August 21, 2020

Pandemic raises OR nurse recruitment, management challenges

By: Cynthia Saver, MS, RN
Share

The COVID-19 pandemic continues to wreak havoc on OR managers’ lives, according to the 2020 annual OR Manager Salary/Career Survey. Many new developments related to the pandemic have occurred and continue to evolve since the spring and early summer, when the survey was deployed. However, the concerns stated by many respondents are still valid and likely are similar to those of many of their peers nationwide.

When asked how the pandemic has affected facilities and staffs, respondents put staffing-related issues (for example, furloughs, redeployment) and decreased surgical volume at the top of the list (sidebar, “COVID-19 effects”). In addition, 30% of managers reported lower surgical volume in the past 12 months, versus 18% in 2019. That 30% figure is not far from the 36% reporting lower volume in 2010, which reflected the effects of the 2008 recession.

Despite decreased surgical volume and upheavals in staffing caused by the pandemic, the survey also reveals some positive trends. Compensation has improved: 78% of managers earn salaries of $100,000 or more annually, up from 65% in 2019, and 46% report total compensation of at least $150,000 or more, compared to 36% last year. And although stress levels are high, OR leaders remain a satisfied group, with 77% viewing their jobs favorably (vs 70% in 2019).

More survey highlights

Other key findings of the survey include:

• Staff may be slightly less mobile. For example, RN and surgical technologist (ST) turnover for the past 12 months has stayed the same for 61% of OR leaders. In 2019, just 50% of leaders reported such stability for RNs and 53% for STs. That’s good news, given that 63% (vs 67% in 2019) of respondents are having more difficulty recruiting experienced RNs, and 56% (vs 51% in 2019) are finding recruiting STs to be more difficult.

• More than half (52%) of OR leaders use data analytics to help with surgery scheduling.

• The adoption of care models has yet to gain momentum, with 42% reporting that none of the care model options listed in the survey, including Enhanced Recovery After Surgery (ERAS) and the Perioperative Surgical Home (PSH), have been implemented or are planned to be implemented in the next 6 months. ERAS remains the most popular model, with 46% reporting adoption or planned adoption.

• Only 20% plan to add ORs within the next year.

Here is a closer look at other findings, including data showing trends over the past decade.

 

Staffing changes

Despite a reduction in overall mobility, staff transitions plague nearly one-fourth of OR leaders, with 22% reporting increased RN turnover in the past 12 months (vs 34% in 2019), and 24% reporting increased ST turnover (vs 29% in 2019). The average turnover rate was 8% for RNs and 7% for STs.

These numbers are strikingly different from a decade ago, when only 7% of respondents experienced increased RN turnover and 10% reported increased ST turnover. In 2010, the average turnover rate was 7% for both RNs and STs.

The percentage of open full-time equivalent (FTE) positions for RNs in the past 12 months increased for 30% of respondents, down from 37% last year; the number of open positions stayed the same for 51%, up from 41% last year. In all, 23% reported no open RN positions, compared to 27% last year. The average number of currently open RN positions was 6.

A third of OR leaders said the percentage of open FTE positions for STs increased in the past 12 months, comparable to the 34% reported last year; slightly more than half (52%) said it had remained the same, up from 47% in 2019. Overall, 29% had no open ST positions (vs 32% in 2019). The average number of currently open ST positions was 4.

Again, the picture was much different in 2010, when just 11% reported an increase in open FTE positions for both RNs and STs, and the percentage of those reporting no vacancies was significantly higher: 54% for RNs and 65% for STs. The average number of open positions was 2 for both RNs and STs.

The most commonly reported staffing change in the past 12 months was reducing use of overtime, which increased from 34% in 2019 to 43% this year. Coming in second, at 36%, was hiring more direct care staff—down slightly from 40% last year, but comparable to 2018 (35%) and 2017 (34%).

More than one-fourth (27%) reduced use of agency and travel staff, up from 20% last year. Nearly a quarter (23%) of respondents have required staff to take time off without pay, compared with only 14% in 2019 and 19% in 2015; but this percentage was 24% in 2017 and 39% in 2010.

More than 20 OR leaders answered “other” to this question, with most specifying changes related to COVID-19, such as furloughing and redeploying staff.

Staff recruitment largely still a challenge

Recruiting experienced OR nurses remains a challenge, with nearly two-thirds (63%) saying difficulty has increased in the past 12 months, compared to 67% in 2019. Only 8% said it was easier (vs 5% last year). OR leaders are having better luck with new or inexperienced OR nurses: 31% (vs 28% in 2019) said it has been easier to recruit this group; only 15% said it was more difficult, down from 26% in 2019.

Recruiting was a bit easier 10 years ago, when 26% of respondents found recruiting experienced OR nurses to be more difficult.

When evaluating candidates, 64% of OR leaders require an associate degree in nursing (ADN), compared to 59% in 2019 and 57% in 2018, and 41% require a baccalaureate degree in nursing (BSN), comparable to the 45% reported last year and 44% in 2018. Only 10% require certification (vs 12% in 2019), and 6% don’t require either a degree or certification, down from 10% last year.

As in 2019, more than half (56% vs 51% last year and 38% in 2015) of respondents are finding it more difficult to recruit STs, and only 12% said it was easier, compared with 9% in 2019 and 17% in 2015.

Care delivery

Nearly half (46%) of respondents said that surgical volume increased in the past 12 months, compared to 40% in 2019. The pandemic may have affected the higher percentage of those reporting an increase (30% vs 18% in 2019).

ERAS remains the most popular of the care model options asked about in the survey, with 46% (vs 53% in 2019) saying it has been implemented or is planned to be implemented in the next 6 months. The next highest was Accountable Care Organizations (25%), followed by clinically integrated networks (17%) and the PSH (15%).

Artificial intelligence (AI) has exploded over the past year, so we asked respondents about its impact on surgery in general and on their own organizations. In all, 214 OR leaders responded to this open-ended question, with most reporting that AI has had no or minimal impact on their organization. However, a few are already putting it to use. One noted: “[It] will be used to start our new total joint program. AI will be used to select patients who will be able to go home the day of surgery.” Another OR leader reported: “[It is] presently helping predict which patients can go home after surgery instead of staying in the hospital.”

Several commented on the possible value of AI, including reducing length of stay, predicting case times more accurately, and improving scheduling, which, in turn, could improve productivity and revenue.

Other comments were:

• “I see it as a positive thing: I think this pandemic has shown us what we can do. Hope we expand on this more.”

• “Reading about AI brings many questions about how soon it will take over healthcare, especially radiology and other tech type jobs. It may eliminate rural healthcare workers.”

• “Will affect diagnostics for years to come; will be used in GI endoscopy to analyze polyps and polyp removed borders.”

• “Eventual elimination of surgical tech jobs to be replaced by AI.”

• “It can help take out the guesswork and perfect certain things to provide safer quality care utilizing data to analyze and act upon.”

We also asked how the migration of traditionally inpatient procedures (for example, total joints, spine, and cardiac procedures) from the hospital to ambulatory care settings was affecting OR leaders and their organizations. Again, 214 responded. Most are not seeing many effects, although some anticipate that could change in the future.

Others report decreased volume, and some are in transition so were unable to respond. One respondent called the trend “disruptive, challenging,” and another said it had been “financially devastating.”

Some trends have changed rather a lot in the past 10 years, whereas others have stayed relatively stable. However, COVID-19 continues to have a dramatic impact on the healthcare industry.

Although it’s hard to know how different OR managers’ jobs will look a year from now, it’s safe to say that skills such as resiliency and creativity will be more important than ever in leading their teams through these challenging times. ✥

–Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat