A big question was circulating amongst the OR professionals at the AORN Global Surgical Conference floor this year: “How do we improve our miscount protocols?” It was clear that nurses and OR managers are looking for a better miscount management solution.
Manual counting has been the standard in preventing retained surgical needles or instruments for a long time. But with the rise of complex surgical procedures that sometimes require hundreds of tiny needles, a nationwide nursing shortage, and the use of complex and delicate instruments, miscounts are on the rise.
Many nurses with whom I spoke at the conference were curious about new adjacent OR technology to manage miscounts, like the Melzi™ Sharps Finder™ (MSF). The MSF is one of the latest innovative tools used in ORs nationwide to help manage miscounts, mitigate the risk of retained surgical items, and potentially improve patient safety.
One recent multi-institutional study reviewed the efficacy of the MSF, and one of the key surgeons involved sat down with me to chat about the MSF and share his thoughts. Before we get into that, let’s examine why so many nurses want to improve miscount protocols.
Miscounts in the OR can harm patient care, create a chaotic environment, cause delays, and impact the psychological well-being of the OR staff. And relying solely on manual counting or X-rays to prevent miscounts can lead to inaccuracies, distractions, limitations, and again, delays. These challenges have led OR professionals to seek out new adjacent OR technology.
Increased operating time. Extended procedure time is one of the leading patient safety issues during a miscount. A miscount prevents the closure of the patient until the missing item is found, potentially exposing the patient to prolonged anesthesia and increasing the risk of complications. Extensive procedures may also require X-rays to locate the missing object, subjecting the patient to unnecessary radiation.
Added stress. For OR staff, miscounts contribute to an even more stressful and chaotic environment in the OR. While the primary focus should be locating the missing object, the search can overshadow other critical aspects of the procedure. The team becomes consumed with finding the needle or item, leading to heightened stress and potential distractions from other vital responsibilities.
Delays. Miscounts can also cause delays in subsequent procedures and commitments. If the surgical team cannot promptly resolve a miscount, it will disrupt the OR schedule, resulting in cascading delays and possibly the rescheduling of other procedures. These delays can impact patient care, strain hospital resources, and hinder the overall efficiency of the healthcare facility.
Relying solely on manual counting presents its own challenges. Count accuracy depends on a perfect match between the pre- and post-count. If the pre-count is incorrect, subsequent counts will also be inaccurate. The most critical issue is when there are more items in the post-count than the pre-count, leading to serious uncertainty about whether an object is missing. Concentration difficulties in the OR, prolonged and complex procedures with multiple shift changes and many needles, and the inability to count certain objects like broken instrument pieces further complicate the counting process.
Alternatively, relying on X-rays to detect missing objects also poses challenges. X-rays have limited capabilities in detecting tiny needles increasingly used in minimally invasive procedures. Additionally, obtaining and examining X-rays adds significant time to the case. The process of inserting the film in the OR table slot—if a C-arm is not available—making sure not to contaminate the sterile field, and waiting for the radiologist to analyze the results can take an average of 20 to 30 minutes and add as much as 45 minutes to the case.
Comprehensive strategies that combine multiple methods and best practices are the best way to minimize miscounts and enhance patient safety. Adjacent technoglogy such as the MSF can help. The following is a Q&A with Sam Weprin, MD, a member of the team who worked on the recently released MSF assessment study.
Q: You recently published a study in Patient Safety in Surgery to assess the MSF that involved several institutions. Tell us about the study and the methods used.
Many institutions were involved, including Virginia Commonwealth University Health, Stanford Health, the Graves Gilbert Clinic, Yale School of Medicine, University of Colorado, and Summit Health. Generally speaking, the preclinical assessment showed that the MSF increased the rate of needle identification, decreased the time to identification, and improved the accuracy of determining the presence of a needle.
The study comprised three steps. The first was about identifying a retained surgical sharp (RSS) in a controlled environment outside of a living being. We set up this model using a container with hay in a laparoscopic trainer box. For the second step, we wanted to see if the team could find an RSS in live pigs during laparoscopic procedures. We divided the pigs into three groups: one using only a C-arm machine, another with a C-arm along with the MSF, and the last using just the MSF.
Q: What is a C-arm?
A C-arm is a special machine used in surgical procedures to take real-time X-ray images. It’s curved, like the letter “C,” and can be moved around the patient’s body, providing live X-ray images on a screen to guide the instruments. It’s commonly used in orthopedic and heart procedures, as well as in other minimally invasive treatments. It’s kind of like the Cadillac of X-ray machines.
Q: And the study’s third step?
The third step was like the second in its setup, but we went for a different approach. Instead of a laparoscopic procedure, we performed a laparotomy. There were two groups: one did a manual search to find the RSS, and the other used the MSF. We compared the effectiveness of these methods.
Q: Walk us through the “needle in a haystack” experiment, the study’s first step. How was that done?
It was a fun study. We hid a 13 mm needle inside a haystack in a small container. The container was 12.7 x 12.7 x 5.1 cm, and we put it into a laparoscopic trainer box.
We randomly assigned people to the control or device groups using a random number generator. The participants didn’t know where the needle was hidden. In the control group, they could use one grasper tool to search through the hay and find the needle. But in the device group, they were given the MSF instead of a grasper.
When using the grasper tool, participants could use their free hand to move the hay and the container around. When using the MSF, they were not allowed to use their free hands. They had to spot the needle directly on the camera in the laparoscopic trainer box, and we recorded how long it took them to find it. The main thing we were looking at was whether the participants could find the needle before the end of the experiment. And the second thing we measured was how much time it took them. They had a maximum of 5 minutes to locate the needle.
Essentially, we wanted to see if people could find the hidden needle using different methods, and how long it took them.
Q: What were the results?
We did a total of 101 trials for the first “needle in a haystack” scenario. The control group, which had 50 participants, found the needle in only 11 trials—about a 22% success rate. But in the device group, with 51 participants, the success rate was significantly higher at 98.1%.
And when they did find the needle in those successful trials, the device group was much faster than the control group. On average, it took the device group only 1.64 minutes to find the needle, while the control group took 3.34 minutes. That’s a substantial and statistically significant difference.
In the second scenario, the control group, consisting of 34 participants, accurately identified the presence of the needle 58.8% of the time, and the device group, also with 34 participants, achieved a perfect accuracy of 100%. The device group also took significantly less time to determine the presence of the needle compared to the control group, at 1.69 minutes compared to 4.89 minutes (sidebar, ‘Needle in a haystack’ experiment).
Q: For an OR manager, there are two main questions guiding the decision to use adjacent technology: how accurate is it when determining the presence of a needle, and how long it takes to make that determination? Did this study illustrate answers to these questions?
The groups using the MSF demonstrated improved accuracy in identifying the presence of a needle, and they achieved a higher rate of successful identification while locating it faster. More research will provide a more comprehensive understanding of the device’s effectiveness and applicability in real-world surgical settings, but the study findings definitely indicated promising results.
This study’s first step was an ex-vivo experiment—like I said, the participants tried to find a needle in a container filled with hay using either a grasper or the MSF. When using the MSF, they could not move the hay or the container with their free hands.
The study’s second and third steps involved in-vivo scenarios. For these experiments, which were approved by the animal care committees at Virginia Commonwealth University and the University of California Irvine, we used live male Yorkshire pigs as our model. We anesthetized them and accessed their abdomen using both laparoscopic [second step] and laparotomy [thid step] approaches, hid suture needles in different parts of the abdomen, and recorded the time it took the participants—who were residents in general surgery and urology and not specifically trained to search for the needle—to find them.
In the laparoscopic clinical experiments, the participants were randomly assigned to three groups. Some used laparoscopic instruments with a C-arm device, some used the MSF device plus the C-arm machine to find the needle, and others only used the MSF. Each trial lasted up to 5 minutes, and we checked the accuracy and time it took for the participants to determine if the needle was present.
We conducted a total of 52 trials for the third experiment. There were nine trials using only C-arm X-ray and manual search; 10 trials with both C-arm X-ray and the MSF; and 33 using only the MSF. The distribution of needle size, needle location, and the presence of the needle were similar across all groups. The accuracy and speed of determining the presence of the needle were similar among all three groups (sidebar, C-arm vs C-arm and the MSF vs the MSF experiments).
Q: Did the use of C-arm X-ray impact these results?
Potentially, yes. This scenario used an expensive, top-of-the-line C-arm X-ray machine, which some hospitals may not have readily available. It made the whole X-ray process much more efficient, eliminating the need to have to use a film. And a trained radiologist was on-hand to interpret images immediately, which is rare. But the MSF alone managed to locate needles at similar success rates as the trials that used the C-arms. So, in a real-life situation, the MSF would likely be able to fully determine the presence or absence of a needle much more efficiently and in less time than with traditional X-ray protocols.
Q: What about the study’s third step?
In the third step, we performed laparotomy on the pigs. The participants were split into two groups: one doing a manual search and the other using the MSF to find the needle. We randomized the trials with different needle sizes and locations. The users had a maximum of 5 minutes to decide. Sometimes, if someone in the non-MSF group said there was no needle, we gave them the MSF device to continue searching. We recorded the time to find the needle with the MSF separately. We also tried a manual search method in some laparotomy trials to see if it affected accuracy or time.
We did a total of 49 trials using the laparotomy model, with a similar distribution of needle size, needle location, and presence between the two groups. The MSF group had a significantly higher success rate than the manual search group, at 97% compared to 46.7%, respectively. And like the haystack scenarios, the MSF group showed a significantly shorter time to determine the presence of a needle at around 2 minutes compared to about 3.9 minutes for the manual group (sidebar, Manual search vs the MSF experiments).
When we looked at the data of both in-vivo studies and took into account things like surgical approach, needle size, needle presence, needle location, and whether we used the C-arm, we found that using the MSF by itself was linked to accurately determining whether a needle was present. And when combined with X-ray, the odds of getting it right shot up by 12.1 times.
Q: Do these results show that the MSF is a reliable tool to help OR managers and nurses effectively manage miscounts?
The nice thing about the MSF is it gives you both sound and visual cues to help you find where the RSS is hiding. This study seemed to show that it effectively determines both the presence as well as the location of these sharp objects, which is exactly what you want in a miscount situation. The groups that used the MSF had better accuracy in detecting the presence of a needle, were more successful in finding lost needles, and did it all in less time. More tests in real-life situations will help us be sure, but this study was a promising start. When combined with current miscount protocols, the MSF seems like a valuable addition to OR tools.
In a miscount situation or if a metal object coming out of a patient is broken, I recommend immediately beginning a search using the MSF. X-ray could still be called, then canceled if the RSS is found. But don’t waste 20 to 30 minutes waiting around.
—Ivy Montgomery is a Go-To-Market executive who is passionate about improving patient outcomes with innovative technologies, especially in the areas of diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of diseases.