April 23, 2020

Developing a COVID-19 Recovery Plan for surgical services

When the coronavirus pandemic begins to subside, hospital leaders will be sorting out the repercussions and trying to resume normal operations. The main impact on ORs has been the widespread cancellation of non-essential procedures. Case cancellations in March and April have reduced elective procedure volumes as much as 90%.

Most of these procedures will eventually be performed, but the growing case backlog is creating a fresh set of problems. In the months ahead, OR leaders must figure out how to accommodate pent-up demand for invasive and endoscopic procedures.

The pressure will come not only from surgeons and patients, but also from hospital executives. Hospitals depend on perioperative services for up to 65% of their profit margins, and COVID-19 has severely curtailed this revenue stream. Here is the math for the typical US hospital:

11.1 OR rooms (median hospital)

x 58.3 cases (average monthly volume per room)

x 60% (estimated COVID-19-related cancellation rate)

x $4,090 (average contribution margin per case)

= $1,588,057 (estimated lost operating income per month)

In addition to these financial losses, many hospitals will face a new strategic challenge. If local ambulatory surgery centers are quicker to reestablish normal operations, hospital ORs could lose a significant volume of high-margin procedures to these competitors.

As the threat of pandemic diminishes, hospital executives will look to perioperative leaders to get the OR back online as quickly as possible. Surgical Directions, a Chicago-based healthcare consulting firm, has worked with numerous hospital systems over the years to help them boost productivity and strengthen their competitive position in the healthcare market. The key to post-pandemic recovery is to create a viable plan for temporarily expanding OR capacity. We recommend a deliberate process that leverages data analytics, new schedule options, close coordination with all OR stakeholders, and a renewed focus on perioperative efficiency.

Perform a gap analysis

The first step to creating a COVID-19 Recovery Plan is to perform a capacity gap analysis. Start by quantifying the backed-up demand for surgery. Case cancellation reports will help, but keep in mind that a percentage of these cases will not come back. Some patients will have lost insurance coverage and canceled their procedures. Other patients may decide to delay their elective surgery indefinitely.

For the most accurate projection of demand, communicate directly with surgeons to understand their scheduling needs over the next 60 to 90 days. Ideally, OR staff have been keeping in touch with surgeon offices throughout the pandemic. If not, reach out as soon as possible to surgeons and their schedulers to develop an up-to-date queue of future elective cases.

Projected volumes may diverge from historical patterns. Some lower-volume surgeons may now have a large backlog to clear out. Other surgeons with substantial block time may have seen very few patients during the COVID-19 outbreak and are therefore unprepared to utilize their blocks fully.

Predictive analytics can help OR leaders develop highly accurate volume projections, design efficient block schedules, and optimize capacity allocation.

Once accurate projections are in place, compare the upcoming case volume to the OR’s existing capacity. Staffing should not be an obstacle for most facilities, but supply availability may be an issue for hospitals with low inventories.

 

Identify expansion strategies

Once OR leaders have quantified upcoming procedure volume, the next step is to identify specific strategies for expanding department capacity. The most straightforward solution is to extend weekday schedules by utilizing after hours. If OR blocks generally end at 3:30 pm, plan to keep rooms open until 5:30 pm, 7:30 pm, or even later. Some ORs may be able to open previously closed rooms for normal primetime utilization.

OR leaders should also consider expanding the schedule to weekend hours. Weekend time could be treated as an extension of the normal schedule or structured as a “Super Saturday” block specifically designed to maximize productivity for key procedures. A well-designed Saturday (or Sunday) block can provide surgeons with an additional 6 to 8 hours of highly productive OR time.

Again, these strategies will depend on staff and supply availability as well as facility resources. However, ORs that fully leverage these tactics could come close to doubling their capacity if they plan carefully and collaborate closely with surgeons.

 

Design effective specialty blocks

Planning is especially important when designing weekend specialty blocks. Begin by projecting basic staffing needs for the OR, postanesthesia care unit, and central sterile. Consider scheduling additional staff to facilitate room turnover. In addition, coordinate with select departments to secure key specialist support. For example, a weekend breast surgery block will require a special staffing plan for pathology.

The goals of a Super Saturday are efficiency and productivity, so offer these special blocks to surgeons who have a proven ability to expedite cases. In addition, consider scheduling flip rooms for appropriate specialties. With proper staff support and overall choreography, an efficient surgeon can use flip rooms to complete 10 to 20 procedures in a single day.

The best way to build a Super Saturday is to focus on procedures that can be bundled for efficiency. This includes many common procedures in general surgery, orthopedic surgery, gynecology, urology, oral surgery, and other specialties.

Meet with surgeons to gauge their interest in setting up a Super Saturday, and find out whether they have enough patient volume. For example, for a special urology block, make sure the surgeon has at least 10 cystoscopy patients in the queue.

To maximize efficiency, all Super Saturday patients should be relatively healthy. For example, OR leaders might decide to restrict these special blocks to patients with ASA status of 1, 2, or 3.

 

Engage key groups

An effective COVID-19 Recovery Plan requires the cooperation of several stakeholders, so it is important to build consensus. Concentrate on four key groups:

Leverage the SSEC. One of the core roles of the Surgical Services Executive Committee (SSEC) is to manage capacity and block time, so the SSEC is the perfect forum for building consensus on a COVID-19 Recovery Plan. We recommend creating an SSEC subcommittee to manage the OR schedule throughout the recovery surge. This scheduling committee can prioritize backlogged cases by urgency, help plan additional blocks, and make decisions about surge capacity utilization.

Work closely with anesthesia providers. Coordinate with anesthesia leaders to ensure support for all expanded days and blocks. In addition, the SSEC should appoint an anesthesiologist and a surgeon to manage the ad hoc scheduling committee. This dyad management team can ensure a realistic plan and resolve all scheduling questions that arise.

Pay special attention to nursing. A successful COVID-19 Recovery Plan also depends on an engaged and motivated nursing staff. For nurses who have lost income during the crisis, the recovery phase will be a good opportunity to regain lost wages. For those coping with the aftermath of the pandemic in their personal lives, however, any attempt to mandate additional hours could be poorly received. Wherever possible, allow nurses to choose how they will take part in the recovery plan. This will help ensure nurses are motivated and ready to provide a good experience for both patients and surgeons.

Work with the finance department on payment policies. Many patients have lost income during this crisis and will be reluctant to undergo surgery if coinsurance and out-of-pocket amounts are expected to be paid up front. Establishing more flexible policies on patient financial responsibility may be in the best interest of both the patient community and the organization.

 

Remember the basics

An effective COVID-19 Recovery Plan requires innovation. Yet the basic principles of OR efficiency are more important than ever. Adhering to proven perioperative management practices will make normal weekday schedules more efficient and ensure additional specialty days are as productive as possible.

Review the existing daily huddle process for managing the OR schedule. At a minimum, the huddle group should preview the next day’s schedule to verify patient clearances and designate staff and equipment. However, the most effective groups review all cases up to 72 hours in advance.

This is also a good time to check turnover processes. In the most efficient ORs, staff members have well-defined breakdown and setup roles, and turnover processes are run in parallel to minimize downtime. Likewise, preadmission testing (PAT) is key for efficiency and will be essential to optimizing productivity in the aftermath of the coronavirus pandemic.

During the weeks of postponement, lab tests will expire for many patients, and some will experience a worsening of their underlying health. The PAT clinic should work with surgeon office staff to stay in touch with postponed patients and provide regular updates on anticipated reschedule timing. Staff should also keep track of patients’ health status and flag individuals who need additional interventions.

H&Ps will also expire for many patients while they wait for their rescheduled surgery. This will create frustration for patients and extra work for anesthesia providers. OR leaders should create a process for managing expired H&Ps. They may want to ask a hospitalist, physician assistant, or nurse practitioner to review and update H&Ps free of charge on the day of surgery. The cost of this strategy will be offset by fewer last-minute problems and greater efficiency.

Finally, add COVID-19 screening questions to the presurgical assessment process. PAT staff should ask all patients whether they have had the coronavirus or may have been exposed to it, and whether they have symptoms such as sore throat, abnormal temperature, body aches, or shortness of breath. Patients with elevated risk should be referred for testing.

The coronavirus pandemic has created major disruption for hospital ORs. Through careful planning, innovation, and teamwork, OR leaders can develop a COVID-19 Recovery Plan that serves patients, supports physicians and staff, and helps their hospitals restore operations and regain lost ground. ✥

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat