March 17, 2016

Healthcare and self-care dovetail as themes at business conference

By: Cynthia Saver, MS, RN
Share

More than 350 surgical services leaders from across the US gathered at the OR Business Management Conference in Glendale, Arizona, in February to learn strategies for managing both healthcare and self-care. Attendees came away inspired by thought-provoking keynotes and ready to implement ideas sparked by interactive sessions, exhibitors, and their own colleagues.

The wide range of topics included how to achieve quality measures, outpatient total joints and other new models of patient care, and innovative uses of Lean techniques. Whether attendees came from a hospital or ambulatory care center, they found new approaches to apply in their practice.

Here’s an overview of the general sessions, which covered both work and work/life balance.

 

Solving the Rubik’s Cube of healthcare

Keith Siddel, healthcare reform, payment models

Keith Siddel, PhDc, JD, MBA, CHC, explored the challenges presented by recent and upcoming changes in healthcare during his opening keynote address.

Keith Siddel, PhDc, JD, MBA, CHC, opened the conference by discussing the challenge of delivering quality care and maintaining revenue in the face of a multitude of healthcare changes. Siddel, vice president of revenue for Baptist Memorial Health Care Corporation in Memphis, said, “Solving the problems in healthcare can be much like solving a Rubik’s Cube,” the 3-D puzzle invented in 1974 by Erno Rubik. He explained that each face of the cube really has nine separate sides, illustrating the complexity of healthcare issues, and then spoke about three “sides”—patients, payers, and population.

Patients.Patient satisfaction is a significant part of pay for performance (P4P), first in the form of the Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (HCAHPS), which Siddel called “Yelp on steroids.”

Since HCAHPS was introduced in 2006, it has evolved into part of hospital value-based purchasing, a P4P program launched in 2012.

This year saw the launch of the Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems Outpatient and Ambulatory Surgery Survey (OAS CAHPS), which measures the experiences of patients who visited a Medicare-certified hospital outpatient department or ambulatory surgery center for a procedure.

OAS CAHPS is not yet linked to reimbursement, but the results are publically reported.

“It’s going to govern how patients look at your facility,” said Siddel, who emphasized that communication with patients and families during the entire perioperative experience is key to obtaining good scores.

Payers. Siddel noted that networks have significantly narrowed, and said hospitals should arrange transfers for any emergency department patients who are out of network.

He traced the evolution of delivery models and reimbursement structures from traditional fee for service to incentive-based pay. Under incentive-based pay is the continuum of P4P, patient-centered medical home, and bundled payments. The next step is transfer of risk, which includes accountable care organizations (ACOs).

“Payers are trying to shift the entire risk to providers,” he said. For example, the Comprehensive Care Joint Replacement Program, being launched by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) in April in 67 markets, ultimately will be rolled out across the nation. “CMS wants to pay one fixed amount to everyone,” Siddel said. “All the penalty is on the hospital.”

Target payments are based on 3 years of hospital and regional data and cover through 90 days after hospitalization, which means hospitals need to build partnerships with postdischarge providers such as physicians and therapists.

By 2020, hospitals could be penalized (or rewarded) as much as 20% depending on their performance. “The good news is that if you can do a good job, you will get a bonus,” Siddel said. Hospitals can share bonuses or penalties with other providers, but need to have a contract in place that defines gain share.

A related payment development is the CMS Bundled Payments for Care Improvement initiative, which is currently voluntary. For more information, see https://innovation.cms.gov/initiatives/bundled-payments/.

Siddel also discussed “site-neutral payment,” which means that Medicare will pay the same amount for a procedure no matter where it is done. He cited data from the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission that found Medicare paid hospital outpatient departments 78% more on average than ambulatory surgery centers for the same procedure in 2013. Site-neutral payments are seen as a way to resolve this issue.

In addition, Siddel noted that in January 2015, CMS started using comprehensive APCs (C-APCs), which he said are like “mini-DRGs.” They represent a specific outpatient procedure such as a hip replacement or pacemaker procedure and incorporate all other ancillary services into a lump-sum payment. CMS created 10 new C-APCs for calendar year 2016.

Population. Currently, there are 5,686 hospitals in the country. “Treatment in hospitals is trending downward and will continue to do so,” Siddel said. “There is an upward trend in outpatient visits because of the increase in outpatient surgeries.” Medicare paid hospitals only $0.88 for every $1 spent in 2013, and Medicaid paid only $0.90 for every $1 spent. “How long is this model sustainable?” Siddel asked. “The margins are razor thin, if there even is a margin.”

“Three dollars of every four dollars spent on healthcare are spent on a chronic condition,” Siddel said. “Seven of 10 deaths are caused by chronic conditions.” In addition, medical expenses are the number one cause of bankruptcies in the US.

These trends have led payers to embrace ACO models of reimbursement, where payments are bundled by population, and more risk is being borne by providers, Siddel said. He advised OR leaders to ask themselves, “How do I get out of the OR silo?”

Siddel suggested talking with other people and doing research as tactics for solving the Rubik’s Cube of healthcare. “Take that information, put it in your Rubik’s Cube, and figure out how it affects the other sides of the cube,” he said. “Everything is now three-dimensional.”

 

Preventing compassion fatigue

Compassion fatigue, burnout, employee engagement

Compassion fatigue takes a toll on providers and patients alike, but there are many ways to guard against it, according to Gail Avigne, MSN, BA, RN, CNOR.

Gail Avigne, MSN, BA, RN, CNOR, principal consultant for Press Ganey Associates, Inc, addressed the human resource side of healthcare with a presentation on compassion fatigue (CF). Avigne defines CF in terms of secondary post-traumatic stress disorder—“emotional, physical, and spiritual exhaustion from witnessing and absorbing the problems and suffering of others.”

CF differs from burnout, which is “a psychological syndrome that involves a prolonged response to chronic interpersonal stressors on the job.” Three markers of burnout are:

• physical and emotional exhaustion

• depersonalization and cynicism

• reduced sense of accomplishment.

CF is a higher level of burnout and is more complex. Symptoms of CF can be divided into categories of cognitive, emotional, behavioral, spiritual, and somatic.

Avigne noted that, to reduce patient suffering, we must address CF in our caregivers. “We have to take care of ourselves so we can take care of others,” she said. “Do whatever it takes to do that.” Leaders should take time for themselves and take vacations so employees don’t feel guilty doing the same.

Leaders also need to be aware of triggers for CF. Avigne cited five from a 2010 study in Applied Nursing Research: missed serious patient symptoms, personally identified with patients, suffered from personal issues such as inexperience, struggled with workplace issues such as high acuity, and believed that their actions would not make a difference.

Employees aren’t the only reason leaders should be concerned about CF. “Patients tell us the effect of compassion fatigue,” said Avigne, citing examples of patient comments such as, “The assistant was arguing with the nurse in front of me. She was very rude and was yelling that she was tired of never having help around there. It made me very uncomfortable.”

Overall, CF has been linked to decreased productivity, more sick days, and higher turnover, all of which affect an organization’s bottom line. Employee engagement fosters loyalty, enhanced satisfaction (for both employees and patients), and stronger financial performance, but these results may suffer when employees experience CF. Patient satisfaction is particularly important given the trend toward value-based purchasing, and Avigne pointed out that increased engagement by physicians and employees is associated with higher HCAHPS scores.

She recommends organizations address external and internal factors associated with CF. External factors include the environment where care is delivered and the relationships that employees have with each other, their managers, and their patients. Internal factors address supporting self-care and helping caregivers manage stress.

Avigne then suggested three approaches to helping those with CF: mindfulness-based stress reduction, teaching compassion, and Press Ganey’s Compassionate Connected Care (CCC) program. The CCC program consists of six themes and includes videos and simulation workshops.

1. Acknowledge the complexity and gravity of the work of caregivers. This includes recognizing employees. “Positive praise should be given daily,” Avigne said, adding that positive comments should outweigh negative remarks by a ratio of five to one.

2. Management must provide the support. That includes a positive work environment.

3. Teamwork matters.

4. Empathy and trust are key components.

5. Caregivers’ perceptions, positive work life, and balance are key.

6. Communication at all levels is foundational.

“Show you care,” Avigne said. “You should know something [personal] about your employees.” She also advised leaders to allow employees to share their emotions and to share their own fears and concerns.

She added that small changes can be effective, for example, cordoning off a section of the lounge with a soothing wall paint color and softer lighting or having students at a local massage school provide massages.

Leaders should meet employees “eye to eye and heart to heart,” and treat them like they make a difference, Avigne concluded.

 

Surviving the tsunami of change

emotional intelligence, culture change, healthcare system change, healthcare system payment

Leaders must develop self-awareness and other traits of emotional intelligence in order to engage their staffs and guide them through change, said William F. (Bill) Vanaskie, MS, MBA, FACHE.

William F. (Bill) Vanaskie, MS, MBA, FACHE, former executive vice president and chief operating officer for Maricopa Integrated Health System in Phoenix, shared his perspective on how healthcare is changing and offered tips for helping staff navigate in this new world.

Vanaskie noted that a number of mergers have occurred, including mergers of payers. “We don’t yet know if this will be a good thing,” he said. He added that payers are consolidating as an offshoot of the implementation of the Affordable Care Act, and that employers are dropping insurers, forcing employees into high-deductible plans.

One effect has been an increase in the number of tools designed to compare cost and quality. In addition, health systems are starting to create their own insurance plans, he noted.

“We are facing a revolutionary change in healthcare,” Vanaskie said. That includes vertical integration of healthcare and migration of care to the outpatient setting. These changes put stress on managers; Vanaskie quoted a study reporting that 81% of managers in healthcare perceive themselves to be at or near change saturation. He also noted that, “70% of change efforts fail because of employee resistance or poor leadership support.”

Vanaskie said that leaders have the power to guide change, and must also look at changing themselves. “You cannot stay the way you are,” he said. He suggested two approaches: enhance workforce engagement and organize to deal with emergence.

Workforce engagement. “Before you can engage the workforce, you need to work on you,” Vanaskie said. He recommended leaders “understand and value the need for emotional intelligence” (EI). Elements of EI include self-awareness, self-regulation, motivation, empathy, and social skill. (Watch for an upcoming article on EI in OR Manager.)

“Emotional intelligence is a skill, and skills can be learned,” Vanaskie said. He added five actions leaders can take to engage their staff:

• Create a collaborative culture.

• Promote the right environment.

• Overcome cultural and social norms. “All people on the team are necessary and should have a say,” he said.

• Gain leadership exposure. “Talk to other leaders and participate in leadership programs outside the hospital,” he said.

• Foster open communication. “Enhance communication so people feel free to talk,” he said. “We need to be attentive, not directive.”

“Culture change takes a long time, but it all has a beginning,” Vanaskie added.

Organize to deal with emergence. “Once staff are engaged, you can respond to disruptive effects,” Vanaskie said. First, leaders must understand the difference between complicated and complex:

• Complicated things have many interrelated parts, linked in discernible ways, and operate in understandable and predictable fashion.

• Complexity arises when there is a dramatic increase in the number of connections and interdependencies. It eliminates any potential for prediction and efficiency.

A key difference is the inability to predict the results of decision making. As Vanaskie said, “Small decisions have surprising results…It becomes impossible to predict the outcome with any certainty.”

Vanaskie recommended forming networks of teams. Establishing effective networks of teams requires trust and a common purpose. “Working in a large organization does not foster trust, but if we work in teams, and the teams work with each other, we foster trust,” he said.

“None of this is easy, but all of it is necessary,” Vanaskie said. He added that leaders must understand that everyone is watching them and that “every interaction is meaningful.” To prepare to change, leaders need to work first on themselves, then their teams, and then other networks such as peers and supervisors.

“Know yourself, know your people, maintain your passion,” he said.

 

Breaking up with stress

stress management for nurses, burnout, mindfulness

“Do something for yourself every day,” advised Jane McLeod, MSN, RN, who presented a lively and humorous approach to stress management.

During her luncheon keynote, Jane McLeod, MSN, RN, cofounder of Capstone Leadership Solutions, Sault Ste Marie, Michigan, said, “We have chosen a profession that’s very, very stressful.”

She noted that a study from the Studer Group found people in healthcare only do something for themselves every few months. “You have to do something for yourself every day,” McLeod said.

She shared several steps participants can take to role model work/life balance to employees and reduce stress.

Create an island of inaccessibility.McLeod recommended attendees devote 30 to 90 minutes each day to themselves. “[Think about] what brings you joy, what fills up your emotional bank account, and do it for 30 minutes,” she said. During that time, others should follow what she called the “blue, broken, or bleeding” rule: No disturbances unless one of those conditions exists.

Know that multitasking is a myth.“Your brain is like a Rolodex,” McLeod said. Every time you flip without completing a task, you leave part of your brain behind.” Instead, leaders should concentrate on a single task at a time.

Foster your relationships. “Relationships are key,” McLeod says. “When we become socially isolated, our resilience goes down.” She compares relationships to glass balls and work to a rubber ball: If we drop the rubber ball, it will bounce back, but if we drop the glass balls, they will break.

Practice mindfulness. Even 2 minutes of mindfulness (focusing on one thing such as breathing) each day can reduce the stress response. McLeod suggested being mindful at work, too, recommending participants stop bringing their phones to meetings. Not having a phone means you’ll truly listen, instead of checking texts and emails. “It will help you identify meetings you really don’t need to attend,” she said.

Empower others.“Teach other people [how to do things],” McLeod said. When others are empowered to take care of situations, it reduces the leader’s stress.

Take care of yourself.McLeod cited research from Harvard that found exercising for 10 minutes spaced out three times a day is more effective than a single 30-minute workout early in the day.

McLeod also shared that 17 hours without sleep is comparable to a.05 blood alcohol level. “Protect your sleep time,” she advised, adding that people who use technology after 9 pm are less productive and more irritable the next day. When it comes to eating well, she advised: “Read valid research and educate yourself. We are what we eat.”

Be optimistic. “You have to practice seeing the good,” McLeod said. One way to do that is to identify three good parts of your day every day, and share them with someone or write them in a journal. A resource for the “three good things” practice is the YouTube video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=57ru-P7EuMw.

 

Join us next year

Next year’s OR Business Management Conference will be held January 31 to February 2, 2017, in New Orleans. Anyone wishing to present at the conference is invited to submit a proposal by April 29, 2016.

For more information, contact Nancy Berlin at nberlin@accessintel.com or Elizabeth Wood at ewood@accessintel.com.✥

 

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat