles adds. “I had to reaffirm this in myself, but I knew I couldn’t give up on myself or my team.”
Kaufman’s experience with the mini-sabbatical and other challenges during the pandemic have helped her become a better leader, she says. “This reminded me how much healthcare is a team sport. Learning to leverage the unique talent and capacity of each member of our team made all of us better.”
Kaufman and Nobles will share their experiences during the annual OR Manager Conference, which takes place October 20-22 in Chicago. To learn more or to register, visit www.ormanager.com. ✥