What happens when global supply chains—which are already typically operated lean across the board—are hit with a once-in-a-century pandemic? An ongoing, collective lesson in economics. The problem is not hard to understand: COVID-19 shutdowns brought manufacturing to a near standstill, during which time the demand for goods increased, and now there is a shortage of workers at shipping yards and warehouses.
How have these supply chain woes impacted hospital ORs? According to a November 2021 Fierce Healthcare article, hospital executives and supply managers believe the pandemic has uncovered soft spots in the supply chain, and that organizations could be doing more to fine-tune efficiencies.
In a discussion with directors of surgical services and supply chain administrators from health systems Swedish Health Services, CommonSpirit Health, El Camino Health, and MyMichigan Health, collaboration and communication were pinpointed as key among the different strategies executed at their organizations that helped them navigate OR supply chain issues.
M. Trevor Bennett, MSN, RN, CNOR, executive director of surgical services at Swedish Health, Seattle, Washington, says the institution sees good throughput in its supply chain, but an emerging challenge is inflationary pressures.
“Suppliers are starting to increase or be less willing to renegotiate our rates,” Bennett says. “Our supply chain is starting to encounter inflation increases without any change in our payer mix. This will have a huge impact, especially when you think about perioperative services being the financial driver of most hospitals.”
In the summer of 2021 and into early 2022, the world saw two significant COVID-19 surges because of the Delta and Omicron variants. Despite being a milder variant, Omicron still caused severe strains for hospitals. Surgeries halted, something that Bennett says had not happened at Swedish since the first wave. With increasing supply costs, it becomes even more imperative to anticipate COVID-19 surges and find ways to manage them when they happen.
“This idea of curtailing surgery to transform staffing matrices is not panning out. It didn’t work in 2020, nor 2021, and here we are doing it again in 2022,” Bennett says. “And it’s not just a cost concern; quality patient care is at serious risk. Someone goes in for a mammogram, a mass is identified, and what today would be a lumpectomy becomes a mastectomy in 3 months. Simple pinnings and orthopedics are turning into fusions because we waited.”
As for the human supply chain, Bennett says using high salaries alone to increase retention is not sustainable, nor is money all that people are seeking. Leaders need to start asking: For the people who stay at organizations full-time and forgo travel assignments, why do they stay put?
Organizations will need to figure out what non-monetary incentives works for them. Bennett thinks healthcare organizations need to reconsider the standard shift schedule of the past: three 8-hour shifts—day, afternoon, night—five days a week. The change to 12-hour shifts is relatively recent. “A lot of nurses don’t want that 12-hour day because maybe they can’t find a daycare or have some other family obligation,” Bennett says. “I tell my staff that I expect them to work hard while they’re here, but that they aren’t married to this place. If I don’t lean into that, I’ll lose them.”
Brian Dawson, MSN, RN, CNOR, CSSM, system VP of perioperative services at CommonSpirit Health, Chicago, Illinois, says that other than the struggle to find personal protective equipment (PPE) during the first months of the pandemic, unlike almost everywhere else, CommonSpirit has not had any supply chain issues. He credits this feat to CommonSpirit’s large size, robust supply chain, and buying power.
When the pandemic hit, he says the VP of infection prevention, supply chain representatives, and himself were “tied at the waist.”
“We have the fourth largest supply chain system in the country,” Dawson says. “Anything having to do with the OR, I have three people on it. We have others in contracting and supply chain that only focus on specialty services like orthopedics, neurosurgery, etc.”
Dawson also emphasizes communication and specialization. At his institution, there are people at the system level who focus only on perioperative—implementation specialists for supply chain at hospitals in each division—and a supply chain leader for each division.
“There’s a system, across our enterprise, of supply chain individuals who, when COVID hit, were all on the same sheet of music,” Dawson says.
Unfortunately, the free-standing city hospitals that are primarily Medicare- and Medicaid-focused will struggle unless they belong to a buying service, like Premier.
“They negotiate the best price for a conglomerate of hospitals, although CommonSpirit is so big we can sometimes get a better price than Premier,” Dawson says.
At El Camino Health, Mountain View, California, Kristin Varnes, MSN, BSN, RN, CNOR, interim clinical educator, says that sterile processing departments are encountering nation-wide supply shortages for basic items that enable them to process and sterilize trays for surgical and procedural cases. These shortages then lead to unexpected case-delays.
“We need to rethink how we support surgical procedures by coming up with creative methods to support cases in ways that do not compromise patient care,” Varnes says. “By partnering with physicians, administrators, department leadership, and staff, we can forecast any potential impact and devise a plan for minimal surgical case disruption.”
In addition, Varnes says that perioperative leaders need to have an ongoing conversation with supply chain players to ensure systems are in place that identify supply trends and have ongoing supply surveillance, consistent communication, and a response plan for mitigating potential issues.
Vicki Montei, BSN, RN, MMHC, CNOR, system director of surgical services at MyMichigan Health, Midland, Michigan, works closely with her team and vendors to identify items that will soon be on backorder and find alternatives for them. This is only possible with tight and consistent collaboration between vendors and their representatives; the clinical team; value analysis; the purchasing department; and supply chain personnel.
“Most of us have responsibilities across the system to make sure that we don’t have any care variation for our patients based on some of these backorders,” Montei says. “We’ve also been sharing a lot of product, moving them across different sister facility members, to make sure everybody has what they need when they need it.”
For staffing, Montei says they have been perfecting a process of sharing staff across their system.
“For example, one of our health system members has a lower volume right now, so we are sharing staff in that area to facilities that are a little bit busier, making sure that those patients get cared for, and the staff continues to get their hours,” Montei says. “We’ve created incentives for pick-up. They’ve created good systems for rotating mandatory overtime to keep it safe and not inequitable by any means. And the staff being a part of that process from the ground-up has been pivotal.”
Dan Burr, MSN, BSN, RN, CMSRN, supply chain and materials management director at MyMichigan Health, took this role six months ago. His background is unique in that he was an OR nurse, then nurse manager for many years before moving into the business side of healthcare, allowing him to connect with surgical services in a new capacity.
“It’s more important than ever to be extremely agile and listen to the internal customers within our health systems, and try to meet their needs and understand where they sit,” Burr says. “Anything that can work in the state of supply chain disruption is going to work in basically any scenario. So, I’m taking advantage of the opportunity we have in front of us to fortify our practices and come up with processes that will work in really any circumstance.”
Before the pandemic hit, typical supply chain practices allowed the market to recover at times. If there was disruption to a product, it would last 1 to 3 days. Items would come back in stock before departments went down to zero, so no action was needed to stay ahead of the curve.
“That same approach today will result in departments being left short-handed and needing to come up with workarounds just to provide basic care to patients,” Burr said. “We’ve had to scrutinize those items that are going short-stock or out of stock, identify where we place our resources, and find substitutions for the system.”
Another strategy that Burr says has been helpful is instituting virtual team huddles. Huddles increase staff feedback and communication and help improve management of clinical cases. Staff began attending these operationally critical huddles because information about product availability and sources of information on potential suppliers was required at a quicker pace than usual.
“We have a system-wide virtual huddle three times a week, for 15 minutes,” Burr says. “We take notes, then we send out an Excel sheet to everyone on the call so they all have access to the same information.” ORM
Wood E. Total joint cases on firm footing after OR team huddles. OR Manager. February 22, 2018.