Perioperative leaders often have to make critical decisions, not just in the middle of an operational crisis but also somewhere in the edges—the routine but still high-stakes moments where leaders need to adjust resources or absorb costs under tight constraints. The economic margin for error continues to narrow, and many of the traditional options leaders once relied on to manage labor pressure—bonus programs, on-call pools, and retention incentives, to name a few—have become depleted, cost-restrictive, or insufficient for today’s demands.
In a year already marked by tighter reimbursements and financially turbulent disruptions, labor costs still are a major pain point in healthcare operations. In most surgical settings, labor is the largest operational expense year over year. Undoubtedly, perioperative leaders must find ways to adopt cost control strategies and innovative staffing models. As one example, a leading children’s hospital reported a dramatic reduction in agency staffing hours from May 2022 to May 2023 and a 25% drop in first-year nurse turnover, demonstrating how a phased pullback on contract labor can deliver stability. Additionally, national reporting in early 2025 notes systems that faced ballooning travel nurse costs ($51 billion in 2023 alone) are now prioritizing investments in predictive scheduling, internal float pools, and per‑diem staffing models to regain control and improve retention.
Optimizing the staff schedule while maintaining profitable case volume and throughput is key. But are perioperative leaders demonstrating cost literacy and cross-functional agility when managing and choosing labor? Are they utilizing predictive tools and gathering actionable insights when tackling these challenges? To examine how leaders are rising to the occasion, OR Manager launched two polls in July focused on labor cost containment and staffing flexibility. As with the previous month, the results—gathered from surveying experienced perioperative leaders with direct operational oversight, most holding over 10 years of leadership experience and working across OR management, outpatient surgery, postanesthesia care, and sterile processing—offer a revealing look at the tactics and instincts shaping OR decision-making today. The findings reveal a cohort that is highly pragmatic, increasingly data-aware, and looking beyond traditional solutions to stay operationally resilient.
Let’s take a closer look. (Note that totals may not add up to a 100 for questions the respondents could select all of the options that applied.)
When asked about strategies used over the past 6 months to manage labor costs, 79% of respondents identified two equally dominant approaches: adjusting staffing models or shift coverage, and cross-training existing team members. These tactics highlight a broader shift toward structural flexibility, with leaders increasingly favoring adaptable, internally driven solutions that allow them to match staffing to demand while limiting reliance on external or overtime-heavy fixes.
The majority (71%) also reported offering voluntary low-census days or reduced hours, while 42% had delayed hiring for open roles. Notably, only 4% of respondents said they had implemented formal retention incentives, such as bonuses or recognition programs, suggesting most facilities are focusing on immediate cost containment rather than long-term labor stabilization. These responses reveal a pragmatic, if reactive, approach to financial management. Leaders appear focused on reshuffling internal resources, avoiding layoffs or dramatic measures, but not yet on investing broadly in systemic retention or engagement strategies.
Meanwhile, more than a third (38%) of respondents said they are asked to justify labor-related expenses, like overtime or agency use, on a monthly basis. An additional 21% reported occasional reviews. This frequency signals that cost accountability is now a routine part of leadership considerations, reinforcing the need for data-driven insights and clear documentation. Despite the scrutiny, leaders generally expressed confidence in their ability to balance care and cost. A combined 79% said they feel either “somewhat confident” or “very confident,” with many relying on a mix of historical data, team input, and benchmarking.
The first July poll tested respondents by posing different leadership scenarios designed to prompt critical thinking and real-world problem-solving. In a scenario where an OR is consistently over budget due to heavy agency staff use, nearly 89% said the first step should be analyzing case load patterns and building a phased plan to reduce reliance, rather than resorting to sweeping cuts. This choice shows a preference for strategic resolutions over reactionary measures. It also recognizes that understanding demand is key to sustainable workforce planning, whereas reactive cuts risk compromising both safety and staff morale.
Similarly, when asked how to address high overtime among a small group of experienced nurses, 100% of respondents chose cross-training additional staff to expand coverage depth, instead of capping hours or offering bonuses. Cross-training emerged as the unanimous response likely because it not only increases flexibility and distributes workload more evenly—helping to curb overtime—but it also builds long-term staffing capacity. That said, its success hinges on thoughtful implementation, with sufficient time, resources, and clear expectations needed to ensure cross-training strengthens the staff rather than overburden them.
As a whole, the results of the first poll reveal a key insight: while current operational decisions are leaning toward reactive, short-term fixes, the responses to the hypothetical scenarios tell a different story. When removed from immediate constraints, perioperative leaders are opting for scalable, sustainable solutions that build team resilience. Actual decision-making is clearly being impacted by real operational pressure that is keeping them from being as proactive as they wish.
