May 23, 2023

Buddies help new leaders in a new world

By: Judith M. Mathias, MA, BS, RN
Share

Takeaways

• This buddy program works for all levels of an organization and for anyone who is starting to do something new in a leadership role.

• New leaders often feel like they are being “thrown into the deep end,” and having buddies can help them feel safe.

• The real “gold” in the new manager and buddy relationship is that the buddy can explain how everything works, especially things that are not on the organizational chart.


With the significant turnover in nursing leadership today, mentors and role models may be scarce in the workplace. In addition, education and management development programs may have been put on hold or canceled as pandemic priorities shifted resources.

Jennifer Misajet, MHA, RN, CNOR, CSSM

To combat these issues, perioperative services leadership at Saint Alphonsus Health System, Boise, Idaho, leveraged their long-time manager-mentor program that provides new nurse managers with a vital peer support person.

“This buddy program works for all levels of an organization and for anyone who is starting to do something new in a leadership role,” says Jennifer Misajet, MHA, BSN, RN, CNOR, CSSM, system chief nursing officer, vice president of operations at Saint Alphonsus Health System. Saint Alphonsus is a part of Trinity Health, which comprises 115,000 staff members, 26,000 physicians, 88 hospitals, and 131 sites of care across 26 states.

 

New leaders, new world

“Our world has been changed by COVID,” says Misajet. “Our people, our services, and our value have changed, and leaders have to respond.” Seasoned leaders have to learn to transition and adapt to the new healthcare reality, and they must help the new leaders do so also.

People. “Much of the workforce development we’re doing now is reacting to urgent needs—trying new roles and the new clinical care models. It can at times feel like people throwing something against the wall and hoping it sticks, but we have to innovate and pilot different approaches to be able to safely and effectively care for patients,” she says.

There also is significant wage and benefit inflation that leaders have to deal with, and it’s difficult to do when travelers are making more than them in some cases.

Misajet believes leaders should take a lesson from the contract labor staff shift, however, and acknowledge that about 25% to 30% of their staff want flexible work arrangements, and that this is going to continue into the foreseeable future.

She suggests that instead of making contract labor a bad thing, leaders need to figure out what percentage of their workforce wants these types of arrangements and create something that works for them.

Services. During the pandemic, inpatient utilization rates were lower and inpatient surgery shifted to outpatient.

Inpatient utilization has rebounded, but many surgical patients who had overnight stays before the pandemic are continuing with the pandemic practice of going home the same day.

“Amazingly,” notes Misajet, “surgeons who previously insisted their patients stay overnight suddenly learned that in order to perform their cases, their patients could go home and were doing so safely.”

Emergency department (ED) visits were lower during the pandemic, but they aren’t any longer. Urgent care is growing, but people are still using the ED because healthcare systems and payers have not yet forged a comprehensive plan to address what the right site of service is. “The same is true with surgeons performing the same cases in hospital operating rooms and ambulatory surgery centers,” she says.

These are all new problems that experienced leaders must learn to solve and new leaders must be taught to focus on.

Value. “Value is a tough one,” says Misajet. “I feel like we, as leaders, have a lot of control over people and services, but not value.”

“Government and commercial payers are all trying to pay us less for what we do while expecting us to do more,” she says. “They are pushing the cost of care and some of the responsibility over to us, and that can be difficult and unsustainable.”

In addition, patients expect more because they are paying more and have a lot more out-of-pocket expenses. For example, patients will ask why they have to pay a nurse practitioner and a surgeon the same co-pay.

“We need to stop and just admit we are not going back, and we can’t go back. The things we were doing before the pandemic won’t work now, and we must adapt and help our new leaders adapt to this new environment,” says Misajet.

 

Why leaders want to quit

Today’s healthcare leaders and specifically OR leaders are at a heightened risk for turnover, and the reasons are many and varied.

Lack of support. Not only do staff feel a lack of support, but leaders do also. “This is huge,” says Misajet. “We know that one of the key indicators for turnover is when no one is feeling supported.”

Increasing span of control. As leaders leave, the ones who are left are having to take on more units and staff, and before they know it they are in charge of 200 staff members. “It’s really hard to provide meaningful support to 200 people,” she says.

Working with a novice workforce.“This is stressful for a leader,” says Misajet. In the past, a leader would have many staff members who had been there 10 or 20 years and who understood the department and the physicians. Now most OR staff have been there 2 years or less. Also, contract labor is 40% to 60% in some ORs.

“When you are working with a lot of staff who don’t know where anything is and aren’t part of your organization, it takes away from the ability to function as a team. In addition, it’s hard to run an effective workforce when half of the people will be gone in 13 weeks,” says Misajet.

Census fluctuations and backlogs.“These have wreaked havoc in the OR. One minute we are busting at the seams, and the next minute we are sending everyone home,” she says.

Smoothing the schedule is more important now because there aren’t enough nurses in the inpatient units, and surgeons still want to do their cases on Tuesdays and Wednesdays.

“We can’t set up block schedule structures that allow surgeons to do this anymore because this puts 40% of the inpatient volume into the hospital on those days, and we can no longer staff for that.”

Access/efficiency vs quality/safety.“Some say that if you provide really good access, and you are really efficient, you can’t provide really high quality care and be safe, but I don’t think this is true. They are not mutually exclusive,” says Misajet. She says that, at times, she has drawn a Venn diagram just to point out to people that there is a sweet spot in the middle—that people can truly run a very efficient operation where they are bringing people in, providing access, and working through backlogs, while providing high quality and safe care.

Pressure from above and below.There is always pressure from above because the OR is such a financial engine for the hospital.

“Administration is continually asking, where is the volume, what are you doing to get busier, or why aren’t you closing rooms? At the same time, the staff are tired because the OR is short staffed, and they don’t want to rotate to other units when rooms are shut down,” she says. “It’s almost like you can’t win.”

Workplace violence. “I really can’t emphasize this one enough,” says Misajet. She notes that one of their system hospitals in Albany, New York, which has a good workplace violence program and leader, was able to tie turnover in leadership and staff to workplace violence events. “When I read, see, and hear about some of these events, I am not sure I would return to work the next day or ever if it happened to me,” she says. “Work should be a safe place to give care and get care.”

 

Better with a buddy

“I can see why OR leaders want to quit, but it is time to stop admiring the problem and time to do something about it,” says Misajet. “We have found that a buddy system, similar to what we had in swimming lessons as children, can go a long way in providing support for and retaining new leaders,” she says.

New leaders often feel like they are being “thrown into the deep end and having buddies can help them feel safe,” she says.

Misajet says they have found that assigning a buddy to a new leader:

• optimizes onboarding and orientation

• accelerates a new leader’s speed to competence

• improves new leader retention.

She explains that their buddy program combines mentoring and coaching and advises taking the best of a formal coaching and a formal mentoring relationship and combining them (sidebar, What is the buddy program?).

“I would call it the best of both worlds. You want to help the new leader adopt new behaviors and skills, and you want to enhance those with caring, sharing, and helping,” she says.

The buddy program is a purposeful approach that includes having a:

• Detailed orientation schedule—“We focus on this, and what it means is there are no appointments or meetings scheduled for new leaders for a month. They are there purely to learn the role and the organization,” she says. “During this protected time, we choose who we want them to meet with and when, whether it’s the CFO, chaplain, or medical group leadership.”

Buddies can be very helpful in setting up context for these meetings, navigating the new leaders through them, and then following up with answering any questions they may have.

“Let them have that month during which they are learning their leadership role without interference because they will never have that time again. The minute they are set loose, you won’t get them back,” she says.

• Checklist of key training items—“Be really intentional about what you want your new leaders to know and be exposed to,” she advises. A checklist of key training items is important so the buddy will know what to focus on at different times and not leave it to chance.

• Check-ins with department leader, new leader, and buddy—The department leader, new leader, and buddy should meet weekly and go over the new leader’s checklist, schedule, what’s working, and what isn’t working. “This also gives you an opportunity to evaluate the new leader-buddy relationship and see if it’s a good fit. Not everyone works well together,” says Misajet.

• Clear expectations and level of agreement—“The most important thing I have learned from the buddy program is to set really clear expectations and levels of agreement for the new leaders and their buddies.

Considering five levels of agreement, Misajet used the following examples when asking a staff member to be a buddy.

A level-one agreement is when a staff member is asked to be a buddy to a new person, and the staff member answers: “Oh yes, I heard Jen started yesterday.”

A level-five agreement is when a staff member is asked to be a buddy to a new person, and the staff member answers: “Great. Where’s her orientation schedule? When is she starting? I need the checklist.”

Misajet notes that she feels much more confident that a buddy and new leader will make a good team when there is a level-five agreement.

“Don’t shortchange yourself on the levels of expectation and agreement you have before you start pairing people up. That’s the purposeful approach,” she says.

 

Focus on specifics and how to’s

It is important to focus on specifics and how to’s during the new leader’s orientation and training.

• Information technology (IT)—“Don’t underestimate IT,” says Misajet. New leaders have to learn the electronic health record system specific to an organization, and how to use it in their roles.

She notes that at one job, she was not given a computer for 2 weeks, which made the job difficult and lowered the way she saw her value as a leader. “Because of this experience, I make sure devices are ready to go, and I and the buddy can spend time at computers with new leaders showing them how to get into the system and use programs,” she says.

• Human resources (HR)—“Human resources data is something leaders need to know how to access, whether they have been doing the job for 2 months or 30 years,” says Misajet.

New leaders will come into a job having HR issues eagerly awaiting their attention, whether its discipline actions or new applicants to interview. “They need to know how to find these reports, and can learn this quickly from a buddy rather than trying to figure it out for themselves,” she says.

• Finance—Most new leaders get a budget as part of their jobs, and they should be getting weekly reports on the budget and other financials. Misajet notes that when her organization changed from budgeting to forecasting, some of the weekly reports were still being sent out, but they were under a different area and were hard to find by the leaders who needed them. She adds that having a buddy in such a scenario would make the new leader’s job finding those reports so much easier.

• Payroll/scheduling—New leaders must know how to get into these programs and use them, and there is no one better to help them than a buddy who already has the expertise at that level and is using the systems daily, she says.

• Policies—New leaders have to know the policies they are going to have to follow, especially if they are in a labor environment, and where they can find them. Again, a buddy is indispensable in helping a new leader navigate through policies and procedures.

• Relationships/structures—“This is one of the easier ones,” says Misajet, “because we are big on providing everyone with organizational charts—who they work for, who works for them, and where they all fit in. We keep these updated and accurate to correctly reflect our organizational structure and accountabilities.”

She adds that “the real ‘gold’ in the new manager-buddy relationship is that the buddy can explain how everything works, especially things that aren’t on the organizational chart, such as: ‘this department head likes it this way, or this department will always help you if you check with this person.’ You could spend months wondering who to email about certain policies that the buddy could do in a short amount of time,” she says.

“We are all living in a different healthcare world today, and we need different approaches in our practices,” Misajet reiterates. “A buddy program is easy to implement and has been very successful in educating and retaining new managers in our organization.”

 

—Judith M. Mathias, MA, BS, RN, is the clinical editor of OR Manager and was previously clinical editor of the AORN Journal.

 

Reference

Misajet J. Everything works better with a buddy. OR Manager Conference. 2022.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat