The Hospital Safety Score, issued twice yearly, uses national performance measures from the Leapfrog Hospital Survey, the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and the American Hospital Association.
Leapfrog rated 2,571 hospitals on their ability to prevent errors, injuries, and infections. Letter grades were assigned as follows: A, 798 hospitals; B, 639; C, 957; D, 162; and F, 15.
New methodology was used in the 2016 report:
• Surgical Care Improvement Project measures were removed
• HCAHPS (Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems) domains were added: nurse communication, physician communication, staff responsiveness, communication about medicines, and discharge information
• measures for methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus and Clostridium difficile were added.
According to an analysis of the results, each year 206,021 avoidable deaths occur in US hospitals, and an estimated 33,439 lives could be saved if all hospitals performed on the level of those receiving an A. The risk of avoidable death, compared with A hospitals, is 9% higher in B hospitals, 35% higher in C hospitals, and 50% higher in D and F hospitals.
Since 2013, Leapfrog reports, 153 hospitals have gotten an A, and this year Vermont edged out Maine as the state with the highest percentage of A hospitals (83%).
Around the same time that the Leapfrog report was published, Truven Health Analytics, which provides analytic tools, benchmarks, and services to the healthcare industry, announced its 15 top health systems. They were chosen on the basis of mortality, complications, core measures, 30-day mortality rate, 30-day readmission rate, average length of stay, emergency department wait times, Medicare spending per beneficiary, and HCAHPS scores.
Several systems have made the list multiple times. New this year were Mercy in Chesterfield, Missouri; Sutter Health and Sutter Health Valley Area, both in Sacramento, California; and Lovelace Health System in Albuquerque. Achievements that distinguish the top 15 are that they:
• saved more lives and caused fewer patient complications
• followed industry-recommended standards of care more closely
• released patients from the hospital a half-day sooner
• readmitted patients less frequently and experienced fewer deaths within 30 days of admission
• had more than 12% shorter wait times in their emergency departments
• had nearly 5% lower Medicare beneficiary costs per 30-day episode of care
• scored more than 7 points higher on patient overall rating of care.
Data transparency and robust communications were cited as characteristics of the top 15. For example, greater access to data helped providers at St Luke’s Health System in Boise, Idaho, cut the infection rate from 1.08 to 0.57 per 100 procedures.
Many factors play into the overall quality of care, and just how to evaluate that quality is complex. To take just one example, consider patients who are socioeconomically disadvantaged. In a 2015 study, researchers linked readmission rates with safety net hospitals (SNH) or those with a high rate of Medicaid patients (HMH). Using the 2004 to 2011 State Inpatient Database of California, they identified more than 110,000 cancer patients treated at 355 hospitals. Of those, 13 were SNH and 31 were HMH, both of which had higher 30-day readmissions and repeated readmissions than did other hospitals.
This is not surprising; even shortly after the CMS Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program (HRRP) went into effect in October 2012, a New England Journal of Medicine Perspective noted that patients who were severely ill or socioeconomically disadvantaged were at high risk for readmission. The authors proposed adjusting readmission rates by socioeconomic status to “put hospitals on a level playing field.”
If new legislation moves forward, this might come to pass. The Helping Hospitals Improve Patient Care (HIP-C) Act, HR 5273, introduced by US Rep Pat Tiberi (R-OH) and US Rep Jim McDermott (D-WA), would prevent hospitals that serve low-income communities from being penalized under the HRRP. At press time, the bill was being considered in the House of Representatives.
Reports from organizations like Leapfrog and Truven provide data-rich, nationwide comparisons of healthcare facilities, and they validate the need for best practices. However, defining and achieving value-based care hinges on many variables. To quote the Perspective authors, “No policy is ever perfectly designed at inception, and policies should be changed as new evidence emerges.” ✥
Castellucci M. 15 Top health systems cultivate a culture of transparency. Modern Healthcare. Published online April 23, 2016.
http://www.hospitalsafetyscore.org/your-hospitals-safety-score/about-the-score.
Hong Y, Zheng C, Hechenbleikner E, et al. Vulnerable hospitals and cancer surgery readmissions: Insights into the unintended consequences of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. Presented at the Western Surgical Association 123rd Scientific Session, November 2015.
Joynt K E, Jha A K. A path forward on Medicare Readmissions. N Engl J Med. 2013;368:1175-1177.
Muchmore S. House bill trims pay for all hospitals to fund leeway in site-neutral Medicare pay. Modern Healthcare. Published online May 24, 2016.