The scenario responses reveal an appetite to lead differently. OR leaders want to treat staffing challenges not as isolated problems, but as opportunities to improve workflow, utilization of resources, and team performance over time. Today’s leaders are not lacking vision. Even in the face of tightening budgets and accountability pressures, their strategic mindset is ready to emerge when conditions allow.
In the second July poll, perioperative leaders were asked how flexible and proactive their teams are when it comes to staffing. Results revealed a growing reliance on float pools and flex teams—but not without significant challenges.
While 24% of respondents reported using float or flex staff weekly, a notable 27% said they never use them. Another 27% said usage was only “occasional” or “rare.” The split responses suggest varying levels of consistency in training, support, or infrastructure to support flexible staffing models. That nearly as many leaders “never” use float staff as those who use them weekly could mean differences in onboarding processes, workflow alignment, leadership experience, resource availability, or even case volume. For instance, facilities with stable, predictable volumes should be seeing little need for flex teams.
But some simply lack access to a reliable float pool. When asked that very question—what their biggest obstacle with float/flex team integration is—the respondents cited inconsistent availability (51%) and lack of specialized training (31%) among float staff. Low familiarity with local workflows and resistance from core teams also were noted. When asked how to best prepare float staff to avoid workflow disruptions, 66% of respondents said dedicated onboarding shifts are the most effective solution, followed by assigning easier cases to help them adapt (28%). Almost no one supported skipping onboarding or relying solely on quick day-of walk-throughs.
The emphasis on onboarding is likely connected to deeper implementation challenges. The top obstacles to successful float team integration cited earlier—inconsistent availability and lack of specialized training—are not only hindering float staff performance but are almost certainly fueling negative feedback coming from those teams. When float staff are placed into unfamiliar environments without proper preparation, it creates frustration on both sides, as core teams feel disrupted while float teams feel unsupported. So, when 86% of respondents said the best move when receiving negative feedback from flex teams is to develop a quick-reference guide or orientation checklist, it reinforced the importance of structured onboarding and communication. Effective integration hinges both on having float staff available and on setting them up for success. Perioperative leaders increasingly recognize that structure, clarity, and early investment in onboarding are essential for building a flex system that works.
Despite the growing complexity of staffing needs, only 17% of respondents reported currently using predictive scheduling tools—whether manual models such as AORN’s staffing formula or vendor-supplied automated technology (8.5% each). Interestingly enough, almost half (43%) said they are actively exploring such tools, although 34% said procuring predictive scheduling assistance is “not a priority.”
This represents a major gap, but also an opportunity. Given the level of operational complexity in today’s ORs, leaders who harness predictive data to model case demand and staffing could dramatically reduce both costs and stress on their teams. Beyond immediate efficiency and scheduling accuracy gains, this capability offers a distinct competitive edge. Facilities that can anticipate needs and staff accordingly are better positioned to maintain throughput, retain talent, and adapt quickly to delays and other disruptions without compromising care quality.
The second July poll again tested respondents’ critical thinking and decision-making instincts. One scenario posed multiple last-minute staff call-outs, for which the most proactive move—selected by 59% of respondents—was to use attendance data to build smarter scheduling buffers. Meanwhile, 31% chose to increase reliance on PRN staff, while only 10% suggested mandating weekend on-call coverage. This shows an inclination toward data-driven contingency planning, as well as a reluctance to overburden core staff with inflexible mandates.
This month’s results paint perioperative leaders as data-aware, operationally flexible, and team-minded. While most facilities are not yet fully embracing advanced scheduling tools or retention strategies, there is a strong emphasis on cross-training and structured onboarding as levers for cost control and care continuity. OR leaders are not shying away from tough decisions. They are responding to rising demands with strategic adaptation and helping their teams to recalibrate as needed.
As surgical departments continue to see cost pressures, staffing complexity, and rising accountability, the insights from these polls offer actionable intelligence for OR leaders nationwide. Whether they are tightening budgets or training their next flex team, the metrics presented here highlight the value of planning ahead, investing in people, and using data to drive decisions.
Stay tuned for the August polls, coming soon on the OR Manager Pulse Check page. Insightful responses like the above show how scenario-based polling prompts leaders to more thoughtfully evaluate their own practices, helping them consider broader implications and benchmark decisions against their peers. The result? Engaged perioperative leaders who are equipped with the perspective and knowledge needed to lead through change with greater confidence and precision.
—Tarsilla Moura is content director of OR Manager.
How to reduce contract labor. Children’s Hospital Association. February 9, 2024.