OR leaders besieged by surgeons and others clamoring for the latest innovations must ensure that the business case for any new technology makes good sense both for patients and the
organization’s bottom line. Building a strong business case requires careful assessment, clear writing, and a strong partnership with the finance department.
“If you don’t have a partnership with finance and don’t know their expectations, you are setting yourself up for failure,” says Dawn Vocke, MSN, MBA, RN, CNOR, director of surgical services at UPMC, a Pittsburgh-based organization with more than 20 hospitals.
Joseph DiRenzo, MBA, director of finance, northern tier at UPMC, adds, “It comes down to both OR leadership and finance having a collaborative relationship. That’s something they have to build over time, and they have to want to build it.”
Before creating a business case, OR leaders must do some research to see if it’s really needed. “Instead of just reacting when a surgeon wants new technology, you have to do the research to see what’s out there and determine if it can meet other people’s needs, not just one surgeon’s needs,” Vocke says.
It’s also helpful to have a process for analyzing requests, for example, a value analysis committee. At UPMC, the process includes OR directors and representatives from supply chain, finance, and clinical specialties.
Before the committee evaluates the technology, the surgeon who wants the equipment is expected to complete a form justifying the need for it (sidebar, below).
New technology or equipment that falls within capital budget limits typically needs to be justified, and even lower-cost items may require a business case if they are part of a larger package.
For example, Vocke is updating video equipment in the OR. Although some individual equipment costs are within the operating budget, she says, the entire upgrade is one that requires significant analysis, planning, and a business case.
According to Vocke, the best way to build the OR-finance partnership is through mutual respect and understanding.
“Finance people think differently than OR people,” she says. “It’s just like you when you work with physicians, you have to understand precisely what they need.”
She adds that she now knows what DiRenzo needs from her to help create a business case; DiRenzo says Vocke understands finance and isn’t afraid to ask questions.
Vocke says DiRenzo’s openness and access, along with his willingness to understand the OR perspective, have promoted the partnership. “We can’t provide business intelligence if we don’t understand the business,” DiRenzo says.
He and others in finance spend time shadowing patients from when they are scheduled to when they are discharged, and observe in sterile processing, supply chain, and the OR.
“[Staff in the OR] have welcomed us, educated us, and allowed us to learn,” DiRenzo says, adding that members of his team want to work in healthcare. “They want to make a difference.”
Finance and OR leaders meet routinely to discuss current projects and proactively identify needs. “We have a vested interest to support them [the OR] because we want to help them manage their business as efficiently as possible,” DiRenzo says. “We also care about OR outcomes and the patient experience. We look at ourselves as one team, not two.”
Others who are often involved in making the business case include representatives from supply chain and a value analysis person or committee.
A thriving partnership will lead to an effective business case, which is typically written by the OR leader, the finance director, or both, depending on the organization’s hierarchy. The case includes the executive summary, project definition, and financial analysis.
“The executive summary is what is going to sell the business plan,” says Jodi Koch, MBA, BSN, RN, director of perioperative and endoscopy services for Lehigh Valley Health Network, Allentown, Pennsylvania. “It needs to project a compelling message, and it needs to intrigue people enough to make them want to read more.”
DiRenzo says the executive summary should include the purpose and background of the new technology, financial highlights, clinical and operational benefits, and assumptions.
Koch likes to start the summary with the current state, including one to two sentences about why the technology is important, how it would help the organization grow or sustain business, and what competitors are doing.
Once she lays the groundwork, she then describes how the new technology will affect key stakeholders. For example, purchasing an innovative laser might enable the organization to create a new surgeon pool.
Koch wraps up with two to three of the top returns on investment (ROIs), with one to two explanatory bullet points for each.
“The executive summary is the hardest part to write,” Koch says. She recommends first writing the rest of the business case, which will help OR leaders pick out the content that is most important to include in the summary. “[The executive summary] is your 2-minute elevator speech.”
The project definition is one of the most important components of the business case. “It answers most of the why, what, and how questions about your proposed technology investment,” Vocke says.
The section includes resources needed for implementation, budget, timeline, measurable goals for project milestones, any considerations such as government regulations, and factors that might affect the timeline, such as the availability of key individuals.
Outline the benefits—including financial and nonfinancial aspects—and limitations of the new technology. Explain why the technology is needed, for example, to improve quality, reduce costs, increase revenue, keep the facility competitive, or improve customer service.
DiRenzo and Vocke say the following questions can help OR leaders and their finance partners better address benefits and limitations:
• What is required? Considerations that help in answering this question include capital expenses, resources, and staff education.
• How is the technology used (or procedure done)? For example, how will the procedure affect other parts of the OR? Could the procedure time impact scheduling?
• Who does what? Leaders will want to know how the new technology might change current responsibilities of the surgeon and staff.
• When will things happen? At this stage, it’s important to consider when the technology is needed. For example, it may need to be timed for the arrival of a new surgeon.
The answers to these questions provide the basis for a risk assessment, which should include consequences, opportunities, and plans for managing risk.
Those who approve funding will be particularly interested in the finance section of the business case, which should present a complete appraisal. DiRenzo says the purpose of the appraisal is to:
• identify the financial implications for the technology project
• facilitate comparison of technology costs against the forecasted benefits
• ensure the project is affordable and that every cost associated with the project is considered
• assess value for money
• predict cash flow and associated revenue.
A market analysis is an integral part of the appraisal and includes both quantitative and qualitative assessment.
“You have to pull in your finance department and work collaboratively to see what is going on in the market and what are emerging trends,” Koch says.
Vocke adds that it’s important to consider customer segments, demographics (age, gender, income), competition, reimbursement, referral patterns, and ability of patients to access services.
Some organizations tap into expertise from consultants such as those from ECRI Institute and The Advisory Board.
“You might also talk to people who have implemented the new technology who are in the region but aren’t direct competitors,” Koch adds. For instance, she sometimes confers with hospital leaders in another area of the state.
A crucial question to answer is ROI, which typically includes growth, quality, productivity, or a combination. All three require making certain assumptions, and the basis for those assumptions should be included in the business case.
DiRenzo and Vocke cite the example of these assumptions for a procedural laser:
• five cases per week (based on referrals and market assessment)
• $300 per case (based on market rate analysis)
• variable operating expenses equal to 30% of net revenue.
In this example, there were no additional fixed costs and no additional staff were required. Factors that help determine the variable expenses (which will vary by project) include incremental labor, supplies, and other fixed and variable amounts required to provide services.
These assumptions can be challenging to identify. “Every analysis is completely different,” DiRenzo says. It can be particularly difficult when the technology will add a new patient population.
In some cases, DiRenzo says, related diagnoses help him understand the need for different types of services for a specific population.
For example, an innovative technology related to wound care could be helpful for a large patient population with diabetes.
DiRenzo says it’s also challenging to try to anticipate what quality benefits may be associated with the new technology.
“We try to understand if there will be fewer infections or better pain management, and find ways to calculate the benefits of each of these,” he says.
Unfortunately, evidence-based quality measures don’t always exist for new technology. In that case, the organization may conduct small clinical trials to gather information.
Once assumptions are established, key financials such as cash flow and depreciation expenses are analyzed over 5 years.
Vocke says OR leaders should be able to quickly answer the question, “Do you have evidence to support or refute your assumptions?” before submitting the proposal.
It’s also helpful to complete a checklist (sidebar, below) and have someone not involved in writing the business case review it for clarity.
Koch says organizational review of the business case usually starts with the department head, followed by the vice president of perioperative services and others, depending on the technology’s cost.
“The higher the cost, the higher up the chain of command it goes,” she says.
Failing to support the case with evidence and using generalized terms that lack meaning are a couple of common mistakes, Koch says. “Instead of ‘support new growth,’ include specifics such as new surgeons, the number of additional cases per week, and the revenue capture on those cases,” she suggests.
On the other hand, brevity is key. Koch notes that sometimes it’s best to first prepare a proposal of 1 to 1.5 pages that includes the current state and what is being proposed. Once that information has been conveyed and accepted, it’s time to move to a full business case.
Another common mistake is not thinking through how the technology will affect stakeholders. “You need to know who all the stakeholders are and think about the takeaways,” Koch says.
For instance, a new system for communicating with families obviously benefits the families, and can also benefit surgeons and staff by improving workflow.
Success of the OR and finance teams in developing a business case depends on communication and having best practices in place, Di Renzo says.
“The result is very rewarding: a more effective and efficient OR with high-quality outcomes and great patient experiences. That’s why OR and finance leaders come to work every day,” he says. ✥
Barkhymer M C, Vocke D, DiRenzo J. Making the case for new technology to improve the bottom line. Presented at the 2016 annual OR Manager Conference.