The terms “best practices,” “benchmarking,” and “leading practices” are often used in healthcare, and sometimes, they are used interchangeably.
What do they mean?
• Best practices are health practices, methods, interventions, procedures, or techniques based on high-quality evidence that are used to improve patient and healthcare outcomes.
• Benchmarking is comparing the performance of an organization or clinicians to others, with the goal of improving quality, efficiency, and patient experience; however, benchmarking will not show exactly where problems may be occurring.
• Leading practices are innovative, people-centered, evidence-informed practices that have been implemented by teams in an organization and can encompass best practices and benchmarking.
OR Manager recently performed a survey that looked at leading practices in ORs around the country that can be used as a guide to set and accomplish goals.
This is the first of a two-part series of articles presenting results of the survey, which can help inform OR leaders on how their facilities’ performance compares with others. Part 1 includes survey data on flip rooms, scheduling, preference cards, first case on-time starts; and the sterile processing department. The total number of respondents for Part 1 of the survey was 142. Part 2 will review survey data on block management, preoperative areas, and room turnover.
Responses to the survey came from a large variety of facilities, with the majority being hospital-based.
The number of ORs and procedure rooms ranged from a single room to the largest having 72 rooms. Most responses were from facilities with 1-5 rooms (sidebar, Respondents: Size of facility by # of OR / procedure rooms).

Responses were categorized into 4 groups: Group A = 1–10 rooms, Group B = 11–20 rooms, Group C = 21–30 rooms, and Group D = 31–72 rooms.
Flip rooms, or the process of running two ORs back to back, is common in many perioperative departments. Flip rooms are typically awarded as part of a surgeon’s block time allocation to allow a very productive surgeon to quickly go from one room to another. As one case is finishing, the surgeon moves to a second OR where the next case is set up and ready to start.
Criteria for assigning a surgeon a flip room should be very clear and designed to work not only to the advantage of the surgeon, but to the hospital as well. While most surgeons prefer a flip room schedule, for hospitals, flip rooms can become an expensive endeavor. Room flipping can create long gaps between cases when not effectively managed, which would drive down utilization and erode profitability. Expectations for staffing, volume of cases, case duration, types of cases, and equipment all factor into the productivity of a flip room.
More than 80% of respondents use flip rooms. Of those, 56% have established policies for when surgeons can be assigned two rooms. Without a policy to support the use of flip rooms, the goal of increasing surgical volume and surgeon productivity can be compromised. All facilities should have a clear policy to support this practice.
Case scheduling is key to OR productivity. Policies and procedures for scheduling patients for surgical procedures must be supported by all involved, including administration.
Key elements to address are:
• When cases can be scheduled (time of day) and how many block and open times are available
• When cases can no longer be added to the schedule
• What patient optimization data is needed and when it must be in the patient’s chart (eg, physician orders, history and physical, consults, diagnostic testing, special needs).
When scheduling elective cases, less than 26% of respondents say they close the schedule before the day of surgery.
On the day of surgery, 62% state they do not limit add-ons to only urgent and emergent cases.
Although the goal of most ORs is to increase surgical volume and add to the bottom line, it comes with the risk of nursing and anesthesia personnel dissatisfaction with overtime. Part 1 of this leading practice survey shows that management of these add-on cases requires a combination of anesthesia personnel and nursing collaboration.
Electronic health records (EHRs) can be seen as a drag on a hospital’s efficiency and a source of frustration for clinicians and managers. According to the 2022 OR Manager Salary/Career Survey, complaints related to documentation time, compatibility with other systems, and report generation are common.
Nevertheless, an intuitive software system can be a powerful tool in running a successful perioperative service. The data available can assist with staffing, charge capture, quality metrics, budgets, scheduling, and block booking.
However, not all facilities have these systems and continue to use manual scheduling and collection of date. The majority of survey respondents use some type of EHR and scheduling software (sidebar, Perioperative EHR, scheduling systems in use).
Managing and updating surgical preference cards continues to be a challenge, whether using paper index or electronic cards. There are several reasons for why this practice can be so challenging. Mostly, constant changes in technology and practice make the task an ongoing process, making it difficult for staff to prioritize.
Several studies have shown that preference cards, when left to surgeon choice, have resulted in significant differing costs for common general surgical procedures. Well-managed, well-maintained preference cards are not only a valuable asset for increasing productivity and lowering costs, but they also save time in sterile processing by reducing unnecessary instrument set processing.
Among the responses from those surveyed:
• 85% have electronic preference cards
• 40% update the cards after each use, and 6% never update the cards
• Electronic preference cards have global change capability—76%
• Patient charges are generated by preference cards—66%
• Preference cards include items designated as “hold”—90%.
When asked about the number of active cards, responses varied widely, from 15 cards to 23,000 cards. Comments such as “too many” and “unknown” were common. Active cards include surgeons who have not practiced in many years and some who have passed away.
The responsibility for updating preference cards mostly fall to RNs and surgical technologists for Groups A, B, and C, and to business managers for Group D (sidebar, Who manages/updates preference cards?).
Tracking FCOTS is a priority quality improvement metric. Starting the first case of the day on time facilitates ending the OR schedule of cases on time and reduces the likelihood of overtime.
• 88% are tracking this metric, with 69% currently working on initiatives for improvement
• 57% allow no grace period for starting on time
• Grace periods range from 4 minutes to 20 minutes, with no correlation to the size of the department
• Percentage of ORs with staggered start times for the first cases of the day is the same as ORs without staggered start times.
As surgical procedures evolve and volumes increase, it is vital that SPD and OR leaders work closely together to ensure continued sterilization and patient safety best practices. The relative success of a surgical department arguably lies in the effectiveness and efficiency of SPD.
Survey findings show that titles of SPD leaders include director, manager, coordinator, and others. The manager title is used in 51% of facilities, with no correlation to the size of the facility.
Other survey findings include:
• 57% of facilities include SPD in the daily perioperative huddle
• 73% of SPDs hold their own daily huddle
• 62% of facilities have a designated liaison between OR and SPD
• 72% of SPDs hold monthly in-service education sessions
• 52% of SPDs are responsible for cleaning inpatient equipment
• 42% of SPDs clean all gastrointestinal and pulmonary endoscopes
• 46% of SPDs are responsible for picking case cart supplies, and 60% pick the instrumentation.
Having OR managers share their institutions’ leading practices with others allows both sides to improve their performance and financial health. That is the goal of this two-part series of leading practice data gleaned from the experiences of some of the top OR leaders in the country. Part 2 will appear in the May 2023 issue of OR Manager.
—Nancy Lombard, MS, RN, CNOR, is the owner of Lombard Consulting, LLC, “A passion for all things Periop.” Her career encompasses 40-plus years working all levels of perioperative services and consulting. For inquiries, she can be reached at lombardperiopconsulting@gmail.com.
Frontline staff input helps build a better EHR system. OR Manager. November 2015.
Mathias J M. Preference or procedure card? Take your pick. OR Manager. February 2017.
Voight P. Benchmarking labor productivity: How is your OR being compared? OR Manager. March 2013.