With healthcare costs continuing to rise, hospitals, payers, and patients are looking for different venues for care and ways to cut costs while maintaining quality and safety.
As more surgical procedures are safely performed in outpatient settings, more ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) are being built or restructured. Partnerships between hospitals and physicians have become more common as the two groups increasingly join forces. This article examines the rising popularity of ASC joint ventures and what hospitals and physicians need to consider before creating a partnership.
Joan G. Dentler, MBA, founder of Avanza Healthcare Strategies, Austin, Texas, has been sharing her knowledge and perspectives on ASC joint ventures for decades. In her ASC experience, she has seen many factors that have shaped the ASC landscape.
Value-based care, which Teisberg et al defined as “the measured improvement in a patient’s health outcomes for the cost of achieving that improvement,” is gaining prominence as more inpatient surgical care is shifted to outpatient settings.
This outpatient migration will continue to grow as patients, payers, and providers recognize the value of providing surgical care in ASCs.
An Outpatient Statistical Snapshot by Avanza showed that between 2000 and 2017, the number of Medicare-certified ASCs almost doubled, increasing from 3,028 to 5,634. Outpatient visits increased from 1,817 per 1,000 people in 1999 to 2,251 in 2015, an increase of almost 24%. Hospital outpatient revenue outpaced inpatient revenue (60% and 28%, respectively). The report noted that ASCs reduced US healthcare costs by more than $38 billion per year, and that the number of Medicare-certified ASCs almost doubled, increasing from 3,028 to 5,634, between 2000 and 2017.
In 2019, Badlani, detailed the different ASC ownership models, each with its own advantages and legal requirements.
Physician-owned ASC. Physicians own 100% equity in the ASC, and as sole owners, they are responsible for all operations and decisions concerning the ASC. They usually contract with a third-party company to help manage the business and administrative sides of the ASC but retain all ownership.
Hospital-owned ASC. In this model, the physicians do not have equity, but rather, they are contracted by the hospital and paid a percentage of the revenue. In these agreements, compensation is often tied to quality and performance.
Two-way joint venture between physicians and an ASC management company. Either party could be the majority owner and exert control based on the percentage of ownership. This model is helpful for smaller ASCs that may not have the expertise or resources to handle the business and administrative sides. Some of the biggest names in ASC management include United Surgical Partners International/Tenet Healthcare, Amsurg, and Surgical Care Affiliates.
Three-way joint venture between physicians, a hospital, and an ASC management company. The ownership structure in this model varies.The hospital and the ASC management company (as a holding company) have majority ownership (the hospital also may have majority ownership in the holding company), or the physicians have majority ownership over the hospital and management company.
In addition to these ownership models, there are also models in which a private equity or a payer is the owner, although it is not always transparent to the public.
In 2018, Avanza reported that joint ventures between hospitals and physicians accounted for 67% of hospital ASCs.
Here, Dentler highlights some of the factors contributing to the growth of hospital-physician ASC joint ventures.
Hospital motivations
• Value-based strategy. As health outcomes are measured against the cost of achieving those outcomes, hospitals are incentivized to provide what is considered a good value to patients and payers.
• Consumer-driven trends. In the US healthcare system, healthcare costs are shared between payers and patients. In addition to an insurance model, many patients are self-pay, or their employers are self-insured. Regardless of the payer model, however, less costly procedures for similar outcomes would translate to lower costs for patients and drive volume to ASCs.
• Benefits to hospitals. There is strong competition between hospitals and physician-owned ASCs for patients. By partnering with physicians, hospitals can prevent physicians from “taking” patients away. The joint venture investment opportunity also helps hospitals in their recruitment efforts.
• Physicians’ changing mindset. The new generation of physician CEOs often has a different mindset than their predecessors, who saw hospitals as competitors. This new generation sees joint ventures as a win for them as well as for hospitals.
• Payer pressures. As healthcare costs rise, payers exert pressure on hospitals to contain costs without sacrificing quality and safety. Some payers will refuse to pay for certain procedures performed in a hospital when these procedures can be performed safely in an ASC.
Physician motivations
• Organizational resources and expertise. Many ASCs, especially small ones, lack organizational resources and expertise such as recruitment and personnel management, billing and collections, marketing, payer negotiation, and compliance oversight that a hospital partner may be able to provide.
• Regulatory requirements. State laws vary greatly when it comes to requiring a certificate of need for an ASC. The process is long and costly. With the hospital’s involvement, the process can be less daunting for physician groups.
• Branding and reputation. Many ASCs do not have the size or name to gain brand recognition or reputation, but a joint venture with a well-known hospital can help elevate those.
• Financial incentives. In a joint venture with a hospital, physicians continue to retain partial ownership of the ASC and receive income from that part. Physician groups also can use the hospital’s clout to negotiate better reimbursement rates. In addition, a joint venture provides a ready buyer for physicians who decide to sell their shares.
In this ownership model, either the hospital or the physicians can be the majority owner, depending on the leverage they have at the time to join the venture. There are no universal equity requirements. A hospital that has lost surgical volume to an ASC, for example, may be willing to take a minority stake in the ownership. An ASC that may not have the size, reputation, financial stability, or administrative expertise, on the other hand, may assume the minority ownership. Some are cautious about whether the hospital could provide the efficiency and expertise needed, as running a hospital is different than running an ASC, said Badlani, cited in the source below.
Though hospital-ASC joint ventures are on the rise, which provide benefits to hospitals, physicians, payers, and patients, there are misconceptions and misinformation about these partnerships, says Dentler.
Here, she dispels some of these myths.
Myth 1: Universal equity requirement. Contrary to common belief, there are no universal equity requirements for either party. A not-for-profit hospital, for example, is not required to have majority ownership (more than 50%) of an ASC to maintain its not-for-profit status. The hospital, however, does need to show that it has control over certain operations or financial situations, according to the applicable rules.
Myth 2: ASC joint venture collects the same HOPD reimbursement. The hospital and ASC have separate fee schedules, and the ASC does not collect hospital outpatient department (HOPD) reimbursement rates even if the hospital owns more than 50% of the joint venture. Depending on a hospital’s leverage with a commercial payer, it may ask the payer for similar reimbursements for ASC and HOPD patients, even though the ASC fee schedule is typically lower than the HOPD fee schedule, which is why payers are pushing for more procedures to be done in ASCs
Myth 3: Physicians cannot own an HOPD. When an HOPD is converted to an ASC, the ASC must be re-licensed as a freestanding ASC and have its own license with different requirements and regulations than the hospital.
Myth 4: Regulation prohibits employed physicians from being ASC joint venture investors. Many hospitals do not let their employed physicians be investors for various reasons, but there is no regulation that prohibits physicians from doing so. In fact, the Avanza Intelligence 2021-2022 Hospital Leadership ASC Survey showed that 54% of hospital systems allowed employed physicians to invest in ASCs. There is also misinformation that physician investors’ “compensation” that comes from ASC distributions would fall outside of the schedule compliance. But this additional “compensation” is actually a return on investment as investors, not as employees. In addition, not allowing employed physicians to be investors but requiring them to perform cases at the ASC potentially creates an acrimonious environment. Independent physicians who are allowed to invest could benefit from cases performed by employed physicians who are not investors.
Myth 5: Competitive physicians cannot be partners in a joint venture. It takes some due diligence to structure the agreements correctly, but there is nothing that would stop competing physicians from successfully joining the partnership.
Myth 6: The hospital can give services for free to the ASC joint venture. The hospital and its ASC joint venture are two separate entities, and the hospital must provide services at a fair market value.
Though ASC joint ventures continue to grow, it does not mean that it is the right thing for every hospital, health system, or ASC.
Needs assessment. It is helpful to start with a needs assessment to understand what the hospital needs, and respectively, what the ASC needs. Supply (capacity) and demand (surgical cases) questions should be examined closely to understand what the ASC can absorb if the hospital partner starts directing cases to the ASC. Future demand and anticipated growth should also be taken into consideration.
Procedure types. Procedure types are another critical question. Are most surgical procedures performed as hospital inpatient procedures, or can they also be performed in an ASC? Safety regulations dictate which procedures can be done in an outpatient setting and whether the recovery would require an in-hospital stay. These issues are critical to assess up front because they would impact reimbursement. The kind of procedures the ASC currently performs or is set up to perform (single- or multiple-specialty) is an essential assessment.
Payers. One of the main drivers for outpatient migration is cost savings. Though most payers would push for a lower-cost surgical venue, they need to also follow certain safety and quality rules. Certain procedures may not be suitable for an ASC setting and will not be reimbursed. For example, Medicare issues a list of ASC-approved procedures with specific billing codes, and any outside of this list may not be reimbursed. This ASC-approved list continues to change as procedures are added.
After the needs are defined and the payment structure is investigated, the hospital and physicians need to ensure that their organizations are ready to join forces. Dentler recommends discussing the following key issues:
• Vision and shared goals. Each group may have a different vision of what “success” looks like and what their goals are. Only when the visions of success are aligned and goals are shared, will this partnership come to fruition and be long-lasting.
• Mutual trust and respect. These are paramount to a sustainable partnership. Competition is often the driving force that sets “us” against “them” in the traditional hospital-ASC relationship. Transparent and clear communication fosters trust and respect in the joint venture. If disagreements and conflicts cannot be resolved, both sides would benefit from bringing in a third-party facilitator with no vested interest in either side.
• Equity and ownership. This will be one of the most contentious issues when the two sides come to the negotiation table. Equity and ownership will determine who will have majority control of the joint venture. The agreement often has a noncompete clause that clearly states if physicians can own another ASC, or if they have the right of first refusal in a new ASC, and similar issues.
• Leadership and governance. Most parties create a steering committee during the forming stages, and as things progress, this committee will morph into a more formal governing board. The hospital-physician governing board will then oversee the official formation of the ASC joint venture and make critical decisions concerning its legal structure, strategy, and financial direction.
• Legal issues. There are many legal issues that arise from any joint venture. The Stark Law, for the most part, is not applicable to ASCs because they are not considered a designated health service. The Medicare Anti-Kickback Statute does apply to ASCs, and states have their own anti-kickback rules. The governing board should involve legal counsel early to ensure that all legal issues are properly examined and options fully explored (sidebar, Stark Law and Anti-Kickback Statute).
The Stark Law, or the Physician Self-Referral Law, “prohibits physicians from referring patients to receive designated health services payable by Medicare or Medicaid from entities with which the physician or an immediate family member has a financial relationship,” as defined by the government. While hospitals are listed as designated health services, ASCs are not; therefore, they fall outside the reach of the Stark Law.
The Anti-Kickback Statue (AKS) prohibits the “knowing and willful” payment of remuneration (eg, cash and other forms of financial incentives) to induce or reward patient referrals or to generate business involving services payable by the federal healthcare programs such as Medicare or Medicaid. Under the AKS, there is a “safe harbor” for ASCs that shields them from certain aspects of the law.
In the Advisory Opinion No. 21-02, the Office of Inspector General provided some guidance on ASC-joint-venture investments using the one-third test:
1. At least one-third of each physician investor’s medical practice income from all sources for the previous fiscal year or previous 12-month period must be derived from the physician’s performance of ASC-Qualified Procedures
2. At least one-third of the procedures performed by each physician investor for the previous fiscal year or previous 12-month period must be performed at the investment entity.
OIG sources provided under References.
• Roles and responsibilities. This goes beyond the leadership and governing board. Some questions include: What does the management structure look like? Who will run the ASC? The roles and responsibilities of the hospital must be made clear: What support will it provide to the ASC joint venture? Will it provide support in billing and collection, marketing, and human resources? Similarly, the roles and responsibilities of the physicians must be spelled out: Are they expected to be part of a committee or to co-manage any part of the operation?
• Operations. The hospital administrators and physicians need to discuss and agree on who has control of which part(s) of the operation, which cases will come to the ASC and which will stay at the hospital, what the schedules will look like, and how cases should be booked. Technology is another critical piece—it helps improve efficiency and effectiveness, but it is often costly. What technology is needed and at what cost could become contentious issues.
• Financial risks. In addition to shared goals and vision, the hospital and physicians need to have similar risks to embark on this joint venture together. Both sides need to come to an agreement on what financial “health” would look like, how the revenue cycle would be managed (eg, who would do the billing and collection), how much cash reserves need to be put aside, and what the profit distribution would entail.
This is a complex partnership, and for it to be successful, both sides need to be flexible and willing to do things a bit differently.
Here, Dentler advises the following.
The hospital should:
• avoid the need to control and allow the physicians to take the lead on ASC-related decisions
• offer to provide organizational support (human resources, recruiting, marketing, and payer contracting)
• embrace the ASC as an extension of its surgical services rather than a competitor
• work with physicians to migrate cases to the ASC.
The physicians should:
• take part in the ASC governance and management (joining or running committees promoting quality and safety)
• support efficient and cost-effective ASC operations
• help recruit new partners
• participate in succession planning.
As the ASC joint venture ownership model continues to grow, many more hospitals and physician groups will consider joining the trend; however, this may not be the right structure for everyone. Every ASC and hospital must do their due diligence and ask if this is the right fit, right time, right partner, or right strategy. Not having one may be better than having a dysfunctional one.
—Uyen Vo, BSN, MBA, is a freelance writer with more than 20 years of experience in healthcare.
Avanza Intelligence 2021-2022 Hospital Leadership ASC Survey. Avanza Healthcare Strategies.
Badlani N. Ambulatory surgery center ownership models. J Spine Surg. 2019;5(Suppl 2):S195-S203.
Dentler J G. ASC Joint Ventures – Risk or Reward? OR Business Management Conference. OR Business Management Conference. 2023.
Outpatient statistical snapshot. Avanza Healthcare Strategies. Accessed May 2023.
Right-sizing healthcare. Avanza Healthcare Strategies. 2018.