January 1, 2025

Surgical legislation advocacy focuses on safety, access

“Surgeons are the only people trained to provide surgery—life-saving care,” says Carrie Zlatos, chief of legislative and political affairs at the American College of Surgeons (ACS). “They are an essential element of a community-based healthcare system. Regardless of where you live, everyone should have access to full quality surgical care.”

Carrie Zlatos

Zlatos meets regularly with legislators and Congressional staff to build awareness around the importance of access to lifesaving surgical care on behalf of the more than 90,000 members of ACS. What she hears from those members—widespread, critical shortages of general surgeons in rural areas—mirrors the findings of the HRSA General Surgeon Projection Report, which was mandated by Congress at the organization’s urging in 2020. ACS is attacking this issue on multiple fronts, including pushing for the revival of expired incentives as well as the passage of legislation that aims to identify more specifics about where resources are most needed.

This is not the only pending legislation focused on surgery. The Ambulatory Surgery Center Association (ASCA) hopes to take advantage of the current lame duck session of Congress to build support for reducing what it claims to be restrictions on access, particularly for seniors.

The backdrop for these ongoing advocacy efforts is a broader problem: a steep decline in numbers of surgeons. A 2021 report from the American Association of Medical Colleges predicts shortfalls of as many as 30,200 surgeons in all specialties by 2034. Two bills before Congress, both focused on education costs, could help address this issue.

Although none of this legislation has moved forward since early 2023, past advocacy efforts show change can take time. Consider the spread of state-level legislation to protect OR staff from hazardous surgical smoke, an issue championed by AORN.

As the organization’s years-long efforts have shown, advancing legislation to improve improved access to surgery and safety standards requires ongoing work, including educating and engaging with lawmakers, impacted healthcare workers, and patients. It requires spreading awareness and building interest and momentum. But as these bills finally start to pass—as hospitals and ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) publicize their “smoke free” status—the initiative takes hold, and others follow suit.

As this state-by-state process continues, advocates for the bills before the federal legislature are also continuing their efforts to drum up support and educate the public. As the 118th Congress gives way to the 119th, senators and representatives can expect continued pressure from ACS, ASCA, and other advocates on addressing critical gaps in access to care, particularly in rural hospitals and ASCs.

 

Reducing the cost of surgical education

As detailed in the American Association of Medical Colleges’ report, fewer students pursuing surgical careers is a driving factor behind shortfalls across surgical specialties. ACS points to the high cost of medical education as a key driver of this decline.

“Physicians often accumulate immense student debt during their education…then must undertake several years of residency training with low pay, during which time their student loans accrue significant interest,” the ACS Advocacy team writes on its website. “This financial burden poses a barrier for students…to pursue certain specialties, practice in underserved areas, or even enter the healthcare profession at all.”

According to ACS, legislation that reduces the burden of student loan debt could go a long way toward meaningfully addressing this decline. To that end, the organization is pushing for passage of two bills under consideration. The first is the Resident Education Deferred Interest (REDI) Act (S. 704/H.R. 1202). Introduced by Senators Jacky Rosen (D-NV) and John Boozman (R-AR) and Representatives Brian Babin (R-TX-36) and Chrissy Houlahan (D-PA-6), this bill would allow borrowers in medical or dental internships or residency programs to defer their student loan payments without interest until the completion of their programs.

The second piece of proposed legislation is the Specialty Physicians Advancing Rural Care (SPARC) Act (S. 705). Introduced by Senators Rosen and Roger Wicker (R-MS), this bill would establish a new loan repayment program that would allow specialty physicians who agree to practice in a rural area for 6 years to have up to $250,000 of their student loans forgiven.

Bills like these would do more than reduce the financial burden of medical education for prospective surgeons. They also would help provide a needed incentive for more surgeons to practice in rural areas that are facing serious provider shortages, ACS argues.

 

Expanding rural incentives

With few incentives for surgeons to move to or practice in rural areas, gaps are growing. According to the HRSA General Surgeon Projection Report, rural areas have just 69% of general surgeons needed to meet demand.

One proposed measure to address the problem is a stopgap. The Affordable Care Act provided an incentive payment for general surgeons practicing in rural, underserved areas—specifically, those designated by HRSA as “Health Professional Shortage Areas (HPSAs). Equal to 10% of the payment for physicians’ professional services, this incentive measure expired in 2015. ACS has urged Congress to reauthorize the payments for 5 years to ensure broader surgical access.

Meanwhile, the organization continues to work on more comprehensive efforts to address the unequal distribution. One key priority is passing the Ensuring Access to General Surgery Act, first introduced in 2016 and again in the current 118th Congress. This legislation would, for the first time, clearly define areas with a “surgical shortage” so they can appeal to Congress for more resources.

“This would allow us to determine what constitutes a shortage and where we lack access to surgical services,” Zlatos explains. “It would provide Congress with the authority to create the surgical shortage designation. Currently, there’s no agreed-upon definition. Addressing that maldistribution is critically important, and having the data is the first step.”

The Act would authorize a study to see whether current methods of determining surgeon shortage designations result in accurate assessments, or whether a different method is needed, such as identifying general surgeons practicing within hospital service areas. They would then determine the threshold of general surgeon-to-population ratios across four levels—optimal supply of general surgeons, adequate supply, shortage, and critical shortage—and submit a report to Congress within 1 year.

Although political momentum on this issue has been slow, passing the bill is an important first step in understanding the full extent of surgeon shortages in rural areas, Zlatos says. ACS continues to meet with legislators and build support among members of the energy and commerce committees.

 

Closing ASC reimbursement gaps

Bill Prentice

Another key piece of legislation, the Outpatient Surgery Quality Access Act, aims to close the reimbursement gap between surgeries performed at ASCs and hospital outpatient departments.

Compared to hospitals, ASCs are reimbursed at 50 cents on the dollar by Medicare for the same surgical procedures—and that delta is growing due to inflation, says Bill Prentice, ASCA CEO. This means patients—primarily seniors—must pay significantly more for these services, effectively limiting their access. “Patients shouldn’t be charged more for a procedure just because it was performed by an outpatient provider,” Senator Richard Blumenthal (D-CT), one of the cosponsors of the bill, wrote in a press release. “The current restrictions on [ASCs] are an unnecessary burden—limiting seniors’ access to care and driving up healthcare costs.”

This disparity in reimbursements is partly due to the fact that ASC payments have been based on the Consumer Price Index. In contrast, hospital outpatient payments have been updated with the hospital market basket—meaning, the pure price change of inputs used by a provider in supplying healthcare services.

The bill also would make price comparisons transparent and public. “We’re big supporters of transparency,” says Prentice. “Patients should have greater access to information—that allows them to become better consumers.”

The bill also would add an ASC representative to the advisory panel on hospital outpatient payment, create a review process for outpatient procedures, and eliminate a copay penalty that impacts those without supplemental coverage. Penalties affect more black (60%) than white (28%) beneficiaries.

An important part of this push is expanding codes for which procedures are covered by Medicare. The current list is outdated, Prentice explains, preventing ASCs from offering beneficiaries surgical procedures they could otherwise perform at lower costs. “There are 300+ procedures we cannot perform,” he says. “But we’ve been adding more orthopedic, spine, and cardiovascular procedures in recent years, and there’s much more we could be doing for Medicare.”

As documented by Healthcare Finance News, ASCs can often perform the same procedures as hospital outpatient departments at a 144% lower average price. As these centers grow to meet surgical demand, this efficiency promises not only reduced insurance costs for taxpayers, but also savings of nearly $700 per procedure for patients.

 

Gaining momentum

Since 2017, AORN has been working to enact state-level legislation that requires hospitals and ASCs to properly evacuate surgical smoke. These efforts have contributed to the introduction of legislation in nearly 30 states. Eighteen of those states, including California, Colorado, Arizona, Kentucky, Louisiana, Minnesota, and Virginia, have enacted these protections (sidebar, The dangers of surgical smoke).

Jennifer PennockUnder AORN’s legislation model, hospitals and ASCs must adopt a policy that requires the evacuation of surgical smoke for planned surgical procedures likely to generate surgical smoke. The bills “allow maximum flexibility for surgical teams and facilities to select and use the equipment of their choice,” says Jennifer Pennock, associate director, Government Affairs, at AORN. As new technologies become available, facilities are able to incorporate them, as long as they are capturing and filtering surgical smoke as it is generated.

It helps that the necessary equipment is already on-site in most cases, Pennock says. “Most hospitals and outpatient surgery centers already have equipment available to evacuate surgical smoke,” she says. “And while many surgical facilities do evacuate during some procedures, few facilities evacuate consistently during all procedures that generate surgical smoke.”

Although legislation is critical for driving positive change, it is not the only way, Pennock says. For example, facilities interested in smoke evacuation need not wait for their state legislatures to act. In the meantime, they can utilize resources on AORN’s website, such as the Go Clear program, to educate staff about the hazards and implement policies to ensure smoke is safely evacuated during procedures.

Perhaps the most important lesson to be gleaned from AORN’s success so far is also a simple one: the need to speak out and encourage others to speak out, too. In a more recent example, Janet Shortt, MHSA, BS, RN, CNOR, president of AORN Chapter 4702 in Richmond, Virginia, spoke on behalf of a state-level bill for surgery smoke evacuation. “After 20 years in the OR, after three bouts of bronchitis and multiple upper respiratory infections, I was diagnosed with asthma,” she said in a public comment. “I thought this odd as I was living a healthy lifestyle, working out 5 days a week, and eating a healthy diet. I now have chronic asthma that requires inhalers.”

The Virginia law, passed in March, goes into effect on July 1, 2025. “The development of the law was a grassroots effort,” AORN reports. Testimony like Shortt’s as well as other efforts—including a survey revealing most Virginia members had evacuation equipment that often went unused—“helped drive home to legislators the necessity of a mandate to ensure surgical smoke evacuation systems are not just present but actually used for every smoke-generating surgery in the state.” ORM

—Brita Belli is an award-winning writer and PR professional with published stories in the New York Times, National Geographic, MSN.com, and Alternet.

 

References

Advocacy/surgical workforce. American College of Surgeons. Accessed November 2024.

Blumenthal R. S.312 — Outpatient Surgery Quality and Access Act of 2023. 118th Congress. Accessed November 2024.

Blumenthal, Cassidy, Wenstrup & Larson Introduce Bill Expanding Seniors’ Access to Affordable Outpatient Surgical Care. Richard Blumenthal, US Senator for Connecticut. February 9, 2023.

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). Section 5501(b) Incentive Payment Program for Major Surgical Procedures Furnished in Health Professional Shortage Areas of the Affordable Care Act (ACA). US Dept of health & Human Services Guidance Portal. August 27, 2010.

Lagasse J. Shifting common outpatient procedures to ASCs shows cost savings. Healthcare Finance News. September 9, 2021.

Outpatient Surgery Quality and Access Act of 2023. Ambulatory Surgery Center Association (ASCA). February 9, 2023.

Schatz B. S.1140 — Ensuring Access to General Surgery Act of 2023. 118th Congress. March 30, 2023.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat