The concept of the hybrid OR was born in the 1990s, but healthcare institutions were originally slow to adopt the model due, in part, to the initial sizable investment required. While there was a steady uptick in adoption around 2008, today there are still only some 100 hybrid ORs in the US. However, an increase in the number of minimally invasive surgeries is projected to augment hybrid OR industry growth.
A hybrid OR is a state-of-the-art space that combines a traditional OR with an image-guided interventional suite. Equipped with both surgical equipment and instrumentation—along with dedicated advanced imaging modalities—hybrid ORs are designed to accommodate traditional surgical, minimally invasive, and interventional procedures in the same space.
Hybrid ORs facilitate collaboration of various multidisciplinary teams such as surgeons from various disciplines such as trauma, interventional radiologists, gastroenterologists, and anesthesiologists. The main challenge that hybrid ORs tackle is the ability to undertake several complicated surgical procedures without having to receive advanced imaging or additional intervention in another location. Hybrid ORs allow clinicians to perform a combination of procedures more efficiently in one room, thereby enhancing productivity and the patient experience.
A cardiovascular procedure was what led to the development of the hybrid OR. Now, many cardiac procedures previously performed in Cath labs are instead done in hybrid ORs. While hybrid ORs are most often used for cardiac and vascular cases, they are hardly limited to those types of procedures.
For example, the use of hybrid ORs is well established for thoracic surgery, neurosurgery, and emergency vascular surgery; and it is emerging for surgeries such as endoscopic, endosurgical, laparoscopic, gynecological, urological, and orthopedic. Properly equipped, the hybrid OR can facilitate virtually any open and minimally invasive image-guided procedure.
A review of several hospital websites that have built hybrid ORs provides a good idea of some of the most common procedures presently performed in that setting. These include:
• revascularization, vascular intervention, and transcatheter aortic valve replacement
• congenital heart disease/coronary artery disease treatment
• endovascular aneurysm repair
• stent graft placement
• endoscopic approaches to bariatrics
• endoluminal resection and drainage
• oncology surgeries/tumor removal
• laparoscopic procedures such as appendectomy.
Thanks to their flexible design and multidisciplinary resources, more procedures are being performed safely and efficiently in hybrid ORs.
Hybrid ORs are typically larger than traditional ORs to accommodate more equipment and people. Most are about 1,200 square feet, house dozens of machines and imaging equipment, and offer enough space for anywhere from 10 to 20 clinical staff.
Like a traditional OR, the hybrid OR is outfitted with surgical equipment, instruments, surgical tables, OR lights, equipment management systems, and surgical booms. However, it also includes advanced imaging systems. Some hospitals choose a table with a fixed base and two tabletops—one for surgical procedures, one for imaging.
Imaging technology found in a hybrid OR is a key differentiator from a traditional OR, with a focus on technology that is highly portable and able to serve multiple purposes. For example, choosing a model that allows for both flexible and surgical endoscopy procedures to be performed in the same system is a smart investment. This allows physicians to swiftly adjust their endoscopic imaging tools and eliminates the need for multiple equipment towers—a space saver for potentially crowded hybrid OR environments.
In addition, hospitals should look for technology that enables direct real-time visualization of tissue oxygenation during endoluminal and laparoscopic procedures, to allow intraoperative decision-making with greater certainty and without the time limitation that indocyanine green can place on a procedure.
An integrated platform is ideal as the use of both flexible and rigid scopes becomes more widely adopted in hybrid OR settings for a range of digestive tract procedures, such as:
• sleeve gastrectomy or Roux-en-Y gastric bypass
• colectomy, where flexible endoscopy can be performed pre- and post-procedure to support surgical planning
• combined endoscopic-laparoscopic surgery, using both flexible and rigid scopes and a single tower.
For radiography imaging, hybrid ORs typically include both standard and portable X-ray, CT scanners, MRI machines, and built-in surgical C-arms. While fixed C-arms have been the traditional choice, some mid-sized and smaller hospitals may lack the space but still want to upgrade their ORs to a hybrid. Many of these hospitals opt for mobile C-arms as a more space efficient and affordable solution.
There is also a hybrid C-arm on the market that offers both fluoroscopy and extended radiography capabilities in one system. This unique design is a game-changer for smaller OR settings, as it allows for a broader range of imaging capabilities in a single device, potentially eliminating the need for an additional portable machine.
Long length detectors are another valuable imaging device for hybrid ORs—especially for scoliosis, spine, and leg procedures. Hospitals should look for detectors that offer intraoperative ability to acquire whole spine or leg length views instantly with a single low dose exposure to help verify measurements, angles, counts, hardware placement, and more. Digital image tools enables surgeons to use real-time images for guidance during complex procedures, enhancing visualization and leading to faster and more confident surgeries.
In a systematic review of 123 studies that described procedures being performed with the aid of 3D imaging in the hybrid OR, 76% mentioned key advantages to the use of hybrid ORs. Improved patient safety and improved accuracy were both mentioned as significant advantages.
Improved patient safety is partly associated with the patient not having to be transported to an imaging facility. Today, there are robust 3D visualization applications on the market that assist radiologists, cardiologists, surgeons, and other specialists by performing state-of-the-art image analysis that assist with interpretation, reporting, treatment, and surgical planning. Another advantage of hybrid ORs is shorter patient recovery due to less stress from multiple procedures. This contributes to decreased length of stay, as well as reduced risk of procedural complications, infections, and OR time.
The same study also indicates that providers recognize the cost savings that come with implementing a hybrid OR. While specialized surgery rooms like endoscopy suites have varying rates of utilization, hybrid ORs are rarely idle due to the number of procedures and surgical techniques they encompass. Additionally, because a hybrid OR features surgical equipment and imaging in one location, equipment or technology troubleshooting is only needed in one place versus two or more.
While there are multiple applications for hybrid ORs, trauma is one area where this model can be lifesaving. One research study explored the clinical impact of dedicated trauma hybrid ORs.
Hemorrhage accounts for some 40% of all trauma deaths, more than 80% of trauma deaths in the OR, and is the most common cause of potentially preventable death from trauma. In a retrospective analysis of 292 trauma patients undergoing immediate trauma surgery, researchers compared those who were treated in a hybrid OR versus those who were not. Implementation of a dedicated trauma hybrid OR was associated with earlier hemorrhage control and fewer early blood transfusions, infectious complications, and ventilator days.
While presently few US hospitals have a dedicated hybrid OR for trauma, this patient population can benefit from a hybrid model. In 2017, the University of Florida Health Shands Hospital opened a hybrid OR dedicated to trauma cases. Their trauma team performs interventional radiology procedures like resuscitative endovascular balloon occlusion of the aorta, as well as angiographic embolization for pelvic bleeding and liver and spleen injuries. In one room, the team can care for complicated patients with multisystem trauma who may require multiple procedures—while avoiding the risks that come with moving seriously injured patients.
Multidisciplinary teams of trauma, neuro, orthopedic, and vascular surgeons; cardiologists; interventional radiologists and gastroenterologists; and more are able to work in tandem on patients with complex time-sensitive problems. A car crash victim with both a possible brain bleed and a spinal injury, for example, can have each addressed simultaneously—with no need to transport the patient to imaging and back to the OR.
In other words, the hybrid OR eliminates the necessity to compromise care of one injury over another because the team can address multiple issues concurrently. In trauma cases, when every minute matters, that can be lifesaving.
With invasive open surgical procedures on the decline and both minimally invasive and non-invasive procedures on the rise, there is a growing need for enhanced surgical visualization. Add to this, clinicians are facing an aging population with more co-morbidities, resulting in more complex procedures.
Experts believe the role of the hybrid OR in the minimally invasive surgical landscape will continue to grow. Sophisticated imaging technology will continue to play a critical role in the success of the hybrid OR—supporting clinical teams across multiple disciplines with the promise of improving patient outcomes.
—Anthony Borrelli is executive director of endoscopy product and marketing and Rob Fabrizio is director of strategic marketing, diagnostic imaging, at FUJIFILM Healthcare Americas Corporation.
Van Pelt J. Hybrid ORs: What’s behind the increasing demand? OR Manager. August 2013.
Wood E. Clear vision critical to successful hybrid OR development. OR Manager. August 2013.