Ccommon cost-saving strategies in the OR include increasing workflow efficiency, reducing turnover times, implementing standardized preoperative protocols, and improving surgical case scheduling and first case on-time starts (FCOTS).
These interventions aim to decrease under- and overutilized time in the OR, but there is conflicting evidence about their economic value. Many studies find that the time saved by these interventions is not enough to add cases, so not much money is saved. Others claim that cutting overtime staffing costs and potential decreases in end-of-day case cancellations have a significant impact on overall operating costs.
At the University of Wisconsin Hospital and Clinics in Madison, the department of surgery launched an improvement project to reduce first case delayed starts within our outpatient ORs. Our academic institution is a 505-bed facility with 36 operating rooms, of which 9 are in our hospital outpatient department. During the 2-year project, we improved our FCOTS and reduced our overutilized OR time.
We decided to focus on elective outpatient cases scheduled for weekdays. In particular, the department’s goal was to reduce the number of cases in which delay was attributed to the surgeon.
We began by trying to reduce first case delays, and all surgeons within the department were made aware of the initiative. Weekly and monthly reports were monitored and enforced, with individual feedback given to specific surgeons responsible for each delay.
This feedback usually involved emailing and, in some cases, face-to-face discussion when delays were attributed to a specific surgeon. Most often, the feedback served as a reminder of our efforts to reduce delays, and usually involved the need for the surgeon to arrive earlier in the day to ensure that H & P and consents were updated and completed.
The most commonly cited reasons for surgeon-related delays were:
• absence of a prepared signed consent for the procedure
• administrative or academic obligations that ran late in the morning
• personal reasons
• delay in updating history and physical documentation
• last-minute change to case plan or equipment needs
• scheduling miscommunication.
A late start was defined as failure to have the first case of the day in the OR within 10 minutes of the scheduled start time. Using data from fiscal year (FY) 2013 (July 1, 2012, to June 30, 2013) as our baseline, we compared that with post-intervention data from FY 2014 (July 1, 2013, to June 30, 2014).
Aside from rate of first case delays, project evaluators were interested in the percent of department of surgery ORs that finished late (after 5 pm), the number of minutes that these ORs ran after 5 pm, and the cost of this overutilized time.
To determine the cost of overutilized time, we used a per-minute cost figure obtained from personnel in surgical services and multiplied it by each minute the ORs were in use after 5 pm. The price of an OR minute was estimated by considering factors such as fixed overhead costs and staffing costs.
Case volume was also determined to ensure results were not simply due to reductions in total cases. Case volume remained consistent over the 2 years, with 3,270 cases performed in FY13 and 3,519 performed in FY14. Statistical analysis included Fisher’s exact chi-squared test to assess proportional differences in first case delay percentage and late finish percentages from one fiscal year to the next.
Overall, the FCOT percentage improved from 83% (n = 721) in FY13 to 88% (n = 851) in FY14 ( P< 0.001). In addition to improving the overall FCOT percentage, surgeon-related delays decreased from 7% (n = 61) in FY13 to 4% (n = 40) in FY14 ( P = 0.01).
Similar results were found regarding the percentage of last cases running past 5 pm. A total of 289 last cases were analyzed in FY13, and 300 cases in FY14.
The department of surgery began the study at a late finish rate of 29% (n = 83) and completed it at 16% (n = 47). This is a 45% improvement in the proportion of ORs ending beyond 5 pm from FY13 to FY14 ( P < 0.001).
Corresponding to fewer ORs operating after 5 pm was a 53% drop in annual overutilized time, from a total of 1,882 minutes in FY13 to 891 minutes in FY14—an absolute decrease of 991 minutes.
The average number of minutes that a late case ran past 5 pm was 23 minutes in FY13 vs 19 minutes in FY14. Over the 2 years of the study, the average was 21 minutes late per late-ending case.
Based on data acquired from hospital business personnel, direct per-minute outpatient OR cost across this particular department was estimated to be $22.45 USD per minute. In FY13, with a total of 1,882 overutilized minutes, this represents about $42,250 over the course of the year, and in FY14, with 891 overutilized minutes, this added cost burden was reduced to $20,002. Considering that late cases run an average of 21 minutes past 5 pm, cost per late case is estimated at 21 minutes x $22.45/minute for a total of $471 per late case.
Our observations suggest an association between reducing first case delays and reducing the time and frequency of outpatient ORs that are in use after 5 pm. Reducing overutilized OR time is a significant cost savings per late-running OR.
The parallel reduction in both first case delays and cases ending after 5 pm suggests a relationship: When the OR day begins on time, it may be more likely to end on time.
Simultaneous improvements occurring in first and last case timeliness have been described in other studies. For example, Cima et al found that increasing efficiency through improved on-time starts, standardization, and parallel processing led to a decrease in ORs running past 5 pm.
Likewise, our efforts to improve on-time starts occurred concurrently with projects aimed at increasing OR efficiency overall, which together resulted in a higher percentage of ORs closed by 5 pm.
A proposed explanation is that beginning the OR day on time banks valuable minutes that can be used to absorb unanticipated delays as they inevitably occur over the course of a day. It is also likely that starting on time sets the tone for the remainder of the scheduled cases, and, because staff are not working to catch up, the day progresses smoothly.
For example, Wright hypothesized that improving on-time starts may remove some of the pressure throughout the day, potentially leading to a safer environment for patients and staff. The implication of these findings is that improving efficiency—even through targeting only surgeon-related delays—could benefit all OR personnel, including nursing and anesthesia, because everyone would be on track to complete the day’s cases in a timely fashion.
Although these efforts clearly enhance OR efficiency, demonstrating a financial benefit is more difficult as there are obvious challenges to estimating the financial impact of overutilized OR time.
Previous models have considered overtime staffing costs as a proxy because staffing costs contribute such a large proportion of OR operating costs. However, simply determining institutional staffing costs per time and multiplying by an overtime factor such as standard time and a half (1.5 times the hourly rate) is likely not the best strategy because staff are often shuffled around between ORs or replaced by next-shift staff to minimize overtime costs. Thus, it is difficult to track exactly how many of those minutes are contributing to actual higher staffing costs.
We accounted for this ambiguity by not basing financial analysis exclusively on staffing costs, but rather using a per-minute cost figure and determining the average time a late OR ran beyond 5 pm. The main limitation of this approach was that the cost savings estimated in this study were based on analysis of a relatively small number of last cases, specific to those performed by department of surgery surgeons.
In reality, our institution’s nine outpatient ORs are in use an average of approximately 250 work days per year, with about 2,250 last cases each year. If last case percentage remained consistent over all potential last cases, the cost savings associated with reducing late finishes from 29% to 16% would be dramatic. Assuming a 29% late finish percentage in FY13, there would be 653 ORs that run past 5 pm. At $471 per late OR, this amounts to $307,563 spent on overutilized OR time.
Applying the same method to FY14, at the 16% late finish rate, overutilized time spending was approximately $169,560. Thus, reducing overutilized time by the same relative amount would have been estimated to save $128,186.
In extrapolating the findings of this project to a more realistic annual case volume, it is clear that reducing overutilized time, whether by improving FCOTS or by other means, results in meaningful cost savings to an institution.
Both the direct costs of staffing an OR and indirect costs relating to employee satisfaction and staff turnover make overutilized time costly.
Reducing surgeon-related delays is only one aspect of OR inefficiency. A scheduled surgical case may be delayed for many reasons; in fact, one study found that surgeon-related factors accounted for only 21% of first case delays. By addressing the other issues contributing to late starts, it is reasonable to predict that cost savings could be amplified further.
The authors thank the Shapiro Summer Research Program and Department of Surgery at the University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health for supporting this project.
Support funding was provided by the Herman and Gwendolyn Shapiro Foundation and Department of Surgery at the University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health. The authors report no proprietary or commercial interest in any product mentioned or concept discussed in this article.
Bhatt A S, Carlson G W, Deckers P J, et al. Improving operating room turnover time: A systems based approach. J Med Syst. 2014;38:148.
Cendan J C, Good M. Interdisciplinary work flow assessment and redesign decreases operating room turnover time and allows for additional caseload. Arch Surg. 2006;141:65-69.
Cima R R, Brown M J, Hebl J R, et al. Use of Lean and Six Sigma methodology to improve operating room efficiency in a high-volume tertiary-care academic medical center. J Am Coll Surg. 2011;213:83-92.
Correll D J, Bader A M, Hull M W, et al. Value of preoperative clinic visits in identifying issues with potential impact on operating room efficiency. Anesthesiology. 2006;105:1254-1259.
Dexter F, Abouleish A E, Epstein R H, et al. Use of operating room information system data to predict the impact of reducing turnover times on staffing costs. Anesth Analg. 2003:97:1119-1126.
Dexter F, Epstein R H. Typical savings from each minute reduction in tardy first case of the day starts. Anesth Analg. 2009;108:1262-1267.
Dexter F, Macario A, Traub R, et al. An operating room scheduling strategy to maximize the use of operating room block time. Anesth Analg. 1999;89:7-20.
Ferschl M B, Tung A, Sweitzer B, et al. Preoperative clinic visits reduce operating room cancellations and delays. Anesthesiology. 2005;103:855-859.
Foglia R P, Alder A C, Ruiz G. Improving perioperative performance: The use of operations management and the electronic health record. J Ped Surg. 2013;48:95-98.
Girotto J A, Koltz P F, Drugas G. Optimizing your operating room: or, why large, traditional hospitals don’t work. Int J Surg. 2010;8:359-367.
Harders M, Malangoni M A, Weight S, et al. Improving operating room efficiency through process redesign. Surgery. 2006;140:509-514.
HCCI. 2013 Health Care Cost and Utilization Report. http://www.healthcostinstitute.org/report/2013-health-care-cost-utilization-report/.
Mathews L, Kla K M, Marolen K N, et al. Measuring and improving first case on-time starts and analysis of factors predicting delay in neurosurgical operating rooms. J Neurosurg Anesthesiol. 2015;27(3):203-208.
Nundy S, Mukherjee A, Sexton J B, et al. Impact of preoperative briefings on operating room delays: A preliminary report. Arch Surg. 2008;143:1068-1072.
Overdyk F J, Harvey S C, Fishman R L, et al. Successful strategies for improving operating room efficiency at academic institutions. Anesth Analg. 1998;86:896-906.
Peltokorpi A. How do strategic decisions and operative practices affect operating room productivity? Health Care Manage Sci. 2011;14:370-382.
van Veen-Berkx E, Elkhuizen S G, van Logten S, et al. Enhancement opportunities in operating room utilization. J Surg Res 2015:194:43-51 e42.
Wachtel R, Dexter F. Reducing tardiness from scheduled start times by making adjustments to the operating room schedule. Anesthes. Analg. 2009;108:1902-1909.
Warner C J, Walsh D B, Horvath A J, et al. Lean principles optimize on-time vascular surgery operating room starts and decrease resident work hours. J Vasc Surg. 2013;58:1417-1422.
Weinbroum A A, Ekstein P, Ezri T. Efficiency of the operating room suite. Am J Surg. 2003;185:244-250.
Wright J G, Roche A, Khoury A E. Improving on-time surgical starts in an operating room. Can J Surg. 2010;53:167-170.