May 17, 2017

Employee engagement: The path to better patient care–Part 1

By: Cynthia Saver, MS, RN
Share

What’s the best strategy for OR leaders to boost productivity, reduce costs, and, most important, provide excellent patient care? Ensure staff are engaged. Staff engagement has become something of a buzzword in healthcare, but for good reason.

Lori Smithson, MBA, MSN

“Employee engagement is the bull’s-eye on the target of providing excellent patient care,” says Lori Smithson, MBA, MSN, director of surgical services for Northern Arizona Healthcare—Verde Valley Medical Center in Cottonwood, Arizona. Smithson and her colleagues at Verde Valley nearly doubled the percentage of engaged employees over 1 year, from 33% to 60%, with the percentage increasing to 68% in 2016, by eliminating low performers and introducing shared governance.

“Shared governance really opened up the ability of the staff to trust me as their leader,” Smithson says.

In the first part of a two-part series on engagement, we explore why engagement is so essential to a healthcare organization’s success and initial steps OR leaders can take—engage front-line managers and get the right employees onboard. Additional strategies will be discussed in a future issue of OR Manager.

 

Boosting productivity

Cindy Kildgore, MSHA, BSN, RN, CNOR

Satisfied employees are happy with their jobs, but engaged employees are passionate about them. “Employee engagement is the emotional commitment employees have to the company and its goals,” writes Kevin Kruse, author of Employee Engagement 2.0.

And although employee satisfaction can reduce turnover, engagement has the added benefit of greater productivity, says Cindy Kildgore, MSHA, BSN, RN, CNOR, perioperative services director for Vanderbilt University Medical Center in Nashville, Tennessee.

Engagement is also a matter of patient safety. In a classic 2005 Gallup study of more than 200 hospitals, the top predictor of mortality was the engagement level of nurses, with the ratio of number of nurses to total patient days second. Engagement was also the top predictor for complications.

A 2016 Gallup meta-analysis found that engagement is related to nine factors: customer loyalty/engagement, profitability, productivity, turnover, safety incidents, shrinkage, absenteeism, patient safety incidents, and quality (defects)—all important issues for OR leaders.

Ultimately, engagement hits both the financial and the clinical bottom line. “Employee engagement improves retention and increases our productivity and our profitability,” says Tracey Carrigan, MSN, director of surgical services at Hendrick Medical Center in Abilene, Texas. “All that relates back to patient satisfaction and better patient care.”

In April 2017, Hendrick received the Gallup Great Workplace Award for the 11th consecutive year.

 

Overcoming obstacles

Most leaders would agree that engagement is important, yet a 2016 Gallup survey found that only 33% of employees are actively engaged. A survey by Quantum Workplace reported that healthcare ranks last in engagement among the 17 industries profiled, with 57% engagement in 2015, down from 65% in 2011. What makes it so hard to move engagement numbers?

“Sometimes I feel we have the idea of engagement backwards,” says Jodi Koch, MBA, BSN, RN, director of perioperative and endoscopy services at Lehigh Valley Health Network in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania. “We feel as though giving our employees rewards, recognition, and perks will build engagement, and it does build a certain level of satisfaction.”

But Koch points out that engagement should flow from employees to employers, not the other way around. “Our employees know where their challenges lie and what works best for them when they’re doing their jobs,” she says. “They want to be heard, and they want to be involved in solving their problems and helping to create a better workplace.”

Tracey Carrigan, MSN

Applying engagement principles is often hindered by time constraints and lack of focus on what’s truly important. “We as leaders get stretched really thin because we’re so busy managing tasks,” Smithson says. “When I get really task focused, I forget that my employees need to have a relationship with me, and that it takes time and effort.”

It also takes the support of top leadership. “Our executive leadership is 100% committed to engagement,” Carrigan says. “They give us the tools we need to improve.”

In 2016, a report from Josh Bersin, principal and founder of Bersin by Deloitte, noted that companies with employees who would recommend others work for their organization were distinguished by a single factor—leadership that places employees first.

