• Supporting nurse leaders is just as important as supporting staff to achieve optimal patient care and a financially healthy organization.
• Organizations can support nurse leaders in many ways, including providing recognition, ancillary support, creative schedule options, and professional development opportunities.
• Novice managers need structured programs to ensure a smooth transition from clinician to their new role.
OR Manager’s three-part series on the state of the perioperative workforce in 2023 concludes with this installment. Part 1, published in April, looked at the hospital OR setting as well as union activities (pp 1, 18–22); a separate article on ASCs appeared in the May issue (pp 25–27). Part 2, published in May (pp 1, 17–20), examined areas outside the OR—postanesthesia care unit (PACU) and sterile processing department (SPD).
Here, in Part 3, the focus is on OR leaders and how they and their organizations are supporting new and experienced managers in meeting today’s challenges.
While the needs of staff rightly receive much attention when it comes to workforce issues, it is worth remembering that managers are a vital part of the workforce as well. Like staff, managers have seen their world undergo seismic changes, especially since the COVID-19 pandemic, and also like staff, many have chosen to leave their roles.
Unfortunately, many organizations have been slow to respond to leaders’ needs, even though nurse manager competence has been shown to improve outcomes, thereby promoting an organization’s financial health.
For example, an analysis by Nora Warshawsky, PhD, RN, NEA-BC, FAAN, and colleagues linked nurse manager competence to better practice environments for leaders and staff, lower missed nursing care, and higher quality patient care. In addition, when Warshawsky, the nurse scientist for Press Ganey, analyzed 2017 study data for top and bottom performers, she found that greater nurse manager satisfaction levels were associated with a greater RN intent to stay and fewer missed care activities.
Understanding the pressures leaders face can point organizations in the right direction to provide support.
“Leaders are trying to balance quality and safety with staffing and volume,” says Rose O. Sherman, EDd, RN, MEA-BC, FAAN, a leadership expert who is the author of two books on nursing leadership and professor emeritus for Florida Atlantic University in Boca Raton. “There’s an awful lot on their plates.”
A large portion of that plate is staffing, which is creating multiple headaches for nurse leaders. According to the 2022 American Organization for Nursing Leadership (AONL) Foundation Longitudinal Nursing Leadership Insight Study, managers spend 60% to 80% of their time on recruitment, staffing, and scheduling.
Managers also are facing a different workforce from prepandemic days. Travelers remain prevalent, and many staff have little or no experience in the specialty. A growing percentage of this workforce is composed of Generation Z staff, who bring expectations such as an environment that supports their mental health, regular career advancement, and more recognition and guidance from supervisors compared to previous generations.
Given the current healthcare environment and constraints in resources, leaders may find it difficult to meet these expectations. “It is not easy to hold Gen Z staff accountable,” Sherman says. Reasons include insufficient performance feedback during nursing school and lack of clarity about role expectations. In addition, members of Generation Z frequently change jobs, which adds to a manager’s frustration when, after investing significant time and money in training new staff, they leave for another organization.
The makeup of the current workforce requires much more coaching and mentoring than in the past. This is challenging enough for experienced managers, but many perioperative leaders have limited experience in the role, magnifying the problem.
Staffing issues spill over to other areas. For example, perioperative leaders must contend with surgeons who are unhappy with travelers and the difficulty of finding hospital beds for postoperative patients as a result of insufficient staffing on units.
At a time when strong leadership is needed, some organizations are instead cutting managers because clinical staff are in high demand. “There is a reluctance to add ballast to leadership teams, but at the same time, that is exactly what’s needed,” Sherman says. She adds that many members of the C-suite, including chief nursing officers, do not have regular contact with managers, so they fail to fully appreciate the myriad pressures. Sherman points to the quarterly meetings that the chief nursing officer at New York-Presbyterian Hospital, New York City, holds with managers as a valuable strategy for maintaining a strong relationship between leaders at different levels in an organization.
Given the stressors leaders face each day and the lack of organizational support, it is not surprising that the AONL study found that 45% of nurse managers were considering leaving their role. Organizations and leaders themselves must tackle several key issues to reduce this percentage, starting with span of control and supporting novice nurse managers.
Most nurse leaders have seen their span of control expand over the years to the point where it is often unmanageable. For example, a 2019 study by Cupit and colleagues found that 44% of nurse managers in the University of Texas Medical Branch, Galveston, had an excessive span of control. The pandemic has only exacerbated the problem.
What is an appropriate span of control? Based on her research, Warshawsky puts the number at between 40 and 50 FTEs. “Once you get over 50 FTEs, it starts to show in patient outcomes,” she says. But Warshawsky adds that span of control is complex, and determining the best number depends on multiple factors such as the size of a unit, the number of beds on the unit, the number of staff needed to staff those beds, and the experience of that staff. Factors in the OR would include number and complexity of cases.
Warshawsky says it is best to consider span of control in the context of teams, with smaller groups preferred. “Smaller teams build cohesion,” she adds. A creative approach also can be beneficial. Traditionally, the thinking has been one leader for one team, but Warshawsky says that comanagers could be an option, provided the two leaders work well together. “It’s a line of research we need to look at,” she says.
A common strategy to address span of control is to provide support staff, but Warshawsky says research shows that although adding support positions, such as administrative assistants, clinical nurse leaders, and support staff for functions such as scheduling, staffing, and payroll provides some relief, it does not fully offset wide spans of control. In fact, according to a study by Warshawsky, Schlotzhauer, and Cramer, top-performing nurse managers have less support staff than bottom-performing nurse managers. A key difference is that top performers have, on average, 20 fewer FTEs to oversee than bottom performers. Overall, top performers averaged 43.8 FTEs, 2.25 units, and 1.8 support positions.
Warshawsky says a key takeaway is, “You need to combine reasonable span of control with adequate support.” Outcomes are better for mangers who have smaller spans of control compared to those with larger spans of control with or without added support. One area where support may be particularly helpful is scheduling, which Sherman says accounts for as much as 60% to 80% of some leaders’ time. “If you can help them with that, it is a big piece off their plate,” she says.
Deb Zimmerman, DNP, RN, NEA-BC, FAAN, president-elect of AONL and chief executive officer of the DAISY Foundation, says it is important for executives to speak directly with leaders in assessing span of control. “Senior leaders need to spend time with managers to really look at what the right span of control is,” she says. Zimmerman also is chief clinical officer and principal of Leaders in Care, which helps improve clinical performance in healthcare settings and create a healthy work environment. She notes that AONL is collaborating with the American Hospital Association on a white paper, expected to be released in 2023, on redesigning the nurse manager role.
A 2019 study by Warshawsky and colleagues found that nurse managers only begin to feel proficient in their role after 7 years, indicating the need for initial and ongoing support for nurses transitioning from clinician to manager. One factor in determining proficiency is graduate education: Those with a graduate education were more likely to feel proficient sooner. In addition, subsequent research by Warshawsky found that graduate education is an important factor in nurse manager competency. However, novice managers of all education backgrounds need support. “You have to actively help them transition into the role, not just say, here’s your office, go for it,” Warshawsky says. “There needs to be a plan.”
The plan should have two components. The first is didactic or what Warshawsky calls the “what” side. It includes knowledge-based information, such as the role of HR and how to create a budget; this component typically takes 6 months to a year.
The second component is the behavioral or “how” side, which Warshawsky defines as, “the way we relate to people, the way we communicate with staff, the way we carry ourselves, our presence.” She notes that the core principle underlying leadership styles described in the literature (ie, authentic leadership, transformational leadership, human-centered leadership), is that the leader creates a relationship with the follower. “Good leaders motivate and inspire followers; they don’t dictate to them,” she says. “There is an art and a science to it.” This component can be integrated into didactic education through scenario-based teaching and role playing, with mentors helping new managers with these skills in daily work life. Mentors can also help ease the path for leaders moving from one organization to another.
An example of how mentorship can be used to support leaders is a peer mentor program. “A peer mentor program helps get people up to speed more quickly and improves leader retention,” says Jennifer Misajet, MHA, RN, CNOR, CSSM, interim chief nurse for Trinity Health, who has worked with several of these programs.
Peer mentors are at the same level as new mangers, but have more experience in the role, in the organization, or both. “The peer mentor can help the new manager navigate the system,” Misajet says. The mentor can provide information such as the right person to contact with problems and the right process to follow when making a budget request. The relationship goes beyond the mechanics, however, with the mentor able to help the new manager understand the culture of the organization and how to function within it.
Mentorship also provides the opportunity for mentees to ask questions they might not want to ask their own manager; for example, new leaders might be reticent to admit to their supervisor that they lack experience in calculating productivity. “New managers feel more comfortable being vulnerable with their mentor than their supervisor,” Misajet says. Often situations can be resolved at the mentor level, without needing to involve the supervisor.
Misajet says the leadership team discusses the pairing of mentor and mentee to determine the best fit. “Having input from the entire team helps in making a good choice,” she says. For example, a person who interviewed an introverted new manager might know that they could benefit from being paired with someone who is not extremely extroverted. Important considerations include whether the leadership styles of the pair are congruent and whether a potential mentor has the bandwidth to take on the responsibility. Both the mentor and the mentee must understand expectations, and those in the organization also need to know about the pairing, in the same way staff know who is a preceptor for a new nurse.
Not all pairings work out. “You might think you made the right pairing, but it turns out not to be a good fit because of personality or style differences,” Misajet says. Quick action to change the pairing is needed to avoid having the new manager leave the organization.
The formal part of the mentor/mentee relationship typically lasts about 6 months. The first 90-to-120-day time frame is intense. More structured meetings are held to review items such as payroll, scheduling, and how to access IT support. In addition to addressing mentee’s questions, checklists are used to ensure needed topics are covered. Trinity has one checklist for frontline leaders and another for senior leadership. “Having a checklist to go along with the mentorship provides a structured orientation and helps new managers get a firm foundation,” Misajet says. Once completed, the checklist is kept in the new manager’s HR record.
The peer mentor can be invaluable in helping the mentee compete the checklist. For example, a checklist item might be to talk with finance, and the mentor can share the best person to connect with. “So much is matrix in an organization that it can be hard to know the best people to contact for all the different situations a new manager encounters,” Misajet says. The mentor can ensure the mentee knows who they need to interact with on a regular basis.
After 6 months, informal mentorship often continues, especially when the mentee is faced with new tasks, such as making a capital request or dealing with a difficult employee. Ultimately, the mentee may become a mentor. “Today’s mentee becomes tomorrow’s mentor,” Misajet says.
The mentee’s supervisor is an integral part of the mentor/mentee relationship. The supervisor regularly meets with the mentee to ensure everything is going well, with the mentor to ensure progress is being made and there are no red flags, and with both the mentee and mentor to be sure that pairing is working. “There are multiple points of support for the new manager,” Misajet says.
The peer mentor program benefits not only the mentee but the mentor as well. “Most people who serve as mentors tell me they get far more out of it than they put into it,” Misajet says. “They feel it helps them grow and is a job satisfier for them.”
Job satisfaction plays a key role in retaining both staff and leaders. A literature review by Keith and colleagues found several factors that influence nurse manager satisfaction, including workloads, nurse manager–supervisor relationships, quality of training and competency, and organizational support. In addition, leaders themselves have identified what could change to improve the work experience (sidebar, Joyful work). With this background in mind, here are a few strategies organizations can use to support leaders.
Job analysis. Organizations can conduct a critical analysis of everything a nurse manager does. “Look at what should be stopped, what should continue, and what should be added,” Warshawsky says, noting that in most cases, the main result will be identification of many activities that could be stopped, freeing up the manager.
Nurse manager councils. “We have shared governance councils for direct care nurses, so why not for managers?” Warshawsky asks. These councils help managers control some of their work, including work that others want to shift to them. “We can’t continue to say a nurse manger can do all of these things and be all of these things to all people,” she says. Councils also provide the opportunity for sharing challenges and gaining insights from other leaders. For example, some leaders are reluctant to delegate tasks and may need help understanding how to do so effectively.
Professional development. Continued leadership development for leaders at all levels is key for continued growth. “Organizations are spending a lot of time on onboarding staff, but aren’t thinking about leader development, even though many of the leaders are inexperienced,” Sherman says. “Investment in education and conference attendance is critical.”
Duke University Health System, Durham, North Carolina, is an example of an organization investing in professional development. The health system offers classes that include topics such as managing change and just culture. Leaders across the system attend classes, which promotes an appreciation of what managers are facing in different areas. Real-life scenarios enhance learning; for instance, a class on patient safety examines how managers address issues that have occurred.
Laura Dickerson, MSN, RN, NE-BC, clinical operations director for heart services at Duke, adds that education is incorporated into her monthly meetings with nurse managers. A manager presents a topic, which may be a situation they worked through on their unit that would be helpful to other leaders. “It allows managers to get presentation practice and share their expertise,” Dickerson says. “I feel it enhances the cohesiveness of the leadership team because we’re all learning together.”
Human resources. Without a strong HR department, recruitment and retention suffers, creating more pressure on leaders. Unfortunately, Sherman says some organizations are losing staff because of HR inadequacies, such as lack of prompt response to qualified applicants. She quotes an attendee in one of her leadership webinars as saying, “Why doesn’t HR see themselves as being in service to us? Instead, they view us as someone they can turf things to.” Sherman suggests that HR departments conduct stay interviews with leaders to help determine what is needed and what is working in the relationship between HR and management.
Recognition. It is not only staff who should be recognized for a job well done; managers deserve recognition as well. “We [nurse leaders] often don’t take the time to celebrate because we’re so focused on problem solving,” Zimmerman says. AONL and The Daisy Foundation are trying to change that with Phase 1 of the Beyond Gratitude initiative.
Phase 1 focuses on meaningful recognition for managers, including acknowledgment of their contributions. A website (nursemanager.org) provides an avenue for organizations—and individuals—to post photos and videos of nurse managers’ work and to nominate leaders for the DAISY Nurse Leader Award. The website also includes additional strategies such as posters, social media templates, thank-you notes, closer parking, and holding listening sessions. Zimmerman says that feedback from staff is particularly important: “When staff give positive feedback to leaders, it really affirms they are making a difference in the lives of those they work with.” She adds that reading thank-you letters from patients also reminds leaders of the important work they do.
Dickerson tries to involve managers anytime Duke’s efforts are being highlighted beyond the organization, such as in publications and through posters at national meetings. In addition, managers are partnered with recruiters to attend external recruiting events, where they can meet with job candidates and talk about the good things happening in the system. “It inspires them [the managers] and makes them feel appreciated,” Dickerson says.
Technology. Technology can be a burden, but it also can be leveraged to support nurse leaders. Data entry for reports should be automated as much as possible, and databases should be integrated into a single access point that requires only one login. Systems that make scheduling easier also will help free up leaders’ times.
Data collection. To ensure their support is effective, organizations should routinely survey nurse managers to gather data. “Data gives us insights into where sticking points are and where an organization might get some traction to make improvements,” Warshawsky says. One resource is Press Ganey’s Workforce and Engagement Solution platform, which can be used to focus on those in various roles, including nurse leaders.
Work/life balance. “Too often we don’t care for ourselves while we care for others,” Zimmerman says. The demands on leaders often make achieving work/life balance difficult. “One of the biggest challenges for nurse managers is they feel they have to be available 24/7,” Warshawsky says. “They need help understanding that they should not set that expectation for themselves and that they are entitled to go home and sleep at night.” Otherwise, leaders will lose resilience and engagement.
Being responsible for a unit is not the same as being available. Structures can be built in, so nurse leaders get the time off they deserve and need. One common strategy that can be easily implemented is to build stronger connections with administrative shift supervisors. Warshawsky says the manager and shift supervisor should consider themselves a team, with hand-offs being done in the same way staff nurses conduct shift transitions. “That’s a low-hanging fruit that doesn’t cost anything,” she says.
Some organizations are rethinking the traditional Monday through Friday work week and creating other innovative schedule options (sidebar, Innovative work program).
To stay successful, leaders are adapting to their new world. For example, in the past, more emphasis was placed on clinical rather than leadership skills when hiring new managers. Now, organizations are recognizing that leadership ability is more important than clinical expertise.
Melissa Lingle, MBA, BSN, RN, surgical services director for Mount Carmel East, in Columbus, Ohio, part of the Mount Carmel Health System, recently hired a manager who, although not an expert in surgical services, has excellent team building skills. “I am an expert in surgical services and so are my educators and clinical managers,” Lingle says. “I didn’t need an expert in surgical services, I needed somebody who can build a team.” An added advantage is that the new manager is from a younger generation and brings fresh perspectives. Staff, who interviewed candidates, were happy with the choice and looked forward to her ideas.
Another adaptation is to accept that there is no going back, only forward. Lingle says that she realizes staff turnover will remain higher than in the past, so it is important to plan ahead and recruit on a regular basis.
Zimmerman sees a positive outcome of the pandemic—greater collaboration between chief executive officers, chief nursing officers, and chief financial officers to address workforce issues. “There is more of a [C-suite] presence on nursing units and at forums where staff and nurse leaders can talk to CEOs and CFOs about the challenges and how we can work together to address them,” she says.
Despite all the challenges, Zimmerman also is seeing hope among leaders. “We have a wonderful opportunity to redesign healthcare and have a seat at the table,” she says. Nurse leaders can help bring people together to make change. “Nurses have the skill to bring people who have dissident opinions together, so that the right decisions can be made for the health and wellness of the community.”
—Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.
AONL. Nursing leadership workforce compendium. Section 1. 2022.
AONL. Nursing leadership workforce compendium. Section 2. 2023.
Cupit T, Stout-Aguilar J, Cannon L, et al. Assessing the nurse manager’s span of control: A partnership between executive leadership, nurse scientists and clinicians. Nurse Leader. 2019;17(2):103-108.
Galura S, Warshawsky N, Hu W, W, et al. A survey of interim nurse managers to understand the role and the impact on patient outcomes. J Nurs Adm. 2022;52(1):42-50.
Gradfield E M, Schlotzhauer A, Cramer E, Warshawsky N E, et al. Relationships among nurse managers’ job design, work environment, and nurse and patient outcomes. Res Nurs Health. Accepted for publication.
Keith A D C, Warshawsky N, Neff D, et al. Factors that influence nurse manager job satisfaction: An integrated literature review. J Nurs Manag. 2020;29(3):373-384.
Schlotzhauer A, Cramer E, Grandfield E M, Warshawsky N E. Evidence-based guidance for enhancing nurse manager efficacy. J Nurs Adm. Accepted for publication.
Warshawsky N. Building nurse manager well-being by reducing healthcare system demands. J Nurs Adm. 2022;52(4):189-191.
Warshawsky N, Garamanica L, Cramer E. Organizational support for nurse manager role transition and onboarding: Strategies for success. J Nurs Adm. 2020;50(5):254-260.
Warshawsky N, Cramer C. Describing nurse manager role preparation and competency: Findings from a national study. J Nurs Adm. 2019;49(5):249-255.