January 27, 2026

ASCA’s Kara Newbury breaks down ASC wins in CMS’ 2026 Final Payment Rule

In its 2026 Final Payment Rule, CMS added 573 codes to the ASC Covered Procedures List (ASC-CPL). It’s a big win for the Ambulatory Surgery Center Association (ASCA) and its advocacy efforts.

Kara Newbury, JD, ASCA’s chief advocacy officer, first and foremost views the rule through the lens of Medicare beneficiaries, who gain expanded access and options for care. “It really is giving the doctor the flexibility to choose where they’re going [to operate],” she tells us. “It’s not dictating that all these procedures are going to move to the ASC. It’s just giving them that option, that if the Medicare beneficiary is a good candidate for surgery in the surgery center setting, they have that option. I think the primary win in the rule is that access to care.”

Ms. Newbury says ASCA does not anticipate a huge shift initially in volume for the vast majority of the added codes.

Hospital market basket

CMS will continue to use the hospital market basket to update ASC reimbursements for 2026. “It’s been a pilot since 2019, a long time now,” says Ms. Newbury. “That alignment with the update is positive for us, because we were seeing a growing disparity in reimbursement between HOPDs and ASCs.” While ASCs are still not reimbursed at the same level as HOPDs, Ms. Newbury says the hospital market basket model has halted further growth in that disparity.

Kara Newbury, JD, chief advocacy officer, Ambulatory Surgery Center Association | Photo via LinkedIn

She says ASCs still on average get only about half of what HOPDs do in terms of reimbursement. “When our payment systems were first aligned back in 2007 to 2009, we were at about 65% of the HOPD rate, which was more manageable in terms of being able to continue to do a lot of Medicare Fee for Service volume,” she says.

However, she says the use of the hospital market basket for updates is preferable to the previous alignment with the U.S. Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U), which focuses on costs of general items such as gasoline and milk rather than the cost of operating a healthcare facility. “Historically, the CPI-U is lower than what the hospital market basket was,” she says, which led to a growing disparity between what hospitals and HOPDs were paid and what ASCs were paid. “Stabilizing the update mechanism is a positive,” she says. “We would like to have CMS make permanent the use of the hospital market basket.”

With that in mind, ASCA is working with an outside firm on a research study and analysis that will show CMS the cost savings that have been achieved since 2019 when the hospital market basket was first used to update ASC reimbursement, and project further cost savings if the policy continues. “Even prior to us being on the hospital market basket, the research shows that we’re saving Medicare between $2 billion and $3 billion a year just by existing as an alternative to other higher-cost settings,” says Ms. Newbury. “That is a critical focus for us.”

She says the research will also show how CMS’ policy has encouraged volume migration to the ASC setting for certain procedures. For example, says Ms. Newbury, ASCA is seeing positive movement with GI codes, with room for much more. “Approximately 50% of colonoscopies are still performed in HOPDs or inpatient hospitals, and not for any clinical reason necessarily,” she says. “Our GI docs tell us that a lot more of those procedures could be performed in the ASC setting, so we’re hoping to see some shift in volume there.” She says ASCA has also seen a “little bit of a shift in volume” with cataracts, even though ASCs already perform the vast majority of those cases.

Anesthesia reimbursement

ASCA is also hoping to work with CMS on the anesthesia cost crisis that has impacted ASCs for most of this decade. “We’re trying to figure out how CMS can help,” says Ms. Newbury. “Reimbursement for anesthesia is extremely low, which is obviously difficult from a Medicare reimbursement perspective for those anesthesia providers. A lot of private payors are seizing upon that and saying, ‘When we’re looking at the No Surprises Act, this should be the qualified payment,’ and they’re trying to base what they think the correct rate should be on the Medicare rate, which is absurdly low. That’s been a problem for the anesthesia providers, which is then obviously a problem for ASCs.

“Similar to hospitals, we are now getting requests for stipends, very significant amounts of money that aren’t paying for the anesthesia services themselves, but just for the anesthesia group to service that facility,” she notes. “We’re trying to figure out how we can help our members with that. It’s not as easy or clear cut of a fix with CMS, necessarily, but we are working together with the national anesthesia groups ASA [American Society of Anesthesiologists] and SAMBA [Society for Ambulatory Anesthesia] to see how we can address this problem, because it’s unsustainable to have extremely large payments – $1 million or $2 million sometimes that facilities are being required to pay – just to have access to that anesthesia group.”

Ms. Newbury says ASCs are trying to adjust to rising anesthesia costs using different models, including bringing providers in-house. “Some are looking at CRNA-only or CRNA-heavy models, but in some areas of the country, especially if there aren’t enough anesthesia providers, CRNA reimbursement is not saving the facility that much over an anesthesiologist,” she says. “I feel that ASCs are hit the hardest by anesthesia issues, because we are solely in business to provide elective outpatient surgery.”

Quality reporting

ASCA also is focused on CMS’ ASC Quality Reporting (ASCQR) Program. “We’re talking to our facilities and determining what we should be reporting to CMS, what would be beneficial to the patients and the public, what would be beneficial to the facilities to know,” says Ms. Newbury. She says ASCA would like ASCs to have more input on what they must report rather than “getting measures thrust upon us” that are more appropriate for inpatient hospitals and “don’t really fit with how we operate.

“We were happy to see that in the 2026 Final Rule, CMS did remove some quality reporting measures that we just didn’t think fit with an elective surgery – having to ask patients, ‘Do you have food insecurity? Do you have transportation issues? Do you have housing insecurity?’” says Ms. Newbury. “These things really should be discussed with their primary care physicians or somebody with whom they have an ongoing relationship in the healthcare community than someone with whom you’re having a one-off outpatient elective surgery.”

On tap for 2027

Looking ahead to the 2027 Final Payment Rule, Ms. Newbury says ASCA is working to move additional codes off the inpatient-only list that CMS plans to eliminate completely by 2028.

“We’ve asked that as part of the next tranche that they include their hernia codes,” she says. “It’s my understanding that there was a change to the way that hernias were coded over the last few years so that it’s now based on the size of the hernia. Sometimes when a doctor is operating, they don’t know exactly how big the hernia is going to be until they are in there. Our members have been requesting to get those hernia codes added to make sure that no matter what the size of the hernia is, the individual will be able to have the care provided at the ASC.”

ASCA is working with specialty organizations to convince CMS to add new ASC procedure codes, which she calls a multiyear process. “There is language in the Social Security Act that indicates that CMS will take under advisement codes that are put forth or recommended by specialty organizations,” says Ms. Newbury. “So with the ASC Covered Procedure List, it is critically important to work with the specialty organizations in that space. It’s much more impactful if we can partner with and collaborate with the specialty organizations, and have them take the lead on providing that clinical data.”

On that front, ASCA has successfully worked with the Heart Rhythm Society and the American College of Cardiology (ACC) to get more cardiovascular codes added to the ASC list. “They really took it and ran with it from a clinical perspective,” says Ms. Newbury. “The Heart Rhythm Society and ACC met with CMS to present the data, and they had their electrophysiologist on the meeting. We built that relationship with them, but then they took it and ran with it from the perspective of providing CMS with the data they needed to feel comfortable adding those procedures to the ASC Covered Procedures List.

Ms. Newbury says ASCA is currently in the process of determining which codes it would like to see added for 2027. “We need to submit those by March 1,” she says.

Building and growing relationships with CMS

Ms. Newbury says ASCA maintains ongoing dialogue with various departments at CMS, including the individuals who run the ASC Quality Reporting Program, payment policy personnel, and survey and certification personnel. She says many of these relationships date back to the first Trump administration and often have picked up where they left off in 2021.

“It is challenging because you’re still trying to figure out who you’re meeting with, but there also has been some continuity,” she says. “Some of the individuals that the first Trump administration had working for them did come back, people with whom we’d had a good working relationship. A lot of those folks come from the Hill, so we had some relationships through our legislative advocacy in the past, and I think just having those relationships and having those connections helps. We have a lot of staff with longevity at the association, and it helps to be able to have that continuity to maintain those relationships. I’ve been with ASCA since 2011, which helps.”

She says relationships with the new administration are productive. “It is difficult when a new administration comes in, because it takes them a few months sometimes to get their folks up and running,” says Ms. Newbury. “I don’t think Dr. Oz was confirmed until maybe three months in, and often the rule is already written by that point. So it’s really a multiyear process. In some ways, I think it might have been a little easier than your normal transition of administration because of the first Trump administration. A lot of policies that had been finalized in what I’m calling ‘Trump 1’ have been brought back, including the expansion of the ASC Covered Procedures List. A lot of that had already been finalized in the 2021 rule, which was the final rule in the first Trump administration. A lot of those codes were then removed, but then they brought them back in 2026.”

Ms. Newbury says ASCA has had successes under administrations run by both major parties, and anticipates more of the same with the current one. “I think it’s as much relationships as it is political party,” she says. “There are individuals over at CMS right now who understand ASCs. They came from Energy and Commerce or other committees of jurisdiction that dealt with ASC issues on a regular basis, so they’re familiar with us and what we have to offer to the healthcare community. We look at it as an opportunity right now to continue to expand access to Medicare beneficiaries, and to hopefully stabilize our reimbursement so we can continue to provide that access for years to come. It took the first Trump administration a while to get up and running, and it wasn’t until the last year of their last rulemaking cycle that they made a bunch of these big changes. So it was exciting to see a lot of positive movement for us in the first year of their second administration. We think that will only allow us more opportunities, since we have three more years, presumably, to continue to make positive changes for ASCs.”

Legislative efforts

Ms. Newbury says ASCA’s advocacy doesn’t stop with CMS and the regulatory environment. The association is also looking to Congress to pass appropriate legislation.

“Our advocacy is often very integrated. The legislative and regulatory are integrated,” she says. She points to the hospital market basket as an example. “That is also something we are trying to fix through legislative means,” says Ms. Newbury. “We will have our bill introduced shortly that would align the hospital market basket with HOPD. Since our payment systems are aligned, it would say whatever update factor is used to update the HOPDs would also be used for ASCs.”

Another area of ASCA’s interest on Capitol Hill is coinsurance. “We already have a bill that was introduced last year that would help Medicare beneficiaries: the Co-pay Cap Bill,” says Ms. Newbury. “There is a per-procedure cap on what Medicare beneficiaries pay in the HOPD setting, around $1,700 or $1,800. There is no such cap in the ASC setting. Even for fairly common codes like total joint replacements, a Medicare beneficiary would be paying slightly more to have their procedure done at the ASC, which doesn’t make sense.

“The hospital is made whole through the Medicare trust fund, so the full amount of reimbursement is getting to the hospital,” she explains. “The sole purpose of this bill is to have a similar cap in the ASC setting. It really only impacts those without supplemental insurance, who often are the ones who would benefit the most from access to the convenience and the care provided in an ASC. We will be promoting the bill heavily this year.”

Another area of legislative interest for ASCA is site neutrality. “While on its face it sounds potentially positive for ASCs, we always warn our members who get excited about it that nobody is talking about increasing ASC reimbursement,” says Ms. Newbury. “They’re talking about lowering everybody to the lowest common denominator. So we are trying to work with members of Congress and committee staff to make sure that any potential site neutral legislation doesn’t negatively impact access to care.”

Dive into more ASC-specific details of CMS’ 2026 Final Payment Rule via this page on ASCA’s website.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat