July 20, 2023

Hospitals look to cybersecurity insurance as cyberattacks rise

By: Brita Belli
Share

Takeaways

• Patient data & safety are at risk: 94% of hospitals have experienced at least one cyberattack.

• Less than half of hospitals in the US carry cybersecurity insurance.

• Security is a two-part strategy: cybersecurity insurance as well as preventative measures (eg, encrypted backups, patches, and training).


When a hospital is hit by a cyberattack, it can bring severe consequences—staff denied access to patient records, network shutdowns, closure, multimillion dollar restoration costs, and a blow to the healthcare system’s reputation.

In April 2023, the Murfreesboro Medical Clinic & SurgiCenter in Tennessee was forced to close 11 locations for nearly 2 weeks after a cyberattack—leaving patients without access to services and unable to fill prescriptions. St. Margaret’s Health-Peru, a hospital in Illinois, abruptly announced that it would close in January 2023, in part because of a cyberattack that affected its billing and payment system. At Johnson Memorial Health in central Indiana, criminals deployed ransomware minutes after gaining access to the hospital’s IT system. Staff lost access to medical records, nurses scrambled to share orders and lab notes via runners and handwritten notes, and fetal monitors stopped working, requiring nurses to stand watch over infants to detect any sudden changes. A network shutdown of Universal Health Services, which operates 400 facilities, resulted in a $67 million loss in 2021.

These are just a few of the cyberattacks that have left hospitals and health systems reeling. The majority of healthcare organizations—around 94%—have experienced at least one cyberattack, according to a 2020 article in the Journal of Healthcare Risk Management, which noted that 150 million protected health records were breached between 2009 and 2014. In 2019, there was a 70% increase in breaches compared to the 6-year average.

Rural hospitals are particularly vulnerable because of lack of resources. According to a May 2022 Guidehouse report, some 25% of rural hospitals in the US are at a high risk of closing because of financial strains, yet 82% are considered “highly essential to their communities.” According to a report from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, 149 rural hospitals have closed or been converted to Rural Emergency Hospitals offering minimal services since 2010.

Another area of vulnerability is patient records. Electronic health record (EHR) data is highly valuable to cyber criminals, drawing 10 to 100 times the value of credit card information on the black market, according to an April 2020 review in the Journal of Medical Systems.

Soumitra Bhuyan, PhD, MPH

The combination of valuable patient data and the time pressure of hospital operations makes them a prime target, says Soumitra Bhuyan, PhD, MPH, associate professor at the Bloustein School of Planning and Public Policy at Rutgers University, New Brunswick, New Jersey, and one of the review authors. “If you hijack a surgeon doing surgery, or doctors in the ICU can’t get access to the system—what will the hospital do? Criminals understand the time aspect and take advantage of it. It’s life and death for the patient.”

The solution is two-fold, say experts: implementing cybersecurity insurance and putting in place a comprehensive security plan that allows for strong preventative measures.

 

Where vulnerabilities arise

Michael Hamilton

“There’s a combination of bad conditions that in aggregate make hospitals good targets,” says Michael Hamilton, former chief information security officer for the city of Seattle and cofounder of security firm Critical Insights. “Hospitals are willing to pay an extortion demand to get back in working order, and they are so financially crushed because of the healthcare system that they can’t prioritize spending [on cybersecurity]. There are other sectors like that—local government and manufacturing—that still have a 20th century attitude toward risk management,” he adds.

Elective surgical procedures represent a significant source of revenue for hospitals, but the COVID-19 pandemic caused many to delay or avoid them, leading to a collective national revenue loss of more than $22 billion, according to a May 2021 Annals of Surgery article.

Lisa Pino

“Cybercriminals took advantage of hospitals and healthcare systems responding to the COVID-19 pandemic,” says Lisa Pino, director of the Office for Civil Rights at the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). “More than one healthcare provider has been forced to cancel surgeries, radiology exams, and other services because their systems, software, and/or networks were disabled.”

Though costs continue to rise sharply for hospitals, including for labor, drugs, and supplies, reimbursements from Medicare and Medicaid have not kept pace. Hospitals experienced a -8.5% margin on Medicare services in 2020, and -9% in 2022, according to a May 2022 American Hospital Association report. Underpayments from Medicare and Medicaid to hospitals were $100 billion in 2020, up from $76 billion in 2019.

”Healthcare systems are struggling,” says Bhuyan. “When they struggle, each department gets affected, including the IT side. Sometimes leadership doesn’t see IT as an investment but as a cost center and struggles with qualified HR on that side.” Rural hospitals, in particular, struggle to find people to help them secure their systems because they need resources they do not have to beef up protection, making them vulnerable to attacks, he adds.

In addition to hospitals lacking resources, the increasing number of devices in hospitals provide prime opportunities for cyberattacks. In the US, there are 10 to 15 connected devices per hospital bed, according to an October 2020 article in the Journal of Health Risk Management. And patients often access their medical records on their own devices, which typically have low security.

“ORs need a lot of medical devices,” Bhuyan says. “It’s one of the weakest links. Some of these devices are costly and are running on old Windows, and there is no way to update the software, making them vulnerable to attack. Staff use those systems to browse, and there’s evidence that they use these systems for questionable material. Each medical device has around six vulnerabilities, and 40% of devices used at end of life care are not protected.”

 

Understanding cybersecurity insurance

Bhuyan says cybersecurity insurance is an important component of a comprehensive plan to protect data and mitigate risk, but adoption remains much lower in healthcare compared to other industries. His research found that only 30% of healthcare organizations had cybersecurity insurance in 2017, compared to 90% of organizations in the financial sector.

Cybersecurity insurance is designed to mitigate the financial liability resulting from damages or losses caused by a data breach. However, there is no standard format for the underwriting of these policies. “Unfortunately, there’s no 200-year-old actuary table for cyber risk,” says Hamilton. “We don’t have empirical data. That’s why we have the mandatory reporting requirement.”

In March 2022, the Cyber Incident Reporting for Critical Infrastructure Act was signed into law, requiring “critical infrastructure” businesses to report cyber incidents to the US Department of Homeland Security Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency within 72 hours from the time the cyber incidents were believed to have occurred. They are also required to report ransomware payments within 24 hours of making any payments as a result of an attack. “As a consequence of the collection of information, we will start to build an actuary table for insurance to price risk better,” Hamilton says.

Guidelines from Bhuyan’s review in the Journal of Medical Systems recommend that hospitals seek cybersecurity policies that include three key components: liability coverage against claims for damages from theft, loss, or unauthorized disclosure of information; coverage for liabilities from regulatory fines, such as those involving the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act and the Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health Act; and coverage against losses from business interruption.

Cybersecurity insurers can also provide expertise in the event of a breach, including incident response teams and breach coaches who can help to restore systems and provide legal counsel, according to a May 2023 BizTech article.

Before choosing a plan, hospitals need to do a comprehensive assessment of their security capabilities and weaknesses to ensure the plan does not leave them exposed to liabilities. For instance, many of these policies do not cover ransomware attacks or attacks from specific nation-states. If they do offer ransomware coverage, they will likely require the organization to provide evidence that they are actively monitoring and following best practices.

Facing exorbitant costs on both the insurance side and in the case of attack, some experts recommend self-insurance as an option for larger organizations. Instead of paying premiums to an insurance company, the organization puts that money into an account overseen by a third party.

Even when cybersecurity insurance is in place, it can fail when it is needed most. For instance, in April 2023, a North Carolina radiology group sued its cyber insurance carrier after its coverage lapsed 2 days before a ransomware attack, claiming that they had submitted the paperwork for renewal but were told only after they filed the claim that they were no longer covered.

 

Taking proactive measures

A comprehensive plan is critical, but it also needs to be regularly tested and effectively communicated. An August 2019 cybersecurity survey of 166 information security leaders by Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society (HIMSS) found that 70% of cyberattacks originated from phishing emails—emails that are fraudulent or malicious but designed to look legitimate to trick people into clicking them.

As these attacks have become more sophisticated, once-a-year cyber security awareness training is not enough. Instead, HIMSS advises regular training with mock phishing exercises to gauge whether the antiphishing program is working, or if it needs to be improved with a goal of less than 10% click rate. “By involving your entire organization in the plan, your incident response plan will be better positioned to act quickly to detect, contain, and eradicate incidents,” HIMSS notes.

In a February 2022 HHS report, Pino writes that it is not enough for hospitals to perform risk analysis only on EHR data; they also need to identify risks across their operations. “You should fully understand where all electronic protected health information exists across your organization—from software to connected devices, legacy systems, and elsewhere across your network.”

Preventative measures include:

• maintaining offline, encrypted backups of data that are regularly tested

• conducting regular scans to identify and address vulnerabilities

• instituting regular patches, updates of software and operating systems

• training employees about phishing and other common IT attacks.

Hospitals can also involve outside cybersecurity risk experts in these efforts who work with organizations to assess their risk and provide 24-7 monitoring. Hamilton’s organization, for instance, provides continuous monitoring along with management and consulting services, and he says they specifically work with local and rural hospitals that do not have IT departments on which to lean. “We put out fires before they get out of control,” he says.

As these attacks and costs increase, insurance companies are continuing to raise their expectations for the preventative security measures that hospitals need to have to provide coverage, says Bhuyan. “Right now, many cybersecurity insurance providers are going through rigorous risk assessment of hospitals,” he adds. “If hospitals are not investing resources, they may not get coverage, or it might be a very high premium. Insurance providers are coming up with significant expectations from healthcare systems, and that will get stronger. Insurance is meant to protect against financial loss, but it’s not a replacement for building a secure system.”


Federal steps to address hospital cyberattacks

The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) released an updated Cybersecurity Resource Guide in 2022 that is designed to help hospitals and health systems keep patient information—including prescriptions, lab results, and records of hospital visits and vaccinations—safe from hackers, as required under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act. “The revision is more actionable so that healthcare organizations can improve their cybersecurity posture and comply with the security rule,” said Jeff Marron, a NIST cybersecurity specialist, in a July 2022 release.

President Biden signed the Cyber Incident Reporting for Critical Infrastructure Act into law in March 2022, which requires that businesses report cyber incidents to the US Department of Homeland Security Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) within 72 hours, as well as ransomware payments within 24 hours of making them. The rulemaking is ongoing, and CISA has received numerous public comments, including from healthcare facilities, that call attention to the complex nature of privacy and reporting when it comes to patient data.

University of Wisconsin Hospitals and Clinics Authority wrote in a public comment: “We request that CISA clarify whether protected health information will be included in reports by healthcare organizations. If we are expected to include such information…we ask that the government consider a higher standard for including this information, over and above the reasonable belief that a cyberattack occurred.”

To address the vulnerability of medical devices, senators introduced the Protecting and Transforming Cyber Health Care Act in March 2022. The act would ensure that cyber devices used in hospitals meet cybersecurity requirements when they are applying for premarket approval from the Food and Drug Administration, and that the manufacturers design and provide updates throughout the devices’ lifecycle.

In January 2023, NIST released the Cybersecurity Framework 2.0, designed to be a “living document” that calls for increased international collaboration and national implementation models and templates for sector-specific threats.

 

References

Cyber incident reporting for Critical Infrastructure Act of 2022 fact sheet. CISA.

H.R.7084 – PATCH Act of 2022. Congress.gov. 117th Congress (2021-2022).

Implementing the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) Security Rule: A Cybersecurity Resource Guide. NIST Special Publication. July 2022.

NIST Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 Concept Paper: Potential significant updates to the cybersecurity framework. National Institute of Standards and Technology. January 19, 2023.

NIST updates guidance for healthcare cybersecurity. NIST. July 21, 2022.

Request for information on the cyber incident reporting for Critical Infrastructure Act of 2022. Regulations.gov.


 

 

—Brita Belli is an award-winning writer and PR professional with published stories in the New York Times, National Geographic, MSN.com, and Alternet.

 

References

Alder S. Ransomware deployed 2 minutes after hackers gained access to Johnson Memorial Health’s network. The HIPAA Journal. October 7, 2021.

Bhuyan S S, Kabir U Y, Escareno J M, et al. Transforming Healthcare Cybersecurity from Reactive to Proactive: Current Status and Future Recommendations. J Med Syst. 2020 Apr 2;44(5):98.

Bose S K, Dasani S, Roberts S E, et al. The cost of quarantine: Projecting the financial impact of canceled elective surgery on the nation’s hospitals. Annals of Surgery. 273(5):p 844-849, May 2021.

Bruce G. Radiology group sues cyber insurer after policy lapsed right before ransomware attack. Becker’s Health IT. May 19, 2023.

Cole D, Kuhn H. Congress imposes new 72-hour reporting requirement for cyber security incidents. Freeman, Mathis & Gary LLP. March 28, 2022.

Davis J. Tennessee health system stops all operations amid cyberattack recovery. SC Media. May 4, 2023.

Fact Sheet: Majority of hospital payments dependent on Medicare or Medicaid; Congress continues to cut hospital reimbursements for Medicare. American Hospital Association. May 2022.

Gooch K. Illinois hospital apologizes for abrupt closure announcement. Becker’s Hospital Review. January 27, 2023.

Gross N. What businesses need to know about cybersecurity insurance. BizTech. November 1, 2021.

Jercich K. Universal Health Services faces $67 million loss after cyberattack. Healthcare IT News. March 5, 2021.

Kabir U Y, Ezekekwu E, Bhuyan S S, et al. Trends and best practices in healthcare cybersecurity insurance policy. J Healthc Risk Manag. 2020 Oct;40(2):10-14.

Kuehne J. When combating ransomware, what are your cyber insurance options? BizTech. May 19, 2023.

Pino L. Improving the cybersecurity posture of healthcare in 2022. Department of Health and Human Services. February 28, 2022.

Predicting COVID-19’s long-term effects. Definitive Healthcare. June 16, 2021.

Resource Center. Three Ways to Improve Your Security Incident Response Plan. HIMSS. June 30, 2020.

Rural hospital closures. The Sheps Center for Health Services Research, University of North Carolina. Updated in real time.

Rural Hospital Sustainability Index Analysis: Trends in rural hospital financial viability, community essentiality, and patient outmigration. Guidehouse. May 9, 2022.

Yousry F. How a cyberattack left one Indiana hospital reeling. NPR. May 13, 2023.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat