Healthcare workers are at risk for bloodborne pathogen exposures in areas ranging from the clinic to the OR—both inpatient and outpatient settings. Such exposures not only cause anxiety, they cost an estimated $3,000 to $5,000 per exposure for things such as baseline and follow-up laboratory testing, treatment of exposed personnel, loss of productivity, and potential loss of career as well as other societal costs.
The risk of exposure comes from needlestick or sharps injuries (percutaneous injuries) in which penetration or stabbing of the skin by a needle or sharp object may result in direct contact with blood or other bodily fluids.
Individual risk depends on whether the needle was hollow bore, deep penetration occurred, or visible blood on the needle was present or was in an artery or vein.
“While all injuries put the employee at risk, the hollow bore needle carries the most risk of exposure,” says Julie Gibbons, BSN, RN, CIC, manager of infection prevention and control at UnityPoint Health in Des Moines. Splashes carry some risk, but the higher risk comes from needles and sharp injuries, she adds. “The top three pathogens we are concerned about include Hepatitis B, Hepatitis C, and HIV [human immunodeficiency virus].”
Hepatitis B poses the highest risk, but there is a vaccine for it, Gibbons says. Baby Boomers are at highest risk for contracting Hepatitis C, for which there is no prophylaxis.
Although HIV has the lowest risk of transmission, it is a concern. People are living longer after being treated for HIV, and they may not have detectable levels of the virus in the blood, she explains.
What are OR leaders doing to manage this risk? What actions should they take to make their work environments safer? This article attempts to answer these questions, raise awareness of this safety threat, and offer strategies for risk reduction.
A 1981 study by McCormick and Maki found only 8.2% of healthcare workers reported sharps injuries, and 23.7% of reported injuries happened during disposal of used needles. Two years later, the first healthcare worker contracted HIV after an occupational exposure, and suddenly the reality of needlestick consequences was in the global spotlight.
In a follow-up study by McCormick et al. in 1991, 18.7% of healthcare workers—which at the time represented more than 1 million workers—reported needlestick injuries. Despite petitions from healthcare workers, however, action was not taken immediately. The Needlestick Safety and Protection Act was not signed into law until November 2000.
The law requires safer needle devices, employee input, and records of all sharps injuries in healthcare settings. In the 5 years after the law was signed, sharps injuries declined as much as 31.6%, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). This was a promising trend, but in the surgical setting, injuries increased as much as 6.5% during this same period.
Current data suggest that exposures have either plateaued or continued to increase in certain areas. In fact, an estimated 385,000 needlesticks occur in the US each year, with more than 400,000 million blood draws. Even more troubling, as many as 50% of needlesticks go unreported, which makes it hard to measure the actual number of needlesticks.
“Overall, we are seeing an increase in sharps exposure, but we track and trend the data quarterly,” says Jill Sabin, MSN, RN, employee health and safety coordinator in the employee health and safety department at UnityPoint Health. Reports are emailed to leaders on a regular basis for follow-up, she notes.
“When we have an exposure, we do a root cause analysis to see if there is a pattern. We identify whether personal protective equipment [PPE] was used, if distractions were a factor, and if policies and procedures were followed,” Sabin says.
UnityPoint recently developed a policy for eye and facial protection against bloodborne pathogen exposure. The policy outlines specific tasks and says employees must wear face shields while performing those tasks when it is suggested they do so.
Tasks requiring face shields include:
• performing respiratory care (intubation, extubations, tracheal care, suctioning, assessing patients with active/productive cough, collecting respiratory specimens)
• performing bedside care likely to generate bodily fluid splashes, such as removing IVs
• performing any procedures likely to generate splashes
• emptying or transporting open containers of fluids and specimens
• managing patients during trauma or codes
• managing patients who spit.
Tasks for which face shields are strongly recommended include:
• performing respiratory care such as turning and other tasks with low risk for splashes
• performing bedside care that poses low risk for splashes
• performing procedures completed in any location with low risk for splashes.
Additional guidelines state personal eyeglasses and contacts are not considered adequate eye protection, and face shields need to be changed between patients. Noncompliance is subject to disciplinary action.
The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) standard 1910.1030(d)(3)(ii) regarding use of PPE was used as a reference for this policy, along with 1910.1030(d)(3)(x), which speaks specifically to the use of masks and eye protection when the potential for splashes exists.
Historically, the OR has been second only to patient rooms in the number of reported sharps-related injuries. The environment presents the perfect storm of intensity, blood, and sharps and other devices that can cause injury. In addition, stress, pressure to turn over rooms, understaffing, fatigue, and lack of training increase the potential for injury.
Most sharps injuries in the OR are caused by suture needles, followed by scalpel blades and syringes. Hands-free zones have proven to be a best practice for preventing injures, but compliance can be challenging.
“Ambulatory surgery centers [ASCs] are a fast-paced environment, so employees need to be knowledgeable regarding the facility’s exposure control procedures, and these practices must become routine. In the surgical team environment, everyone must adhere to the practice,” says Jan Kleinhesselink, BSHM, RN, CPHQ, chief clinical officer at Lincoln Surgical Hospital (Charon Shared Services), Lincoln, Nebraska, and a surveyor for the Accreditation Association for Ambulatory Healthcare (AAAHC).
Sabin says being distracted or in a hurry can contribute to noncompliance. “Staff go on autopilot and don’t pay attention to their surroundings, or their patient may be in distress, so they skip PPE.” She notes that it’s critical to have PPE readily available in a consistent location to help staff comply with use.
Kleinhesselink agrees: “Employees practice may drift, and they may lose awareness of the exposure risks associated with their role. It’s similar to running a yellow light; when nothing bad happens, we become complacent. When that occurs, employees may not consistently follow recommended exposure control practices.”
To ensure compliance, Kleinhesselink suggests auditing and confirming that department leadership is aware of daily practice.
“When an injury does occur, it is necessary to review the incident and analyze processes; action taken should be based on problems identified,” she says. “Formal audits are important, but if you witness an employee drifting from procedure, for example, wearing glasses instead of goggles, coach the employee at the time. Discuss behavior and determine if barriers and process issues need to be addressed to reduce the risk of recurrence.”
Kleinhesselink says exposure control practices increasingly are a focus at ASCs—especially the use of PPE during the instrument decontamination process.
UnityPoint requires annual education for bloodborne pathogen exposure and collaborates with infection control when changes in policy, procedures, or equipment occur.
“Ongoing training and monitoring of compliance with exposure control practices are key, particularly when employees in ASCs often have multiple roles, which can include handling contaminated items,” Kleinhesselink says.
It is recommended that facilities have policies and procedures for exposure to bloodborne pathogens that define what testing is needed for the employee and the patient, and what information is given to the patient. The need for follow-up testing will depend on the results of initial tests.
“The testing can be an emotional experience for the employee,” Gibbons says. “It has the potential to impact the lives of our healthcare workers and their families.”
It can take weeks or months to confirm that the injured person is free of infection, and—depending on the type of exposure—testing may need to continue for a prolonged period of time. Employee assistance programs may be of value if the need for counseling is identified. Managers need to maintain communication with employees who will require ongoing testing.
UnityPoint has a Bloodborne Pathogen Committee with representatives from all disciplines who monitor all exposures, develop education for new devices, and coordinate projects related to bloodborne pathogens, Sabin says. Leadership is also represented to help reinforce changes in policy.
Outpatient clinics tend to have more needlesticks because of the volume of blood draws. ASCs and other places where surgery is performed have many IV starts, so using best practices in sharps handling is a must.
Best practices for sharps handling in any area include:
• Always use PPE.
• Do not uncover or unwrap a sharp object until it is time to use it.
• Keep the object pointed away from you at all times.
• Never recap or bend a sharp object.
• Keep fingers away from the tip of the object.
• If the object is reusable, put it in a secure place.
• Use the neutral zone to hand off sharps, and announce when you are handing off.
Best practices for sharps disposal include:
• Never put your hands in a sharps container.
• If the container is full or has protruding items, call to have the container removed.
• Make sure sharps containers are at eye level.
ASCs may have fewer resources than hospitals, so they should appoint a staff person to lead efforts to prevent bloodborne pathogen exposures—someone who is a champion for education and compliance.
It is also recommended that bloodborne pathogen exposure be reported monthly to the board and facility owners. If necessary, a gap analysis can be performed to assist in the development of policies and procedures.
An excellent guide for assessing an infection prevention program is available from the CDC: https://www.cdc.gov/hai/settings/outpatient/outpatient-care-guidelines.html. In addition, the AAAHC has resources that include a patient safety toolkit for safe injection practices, Kleinhesselink notes (https://www.aaahc.org). And OSHA provides an online toolkit, Worker Safety in Hospitals (https://www.osha.gov/dsg/hospitals/).
A multitude of equipment is available to help reduce exposure to bloodborne pathogens: blunt suture needles; safety scalpel devices; safety engineered syringes, needles, and IV catheters; and sharps containment systems.
Adopting these can be challenging because of the training and education needed for each device. When completing an annual sharps evaluation, it can be hard to find an acceptable replacement for a sharps device because of provider preference and the need for precision, especially in the surgical field, Kleinhesselink notes.
Using the neutral zone technique and no-touch technique are effective ways to handle sharps.
Sabin offers this advice to reduce exposure risks:
• Stop and ask for help if you are not familiar with the equipment.
• Hardwire the use of PPE.
• Avoid distractions; pay attention to your environment.
• Follow policies and procedures in handling and disposing of sharps.
Following steps like these can go a long way toward enhancing the safety of patients and staff alike. ✥
–Amy L. Bethel, MPA, RN, NE-BC, is an independent consultant in Des Moines, Iowa.
Anderson J M. Needlestick injuries: Prevention and education key. J Controvers Med Claims. 2008;15(3):12. https://go.galegroup.com/ps/anonymous?id=GALE%7CA183042740&sid=googleScholar&v=2.1&it=r&linkaccess=abs&issn=15301060&p=AONE&sw=w.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Guide to infection prevention for outpatient settings: Minimum expectations for safe care. https://www.cdc.gov/hai/settings/outpatient/outpatient-care-guidelines.html.
Cunningham T R, Sinclair R C, Harney A M G, et al. A safety information campaign to reduce sharps injuries: Results from stop sticks campaign. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Stacy_Smallwood/publication/233657999_A_safety_information_campaign_to_reduce_sharps_injuries_Results_from_the_Stop_Sticks_campaign/.
Daley K A, Laramie A K, Mitchell A H. Sharps injuries remain major occupational safety concern for healthcare personnel. Infect Control Today. Published online November 20, 2017. https://www.infectioncontroltoday.com/sharps-safety/sharps-injuries-remain-major-occupational-safety-concern-healthcare-personnel.
https://medlineplus.gov/ency/patientinstructions/000444.htm.
Jagger J, Berguer R, Phillips E K, et al. Increase in sharps injuries in surgical settings versus nonsurgical settings after passage of national needlestick legislation. J Am Coll Surg. 2010;210(4):496-502.
McCormick R D, Maki D G. Epidemiology of needle-stick injuries in hospital personnel. Am J Med. 1981;70(4):928-932.
McCormick R D, Meisch M G, Ircink F G, et al. Epidemiology of hospital sharps injuries: A 14-year prospective study in the pre-AIDS and AIDS eras. Am J Med. 1991;91(3), Suppl 2: S301–S307.
O’Malley E M, Scott R D, Dekutoski G J, et al. Costs of management of occupational exposure to blood and body fluid. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol. 2007;28(7):774-782. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17564978.