April 19, 2024

Recognize, report, prevent: Building accountability for workplace violence

By: Dawn Whiteside, DNP, MSN-Ed, RN, CNOR, NPD-BC, RNFA
Share

Anyone doubting the prevalence of workplace violence (WPV) in the healthcare setting need only search online for “injuries to healthcare workers.” In a sector rife with occupational hazards—from slips and falls to sharps injuries and infections—a significant portion of the links are sure to mention WPV, with many even focusing on it.

The epidemic even has its own social media tag: #EndNurseAbuse. In addition to anecdotes and commentaries, the long list of search results will include plenty of hard numbers confirming the disturbing reality: WPV is pervasive in healthcare, impacting not just mental and physical health but also productivity and turnover rates.

In one example from 2020, the US Bureau of Labor Statistics estimated in the private healthcare and social assistance industries, the number of nonfatal occupational injuries and illnesses resulting from intentional injury by another person nearly doubled in an 8-year period, jumping from 8,180 in 2011 to 15,230 in 2018.

More recently, a 2022 survey by Press Ganey revealed that at least two nurses are assaulted every hour. This devastating number translates to approximately 57 assaults per day, 1,739 assaults per month, and 5,217 assaults per quarter.

This state of affairs is both deplorable and unacceptable. We can and must do a better job of recognizing, reporting, and preventing WPV.

Recognizing WPV

Recognizing WPV requires establishing a definition that is universally accepted and incorporated into workplace policies. The definition published in The Joint Commission glossary is, “An act or threat occurring at the workplace that can include any of the following: verbal, nonverbal, written, or physical aggression; threatening, intimidating, harassing, or humiliating words or actions; bullying; sabotage; sexual harassment; physical assaults; or other behaviors of concern involving staff, licensed practitioners, patients, or visitors.”

The Joint Commission has gone further than defining WPV. It has also released accreditation standards to spread recognition of WPV—and resources to fight it—throughout every level of individual organizations. As of January 2022, revised WPV standards require all accredited and critical access hospitals to develop education, training, and resources for all staff members.

Among other requirements, they must:

• provide a definition and examples of WPV

• clearly define roles and responsibilities for all staff

• offer training in de-escalation, intervention, and emergency response

• provide a process for reporting WPV.

That last item is particularly critical because the number of unreported events is staggering. According to the American Nurses Association (ANA), as many as 80% of incidents of WPV against nurses go unreported. Recognition is the first step in accountability toward creating an environment that strives to prevent WPV, but recognition must be followed by a culture that encourages reporting.

 

Reporting WPV

Gaps in the data show the extent of the reporting problem. For example, 2011 estimates from the Department of Labor peg the number of annual WPV incidents at 22,250. Yet, according to The Joint Commission, only 256 incidents of WPV were reported between 1995 and 2010. According to ANA, there is no standardized process or requirement to report WPV.

Legislation to help address this issue (and WPV more generally) is moving through Congress. In 2021, the Workplace Violence Prevention for Healthcare and Social Service Workers Act was introduced to direct the Department of Labor to mandate certain employers to institute workplace violence prevention plans—including reporting procedures. Although the House of Representatives passed the bill, the Senate has yet to act. So far, 16 states have passed their own mandatory WPV reporting requirements.

Barriers to accurate reporting of WPV vary. Fear of retaliation or perceptions of how leadership will use submitted information may dissuade some. Others simply accept some WPV behaviors as “part of the job.” And still others might balk at the time required to complete documentation, or at the idea that nothing will change after an incident is reported. Lack of knowledge about the reporting system could stymie a well-intentioned whistleblower, while misunderstanding about definitions and scope may lead to issues going unrecognized in the first place.

Whatever the reasons for under-reporting these incidents, organizations must adopt zero-tolerance policies as well as include education and training on what WPV is and how to report it. As ANA puts it, “A workplace culture that values silence over safety is just another form of violence.”

 

Preventing WPV

ANA has urged regulatory agencies to supplement legislation already presented to Congress with new standards on WPV recognition, reporting, and prevention. It reportedly submitted this request in 2017 to the Occupational Health and Safety Organization but has not received a response. ANA states that specific standards and competencies developed to prevent WPV should focus on three levels of prevention:

• Primary prevention: Stop violence before it starts through varied strategies that include education about risks and how to reduce exposure when a vulnerability in the process is witnessed.

• Secondary Prevention: Response to any violence is immediate, and interventions are implemented to reduce negative outcomes.

• Tertiary Prevention: Interventions focusing on long-term effects of WPV should look at ongoing ways to improve prevention programs within the organization (ANA, 2019).

Meanwhile, organizations are free to take their own steps. According to ANA, WPV prevention requires organization-wide participation. Employees must be actively engaged in WPV prevention strategies, incorporate environmental and administrative controls set in place for safety, use the established reporting system, and participate in evaluation and process improvement of the system. Organizations and leadership must maintain awareness of current WPV statistics and prevention strategies, demonstrate a commitment to a nonpunitive environment that supports a culture of reporting WPV, and launch a root cause analysis when an incident occurs.

Put simply, addressing this epidemic requires cultivating a culture of accountability around WPV—specifically for recognizing, reporting, and preventing incidents.

 

—Dawn Whiteside, DNP, MSN-Ed, RN, CNOR, NPD-BC, RNFA, is director of education and professional development at CCI. Dr. Whiteside has over 35 years of experience as a perioperative nurse in many roles, including circulator, scrub, first assistant, team leader, charge nurse, manager, and educator.

 

 

References

ANA, ENA, & ACEP sound the alarm on violence against nurses. American Nurses Association. March 22, 2024.

DeSanto Iennaco J, Molle E, Allegra M, et al. The aggressive incidents in medial settings (AIMS) study: Advancing measurement to promote prevention of workplace violence. The Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety. November 25, 2023.

Doucette J. On average, two nurses are assaulted every hour, new Press Ganey analysis finds. Press Ganey. September 8, 2022.

Falcone S. Legislation to prevent workplace violence in healthcare awaits a senate vote. Nurse.org. September 11, 2023.

Injuries, illnesses, and fatalities. US Bureau of Labor Statistics. April 2020.

Levine Z. ANA commends introduction of critical workplace violence prevention bill. American Nurses Association. April 18, 2023.

Reporting incidents of workplace violence (ANA Issue Brief). American Nurses Association. 2019.

Tucker C. Analysis: States propel curbs on healthcare workplace violence. Bloomberg Law. October 5, 2023.

Violence, incivility, and bullying. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH). April 28, 2022.

Workplace violence prevention standards. The Joint Commission. June 18, 2021.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat