September 1, 2025

Survey: Staffing problems increase as surgical volume continues to rise

By: Cynthia Saver
Share

Takeaways

• Most respondents reported an increase in the percentage of open positions for RNs and STs compared to 12 months ago.

• Most respondents struggle to hire experienced RNs, yet time-to-fill positions has dropped, suggesting rapid but possibly unsustainable staffing shifts.

• Leadership is getting younger (average age 38), credentialing requirements have surged, and staffing patterns show some surprising contradictions like layoffs amid rising surgical volume.


About the survey and thank you: Data for the Career/Salary Survey were collected from April 1 to June 27, 2025. The list comprised OR directors, managers, or similar roles within hospitals. The survey closed with 381 responses. The margin of error is ±5 percentage points at the 95% confidence level. Thank you to those who generously took time to complete this year’s survey!

The slight staffing improvements reported in 2024 were short-lived, according to the 2025 OR Manager Career/Salary Survey. For instance, OR leaders reported an increase in the percentage of open full-time equivalent (FTE) positions for both RNs (64% vs 28% in 2024) and STs (68% vs 38%) compared to 12 months ago. OR leaders also reported higher numbers of open positions for both RNs and STs.

Rising volume may have exacerbated staffing problems. Three quarters of OR leaders reported the volume of surgical procedures had increased in the past 12 months compared to 65% in 2024. Only 3% reported decreased volume, down from 10% last year.

The data include some apparent contradictions. For instance, 69% of respondents said RN turnover decreased in the past 12 months, while 65% reported increased ST turnover, despite more open positions for both.

Other key survey findings include:

• Most (78%) OR leaders found recruiting experienced OR nurses to be more difficult this year.

• The turnover rate for both RNs and surgical technologists (STs) was 17%, up from 12% and 13% respectively.

• Results for some of the staffing changes over the past year, such as 55% reporting layoffs of direct care staff, varied considerably from past surveys.

This article focuses on the survey’s findings related to staffing. (Percentages may not add up to 100% due to rounding.) Read about results related to OR leaders’ compensation, scope of responsibility, and job satisfaction in OR Manager’s November/December issue.

 

Staffing patterns

Most results indicate that staffing remains problematic for OR leaders.

Turnover. The 17% turnover rate for both RNs and STs was higher than last year, but aligns with the 16.4% national turnover rate noted in a report from NSI Nursing Solutions, Inc. The turnover rate for RNs had increased in the past 12 months for 16%; the same percentage reported it had remained the same. The 16% who reported decreased RN turnover marked a new high from the previous 10-year peak of 22% in 2024.

The 65% of those reporting increased ST turnover rate was another 10-year high. The previous high was 48% in 2022, during the COVID-19 pandemic. In all, 15% of OR leaders reported ST turnover rate had decreased. ST turnover stayed the same for 20%.

Open positions. In 2024, 20% of OR leaders had no open positions for RNs or STs. This year, that number dropped to 9% for each position. More than half (56%) had five to nine open RN positions (vs 19% in 2024), and 51% had 10 to 14 open ST positions.

As previously noted, most OR leaders reported the percentage of open positions had increased compared to 12 months ago: 64% for RNs and 68% for STs. The last time those percentages were over 50% in the past decade was during the COVID-19 pandemic in 2022, when it was 58% for RNs and 56% for STs. Some respondents reported the percentage of open positions had decreased: 19% for RNs and 12% for STs.

Staffing changes. Given the issues with turnover and open positions, some of the reported staffing changes are surprising. For example, 60% eliminated open positions (vs 16% in 2024), and only 23% hired more direct care staff, down from 48% last year. Meanwhile, 61% reported hiring more management.

OR leaders reported losing fewer staff to retirement (18% vs 38% in 2024), burnout (12% vs 25%), and transfers to other units (14% vs 33%). Organizations may have maximized reductions in the use of agency/travel staff: only 11% reported this as a staffing change, compared to 36% in 2024. In addition, just 7% increased use of this staffing option, compared to 23% last year.

Recruitment. After some encouraging signs last year, RN recruitment difficulties returned. Last year, nearly half (45%) of respondents reported recruiting experienced RNs had become more difficult in the past 12 months. That figure may have been an outlier because this year’s 78% is more comparable to 70% in 2023 and 75% in both 2022 and 2021. More than two-thirds (69%) even found it difficult to recruit new or inexperienced OR nurses, surpassing the previous 10-year high of 32% in 2022.

Conversely, 58% (vs 15% in 2024) of respondents found it easier to recruit STs; the next highest percentage in the past decade was 17% in 2015. About a quarter (24% vs 50% in 2024) found ST recruitment to be more difficult.

Although recruiting may be difficult, the average number of days to fill an RN position dropped from 77 days last year to 35 this year. For STs, the same figured dropped from 120 days to 49. By comparison, the report from NSI Nursing Solutions found it took an average of 86 days to fill an open OR nurse position, compared to 92 days in 2024.

The percentage of managers who require staff to have certification in perioperative nursing spiked from 17% to 59%. Just 2 years ago, the percentage was only 7%. Most OR leaders (77%) require an associate degree in nursing, comparable to last year’s 71%. The percentage of those requiring a baccalaureate degree in nursing was 23% (vs 41% in 2024). An additional 15% (vs 5% in 2024) require a baccalaureate degree that does not have to be in nursing.

 

Thoughts on robotics

In a series of open-ended questions, we asked OR leaders to comment on the implementation and impact of robot-assisted surgery (RAS). Challenges cited encompassed high costs, complex training requirements, scheduling conflicts, set-up time, and occasional technical failures, with many hospitals addressing these through structured training, simulation drills, and dedicated scheduling systems. Comments included:

• “Occasional technical failures of the equipment affect the surgical process. We formulated detailed emergency plans, regularly conducted comprehensive inspections and maintenance of the equipment, and established a rapid response mechanism with the supplier to ensure that failures can be repaired in a timely manner.”

• “When robotic surgery was newly carried out, team members did not cooperate well. We organized team-building activities, conducted multiple simulated surgery drills, clarified the responsibilities of each member, and continuously optimized the cooperation process through practical operations.”

• “Complex surgery scheduling: Due to the limited robotic surgery equipment and high patient demand, the scheduling is chaotic. We developed a dedicated surgery scheduling management software that conducts intelligent scheduling based on the urgency of the surgery, patient condition, and equipment availability time. We also increased some surgery arrangements during non-peak hours.”

• “Difficult training: It is challenging for doctors and nurses to master the operation techniques of robotic surgery. We established an internal training center, invited experts from equipment manufacturers to provide in-hospital guidance, carried out simulated surgery training, and arranged for medical staff to further their studies in experienced hospitals.”

Respondents also described assessing the return on investment (ROI) through cost/benefit analyses comparing robotic and traditional surgery. Here are sample comments related to the question, “How do you measure the ROI of robotic surgery, and what impact, if any, have you observed on patient outcomes, efficiency, or revenue?”:

• “Measure ROI through cost-benefit analysis: Compare the costs (equipment, consumables, manpower, etc) and revenues (surgery fees, patient follow-up visit revenues, etc) of robotic surgery and traditional surgery. Although the upfront investment in robotic surgery is large, patients recover faster and have fewer complications. In the long run, it can reduce patients’ hospital stay, increase the bed turnover rate, and improve overall revenue. It significantly improves the postoperative recovery effect of patients and also enhances surgical efficiency.”

• “ROI metrics: case numbers, cost-revenue ratio, surgeon productivity. Impacts: better patient outcomes (lower morbidity), faster OR turnover, and revenue growth.”

• “ROI tracks case growth, cost-effectiveness, revenue. Observed better patient outcomes (faster recovery), higher efficiency, and revenue uplift.”

• “We measure ROI by analyzing costs (acquisition, maintenance, training) against benefits: shorter patient stays, lower complication rates, and higher surgeon productivity. This drives efficiency, attracts more patients, and increases revenue via premium procedures.”

Finally, we asked whether respondents anticipated expanding, maintaining, or reducing their use of robotics over the next year. Comments included:

• “Continue to expand in specialized fields that are technologically mature and have clear demands (such as urology and thoracic surgery), while cautiously explore in high-difficulty areas (such as cardiac surgery).”

• “Expected to reduce usage: Due to the continuous increase in equipment maintenance costs, and some doctors showing burnout towards new technologies. At the same time, competitors have introduced more advanced equipment to attract patients, resulting in a decrease in the number of patients choosing robotic surgery in our hospital.”

• “Expected to expand usage: With the maturity of technology and the improvement of doctors’ operation proficiency, and the increasing acceptance of robotic surgery by patients, the hospital plans to introduce new robotic surgery equipment and expand the application scope of surgical departments.”

• “Over the next year, we anticipate expanding robotic use, driven by rising patient demand for minimally invasive options and clinical data showing improved outcomes (eg, reduced pain, shorter stays). Factors include:

    1. growing surgeon proficiency via ongoing training
    2. optimized OR scheduling with dedicated robotic suites
    3. new reimbursement codes for advanced procedures.

While upfront maintenance costs remain, scaling case volume (>300/year) should improve ROI. Potential challenges: supply chain delays for instruments, but strategic partnerships with manufacturers mitigate risks.”

Looking ahead, some expect to expand RAS as technology matures and demand rises, while others foresee reductions due to costs, staff fatigue, or competition. For more information about robot-assisted surgery, see the article “Robots reshape surgical services, part 1: Emerging tech, rising risks.”

 

An aberration or a trend?

Several of this year’s results showed wider variation than in the past. For example, the number of open positions was much higher (despite a substantial increase in respondents reporting decreased RN turnover), while results for several staffing changes were significantly different from 2024.

This year, the average age for respondents was 38 years—the lowest in the past 10 years, when the average ranged from 49 to 54 years. It is unclear whether this was a factor in the results. In addition, the emphasis on staffing in new ways to better meet current demands may have prompted more rapid practice changes. Next year’s survey will help answer whether this year’s results mark the beginning of a trend or serve as an outlier.

 

—Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, of CLS Development in Columbia, Maryland, provides editorial services to healthcare publications.

 

Editor’s Note: For details on this year’s results regarding business managers, see the companion page, “Survey: 2025 business manager profile.”

 

Reference

NSI Nursing Solutions. NSI national health care retention & RN staffing report. 2025.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat