Not all hospitals have a preadmission testing (PAT) process, and even when they do, communication breakdowns and inefficiencies can make the process ineffective. Recognizing that the PAT process at Yale New Haven Hospital, New Haven, Connecticut, needed a makeover was the first step in launching an improvement project that led to better staffing, more patients optimized for surgery, reduced delays, and greater satisfaction for staff and physicians.
“There was a lack of collaboration between the surgeon, anesthesiologist, and nursing team,” says Lori Ryder, MSN, RN, CNML, nursing director of ambulatory services. “It was inefficient, with NPs [nurse practitioners] reviewing charts for 30 minutes before seeing patients because patients weren’t assigned and no prep was done before patients arrived for their clinic visit.”
Other problems were exclusion of surgical outpatients, vague guidelines for who should receive surgical optimization, lack of information technology (IT) support for the process, and poor follow-up to verify that patients seen in the clinic completed their testing.
To accomplish the makeover, Ryder collaborated with Jill Zafar, MD, assistant professor of anesthesiology at Yale University and medical director for presurgical evaluation at Yale New Haven Hospital. The two worked with a multidisciplinary committee consisting of surgeons, anesthesiologists, NPs, and perioperative nurses to design a preoperative pathway, guidelines, and expectations for PAT.
The team first created the following vision of what they wanted to achieve:
• optimize all surgical patients by using a robust preoperative assessment, best practice alerts, and algorithms
• develop guidelines and expectations to support an efficient, patient-centered process
• ensure all patients are clinically ready and well informed for the day of surgery
• use electronic health record (EHR) functionality to streamline and automate the process
• improve communication across disciplines
• have all healthcare providers work to the top of their scope of practice.
To achieve the vision, the team collaborated with the anesthesia department in developing evidence-based preoperative testing guidelines.
The new preoperative process and guidelines were then presented to the chief of surgery for input and support before being endorsed by the perioperative executive leadership council. “Surgeons were receptive because they were ordering tests that weren’t necessary to prevent cases from getting cancelled,” Ryder says.
The groundwork the team laid helped build a case to fund EHR revisions and hire additional staff, but Ryder needed to do more. “I was first told I had to be budget neutral,” Ryder says.
In response, she researched the benefits of a PAT clinic (http://anesthesiology.pubs.asahq.org/article.aspx?articleid=2536210), which she included in the business plan, along with surgical volume (both surgical inpatient and outpatient) and length of time needed for each of the following: preoperative nursing phone call; NP chart review, clinic visit, and follow-up; and nursing postoperative phone call.
Ryder says one of the most important steps was improving collaboration with surgeons’ office staff. That included asking office staff to tell patients they might receive multiple calls (including from PAT staff), all designed to keep them safe. When the surgeon’s office staff have a question, they now know who to call to resolve any problems quickly and collaboratively. Creating a process map with clear role expectations helped standardize the workflow.
On the PAT side, the staff committed to ordering tests based on evidence, making preoperative calls 2 to 3 weeks before surgery, following up on preoperative testing and consultations, and streamlining patient instructions. To better accommodate patient schedules, staff agreed to change their hours and make preoperative (and postoperative) calls on Saturdays. “We don’t schedule phone calls, but instead leave a message asking the patient to call back,” Ryder says.
Dr Zafar says that IT improvements played a big role in streamlining the process: “We tried to automate things as much as possible to avoid scraps of paper being sent from person to person.” Testing and clinical decision algorithms were put into the EHR so that the PAT staff could easily access them. “The system prompts the nurse about what should happen at each step of the process, although the nurse can use clinical judgment and override as needed,” Dr Zafar says.
Other improvements include:
• a phone system where all calls are routed to a single number that any nurse can answer, essentially creating a call center
• an outgoing automated message nurses can send when they get a patient’s voicemail
• real-time work lists for NPs, based on evaluation and testing that patients need
• work lists that clerical assistants use to schedule appointments
• follow-up reports indicating what needs to be done for each patient so all consults and testing are reviewed and patients don’t fall through the cracks
• individualized preoperative instructions sent via a patient portal
• updated website
• automated text message with a day-in-the-life video showing what the patient will experience on the day of surgery.
All relevant information related to surgery is now included in one place, called Procedure Pass, in the EHR. The history and physical and consent form are linked to this section as well.
“IT optimizations were extensive and costly, but they were key for success,” Ryder says, adding that an IT team member was assigned to the initiative.
Not all patients are seen in the clinic; most are screened only by phone. “Virtual patients are sent to get their blood drawn near their home, and the results are sent to us,” Dr Zafar says.
The team created an algorithm for the PAT process that was rolled out by service line, starting with bariatric surgery because the chief was one of the project’s champions (sidebar below).
The rollout started in August 2015, and the final service lines will be added in 2018, although most service lines were added within the first 12 months. The team created a timeline for when services would be rolled out. For example, 3 months after bariatric surgery was launched, the team expanded their efforts to spine and vascular, and 3 months after that, thoracic, oncology, and urology came online. Service lines with more high-risk patients received higher priority in the schedule.
The staggered launch allowed the team to discuss expectations for each service line, which had varying needs. For example, the spine surgeons wanted coagulation studies on all their patients, so this was built into the EHR algorithms.
To support the process, the PAT center now has a director of nursing, medical director, anesthesiologist, five NPs, one to two anesthesia residents, 13 RNs, two patient care associates, three secretaries, and a patient service manager who oversees all staff and daily operations. When the PAT clinic originated 10 years ago, it started with only two NPs, one anesthesiologist, one patient care associate, and one RN, who was shared with the postanesthesia care unit.
Currently, 88% of elective surgical patients are seen by PAT, with the goal of 100% in the next few months. Further expansion to endoscopy and procedures done outside of the OR is also being planned. “We screen about 32,000 to 35,000 patients each year [by phone or in-person visit],” Dr Zafar says. “Some doctors call and ask for patients to be seen today, and we never refuse. Fortunately, it’s not a big problem.”
The new process resulted in dramatic decreases in various parameters, including day of surgery preoperative laboratory tests. For bariatric surgery, this went from 22% before implementation to 0 to 8% after. For both bariatric and spine surgery, the number of surgery cancellations attributed to PAT were virtually eliminated. The length of a patient’s visit in the PAT declined from 90 minutes to 60 minutes, and the team is now targeting 45 minutes.
The reports generated to track progress helped identify needed refinements. For example, the number of preoperative electrocardiograms (ECGs) done the day of bariatric surgery spiked from 5% to 11%. “We realized we needed more places to do ECGs,” Dr Zafar says. “We worked with the director of labs to add ECG testing to their ambulatory sites.”
Tracking results is key because patients aren’t billed for their preoperative evaluation. “We have to show value in other ways,” Ryder says. Outcomes include reductions in day-of-surgery cancellations, first-case start delays, and preoperative testing on the day of surgery. “We’re working on showing improvement in patient care and cost savings in other ways, too,” she adds.
The team continues to look for ways to improve, plan, and adjust to OR volume fluctuations, and enhance patient portal participation. Plans are in the works for a patient questionnaire that can be completed through the portal.
Ryder and Dr Zafar say that past and future success depends on having a strong partner. “Working together, we were able to change the old philosophy and build something new and effective,” Ryder says. ✥
Wanderer J P, Sweitzer B J, Bader A M, et al. The many benefits of a preoperative clinic. Anesthesiology. 2016. http://anesthesiology.pubs.asahq.org/article.aspx?articleid=2536210.
Zafar D, Ryder L. Preadmission testing redesign. OR Business Management Conference. 2018.