Kildgore says Vanderbilt leadership has found that applying concepts from the book The 4 Disciplines of Execution: Achieving Your Wildly Important Goals helps to enhance engagement (sidebar, p 7).

“Many studies have indicated that the number one determining factor of how employees feel about their jobs is directly related to their supervisor,” Smithson adds. “That should inspire us because we have the power to engage our employees.”

Engagement is challenging not just for leaders, but for employees, too. “Healthcare and the perioperative environment are really challenging,” Koch says. “There’s a lot more pressure now to balance the patient experience with cost and quality.”

To meet the challenge of engagement, OR leaders need to start with their front-line managers, and then be sure they have the right people in place.

 

Focusing on front-line managers

Jodi Koch, MBA, BSN, RN

An organization can’t have engaged employees without engaged leaders. “If there is an engagement problem it’s because I as a leader have not set the tone for engagement,” Smithson says.

Front-line managers are particularly key. “About 70% to 80% of people in the workforce report directly to a front-line manager, so it’s really the front-line managers who are setting the tone; they’re the ones responsible for motivating employees,” Koch says. “If our middle managers aren’t at their best—if they aren’t feeling that they are growing—we will totally miss the mark in engaging our front-line employees.”

Coaching can help managers be more effective. “Coaching is the missing piece in the equation of employee engagement,” Koch says.

“As leaders, we don’t know how to handle every situation, but if we can have somebody come alongside us and coach us and show us the right way to do it, we grow and they grow through that process,” Smithson adds.

Koch says spending time with managers as they interact with their teams yields many coaching opportunities. “It’s important for you to see and understand how the managers relate to their direct employees and their peer groups.”

Leaders can offer concrete feedback about these interactions, often in just a few minutes. “Coaching isn’t one big power session,” Koch says. “It’s more like intermittent spurts.” Carrigan agrees: “It’s very important to give real-time feedback on a regular basis, not just at the annual performance assessment.”

Front-line managers still need one-on-one time with their own leaders. Although Smithson’s door is open to her managers, she also sets aside 2 hours each month for uninterrupted time. “We have lunch and talk about the issues,” she says.

Kildgore adds that leaders need to know when to step back. “A lot of it has to do with not micromanaging them,” she says. “If you give them the processes and allow them to function independently, they can do their best work.”

Professional development is an avenue to help leaders become better at engaging staff, which, in turn, will help them be engaged. Vanderbilt provides options designed to hone leaders’ skills.

“We have an entire selection of free classes they can take on different topics, such as how to deal with difficult behavior, and an online managers’ toolbox so they can enrich and enhance their leadership style,” Kildgore says. She adds that leaders need to ask front-line managers about their career goals and provide support to help them meet those goals.

In addition to education classes, leaders at Verde Valley are currently participating in Excellence in Everything, a 3-day training program that applies the Baldridge Framework to improving the organization.

Education doesn’t have to be formal. The chief executive officer of Hendrick provides managers and directors with a book to read; during the monthly management council meetings, different leaders speak about how they can apply the book to their own work. Carrigan asks her direct reports to read the same book so they can discuss it at the weekly team meeting. “Besides the financial report, we are often reading a book together and discussing how to apply it,” she says.

 

Setting expectations

When Smithson became a leader at Verde Valley in 2012, she quickly realized she had a problem, with engagement at only 33% (sidebar right).

“We had highly influential, long-term employees who created an atmosphere of disrespect and dysfunction,” she says. However, other members of the team were reluctant to lodge official complaints about these employees’ behaviors.

The behavior of the poor performers took its toll on others. “You had these high performers who really wanted to be high performers, but they felt stifled because of the low performers,” Smithson says, adding that high performers didn’t want to work with low performers even though in some cases they were friends with them.

Those in the middle were easily swayed either to excel or not to excel, depending on the group with which they affiliated.

Smithson moved out the low performers by establishing clear expectations and then terminating those who didn’t meet those expectations. Other low performers opted to leave once the writing was on the wall, Smithson says. After the low performers left, the work environment improved, providing benefits to both high and middle performers. “They enjoyed the work environment so much more; you could see morale increase,” she says.

 

Leading with heart

“As leaders, we must move employee engagement from a ‘check-the-box’ activity to a vital factor of our human capital strategy,” Smithson says. One way to do that is to be sure to include time to engage with staff. “Our schedule is the most important thing we manage as leaders,” she notes.

She conducts quarterly formal rounding on staff in addition to daily rounds. The quarterly meetings give Smithson the opportunity to “hear what’s in their heart,” she says.

Simple tactics can facilitate the conversation. For instance, Smithson moved her chair away from her desk and closer to the employee so she isn’t tempted to multitask. “I ask them how they are managing their work-home life balance and what I can do to help.”

These types of conversations help managers better understand staff so they can help them excel. “You have to get to know everyone because everyone is unique, and you have to find how their talents fit within the OR,” Carrigan says. “You need to give employees enough autonomy so they use their talents and skills to do what they do best.” ✥

 


Engaging the four disciplines of execution

The authors of the book The 4 Disciplines of Execution: Achieving Your Wildly Important Goals explain how using the disciplines can help organizations achieve desired outcomes.

Cindy Kildgore, MSHA, BSN, RN, CNOR, perioperative services director for Vanderbilt University Medical Center in Nashville, Tennessee, comments on how these disciplines can be applied to engagement.

Focus on the wildly important. When you focus on the “wildly” important, you focus on less to achieve more. Narrowing your focus to a few highly important goals increases the likelihood for success.

“Take the pulse of your staff,” Kildgore says. “Find out what their greatest concerns, goals, and ideas are, identify the top ones, and then begin to execute.”

Act on the lead measures. Lead measures tell you if you’re likely to achieve your goals. For example, turnover rates can show you trends for those leaving the organization, but at Vanderbilt, leaders also collect information from current staff. “We do the ‘stay interview,’ every 6 months as part of our regular one-to-one meeting,” Kildgore says. “We ask them why they stay with the organization and how we can help them in their career path.” This helps identify lack of engagement early, before someone decides to leave.

Keep a compelling scoreboard. The scoreboard, ideally designed by staff themselves, allows everyone to see progress. At Vanderbilt, each service line receives scorecards for hand hygiene, surgical site infections, turnover time, and staff retention. The scorecards rank each item as red, yellow, or green. “When we reach green, we celebrate,” Kildgore says.

Create a cadence of accountability. Accountability is achieved through regular and frequent meetings to assess progress. In the case of engagement, this is enacted as a daily morning huddle that includes all perioperative services disciplines. “We follow an outline that reviews first-case starts, delays, throughput for the coming day, announcements, and follow-up from issues brought forward the day before,” Kildgore says.

Each discipline is held responsible for follow-up, and quarterly reports are reviewed to measure improvement. “This has brought about engagement from every department because they must share publically their results and data,” Kildgore notes. “We’ve seen a vast improvement in throughput from these huddles.”

References

Bersin J. Predictions for 2017: Everything is becoming digital. Bersin by Deloite Research Report. 2016.

Blizzard R. Nurse engagement key to reducing medical errors. Gallup. 2005. http://www.gallup.com/poll/20629/nurse-engagement-key-reducing-medical-errors.aspx.

Harter J K, Schmidt F L, Agrawal S, et al. The relationship between engagement at work and organizational outcomes. 2016 Q12® meta-analysis: ninth edition. Gallup. April 2016.

Kruse K. The ROI of employee engagement in hospitals. Forbes. February 26, 2015. https://www.forbes.com/sites/kevinkruse/2015/02/26/the-roi-of-employee-engagement-in-hospitals/#31b8545e54ce.

McChesney C, Covey S, Huling J. The 4 Disciplines of Execution: Achieving Your Wildly Important Goals. New York: Free Press. 2016.

Quantum Workplace. Employee engagement in healthcare: Three key ingredients to cultures that save more lives.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat