October 10, 2023

Refreshed outlook for addressing healthcare’s staffing crisis

By: John Young and Holly Moore
Share

The COVID-19 pandemic has amplified existing personnel shortages in hospitals and ambulatory surgery centers (ASC), which are anticipated to persist. Before the pandemic, nursing supply and demand were already affected negatively by several factors, including approximately 70,000 Baby Boomer RNs retiring per year. As the remaining Baby Boomer RNs retire over the next decade, the expected loss of nursing experience is estimated at over 2 million years annually between 2020 and 2030. And the pandemic has only heightened the demand for healthcare staff.

In 2022, recruitment was unable to keep up with the turnover rates, leading to an RN vacancy rate of 17%, with experienced OR nurses being among the most difficult to recruit. Retaining nurses also became challenging between 2020 and 2021, with the total supply of RNs declining by over 100,000—the largest drop in the past 40 years.

Today’s workforce makeup is also more complex than ever before. For the first time, employees include individuals from five generations:

  • 2% Traditionalists
  • 25% Baby Boomers
  • 33% Generation X
  • 35% Millennials
  • 5% Generation Z (Gen Z).

Each of the above groups has different career goals, motivations, and needs. Further, inadequate compensation and career advancement opportunities, unsustainable work expectations and environments, and a lack of meaningful work and flexibility continue to contribute to burnout and job dissatisfaction among healthcare professionals.

There are a multitude of contributing factors to the current shortage, including many new workforce challenges related to the pandemic. Evolving needs of a multigenerational workforce create a critical call to action for hospitals and ASCs to develop mitigation strategies and new solutions to stabilize this issue. The potential repercussions for not doing so may lead to delays in patient care, staffing-related adverse events, increased episodic cost of care, diminished community trust, risks to hospital reputation, exposure to liability, suspension of services, and the inability of an organization to invest and grow.

 

Solutions to stabilize the issue

By taking a comprehensive and collaborative approach to address the staffing crisis, healthcare organizations can ensure they have the workforce necessary to provide high-quality care to patients. As an example of a collaborative approach, we convened dozens of healthcare and human resources executives from 13 unique health systems in early 2023 to explore the healthcare staffing crisis through knowledge acquisition, experience sharing, networking, and solution building.

The learnings from this summit focused on four key areas: recruitment, retention, alternative practice models, and technology solutions. As a result, we discovered an array of tactics that hospitals can implement to hire and retain their employees more successfully:

  • Up-level your recruitment tactics: It is time to reassess how your hospital recruits clinical staff, as what once worked before may not work now. For example, recruiting on career desires rather than job positions will help identify a higher volume of strong candidates. This can be done by incorporating relevant experiences (or passions) and career advancement opportunities into job descriptions.
    Another tactic that is often overlooked for long-term impact includes engaging with potential candidates earlier and inspiring them to join the healthcare field. This could involve offering opportunities to those in high school or college to shadow healthcare professionals or participate in volunteer programs. Additionally, creating a culture where recruitment is owned by all stakeholders—a collaborative team participates in building relationships with candidates at the onset—may lead to more positive hiring rates.
  • Retain your staff with a refreshed approach: Hiring managers should also refresh their retention tactics, as keeping staff is just as important as recruiting them. To increase satisfaction, it is important to optimize engagement and focus on well-being and belonging for your staff, as they often may focus more on patient care than their own self-care. Increasing interactions between leadership and employees by scheduling regular “stay” interviews allows for constructive feedback and the ability to uncover and intervene when instances of burnout or job dissatisfaction are identified—making burnout prevention a shared responsibility across leadership.
    Additionally, career development should not only be seen as a vertical path, but also as lateral or horizontal paths by helping staff pursue what they are passionate about and ensuring professional pathways incorporate an employee’s entire life cycle. Given the pandemic’s impact on clinical experiential learning, consider re-evaluating the onboarding process for all newly licensed professionals by developing a plan to support new staff as they transition to clinical practice.
  • Implement alternative practice models: Leveraging alternative practice models is another strategy that can aid in improving your staff’s well-being and satisfaction. This could include shared staffing through cross-training with similar nursing units across the organization, which can help employees feel less overwhelmed by balancing their workloads. It is also important to consider generational differences in staffing models, especially for Millennials and Gen Z, by offering multiple options on flexible scheduling, for example.
    Additionally, ensure that frontline staff have the autonomy to work at the top of their license. Team care nursing may also be an option, with a focus on the right team makeup rather than ratios. Finally, incorporating virtual nursing or virtual mentoring can help bring back experienced or retired nurses to support frontline staff.
  • Take advantage of technology: It is crucial to use technology to improve work-life balance, efficiency, and motivation. Technology can enable flexible scheduling, which grants workers the freedom to self-schedule desired shifts and remove administrative burdens, or offer tools such as virtual nursing, which creates a hybrid work approach and more flexibility. Additionally, predictive analytics can be used to project staffing needs to prevent staff from being overworked or experiencing burnout.

As healthcare providers and nursing leaders continue to grapple with the staffing crisis, hospitals must adapt to the evolving needs of employees for optimal talent attraction and retention by refreshing traditional approaches to hiring and career development. By embracing new solutions and adapting to the changing landscape, hospitals can better address the workforce shortage crisis and reduce the challenges that come along with it.

Healthcare providers and perioperative leaders should start by assessing their current status related to the four key areas: recruitment, retention, alternative practice models, and use of technology. This assessment will identify gap areas and allow organizations to develop an action plan that focuses on easy wins at the beginning while simultaneously planning and initiating strategies that require more time and resources.

—John Young, MD, MBA, FACHE, is HealthTrust’s chief medical officer and Holly Moore, MSN,
CCRN-K, is director of HealthTrust’s clinical services and data solutions.

 

References

Bean M, Masson G. The less-discussed consequence of healthcare’s labor shortage. Becker’s Clinical Leadership. Updated October 4, 2021.

Buerhaus P I, Auerbach D I, Staiger D O. How should we prepare for the wave of retiring baby boomer nurses? Health Affairs. May 3, 2017.

De Smet A, Dowling B, Hancock B, et al. The Great Attrition is making hiring harder. Are you searching the right talent pools? McKinsey & Company. July 13, 2022.

Generational Differences in the Workplace. Purdue Global. nd.

Innovative nurse residency program aims to reduce nurse turnover. American Hospital Association. nd.

Nursing Shortage Fact Sheet. American Association of Colleges of Nursing. Updated October 2022.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat