After more than a year in hiatus, OR Manager Conference was held in October 2021 in Chicago, bringing together hundreds of attendees, speakers, and exhibitors. After the live conference, OR Manager sat down with Cindy Kildgore, education coordinator for the OR Manager Conference; Amy Bethel, education coordinator for the OR Business Management Conference; Casey OrthNebitt, director of Surgery at Buena Vista Regional Medical Center; Beverly Kirchner, compliance officer of SurgeryDirect LLC; and Donna Doyle, perioperative consultant with DJD Consulting Services to discuss the biggest takeaways from the conference.
Q: What was the main theme heard throughout the conference?
Doyle: Everybody was so excited to be back in person again. The excitement was very palpable.
Kirchner: Not only was it palpable, but it was also fun to watch people congregate, get together, and discuss what they’ve been going through over the last 20 months. It’s amazing, the many similarities between us as well as the many differences in each of our environments. It was very informative.
Orth-Nebitt: Even talking to the vendors was exciting because it’s easy to get stuck in our own little circle in our own little world. Once you get out and see the products and the resources that are available to you, it’s exciting.
Kildgore: Staffing was a main theme. The struggle to keep your staff engaged and happy, since many OR nurses were called upon to become ICU nurses. OR nurses really jumped in and did what was needed to be done over these last 18 months. What can we do as leaders to give back to them, reduce their stress, and keep them engaged?
Doyle: We do a lot to care for our patients, but we aren’t very good about caring for ourselves, so resilience was a big theme. How do we provide that selfcare that keeps us going, so that we can keep our patients going?

Dr Marty Makary presenting “The price we pay and the re-design of healthcare” at the OR Manager Conference.
Q: What were some of the biggest challenges heard from attendees?
Kirchner: Staffing was mentioned throughout this conference. One of the other things that ran through it is nursing education, and how are we going to replace the baby boomer nurses that retired during the pandemic. The shortages are increasing weekly across the country.
When we were talking about different ways of helping, one of the things that came away from some of the educators was that their hospitals shut down and are not allowing nursing students in to do their clinicals. That is holding up their graduation. I think that was a huge thing.
Doyle: And because our elective surgery shut down for a period of time, our organizations are experiencing a financial problem as a result. How do we continue to care for our patients in an environment where we are being told we have to do more with less? Staffing is a big component of that. How do we keep people engaged? How do we keep them in our departments? How do we use recruitment and retention strategies so that we can attract folks from all generations?
Bethel: Financial pressures are going to increase when you have a large percentage of your surgeries shut down for a period of time. They always look to the OR to provide the revenue. The OR is the largest revenue producer in a hospital. We are going to be under tremendous pressure to make that up.
Q: What wins, solutions, or accomplishments were discussed at the event or at any of the sessions?
Orth-Nebitt: In the “Ask Me Anything” sessions, recruitment and retention, and how we are competing with travel nursing, were big themes. In one of the sessions, it was offered that eventually there might have to be mandates for traveling because nurses are leaving the field in droves to travel as well.
A creative recruitment strategy is to visit local high schools. It is the opposite of what we did during the height of the pandemic, but we are starting to come out of that now, and we are asking students to engage much earlier. It is not necessarily just nursing students or students who are already enrolled in a program. It is also about starting recruitment a little bit earlier, trying to get kids who maybe are interested in the medical field but are not sure what places exist for them. I find even a lot of nursing students do not necessarily know very much about surgery.
It is a great opportunity to go and talk to people who are interested in the medical field, and maybe even get them to job shadow, or give them as much information as you can about your field and start to recruit earlier.
Kirchner: One of the nursing leaders with whom I spoke said that she is actually hiring nursing students to come and work, mostly in a nursing assistant’s way, but also getting them to see how to scrub and what the work is like in the sterile processing department. She is interviewing them the whole time they are working for her. Then at the end of their education and when they are looking to graduate, she is looking at the ones to immediately bring into her facility. I thought that was a great idea.
Bethel: We have to go back. We have been dealing with nursing shortages off and on for decades. This one is different, and we, as organizations, need to take a deep dive into the whys. All those things that we do for staff engagement and have always done need to be hardwired. Find out what makes your staff tick and what keeps them. It’s not always the money.
Orth-Nebitt: Nurses are smart. If they are overworked at their current organization, why wouldn’t they go and be overworked somewhere else for double their pay? Nurses will figure out a solution. They are autonomous, and they know that they are in a valued profession and can find something that fits, if they are not finding it at their current placement.
I know a hospital near me that, even within the same city, is allowing nurses to travel. The hospitals in Omaha, which is south of where I live, but not far from me, have an agreement with each other not to accept travelers from within Omaha. They have a suburb, so I’m not sure what the technicality of that is.
If local hospitals come to an agreement, and competitive hospitals can agree on certain parameters for hiring travelers, then it could be more structured. Nurses will not be able to just hop, so to speak. They can’t hop from hospital to hospital within the same 60-mile radius because the hospitals have such an agreement.
From what I understand, that helps a little bit. That does not mean that you can’t. A nurse could still do that. They could still get hired at the hospital instead of traveling. It will be very interesting. I don’t know that anyone has all the answers. We’re going to have to continue to be creative.
Kildgore: This is a big subject for myself because we didn’t have travelers ever until about three years ago. Every time I talked with someone who came in who was a traveler, I would ask, “What made you leave your facility? What is it you like about traveling so much?” They always told me they had not found a home base.
I actually had the opportunity to hire probably five or six of the travelers who came through. That spoke to what the leaders were doing within the perioperative teams back in the OR. They were making them feel like they were part of a family, and that led these travelers to want to stay.
Doyle: Whenever we talk about the supply side and the shortage, I think culture and civility in the workplace are things that are probably equally, if not more, important than the money side of the equation. Part of that too is mentoring relationships. Organizations that have good mentoring relationships have the ability to retain staff far greater than those who have a poor culture and where it’s a fend-for-yourself type of an environment.
One of the things we have done right over the last several years as a planning committee is the session on “Ask Me Anything” because that’s not just networking. It’s also a chance to mentor the next generation of leaders. That’s very important in a culture.
If you are going to find a culture that fits, that becomes your family. You are going to be more loyal to that organization and feel like you belong.
Orth-Nebitt: The manager can have a huge effect on the culture of the organization. I don’t think we should feel powerless as far as retention goes because if you have a good team and you have the expectation that everyone on the team is to have a good relationship with their coworkers, you don’t have to be best friends, and you don’t have to always agree, but you do always have to be respectful and treat each other kindly.
If you establish that as a manager and you have a good culture in your unit, it makes people want to stay.

“New Manager Panel” with Denise Martinez, Casey Orth-Nebitt, Natasha Luster, and Stephanie Davis (left to right).
Q: What were some surprising new things learned or heard in Chicago?
Kirchner: One of the surprising things I heard was the fact that the media, and not just the news stations, says so much that is not the truth. We have to be careful with what we’re hearing, reading, and spreading.
I think that’s even more apparent with some of the things that are coming down through mandates. COVID-19 has taught us a lot of lessons that I don’t think I have ever seen in the 40-plus years I have been working as a nurse. What we are learning is that we want truth, and the surprising thing is that we are not getting the truth.
When we talk about culture as leaders, we have got to identify truthfulness in our actions and exercise transparency when we communicate that truth to our teams. It was loud and clear through everything we heard from our speakers that truth is important to our staff. Truth is a part of that culture.
Kildgore: One of the sessions that I attended was on telehealth and the advances that it is making within perioperative services. It was within our ambulatory surgery center (ASC) track, and it was very interesting how they are able to go into rural communities and have specialists be able to participate in surgeries virtually.
I know we have heard of this in very selected cities and places, but that is a real growing entity. The pandemic pushed that along much, much quicker with Teladoc and telehealth and things like that. I was surprised at how quickly it is been embedded into the industry.
Kirchner: Another place, too, was the ASC industry. The pandemic has brought a light to the ASCs and their value in healthcare. The ASCs stepped up to the plate and became hospitals without walls. Through this, we could convert ourselves to hospital outpatient departments and keep patients longer than 24 hours. A lot of centers did that.
There was tremendous growth in the number of surgery centers being built during the pandemic because the hospital systems found out we were not shut down for near as long as they were. Therefore, we did not have the backlog in surgeries or the complaints, and we were able to move forward.
The other thing is supply chain management. We’re all going to be seeing a lot in supply chain management. Now, in my environment, the ASC, we don’t purchase the volumes that these big hospital systems do. Therefore, our allocations are very low, so we have to be very careful.
Doyle:I was impressed by Richard Leider’s session on the “Power of Purpose.” Although it wasn’t new information, it was a good reminder to all of us as to why we get up in the morning, why we do what we do, and it was a new take on thinking about our purpose within nursing, particularly periop.
Bethel: I attended some of the PACU sessions. While enhanced recovery is not necessarily a new concept, I was surprised by the number of people in those sessions who were just learning and did not really understand what it was. More importantly, they wanted to know, “How on earth do I implement this?” I think that there was a lot of learning that went on for the participants in those sessions.

OR Manager Conference’s exhibit hall featured several attractions including massage sessions, popcorn and cocktail stations, and our hybrid OR.
Q: Dr Marty Makary’s session was a big hit with attendees in Chicago. What were some takeaways from his presentation?
Kirchner: One of the things that wasn’t a surprise to me, but came into clearer focus, was our cost, what we are charging patients, what their insurances are paying, and what we can do better as leaders and as a part of the health system to keep that cost down so our patients can afford to seek and get the care that they need.
Looking at what Dr Makary has been doing with his foundation, and working with patients to get them out of healthcare debt and keep them from having to declare bankruptcy, was a big piece. The other thing that surprised me in his talk was the fact that our own National Institutes of Health did not fund any grants at the start of the pandemic for our professionals to understand COVID-19 in this country. We did not see medical professionals step up sooner and let politicians be our source of truth.
I was just blown away by that, because how are we going to improve and how are we going to find the lessons learned if research isn’t being done in our own country, and we’re having to depend on research from other countries to give us the information we need to move forward? Those were two of the big, stunning things I thought he shared with us that were monumental. And his lessons should be helping us as leaders to focus on where we’re going in 2022 and beyond with our practice of medicine and with what we provide our patients.
Bethel: That, and the new generation of healthcare professionals coming on board who are not afraid to ask why: “Why on earth are we doing things this way?” We should be teaching this level of curiosity to new and upcoming healthcare leaders, and that came through in his message as well.
Orth-Nebitt: In addition to asking why, asking, how much does this cost? I don’t think that is in our culture when it comes to a medical problem. If you need it, do it—that’s the American way of accepting healthcare.
He also talked about precision medicine, and I liked that approach, where you are not doing extra testing and wasteful spending. I was thinking about that, and I’m not sure how much of an effect OR managers can have on precision medicine. As patients in healthcare, we can certainly ask questions about that.
As OR managers, we can have more of an effect on price transparency. We should continue to ask why: why does it cost this much, what research and development went into the product, and how is it billed to the patient? These are important questions for us to ask our vendors. By scoping out and shopping those prices for our patients, and making sure that we’re getting the best quality product for the best price, we are already making an impact.
The other interesting thing from Dr Makary’s session was the talk around the complex billing system that we use. He was talking about a student of his who is by all standards a genius. The student went and actually spent some time with the billing people for an ER department to observe that side. Later, he texts Dr Makary saying, “This is the most confusing thing I have ever dealt with,” as far as the coding and billing of medicine in our country goes. And it’s so true. If you’ve ever had to look up a HCPCS code or something, or help the biller that way, it’s so many hoops. It was very interesting and entertaining to see the new generation questioning things we know to be problems.
Q: Were there other clinically focused sessions that stood out?
Bethel: I went to one in the vendor hall that I thought was quite good. It was on pressure ulcers, which is a huge issue. I thought it was very well done. You still got CEUs for it. You still were able to wander around the vendor hall.
Kirchner: We also had a session on the COVID-19 mandate vaccinations. That went over well. The problem is that information is changing daily. Some of the information that was even shared at that time has changed as we have moved forward.
I don’t think we have any answers regarding the mandate yet, except that the federal government has given us some time frames now, and January 4, 2022, is practically here. How are we going to work with those who absolutely refuse to get the vaccination, for whatever their personal beliefs or religious affiliations are, is another target that’s coming down on us quickly.
There is a lot that we still need to be looking at in the literature. I know that OR Manager is going to be putting out a lot more information as it becomes available to us. Stand by, because that topic’s not going away, and it’s not going to get any better. We’re going to have to work together as teams to figure this out.
I’ve done a lot of research because our surgery centers in Colorado had a vaccine mandate as of October 1. We lost 70 percent of our staff. I will tell you, we had not turned over one staff member in over two years in that facility. It was mainly young nurses who were of childbearing age. For some reason, they just felt that the vaccine was not for them.
The way that it’s written in that state, you can get a religious exemption or a medical exemption. We can medicate to the best of our ability, but you cannot touch a patient if you’ve not been vaccinated, you put them at risk.
That’s going to be another hurdle we’re going to be facing. I’m really grateful to be a part of the OR Manager team, because we’re staying ahead and on top of this developing issue and providing the most relevant information to our community.
Kildgore: What’s nice and refreshing is also that OR Manager is willing to bring forward these subject matters that can be somewhat controversial. Here, they can be discussed openly because these are the types of things that we won’t know a lot about for many more years. To be able to have those open discussions is very important.
Doyle: The COVID-19 pandemic really brought forth a silver lining of sorts, especially as it relates to smoke evacuation and evacuating aerosols. We have struggled with this issue for years and years because it’s a workplace safety issue. I recently testified on a Senate bill here in Ohio regarding smoke evacuation. I think that topic was very well timed. We’re going to hear a lot more about that as we start to see the domino effect, across more than the five states that currently have legislation on this topic.
Kirchner: In the state of Texas, we actually had a bill up. For some reason, this year in session, we got 11 bills passed. We are on our fourth special session, and it has not come back up. We have gone the regulatory route.
For those of you who are struggling in your hospital, if you look at the emergency OSHA rule that talks about airborne risks and protections, if you read that carefully, it falls right into smoke evacuation and that we have to provide an environment that is safe from these kinds of aerosols. You have some leverage even in your own hospital systems right now thanks to OSHA’s emergency standard
Q: What were some of the leadership-focused sessions that stood out?
Doyle: I did a session, it was a workshop on conflict management and emotional intelligence. We know that conflict in the OR is bound to take place. We work in a very fastpaced, very turbulent environment, where we’re trying to care for patients who have life threatening conditions. When conflict comes up, we need to figure out how to handle that.We’ve got to balance our critical thinking and our emotional intelligence skills together in order to handle conflict.
I urge all our readers to check it out to learn some really valuable skills, like emotional literacy, above-the-line and below-the-line thinking, leading with presence, unarguable communication, and speaking with candor and empathy. These are some of the skills that will help you work through some of those conflict situations in the OR.
Orth-Nebitt: It is information that every manager needs. If you have not dealt with conflict, are you even a manager?
Kildgore: I was looking through the leadership series on demand. The theme under leadership was, how do we deal with some of these really stressed out nurses? This applies especially if you are in a director position because then you are also having to manage really stressed out leaders with their own staff.
It is all about working with all staff members as appropriate, and everyone understanding that conflict is pretty normal. It is going to be even higher charged during this time. How do we deal with that in a way that may not always come to a win-win solution, but you come to an understanding.
We had so many presentations that dealt with that and gave a lot of insight into how to deal with difficult or emotional conversations, such as death in the OR. We’ve probably dealt with more death during the pandemic because of OR nurses working in ICUs. As leaders, we were looking for ways to communicate and get our styles sharpened back up.
Doyle: The other thing is resilience. Nurses, again, are not very good at taking care of themselves. Because the OR is a very stressful work environment, we have to ask, how do we build ourselves up, and how do we develop and strengthen our own resilience to keep us going in this stressful time?
Bethel: The closing speaker, Frances Cole Jones, did a very nice job of trying to give us skills to communicate appropriately and to get our message across as leaders. I thought it was well done, with a little humor. She gave some very good practical tips.
Orth-Nebitt: The “Ask Me Anything” sessions are so valuable, especially for new managers who aren’t sure what they are doing and/or have unique situations. It’s a great opportunity to ask and to talk to other leaders.
As far as strategies for new managers discussed in those sessions, here is an overview:
• Utilize your network. Establish your network, or take a step back and figure out who is in your network. You certainly have a mentor or an administrator, or someone who is more of a colleague with whom you can network Nursing organizations are a great way to network locally. If you are in Iowa, you have the Iowa Organization of Nursing Leaders through the Iowa Hospital Association. Seek out events like OR Manager Conference and OR Business Management Conference. Being a member of AORN and other organizations can get you involved and give you a platform to ask questions.
• Utilize all your resources. As OR managers, we deal with a lot of vendor representatives (reps). You can and should also use reps as resources. I don’t think that a new manager will necessarily realize that reps can be good resources. Some of those vendors that have been around a long time have a lot of information about the OR. Most vendors know their products inside and out. If you have a question about a product, they’ll give you all of the information that you need. There’s a wealth of information to be gained if you seek it out.
• Ask for feedback. That is one thing managers aren’t sure if they’re supposed to do. You are doing the best that you can, but it’s also ok to ask for feedback. On the other side of that, be kind to yourself. No one is perfect. Just because all of sudden you have a manager position, it doesn’t mean that you have to be perfect. I touched on that at the “Ask Me Anything” sessions. I wanted to be perfect my first year as a manager. I lost a lot of sleep over it. It took me a while to realize that no one’s perfect. The staff don’t expect you to be perfect. In fact, if you are perfect, they’re not going see you as genuine. Be kind to yourself.
Bethel: I had the opportunity to do the new manager bootcamp. Mine focused mostly on finances. It’s entitled “Managing Dollars and Sense.” All of the topics that I covered, you could probably spend a whole day talking about them. It’s a nuts and bolt kind of session of the basics.
Cindy: Sheri Vos gave a nice presentation called “Rising to the Top, an Effective Guide to Leadership.” It was very thoughtful in how to gain your knowledge, how to express yourself, how to watch for those openings when they come and position yourself well.
Doyle: We are individuals who are lifelong learners. These conversations are there to teach us new things, reflect on long-standing chanllenges, as well as maybe spark interest in areas we never thought possible. This is a powerful community. You are not alone. ORM
—Tarsilla Moura