Less than 2 years after the New England Baptist Outpatient Care Center was imagined, its doors opened in September 2013. The sparkling new ambulatory surgery center (ASC) in the Boston suburb of Dedham, Massachusetts, isn’t far from the country’s oldest timber-framed house, the Fairbanks House, built in 1637—long before building codes arrived.
The new facility, which occupies about half of a 66,000 sq ft building, illustrates the complexity, opportunity, and satisfaction associated with building a new ASC. It was developed from the ground up, with the location carefully selected for commuting ease; it is close to the Massachusetts Route 128 highway that surrounds the western side of Boston.
Specializing in sports medicine and orthopedic surgery, the Dedham center offers patients a single location for outpatient surgery, pain management, and rehabilitation services. It contains 8 ORs, each 515 sq ft. Adjoining space holds the Shields Health Care Group, a diagnostic imaging practice that operates in partnership with the ASC.
Officials at New England Baptist Hospital (NEBH) in Boston had rushed the development of the ASC to have a replacement ready before the lease on its other ASC expired. Not only did the fast-track project meet its deadlines, but business has been brisk enough to keep the original ASC, SurgiCare in Brookline, open as well.
“It happened so fast,” Val Giordano, RN, recalls. As associate vice president of support services at NEBH, Giordano managed the Dedham project after an executive planning committee signed off on the concept and major criteria for the ASC, including a suburban location.
“It was a chance to branch out of Boston, to open up new markets,” Giordano says. The hospital also hoped to attract its current outpatient population away from the Boston campus, to free up more inpatient space there.
A 22-member steering committee spent the summer of 2011 evaluating architects and contractors. They sought local professionals with experience in designing and building healthcare facilities. They selected Steffian and Bradley Architects and Suffolk Construction, who quickly got to work. “Usually the design takes a year,” Giordano says. “We compressed it into about 12 weeks.”
The committee, which included physicians, nurses, and administrators, reviewed statistics on patient populations as well as surgery volume and procedures, and then the architects translated the results into a design for the facility. Before signing off, the committee examined the layout for efficiency, space needs for equipment, and patient flow. Then the rest of the staff—some awaiting transfer from the other NEBH sites, others representing disciplines that would be hired—toured the site with the architects and made recommendations.
“Everything was taken into consideration in the design phase,” Giordano says. “Every discipline was invited to the table at some point.” Among enhancements that resulted from this feedback were reconfiguration of the space allocated to billing and placement of Pyxis automated medication dispensers in the ORs, saving clinicians a trip to the pharmacy for each procedure.
Planners kept an eye on the future, Giordano notes. “I think the challenge is always how to assimilate ideas into the future. You want to have a state-of-the-art facility that you’re not going to outgrow in 2 or 3 years. Change to be a leader in what you do.”
The décor is in relaxing earth tones, and the building has large windows that give views of the wooded landscape. The preoperative and postanesthesia care unit (PACU) bays perform double duty: When patients arrive for admission, the bays are preoperative areas, and as patients emerge from the ORs later, they serve as PACUs. The equipment layout is identical with those in the hospital so that staff can transfer back and forth comfortably.
Volume has been steady since opening day, Giordano reports, and patients have been appreciative. “They comment, ‘this is such a beautiful place,’ ” she says.
Despite the deadline pressure, the Dedham project managers demonstrated many of the best practices for building a new ASC. They chose professionals with healthcare experience to design and construct the building. They sought input from all types of employees.
Not every new ASC development runs so smoothly, according to Denver architect John Marasco, whose firm, Marasco & Associates, has designed some 350 ASCs across the US and abroad. One critical mistake ASC developers can make is to start before consulting state regulators.
“Although it is inconceivable to me,” Marasco says, “we’ve actually encountered several facilities that have neglected to consult their state departments of health until after completing construction.”
It is the state, not federal, government that signs off on an ASC’s Medicare certification and issues a billing number, along with any state license that may be required. That is because the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid (CMS) designates states to interpret and administer federal codes. At the local level, city or town building departments must approve construction and issue building and occupancy permits.
Another potential error might be thinking too narrowly. Before lifting the first shovel for a new ASC, Marasco recommends that owners consider its expansion and resale potential. He finds that single-specialty ASCs could improve future profits by making early, low-cost modifications to accommodate other specialties or unexpected volume increases.
Planners should consider upgrading heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) systems beyond code requirements, Marasco adds. “Temperature and humidity control in the operating room is another top complaint we hear about,” he says. Surgeons often prefer ORs to be cooler than the 68-degree CMS requirement, yet they also want to maintain required humidity levels, a combination that demands a more advanced HVAC system.
Where to construct a new ASC depends on many factors, but essential considerations are availability and cost. Marasco notes that it may be cheaper to build a new ASC than to try to bring an existing building up to code. However, ASCs can spring up in unexpected locations. He has built ASCs in former grocery stores, gas stations, car dealerships, strip malls, and a century-old sorority house. Other sites include a Philadelphia Navy Yard warehouse and a downtown Chicago skyscraper. The most typical conversions, however, are in medical office buildings.
“ASCs are located where the patients are and where the physicians are,” he says.
He offers the following estimate of comparative costs to prepare a new site and build, or to demolish the interior and remodel an existing structure of 15,000 sq ft.
• Site work: $5-$9 per square foot ($6 average)
• New ASC: $238-$390 per square foot ($297 average)
• Demolition: $7-$11 per square foot ($9 average)
• Remodel: $160-$262 per square foot ($199 average)
Building costs vary widely by region. “It costs a lot more to build in Manhattan, New York, than in Manhattan, Kansas,” Marasco notes. To be specific, he estimates the cost per square foot for the same new ASC to be $256 to $298 in Kansas and $399 to $478 in New York. In general, costs are lowest in central Southern states and highest in the Northeastern and West Coast states.
In addition to regional variations, construction costs in urban areas are usually higher than elsewhere, partly because of higher wages. A shortage of building materials can raise prices as well. Even the weather makes a difference: “Hurricanes in the Gulf Coast region not only affected gas prices for us all, but due to the same disruption of petroleum manufacturing, also affected the costs of asphalt roofing, PVC piping, and insulation—not to mention the availability of big ticket items like transformers and generators,” Marasco recalls.
The size of the facility affects the cost in 2 ways: A larger building will cost more overall to build, but the cost per square foot will be less than for a smaller building. For one thing, Marasco notes, the cost of materials decreases with higher volume. He adds that architects and contractors should also charge lower unit rates for larger projects. “It’s simply less expensive, on a square-foot basis, to produce a large facility than a smaller one,” he says.
After the owners and executives have set overall criteria, a steering committee selects an architect through the request for proposals and interview process. The committee can then choose a contractor in the same way, or—in a more traditional process—let the architect first develop building documents and specifications and then bid the project to select contractors.
Either way, at an early stage clinical and administrative staff should be consulted. “If a hospital is adding an ASC, nurse managers will absolutely get involved,” Marasco says.
But what if the ASC is a new creation? The administrator and OR managers are not usually hired until 3 to 6 months before opening day, and they bring in other staff even later. In that case, Marasco calls on clinical consultants, who specialize in ASC setup and employ nurses, to advise designers on patient flow, technology, and equipment.
The new Dedham ASC is unusual in that fewer new ASCs are opening than in the past. “It’s a market that’s becoming saturated,” Marasco says. The majority of new ASCs are commissioned by physician practices rather than hospitals.
The motivation to develop a new ASC has not changed, however. Marasco finds that the primary goal is to benefit patients, with lower costs and a more pleasant environment. Second is a more convenient location with better working conditions for physicians. The third, and last, motive is profit.
“It’s not the first priority, as some people think,” he says. ✥