August 28, 2024

How perioperative staff can combat human trafficking—Part 1

By: Francine Bono-Neri, PhD, RN, APRN, PNP
Share

Human trafficking (HT) is a global public health crisis and one of the fastest growing criminal enterprises that grosses hundreds of billions of dollars annually, all of which are tax-free profits made off the sale of human cargo. And yet, research shows the problem is poorly understood or recognized among many healthcare professionals. Even those with a basic understanding of the issue might buy into the same myth blinding the US public at large: that HT is a foreign crime, not one taking place within their own communities. Meanwhile, victims cycle in and out of the healthcare system, seen but essentially invisible to professionals who are ideally positioned to help.

The goal of this two-part series is to narrow this education gap. Here, we illuminate the scope of the problem and its intersection within perioperative services, including recognizing signs of HT in the OR. Part 2 dives deeper into identifying and treating victims, reporting the crime, and other aspects of how perioperative leaders can help combat this complex, nuanced form of modern-day slavery.

 

Hidden yet pervasive

The Trafficking Victims Protection Act of 2000 defines HT as “the recruitment, harboring, transportation, provision, or obtaining of a person for labor or services, through the use of force, fraud, or coercion for the purpose of subjection to involuntary servitude, peonage, debt bondage, or slavery.” In keeping with this broad definition, Anti-Slavery International cites examples ranging from sex trafficking and forced labor to forced marriages, criminal activity, and child soldiering. A more recent variety is technology-facilitated sex trafficking (TFST), in which digital technologies provide perpetrators with the reach to expose victims to an immeasurable number of sex buyers.

Films like Taken and Sound of Freedom focus on abduction and physical restraint, but real-world HT is not like the movies. Although such tactics characterize a small number of cases, most involve traffickers luring vulnerable victims with false promises of a better life (sidebar, Recruiting the vulnerable). Similarly to the trauma bond that characterizes Stockholm Syndrome, tactics such as gaslighting and grooming can create a dysfunctional emotional attachment and leave victims reluctant to self-identify.

These individuals continue to attend school, use public transportation, go to work, and participate in all the activities of daily living. Some may fear retribution for seeking help, including violence to their offspring and extended families. Young, old, male, female—victims hail from all walks of life. So do traffickers, who can be victims’ boyfriends or girlfriends, husbands or wives, parents or other authority figures, or virtually any other seemingly innocuous relation. Whatever the specifics of the case, HT is a crime that often goes undetected.

Although the hidden nature of the crime makes quantifying the number of victims difficult, estimates reveal HT is pervasive. The International Labour Organization pegs the number of victims worldwide at 50 million, while the Office on Trafficking in Persons has documented cases in every US state and territory. Globally, those profiting from this fast-growing criminal enterprise rake in approximately $350 billion annually, according to Nasdaq and Verifin—a tax-free profit on human cargo that is roughly equivalent to the gross income of Nike, Google, and Starbucks combined.

 

Combatting trafficking

HT is viewed predominantly as a law enforcement, judicial, and social service issue. However, healthcare professionals (HPs)—including perioperative staff—are on the frontlines of this problem, even if they do not always realize it. In fact, retrospective studies from Chisolm-Straker et al as well as Lederer and Wetzel show that between 70% to 90% of survivors reported being seen by an HCP while in “the life.”

In addition to sharing all the health risks common to general patient populations, ongoing abuse can make victims susceptible to a number of acute and chronic conditions, including the downstream effects of profound, extreme trauma. Examples going beyond visible injury include urinary tract and sexually transmitted infections, unwanted pregnancies, and mental health concerns such as depression, anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and suicidality.

In perioperative settings, HT victims are likely to present with the following diagnoses or interventions:

• Head trauma

• Diverse fractures, in particular orbital, nasal, or mandibular (s/p trauma or a “fall”)

• Bruising patterns that are inconsistent with history

• Poor dental hygiene, dental/oral abscess(es)

• Gastrointestinal (GI) bleed

• Endoscopy or colonoscopy

• Dehydration, vitamin deficiencies, malnourishment

• Substance use or eating disorders

• Cyclical vomiting with no underlying cause (somatic complaints)

• Abscesses/wounds in need of incision & drainage (I&D)

• Vaginal or anal foreign body removal

• Vaginal tears/lacerations

• Anal tears/lacerations

• Ectopic pregnancy

• Dilation and curettage (D & C)

• Hx of medically unsafe abortion(s)

• C-section

• Pelvic inflammatory disease (PID), sexually transmitted infections/diseases (STIs/STDs)

• Urinary tract infections (UTIs)

• Breast cancer, cervical cancer

• Plastic surgery (may be forced/involuntary)

• Liposuction

• Organ transplantation—both donor and recipient (organ trafficking)

• Traumatic dismemberment of digits or limbs (labor trafficking)

• Bite or burn marks

• Profound anxiety and/or claustrophobia with CT or MRI (can be r/t past torture or abuse)

• Coronary heart disease

• Presenting with or Hx of myocardial infarction (MI), cerebrovascular accident (CVA), or transient ischemic attack (TIA).

 

Knowledge gap

Although HPs are ideally positioned to identify and assist victims, the literature shows they often will not recognize the signs. Missed opportunities can be attributed in part to victim nondisclosure, but gaps in HT and anti-trafficking education also play a major role.

HPs routinely fail to meet mandatory reporting requirements in cases involving minors who are in commercial sex acts. In these pediatric cases, federal law dictates that force, fraud, or coercion need not be proven—it is HT, it is a crime, and ultimately these providers are failing as mandated reporters (more on this next month).

In a 2012 study by Chisolm-Straker et al, 97.8% of emergency department (ED) professionals reported never having received formal training on the clinical presentation of HT victims. Most—95%—also reported never having received formal training on appropriate treatment for HT victims. Only 4.8% reported confidence in their ability to identify HT victims, and only 7.7% reported feeling confident in treating victims of HT.

And in 2022, a systematic scoping review conducted by Marcinkowski et al confirmed the above findings, which demonstrates a lack of formal ED training programs, validated proper screening tools, and standardized institutional protocols to aid in the care of trafficked patients.

A 2023 study in Nurse Education Today revealed similar gaps among prelicensure RN students. Findings show more than 91% (n=589) of respondents reported minimal to no HT content taught across prelicensure RN curricula. Approximately 82% (n=527) reported some to no knowledge of HT, as found by calculating a perceived HT knowledge sum score. Additionally, less than 5% of respondents had full confidence in identifying and responding to a victim of HT, with about 75% reporting halfway to zero confidence.

As noted by Powell et al in a 2017 study assessing HT education in healthcare, “most HCP are unfamiliar with how to care for trafficking survivors,” and “the field is wide open for progress to be made.”

Stay tuned next month for part 2, which will dive deeper into identifying victims, mandated reporting requirements, the impact of the care setting (eg, hospitals vs ASCs), and other aspects of the intersection of HT and perioperative services.

 

—Francine Bono-Neri, PhD, RN, APRN, PNP, is co-founder and president of Nurses United Against Human Trafficking, PA, a professional association dedicated to anti-human trafficking effort. A pediatric nurse practitioner, academic nurse educator, and trained sexual assault nurse examiner, Bono-Neri was recently recognized at the United Nations with the 2024 Inspiring Global Nurse Award and the 2024 International Ceca Award and accepted to be inducted as a Fellow in the American Academy of Nursing.

References

50 million people worldwide in modern slavery. International Labour Organization. September 12, 2022.

Anti-Slavery International. What is modern slavery? 2024.

Bono-Neri F. (2024). Human trafficking: A vulnerable population that is seen, yet remains invisible. Policy and Politics for nurses and other health professionals: Advocacy and Action, Fourth Edition. May 21, 2024.

Bono-Neri F, Toney-Butler T J. Nursing students’ knowledge of and exposure to human trafficking content in undergraduate curricula. Nurse Education Today. July 27, 2023.

Chisolm-Straker M, Baldwin S, Gaïgb´e-Togb´e B, et al. Healthcare and human trafficking: We are seeing the unseen. Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved. August 9, 2016.

Chisolm-Straker M, Richardson L D, Cossio T. (2012). Combating slavery in the 21st century: The role of emergency medicine. Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved. July 26, 2012.

Cryptocurrency and the trade of online child sexual abuse material. International Centre for Missing & Exploited Children. 2021.

Cyberspace: A fertile hunting ground for sex traffickers. National Center on Sexual Exploitation. June 30, 2022.

Ernewein C, Bono-Neri F, Toney-Butler T J, et al. Healthcare Response to human trafficking: Integrating the social-ecological model. Human trafficking: A system-wide public safety and community approach, second edition. 2017.

Gilmer D G. The outcomes of collaborative, human trafficking multi-disciplinary teams based on the experiences and perceptions of participants. Doctoral dissertation, Columbia International University. ProQuest. August 2021.

Hiding in plain sight: How nurses can stop human trafficking. Shift. May 12, 2022.

Human Trafficking. US Department of Justice. January 13, 2022.

Human trafficking and health care providers: Legal requirements for reporting and education. Jones Day. July 2022.

Lederer L J, Wetzel C A. (2014). The health consequences of sex trafficking and their implications for identifying victims in healthcare facilities. Annals of Health Law. 2014.

Marcinkowski B, Caggiula A, Tran B N, et al. Sex trafficking screening and intervention in the emergency department: A scoping review. Journal of the American College of Emergency Physicians Open. January 15, 2022.

Metz-Howard C. Research to map organized crime, terrorism hotspots in Eurasia. KU News Service. May 28, 2015.

Nasdaq Verafin. Global Financial Crime Report: Insights at the intersection of financial crime data & real survivor stories. 2024.

Powell C, Dickins K, Stoklosa H. Training US health care professionals on human trafficking: where do we go from here? Medical Education Online. January 6, 2017.

The intersections of human trafficking in healthcare: Unified to break the chains. Nurses United Against Human Trafficking. 2022.

What is human trafficking? Office on Trafficking in Persons. December 24, 2020.

 

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat