• Although the central tenets of value-based healthcare have not changed, in many cases implementation has been reduced to little more than reducing costs, to the detriment of clinicians and patients.
• The right incentives, such as recognition and work support, can effectively inspire clinicians to deliver high value while also reducing costs.
• Linking incentives to specific performance measurements is essential to making a shift to value-based care.
Payers have a tremendous influence on how healthcare is delivered—enough to shift providers’ strategic priorities in ways that are fundamentally antithetical to the reasons why people get into medicine in the first place. This has to change, says Susanna Gallani, PhD, a Harvard Business School economist struck by what her recent research has revealed about the frustrations of front-line clinicians. For all the talk of value-based care, she explains, a payer-centric model that encourages a volume over value approach continues to persist, resulting in burnout, staffing shortages, and high turnover.

Susanna Gallani, PhD, teaches at Harvard Business School in Boston, Massachusetts. Photo by Stu Rosner. Used with permission.
As a researcher and accounting professor at Harvard Business School in Boston, Massachusetts, Dr Gallani investigates incentive design and performance measurement within management control systems, including motivators and demotivators for rank-and-file workers. Bringing an economic perspective to the application of value-based care can help better align key players and accelerate the transition, she says.
“We need to equip the people who produce healthcare while also making sure their goals are aligned with the goals of the organization, which happens through incentives,” she explains. “We also need to achieve what the patient wants, which is the delivery of health. In addition, I look at the financial viability of these promises. We have to balance all of these things, which is a very interesting puzzle but nonetheless a very complicated one.”
Dr Gallani says her findings on clinician incentive design pinpoint recognition, work support, and other non-financial motivators as effective in inspiring clinicians to not only reduce costs, but also improve care quality. The suggestion of a strong link between clinician job satisfaction and financially beneficial value-based care is leading her to ask a bold question: Could healthcare organizations compensate clinicians based on performance of the strategic mission, and keep clinician pay independent from payer reimbursement models?
Dr Gallani’s OR Business Management Conference keynote session, “Charting your course to success: Financial wins through value-based performance,” will explore this question. Attendees also will learn performance management lessons from industries beyond healthcare. Specific topics will include:
The original value-based care framework was proposed by Michael Porter and Elizabeth Olmsted Teisberg in 2006. They suggested that value—measured improvement in a patient’s outcome for the total cost of achieving the outcome—should be what drives competition in healthcare. They also emphasized the importance of containing costs by rewarding results (outcomes) rather than process compliance.
These fundamental principles have not changed, Dr Gallani says. What has changed is the interpretation of value-based care. For example, some alternative payment models offer shared savings based on the payers’ determination that care cost less than expected. “It breaks my heart that in many cases the value-based healthcare strategic framework has been reduced to a payment model pushed to incentivize cost reductions,” she says.
Citing her field work and studies, Dr Gallani says plenty of clinicians’ practices are in line-with the tenets of value-based care anyway. However, healthcare leaders can do more, starting with looking harder at clinician incentives.
The long legacy of misaligned incentives-—compensation depends on volume despite a purported mission to put patients first-—is a structural problem, Dr Gallani says. It calls for a structural solution, beginning with understanding what motivates the ultimate drivers of value: clinicians.
In a 2024 study, Dr Gallani and other researchers linked burnout to the disconnect between physicians’ desire to help patients and the pressure to work faster. Although that study focused specifically on neurologists, she says the same thing is happening with physicians and other clinicians throughout healthcare. Even worse is evidence of moral injury—especially from surgeons—when time and volume pressures impact care. “Everyone is barely surviving,” she says. “As we look at ongoing shortages and recognize that clinicians have a high level of burnout, we need to consider what this is costing. Turnover is extremely costly in terms of replacing clinicians and risking patient safety as a result.”
Leaders need to invest in creating a work environment that supports clinicians feeling their work is aligned with their values. This is where incentives come in, and not just monetary incentives, because in many situations there are limits to salary and compensation plans. “Incentives like recognition, status, and valuing the contribution of others make a difference, especially in a mission-driven field like healthcare,” Dr Gallani says.
A 2023 study investigated the efficacy of conduit incentives, in which employees receive bonuses for performance that depends on the cooperation of peers who are not eligible for a bonus. Dr Gallani tested this in a California hospital that offered a one-time bonus program for non-physician care team members to improve hand-washing compliance. However, physicians’ handwashing counted toward the goal. As a result, bonus-eligible workers used social pressure to incentivize physicians’ performance, absent any tangible benefits for the physicians. Physicians improved performance, and improvements persisted beyond the removal of the incentives. These results speak to the power of recognition as a motivator for physicians, Dr Gallani says.
Other, ongoing research is revealing how siloed hierarchies of healthcare teams cause problems when there is poor coordination in the cycle of care (for example, a physician frustrated by delayed X-rays).“This disconnect can present a manager with a challenge to address in a way that requires a redesign of relationships within a healthcare organization, as well as a realignment of incentives and resource allocation,” Dr Gallani says. Fresh focus on patient outcomes could break the current fee-for-service cycle, which restricts leaders’ propensity to rethink strategic goals.
If a healthcare organization’s internal incentive system can be reshaped to better align with a performance management approach linked to patient outcomes, the question becomes what to measure and how to link it to specific incentives. Dr Gallani suggests considering metrics beyond readmission, morbidity, and mortality. “When thinking about measuring outcomes that patients perceive as valuable, it’s more than not dying on the table,” she says, adding that surgical leaders must take a lead role in measuring what matters and tying it to incentives. “Many are waiting for the payers to make this shift first, but I fear they will be waiting a long time.”
Dr Gallani suggests offering a mix of rewards in addition to cash compensation, such as funding for a project the clinician wants to develop, training opportunities, or preferred OR scheduling. Such incentives can empower clinicians to suggest and appreciate solutions that capitalize on their expertise while also rewarding performance improvement. “These are not radical ideas,” she says. “It’s a question of considering possibility.”
Overall, change will require surgical administrators and clinicians to step away from the full-speed train that is healthcare and seek opportunities to work together, Dr Gallani says. Ideally, the conference will provide a perfect forum for sharing ideas.
—Carina Stanton is a freelance science journalist who lives in Colorado.