Remote surgery has come a long way since the first-ever case in 2001, when a surgeon in New York City operated on a patient in Strasbourg, France. No longer a product of science fiction, telesurgery’s advance promises to change—and save—countless lives, from patients in remote areas to those in warzones and even in space. Remote-controlled surgical robots even offer potential advantages over traditional surgery, such as potentially reduced infection risk due to physical separation of the surgeon from the patient.
Telesurgery’s great promise provides good reason to be optimistic that remaining cost and technology barriers will eventually fall away. In the meantime, understanding the financial, technical, regulatory, training, and other challenges associated with operating on patients in a far-away OR will become more important for perioperative leaders as capabilities and access expand.
Continued evolution
Surgical robots have advanced significantly since Dr Jacques Marescaux performed that groundbreaking cholecystectomy nearly 25 years ago. For example, the availability of a fourth arm—one of the most obvious differences between Marescaux’s now-defunct Zuess system and a modern da Vinci robot—can minimize the need for staff to change instruments, help support tissue, or otherwise streamline and reduce the risks associated with complex telesurgery procedures.
Marascaux relied on remote control and video feed just as surgeons do today, although modern connections are faster and more robust. Modern surgeons are also more familiar with robotic surgery. In fact, Intuitive Surgical—which manufactures the da Vinci system—estimates that surgeons have performed more than 10 million procedures globally using that system alone. Meanwhile, other robotics manufacturers have entered the market since Marescaux performed that first intercontinental telesurgery, expanding competition and further reducing barriers to entry. The more these systems advance, the more organizations invest in them, and the more surgeons train on them, the more accessible robotic surgery—and by extension, telesurgery—is likely to become.
Expanding capability, accessibility
Progress aside, challenges to widespread adoption remain prevalent. Notable examples include:
- Financial barriers. Costs for equipment, training, and ongoing maintenance remain substantial for organizations investing in surgical robotics, let alone telesurgery. A facility might need to shell out hundreds of thousands of dollars per year in service fees and replacement parts. In addition to the robot, telesurgery requires investing in haptic feedback devices (which mimic the sensory input from physical touch), remote collaboration software platforms, remote health monitoring devices (pulse oximeters, glucose monitors, etc.), high-resolution real-time imaging, and more. And whatever the real-time data transmission capabilities of the latest high-speed, low-latency communication networks, organizations may judge as-needed travel expenses for surgeons and support staff as more cost effective. To mitigate these challenges, individual organizations might consider cost-sharing collaborations with other institutions or seek grants, subsidies, or partnerships from robotics companies.
- Technology hurdles. In telesurgery, the concern for connectivity interruptions, server issues, and mechanical failures is always prevalent. Ensuring safety requires not only robust infrastructure investment (including backup systems), but also routine equipment checks and updates, as well as developing contingency plans and having IT professionals on standby during surgeries to address any technical glitches immediately. The good news is that as 5G becomes more widely available, issues of cost and latency can be addressed simultaneously. As detailed below, workflow modifications and remote communication protocols also are essential to safety.
- Regulatory compliance. In cases where a state or regional medical license is required to practice medicine, a surgeon may not perform remote surgery if they are not licensed to practice in the state where the surgery is taking place. Medical boards, licensing authorities, and legal experts can shed light on compliance with regulations governing interstate—and international—surgical procedures. Meanwhile, regulatory bodies are working to streamline cross-border medical practices. For example, the Interstate Medical Licensure Compact (IMLC) simplifies the licensing process for physicians who wish to practice across state lines. Although the IMLC focuses mostly on telemedicine and cybersecurity, the framework could serve as a foundation for future efforts to address remote surgery specifically.
- Additional staff training. Whether remotely or on-site, operating surgical robots requires specialized training and credentials (eg, board certification in a relevant specialty and completion of an accredited robotic surgery fellowship or equivalent program). Telesurgery demands that staff also must be proficient in operating and troubleshooting advanced equipment, understanding remote communication systems, and executing emergency protocols without immediate physical guidance from the surgeon. The latest virtual reality and simulation tools can provide practical experience without risk to patients.
- Workflow adjustments. For the perioperative team, working remotely changes the approach to collaboration and responsibility distribution. Clear communication protocols and synchronized workflows become more critical, particularly given the need for ongoing patient assessment and coordinating with the remote surgeon in addressing any potential complications. In the preoperative phase, on-site surgical staff must handle tasks that might otherwise be performed by the surgeon in non-remote settings. Examples include patient positioning, instrument setup, and confirming all surgical tools are functioning correctly. Verifying network connectivity, establishing backup communication methods, and other essential tasks can make preoperative meetings more rigorous. From there, HIPAA-compliant videoconferencing tools help relay the surgeon’s directives and enable instantaneous feedback from the operating room. They also can facilitate postoperative debriefings, including reviews of imaging and patient vitals.
Telesurgery has the potential to transform healthcare delivery, making specialized surgical care accessible to patients worldwide regardless of geographical boundaries. However, it also requires thinking carefully about surgical techniques, tools, and team dynamics. By meeting specific requirements in technology, education, processes, and finances, the medical community can make fully remote surgery a more accessible and standard practice.
—Steven John Cumper, B.App.Sc. (Osteo), M.Ost., is a businessman with a background in biomedical science and osteopathic medicine. He founded Medshop and ScrubsIQ while studying at RMIT University in Australia.
References
Eckhoff JA, Müller DT, Brunner SN, et al. Do the costs of robotic surgery present an insurmountable obstacle? A narrative review. International Journal of Abdominal Wall and Hernia Surgery. April-June 2023.
Intuitive reaches 10 million procedures performed using da Vinci Surgical Systems. Intuitive Surgical. December 14, 2021.
Marescaux J, Leroy J, Rubino F, et al. Transcontinental Robot-Assisted Remote Telesurgery: Feasibility and Potential Applications. Annals of Surgery. April 2002.
Nankaku A, Tokunaga M, Yonezawa H, et al. Maximum acceptable communication delay for the realization of telesurgery. PloS One. October 2022.
Redan J. Video-Based Technologies in the OR Have Potential to Transform Healthcare. American College of Surgeons. December 6, 2023.