April 24, 2023

How benchmarking data informs leading practices: Part 2

By: Nancy Lombard, MS, RN, CNOR
Share

Takeaways

  • Leading practice is innovative, people-centered, and evidence-informed and can encompass best practices and benchmarking data.
  • This article includes survey data on preadmission and preoperative practices, block scheduling, and room delays/turnover.
  • The total number of respondents for Part 2 of the survey was 133, the majority of whom (70.7%) were hospital-based.

OR Manager recently performed a survey that looked at leading practices—innovative, people-centered, evidence-informed practices that have been implemented by teams in an organization and can encompass best practices and benchmarking—in ORs around the country that can be used as a guide to set and accomplish goals.

This is the second of a two-part article series presenting the results of the survey, which can help inform OR leaders on how their facilities’ performance compares with others. Part 1, published in April 2023 (pp 1,15–17) included survey data on flip rooms, scheduling, preference cards, first case on-time starts, and sterile processing department. Part 1 also defined the terms “best practices,” “benchmarking,” and “leading practices,” which are often used interchangeably in healthcare.

Part 2 includes survey data on preadmission and preoperative practices, block scheduling, and room delays/turnover. The total number of respondents for Part 2 of the survey was 133. As with Part 1, there was a range of responses from hospitals, ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs), and other facilities.

 

Responding facilities

Responses to the survey came from a large variety of facilities, with the majority being hospital-based.

The number of ORs and procedure rooms ranged from a single room to the largest having 110 rooms. Most responses were from facilities with 1 to 5 rooms.

 

Scheduling, preadmission testing (PAT)

Obtaining key information such as accurate patient demographics, type of surgical procedure, length requested for procedure, physician preoperative orders, and current H&P (history and physical) information at the time of scheduling allows the PAT department to better prepare the patient in a timely manner. Insurance information with prior authorization, which most insurance companies need at least 5 days to issue, is also needed.

Why does having this information in order matter?

• H&P, preoperative orders, and signed consent for surgery forms are all necessary for the PAT nurse to properly assess and educate the patients and their families.

• Anesthesia personnel can also develop their plan of care regarding the patients’ medical readiness for the surgical procedure if they have access to these documents.

The survey showed that less than half (45%) of responding facilities require patients to submit their signed consent forms before the day of their procedures. A recommendation for facilities looking to implement such practice is to partner with the surgeon(s); when they see the patient in their offices before surgery, they can collect signed consent forms at that time (being mindful of the designated time period for when consent is considered valid), then send the signed forms to scheduling along with their preoperative orders.

H&P information, however, is easier to secure in a timely matter. According to the survey, 73% of respondents said their patients have a current H&P in the record before the day of surgery. The nursing staff at these facilities have better insight into the patients’ medical status, and their anesthesia personnel can create better-driven protocols to determine what testing or medical clearances are needed.

Optimizing patients for surgical procedures has many important parts that need to flow together in an orderly process to result in patients having the best outcomes possible. A PAT department with clear expectations of what is needed to prepare patients for the safest surgical experience will have less cancellations or delays on the day of surgery; higher OR utilization; increased patient, nurse, and physician satisfaction; and improved patient outcomes.

PAT departments are tasked with doing nursing assessments with the patients and/or their families; however, they often try to assess patients without basic information. This can be a big pain point for the nursing staff because many phone calls must be made to collect all the information needed to prepare the patients.

If the goal is to have a more efficient scheduling and PAT department, having guidelines—as well as enforcement protocols—that support perioperative efficiency is key.

 

Holding areas, ambulatory surgical unit (ASU)

Holding areas have become one of the common spaces to eliminate and/or repurpose. Along with the benefit of meeting the need for expansion, there is also some benefit to not having to staff holding areas. RNs are in great demand in all parts of the country, and eliminating holding areas allows for RNs to be assigned to other surgical areas. According to the survey, only 38% of facilities still maintain a holding area.

Facilities that responded to the survey showed that ASUs are expanding their original purpose of preparing patients for surgical procedures to add second phase recovery and/or discharge of these patients.

According to the survey, 58% of facilities admit only surgical patients; the other 42% of respondents care for patients scheduled for procedures in many departments, including cardiovascular laboratory, endoscopy, infusion and electroconvulsive therapies, obstetrics, ECT, radiology/imaging, cardiac diagnostic areas, interventional radiology, and pain management.

As hospitals continue to expand their number of ORs and procedural rooms to meet the needs of growing services, all existing space has become “prime real estate” for their expansions.

 

Block scheduling, open time, block release

Surgical block time is the process of assigning OR resources to a surgeon or group of surgeons for a period of time, on a specific day. Staff, equipment, and ORs are allocated, and surgeons can schedule cases one after another to fill the designated time.

The goal of block scheduling is to utilize as much OR time that is available to actively fulfill cases. According to the survey:

• 88% of responding facilities have a surgical block policy

• 7% have assigned blocks on weekends.

Governance of block time is often the responsibility of a committee comprising the chief of surgery, chief of anesthesia, and nursing director of perioperative services. A representative of a senior team may also be included as an ad hoc member. Authority is granted to this committee to implement top-down decisions, which are often reported to the overall perioperative governing committee to keep the OR staff abreast of changes.

The surgical block committee is tasked with the decision-making process of utilizing the OR department to its fullest capacity most efficiently while understanding any limitations and/or constraints that might pose a challenge (eg, lack of staff). This includes:

• assigning blocks to surgeons

• rescinding/limiting block time based on policy guidelines for utilization

• assigning time to new surgeons

• reviewing utilization of assigned blocks

• designating open and/or emergent blocks.

When developing an effective block scheduling policy, specific elements need to be addressed to govern this valuable resource equitably. These include:

• Are blocks granted to individual surgeons or specialties?

• How is utilization calculated and how often?

• Is utilization required to maintain a block?

• How are new surgeons assigned a block?

• When are assigned blocks released if unused?

• Will “flip” rooms be assigned and to whom?

Assigning open/add-on/emergent time (designation can be any of these terms) is essential in order to efficiently run the OR. When there are no open blocks assigned, scheduled cases then need to be moved, delayed, or cancelled to accommodate. As part of block policy, bumping of scheduled cases must be addressed in detail. Of those who responded, 77% assign open time.

Because the priority of the surgical department is to utilize its ORs to their fullest, blocks that are not utilized need to be released to other surgeons as soon as possible. According to the survey, 74% of respondents have automated their release time, and 54% have guidelines in place, by specialty, for when to release time.

 

Quality metrics: Delays and turnover

Tracking of first case on-time starts (FCOTS) has been a quality metric for the surgical department for the past 10 years. Many facilities still struggle with this metric.

The ability to track this metric in real time is key. While many of the electronic health record software options can provide this metric, many facilities have not fully developed strategies to address the FCOTS issues in a timely manner.

The implementation of daily huddles can help ensure that delays are reviewed in a timely manner with all relevant departments involved. Even a 5-minute huddle right after the first surgical cases of the day get underway can be used to review any late starts and immediately address the cause.

Survey results show that surgeons, patients, and Anesthesia personnel are the top three reasons for delays, with surgeons being the highest (63%). However, reasons behind delays will differ from facility to facility. A facility that has effectively addressed delays will have dug deeper, found specific causes (which may be individual or systemic), and sought sustainable solutions.

The second most common quality metric in the OR is turnover time that is measured wheels in to wheels out. This metric has shown steady improvement over the years because of the limited number of variables impacting the results.

Perioperative leadership started measuring room turnovers without considering specialties but soon understood that case type determines the length of turnover time. Turnover time by specialty was developed to better quantify the complexity of cases.

According to the survey:

• 64% of respondents have established turnover goals that are specialty specific

• 60% have ongoing projects to continue lowering times

• Current average turnover is 25.6 minutes; some facilities reported 5-minute turnovers while others reported up to 50 minutes

• Goals set for turnover averaged 22 minutes, with a range between 6 and 39 minutes.

Having turnover teams is one recommended process to help improve turnover times. Designated tasks for each member in the team will eliminate redundancy and make staff, individually and collectively, be accountable for efficiently completing the assigned tasks. According to the survey, the staff members included in such teams varied, with most facilities (96%) always including a circulating RN and surgical technician.

Ultimately, everyone in the perioperative staff want safe and stress-free surgical experiences for their patients. It is by listening to peers, asking what is working (or not working) for them, and understanding what makes their practices not just best but leading practices that any facility can use to improve its delivery of surgical care.

—Nancy Lombard, MS, RN, CNOR, is the owner of Lombard Consulting, LLC, “A passion for all things Periop.” Lombard’s career encompasses 40-plus years working all levels of perioperative services and consulting. For inquiries, she can be reached at lombardperiopconsulting@gmail.com.

 

Read part 1 here.

 

Resources

Douglas A J, Shoff R, Pankratz B, et al. Efficiency efforts improve staff satisfaction with turnover time. OR Manager. 2017;33(10):22–24.

Saver C. Room utilization rises with dynamic block scheduling. OR Manager. 2018;34(12):1,13–16.

Time Busters: A Lean team tackles OR turnover. OR Manager. July 2012.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat