Creating a “Cost Conscious Culture Committee” helped Maine Medical Center (MMC) in Portland shave more than $1.8 million in operating costs from the beginning of 2014 to the end of 2015. Not only that, but during 2015, MMC’s perioperative services leaders were also involved in a $40 million expansion project that culminated in five brand new ORs and 20 pre- and postanesthesia care unit bays.
“We had a lot of extracurricular activities going on in FY 2015,” says business manager David Cote.
That’s putting it mildly. “I was taken out of my role as a clinical leader and assumed an interim position as manager of the OR expansion project—2015 was a huge year for us,” says Janice Nichols, BSN, RN, clinical leader and manager of the orthopedic and urology service.
MMC, the state’s largest medical center, is a Level 1 trauma facility with a 29-bed OR. “I’m elated that the five ORs opened without a hitch, and on top of that we were able to realize more than $600,000 in cost savings in 2015,” Nichols adds.
Nichols and Cote have reason to be proud of MMC’s banner year, but it’s the achievements of their Cost Conscious Culture Committee (CCCC) they seem to find most rewarding. Not only has the CCCC helped to meet cost-saving goals, it also has engaged staff and boosted morale.

Janice Nichols, BSN, RN, and David Cote have led the Cost Conscious Culture Committee at Maine Medical Center in Portland for the past 2 years. Source: Maine Medical Center. Used with permission.
“A couple of years ago, we were experiencing tough financial times and low morale in the OR,” Nichols told OR Manager. “Senior leadership asked everyone to look at their departments and come up with cost-saving strategies. Dave and I reflected upon a statement made by our CFO, Lou Inzana, ‘You can’t cut your way to prosperity.’ We then thought about how Maine Medical and other organizations often turn to external consultants. Dave coined the phrase ‘internal consultants’—meaning that our staff members are the best source for finding ways to save money. We asked staff members to join the committee, and we received more volunteers than we needed. At our first meeting in January 2014, we began compiling a list of potential cost savings.”
The committee consists of 15 people who represent OR management, all disciplines of OR staff, and materials management. Co-chaired by Nichols and Cote, the committee meets twice monthly. The current committee members include Megan Bartholomew, Amy Price, Amy Hyland, Deborah Aylward, Kenna Small, Michael MacLean, Eric Ng, John Garrett, Mary Smith, Michael Jackson, Teresa Regan, Cynthia Jones, and Kenneth Lamb.
When the CCCC was first formed, Nichols says, staff were introduced to the “plan-do-check-act” philosophy for making changes. “The number one idea came from a retired RN with 47 years of experience at Maine Medical. She still places our suture order each week, and she thought that would be a great place to start,” Nichols says.
That’s because she knew a lot of specialty sutures were being used. Specialty sutures cost up to 300% more than stock sutures, according to Cote. As part of the initiative to switch to stock sutures, Nichols says, surgeons were asked to delay having suture packs opened until they were actually needed. “Instead of having dyed and undyed suture, we asked if we could have just one or the other, not both. We have 18-, 27-, and 36-inch suture lengths, and we sought to consolidate the lengths to decrease inventory.”
With the exception of just four sutures, Cote says, everyone agreed to switch to stock sutures—a change that yielded annual savings of more than $98,000. That number is especially impressive in light of the increase in suture costs in July that occurred in tandem with a surgical volume increase, Cote points out.
Both Nichols and Cote credit the surgical services staff for this success. “We asked staff who work side by side with the surgeons to start the conversation. It’s the relationships between OR staff members and surgeons that got their cooperation with this first big initiative,” Nichols says.
“The only constant in life is change, and inclusion helps to breed acceptance,” Cote adds. “Knowing that, we make sure that no one is surprised. When a surgeon is being handed something on the surgical field is not the time to find out about a change.”
The suture project took several months, Nichols says, whereas smaller initiatives such as surgical scrubs led to more immediate savings. Instead of continuing to use a custom color for OR staff scrubs, the committee recommended changing to a stock color. That saved $7,000.
Another $6,800 in annual savings came from simply opening different robotic drape packs. A committee member noted that in many robotic procedures, only three robotic arms are used, so she asked surgeons if it would be acceptable to open a three-pack instead of a four-pack. An extra robotic drape could quickly be obtained if needed, she said, and surgeons happily complied with this request.
Some projects, such as surgical glove consolidation, led to a decision not to make a change, Nichols says. “We thought we would be able to save money, but conversations with surgeons and other staff members showed us we couldn’t consolidate our gloves,” she explains. “We are already part of Maine Health, a group of several local hospitals that purchases items in bulk for cost savings, so we already had a low price. Moving from a mixture of latex and latex-free to all latex-free would have cost a lot more money.”
Although no change was made, Cote says, this research project established the CCCC as the “glove experts” who are now seen as the conduit for any future glove initiatives. High regard for the committee is also evidenced by the support it has received from executive leaders. “Once the committee was formed, we asked certain individuals if they wanted to be executive sponsors. They all eagerly signed up for it,” Cote says. “The executive vice president and chief operating officer has become our executive champion.”
“One of our biggest challenges is to find time for our committee members to get out of the OR,” Nichols says. “We’re a Level 1 trauma center, so we have urgent and emergent cases added all day long to our schedule. On average, I would say each member needs at least 8 hours per month, or 2 hours per week to do their assignments between meetings. We ask staff members to keep us informed and let us know what they need.”
Initiatives are posted on electronic bulletin boards in the OR to remind staff of changes that have been implemented, and cost savings are tracked on spreadsheets, Cote says. A list of initiatives and projected savings associated with each for the beginning of FY 2014 to the end of FY 2015 is shown in the sidebar on below.
“We’re also making sure the $1.2 million savings achieved in 2014 is sustainable,” he adds. “Not only do we have new initiatives, but we keep an eye on what we’ve done, and we’re adamant about making sure the savings aren’t just a flash in the pan. Some of these things require a mindset change, and if you take your eye off the ball, sometimes things slip back to the old ways, but so far, we’ve sustained all of our cost savings.”
Doing something fun is one way to keep cost-saving initiatives at the forefront of everyone’s minds, says Nichols. “With sutures, for example, we put a clear bucket of expired suture at the front desk and asked people to estimate how much these sutures cost. Estimates ranged from $3,000 to $200,000, and the person with the closest estimate was awarded a $25 gift card. We posted the actual value of the suture on the bulletin board and reminded people of ways to save money through sutures,” she explains.
“Two main benefits of serving on this committee are increased professional satisfaction and personal and professional growth,” Nichols says.
“Not only are we getting ideas from the committee members and staff, but other people like the vice president of supply chain is approaching us and saying, ‘I’d like to use this committee to help implement point of use in the OR,’” Cote says.
“Many staff members have asked to join the committee, but we’ve had to keep them on a wait list,” Nichols says. “When someone leaves the committee, we ask the members to nominate and vote on the replacement.”
During the first year, Cote and Nichols gave committee members a $100 gift certificate, an engraved pen, and a leather-bound notebook. As a thank you to the committee members’ co-workers, Nichols says, they also purchased an industrial-sized refrigerator for one of the staff lounges.
Several initiatives for 2016 have been identified, and more planning is underway. “We have a suggestion box by the main OR desk,” Nichols says. “Every quarter, the entire surgical services department meets for an hour before the OR schedule starts, and we discuss upcoming initiatives.” Among the key projects thus far identified:
• recycling clean OR waste
• maximizing and sustaining single-use device reprocessing
• implementing point-of-use in the OR (bar coding/scanning)
• addressing back orders and order integrity.
“We’ve reprocessed single-use items in the OR for 2 years, and both years we’ve won an award for being the number one hospital in New England from a cost-saving standpoint. We’re trying to sustain that and perhaps improve our reprocessing,” Cote says.
“We have an excellent supply chain and purchasing department,” he adds. But until the CCCC was formed, there was no one person or committee devoted to improvement. “We felt that, for every dollar there is to be saved with contractual opportunities—by getting a vendor to reduce the price on something—there’s equal or greater savings to be had through utilization, process, and waste reduction opportunities. We proved that with sutures. We actually had a price increase mid-year and our volume went up, but we still saved money by changing our process. It has opened many people’s eyes at many different levels,” he says.
Saving money and improving patient care is not an either/or proposition, Cote points out. “You can do both, and when done correctly, this process feeds upon itself and keeps growing and getting stronger.” ✥