May 24, 2024

How awareness evolves to action on surgeon, patient gender gaps

Takeaways

  • Although women comprise half the population, they were left out of medical research on major causes of death for both women and men—cancer, heart disease, and stroke—until 1990.
  • Using surgical tools designed by men, for men can impact every aspect of a woman surgeon’s work, from learning new procedures to avoiding discomfort and injury.
  • Awareness is the first step toward action. For instance, patients and caregivers alike might lack understanding of nuances in cardiac care and outcomes for women.

Cardiovascular disease is the leading killer of both women and men, but more women are dying. Why?

C. Noel Bairey Merz, MD

Evidence points to lack of research and a one-size-fits-all approach to care, including in the OR. “Many of our protocols are male-standard, beginning with dosing,” says C. Noel Bairey Merz, MD, a leading cardiologist who directs a number of cardiology centers at Cedars Sinai, including the Barbra Streisand Women’s Heart Center. “Women on average are smaller, they have more bleeding complications, and there’s a body of evidence they generally don’t do as well with bypass.”

Gender disparities in healthcare extend beyond the cardiovascular space. They also extend beyond the patient. For female surgeons, challenges range from pay gaps that grow as their careers advance to difficulties with maneuvering surgical instruments designed for men by men.

Nicole Fox, MD, MPH, FACS

The good news is that awareness of these issues seems to be growing, and awareness is the first step toward action, says Nicole Fox, MD, MPH, FACS, a trauma surgeon at Cooper University Health Care in New Jersey. At a recent surgical conference she attended, a gender equity session packed the room. “People want to hear and talk about solutions,” she says. “They want to know: How do we fix this?”

Improving working conditions for female surgeons is likely to filter down into patient outcomes as well. However, getting beyond “one-size-fits-all” care also requires surgeons—including the men—to take action, beginning with improving their understanding of how women of various backgrounds and ethnicities present with certain conditions and how they respond to treatments.

 

Closing data gaps

Although women comprise half the population, they were left entirely out of medical research around the major causes of death for both women, and men—cancer, heart disease and stroke—until 1990, when the National Institutes of Health (NIH) established the Office of Research on Women’s Health (ORWH). Women were a rarity in medical professions as recently as the 1970s, and women of childbearing age were excluded from clinical trials per a 1977 Food and Drug Administration policy, resulting in all-male trials and a dearth of information on how drugs impact women. It was not until 1994 that the NIH required all clinical trials to include women and minorities in clinical research.

However, research is slowly catching up—and shows signs of accelerating. In November 2023, President Biden and First Lady Jill Biden announced the White House Initiative on Women’s Health Research. Then in March 2024, President Biden called on Congress to invest $12 billion into the cause, signing an executive order to ensure “women’s health is integrated and prioritized across the federal research portfolio and budget” and to “galvanize new research on a wide range of topics, including women’s midlife health.”

Although these efforts might take time to materialize, researchers are taking steps to get more women from underrepresented groups to engage in clinical trials to provide the data needed to best serve those populations. For example,

Heather Yeo, MD, MHS, MBA, MS

Heather Yeo, MD, MHS, MBA, MS, associate professor of surgery and population health sciences at Weill Cornell Medicine, developed an app called mHeals that allows patients recovering from abdominal cancer surgery to track various health measures—mobility, pain, fluid intake, and diet—using a Fitbit and daily surveys to monitor their own health and signal doctors when intervention is needed.

“We’re looking at recovery after surgery and whether an app can help them return to baseline at a faster rate than those without it,” Dr Yeo says. She adds that her team has focused on ensuring a diverse patient population, which can be challenging. “The Hispanic population is very wary of sharing data, as we know from other studies,” she says. “So, we’ve tried to over-enroll that population.”

 

Getting beyond ‘one size fits all’

As a colorectal surgeon, Dr Yeo uses a colonoscope—a surgical device with a control end and a long flexible tube containing a camera—frequently in her work and training. However, colonoscopes can be cumbersome. “These devices come in one size,” she says. “Sometimes, in order to train a female resident or a male one with smaller hands, I have to have them use two hands to maneuver because it’s difficult to do with smaller hands.”

When researchers used electrodes to track muscle movement during surgical procedures, they found women surgeons had increased muscle activation and higher fatigue levels compared with men. Women with smaller hand sizes are also more likely to be injured from the use of laparoscopic instruments. Wrong-sized tools can impact everything from a surgeon’s ability to learn a procedure, to passing required tests, to performing her duties without injury.

In a story from the Cleveland Clinic looking at women and surgical tools, Amy Park, MD, section head of female pelvic medicine and reconstructive surgery at Cleveland Clinic’s OB/GYN & Women’s Health Institute, noted she has experienced frequent soreness in her forearm and the place where her thumb and hand connect (the thenar eminence) from using the laparoscope because of the force required to close it. “Due to the size of my hand, I cannot extend it enough to generate the force to easily operate the tool,” she said.

Dr Yeo has advocated for medical device companies and engineers to work together to improve the design and ergonomics of surgical devices, including developing devices in multiple sizes or that are adjustable.

With growing recognition of the need for surgical tools and personal protective equipment designed for women, some universities are providing opportunities for students and medical professionals to brainstorm new solutions. Harvard Grid, which brings together the engineering department and Harvard’s tech transfer office to form new tech ventures, hosted an event last year on the need for surgical tools designed with women in mind.

 

Preventing obstacles for surgeons from becoming obstacles for patients

Obstacles for women in surgery are particularly stark. Women surgeons earn $83,000 per year less than their male counterparts. Women surgeons are 18% less likely to be named full professors, and only 15% of surgical chairs are women. “These are the two major issues: Pay equity…and opportunities for advancement,” Dr Fox says. “You’ll hear about work-life balance—and while that is a real issue for men and women, it’s not the main thing that is limiting the advancement of women in surgery.”

Additionally, data suggest female surgeons are particularly rare. About half of medical school students are women, but less than a quarter of these graduates pursue surgical specialties. The only exceptions are gynecology and obstetrics, where women outnumber men.

“Now that we know, what do we do?” Dr Fox says. “In a hospital, if you run a surgical department, should you look at all the salaries and ensure equity? If you are a CEO of a hospital, should you look at your leadership and determine if there’s too much homogeneity and make a change?”

Whatever the solution, the need is dire—and not just for the surgeons’ sake. Evidence suggests disparities in how surgeons are treated can lead to disparities in how patients are treated, too.

For example, even as female surgeons remain underrepresented, recent study data show female patients fare better when their surgeon is a woman. Looking at more than 1 million patients treated by nearly 3,000 surgeons in Canada, the researchers did not offer definitive reasons for this disparity.

However, the findings pointed to a number of likely culprits, such as:

  • dismissal of women’s symptoms by male doctors
  • women patients reporting less pain
  • women preferring same-sex doctors for sensitive examinations
  • male doctors failing to properly identify and intervene when women patients demonstrate deviations from expected postoperative outcomes.

“In order to receive good care, patients need to be comfortable with physicians, and they need to be heard,” Dr Fox says.


Documentary ‘1001 Cuts’ shares women surgeons’ stories

To showcase the story of women surgeons—including the gender discrimination they face and how they overcome it—gynecologic oncologist Sarah M. Temkin, MD, produced a documentary, 1001 Cuts. Shown at a number of 2024 film festivals, including the Bethesda Film Festival, the DC Independent Film Festival, and Women’s Voices Now, the documentary is intended to show stories of resilience and let women surgeons know they are not alone.

“After speaking with other surgeons, I found a common theme: A lack of respect and support in the OR,” Dr Temkin told Healio.

She noted that she hopes the film will spark conversation, and provide potential solutions to gender inequities in surgery. “My hope is that this film allows space for women, health care administrators, nurses, physicians and everyone to discuss these experiences openly,” she says.

1001 Cuts is more than just a documentary. Complementing the film is a related podcast, Voices in Medicine, as well as a blog covering issues ranging from equipment that doesn’t fit to dealing with unprofessional behavior to occupational segregation. Learn more at www.1001cuts.org/more-info.

References

1001 Cuts. 2024.

Southall, J. Documentary aims to expose gender inequality, need for reform in surgical field. Healio. May 6, 2021.


Driving at the heart of the issue

Heart disease—which is preventable if caught early and treated—is a prime example of the way that lack of research, bias, and one-size-fits-all care has led to poorer outcomes for women.

The landmark Framingham Heart Study—a multigenerational study of cardiovascular health in the US that began in 1948 and has come to include over 15,000 participants—only began to report on how heart disease has specifically impacted women in the mid-1980s. The results were eye-opening.

Researchers discovered that women are more likely to die from an acute cardiac event and are more likely to have a poor prognosis following such an event. They are diagnosed later in life than men, when the condition is more deadly. When it comes to strokes, there are a number of gender differences as well. Carotid stenosis, when the large blood vessels on the neck become narrow, occurs more frequently in men but is more likely to trigger stroke in women. Additionally, men respond better to surgery to repair these blood vessels, perhaps because their blood vessels are larger. Although men and women have the same risk factors for heart failure—a long-term condition in which the heart stops pumping blood as effectively—women are more prone to developing it, and it leads to higher rates of hospitalization and death in women.

Ensuring sex differences are better understood, better recognized by the public, better diagnosed, and better treated requires improved education for both clinicians and the broader population, says Dr Merz at at Cedars Sinai. A survey found that despite the prevalence of heart disease, which is the leading cause of death for women, just 22% of primary care physicians and 42% of cardiologists felt prepared to address the risk factors in women.

Similarly, despite public awareness campaigns, many women are not aware that, in women, heart disease often presents with more subtle symptoms than the chest-clutching “Hollywood heart attack.” These symptoms can include sweating, dizziness, fatigue, shortness of breath, nausea, and even jaw pain. It is important that women learn to recognize these symptoms and advocate for EKG testing, experts say. “If you pay attention to these additional symptoms and don’t call them atypical, or ‘women symptoms’—we not only help two thirds of women to recognize these symptoms but also one third of men,” Dr Merz says.

Growing awareness can increase the likelihood of caregivers finding and taking advantage of innovations that can benefit women, including new surgical techniques. For example, using noninvasive transcatheter aortic valve replacement as an alternative to surgical aortic valve replacement has been shown to improve survival rates for women.

With 26.8 million Americans suffering from cardiovascular disease and nearly 700,000 people dying from it in the US each year, the potential for such innovations to move the needle on improving outcomes is huge. And yet, cardiovascular care is just one of many specialties where awareness is slowly evolving toward action. For the healthcare sector as a whole, the potential benefits of closing the gender gap are undoubtedly vast.

 

—Brita Belli is an award-winning writer and PR professional with published stories in the New York Times, National Geographic, MSN.com, and Alternet.

 

References

An app to improve outcomes for patients with GI cancer. NewYork-Presbyterian Personalized Care & Precision Medicine. Accessed May 2024.

Biden J. Memorandum on the White House initiative on women’s health research. The White House. November 13, 2023.

Cardiovascular Diseases (CVDs). World Health Organization (WHO). June 11, 2021.

Chieffo A, Petronio A S, Mehilli J, et al. 1 year clinical outcomes in women after transcatheter aortic valve replacement: Results from the first WIN-TAVI Registry. JACC: Cardiovascular Interventions. January 1, 2018.

Douthard R, Whitten L A, Clayton J A. Research on women’s health: Ready for the future. Journal of Women’s Health. February 10, 2022.

Fact Sheet: President Biden issues executive order and announces new actions to advance women’s health research and innovation. The White House. March 18, 2024.

Female surgeons need better equipment design. The Cleveland Clinic. June 30, 2022.

Fox F, Schroll R, Quiodettis M, et al. Women in trauma surgery: Advancing our profession through international collaboration. Trauma Surgery & Acute Care Open. March 8, 2024.

Gao Z, Chen Z, Sun A, et al. Gender differences in cardiovascular disease. Medicine in Novel Technology and Devices. January 11, 2020.

Gender Equity Toolkit. Association of Women Surgeons. Accessed May 2024.

Haskins J. Where are all the women in surgery? AAMCNews. July 15, 2019.

Heart Disease Facts. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. May 15, 2023.

Heart disease risk factors in women highlight need for increased awareness, prevention. American Heart Association. February 12, 2024.

Hong Y. Framingham Heart Study (FHS). National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute. 1948.

Inclusion by Design—One Size Does Not Fit All: Medical Instruments and PPE. Harvard Grid. September 28, 2023.

Martin S M, Aday A W, Almarzooq Z I, et al. 2024 Heart Disease and Stroke Statistics: A Report of US and Global Data From the American Heart Association. AHA/ASA Journals. January 24, 2024.

Mesiti A, Yeo H. Surgical device design: Do instruments fit today’s surgeons? BMJ Surgery, Interventions, & Health Technologies. July 14, 2023.

NIH Inclusion Outreach Toolkit: How to Engage, Recruit, and Retain Women in Clinical Research. National Institutes of Health, Office of Research on Women’s Health. Accessed May 2024.

O’Connor A. Why heart disease in women is so often missed or dismissed. New York Times. May 9, 2022.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat