OR Manager interviewed Vicki Smith-Daniels, PhD, professor of supply chain management at Arizona State University, Tempe, about her research on supply chain management in the surgical suite.
Qwhy do we need an academic study of the surgical supply chain?
Smith-Daniels: The short answer is: Clinicians like scientific evidence. The surgical suite has been studied over the past decade with a number of different lenses. Studies have looked at teamwork, quality outcomes, processes, and related topics. So there is evidence on surgical suite improvement. But few studies have looked at the impact of the supply chain on the performance of the surgical suite.
QWhy do you think research is important?
Smith-Daniels: Let me address that on 2 levels. First, the OR is what I would call the primary strategic asset of a hospital. There has been a great deal of work on how to improve operational measures such as utilization, start-time accuracy, and scheduling accuracy. We have seen a lot of case studies on process improvement using Lean management and other methods.
Second, we have seen industry come out with new technologies that offer ways to minimize delays in surgery with respect to supplies. Among these are information systems, inventory monitoring, and custom packs. Most of these try to synchronize the flows of patients, materials, and information.
But hospitals have not adopted all of these solutions. My belief is that is because the return on investment is not clear to a number of stakeholders.
I believe surgical suites have reached the point where a significant investment by the hospital is going to be needed to take them to the next level of improvement.
We need an academic study to show to what extent the improvements we have made so far have made a contribution. Have they improved OR utilization by 5%, by 15%? Is case cart management the missing link?
Are these improvements complementary? Do you need more than one— for example, consignment, inventory tracking, and case cart management— to get the maximum improvement out of your OR?
Some people would say, “We’ll bring in a consultant to tell us what we should do.” Or, “We’ll bring in more vendors.”
My response would be, “Yes, that’s valuable. But it is not a neutral, third-party perspective.” An academic study attempts to bring neutral, third-party evidence to these questions.
Q How do you anticipate your study will help provide those answers?
Smith-Daniels: We will be conducting the study by doing assessments of the surgical suite.
The assessments will be completed by 2 informants from each hospital—a supply chain manager and a clinician manager who has responsibility for the surgical suite.
Before designing the assessment, I conducted about 10 intensive case studies of surgical suites in different kinds of hospitals. We’ve also looked at how other industries like manufacturing and retailing measure best practices and integration of the supply chain.
From this, we developed measures that tell us what the dimensions of a best practice look like. These measurements have been validated by industry experts and statistical testing.
For example, we ask about the extent to which respondents track instrumentation. We also ask about vendor access policies and whether they are enforced. We ask how the respondents work with physicians on physician preference items.
We also ask for some operational indicators, including OR utilization for the past 6 months, case-start accuracy for the first case of the day and subsequent cases, and OR supply expenses using the definition developed by AHRMM and HFMA (Association for Healthcare Resource and Materials Management and the Healthcare Financial Management Association).
After the assessments are returned, we will use statistical methods to test our hypotheses. For example, do hospitals with a higher degree of integration in their supply chain and closer collaboration with their physicians have better utilization of their ORs and lower supply expenses? We may find, for example, that some are getting better utilization, but their supply expenses are still high.
Q What is your time frame for completing the study?
Smith-Daniels: We are sending out the surveys. We need much higher participation. The assessment takes about 45 to 60 minutes to complete. Hospitals that participate receive a copy of the benchmark report and copies of white papers and academic publications.
We plan to finish collecting data by February 2010. We will then start analyzing results. We hope to have sample benchmarking reports out to the participants and initial white papers available in the first quarter of 2010.
For information, contact vicki.smith-daniels@asu.edu or phone 480/229-4202.