Despite continued challenges ranging from declining reimbursements to finding qualified staff, most OR leaders (71%) are satisfied with their jobs, according to the 2017 annual OR Manager Salary/Career Survey. However, they are less inclined to view some parts of that job favorably.
Slightly more than half (55%) are satisfied with their total compensation, perhaps partly because 71% of them hadn’t received a raise in the past 12 months. When raises did come, they averaged a modest 3.07%, compared with 3.38% last year and 3.4% in 2015, but consistent with predicted nationwide raises of only 3% for 2017. These financial effects come at a time when OR leaders are seeing their scope widen. This year, they reported overseeing an average of 117.27 employees, up significantly from 95.4 last year and 94 in 2015. In addition, 43% reported increased surgical volume in the past 12 months, and only 23% saw a decrease.
Administrators can take some comfort in the fact that 71% of OR leaders plan to stay with their current employer until retirement. Only 4% said they intend to leave within a year—a much lower rate than the 34% reported for employees by Mercer.
However, the exit of expert leaders remains a concern. In all, 42% plan to retire in 2026 or later, and 17% plan to close the doors to the OR between 2018 and 2020. Responses to the 2016 survey found that 22% planned to retire between 2017 and 2020.
Other highlights from the 2017 survey include:
More than two-thirds (69%) of OR leaders earned an annual salary of $100,000 or more, comparable to 66% in 2016. OR leaders in the West earned the most; for example, 39% received $150,000 or more, compared with 18% in the Midwest and 17% in the Northeast and the South. No one in the South or West earned less than $60,000.
Most respondents (81%) earned $100,000 or more in total compensation, with 12% earning $200,000 or more. Again, those in the West earned the most, with 24% receiving $200,000 or more, compared with 13% in the Midwest, 11% in the Northeast, and 5% in the South.
Consistent with past surveys, OR leaders in teaching hospitals report higher salary and compensation figures than those in community settings. For instance, 80% of those in teaching hospitals reported an annual salary of $100,000 or more, compared to only 52% of those in community hospitals. However, 83% of those in teaching hospitals hadn’t received a raise in the past 12 months, compared with only 17% of their community hospital counterparts.
Also consistent with previous surveys were higher salary and compensation numbers for those in administrator or administrative director roles. Most (52%) earned $200,000 or more in total compensation.
The most common range for directors was $120,000 to $149,999 (26% of respondents) followed by $150,000 to $174,999 (22%).
For nurse managers, 36% reported earning $100,000 to $119,999, and 27% reported a range of $120,000 to $149,999.
Respondents oversee an average of 13.91 ORs and an average of 4.88 other departments, down slightly from the 5.71 reported in 2016.
Areas outside of the OR where more than half of OR leaders have responsibility are the postanesthesia care unit (68%), central sterile processing (56%), preoperative unit (54%), gastrointestinal/endoscopy (53%), and outpatient surgery (51%).
OR leaders oversee an average of 117.27 employees. That breaks down into 95.94 for clinical and 21.33 for nonclinical staff. In 2016, the averages were 79.05 for clinical and 16.37 for nonclinical staff.
Leaders in teaching hospitals oversee more employees than those in community hospitals. Only 38% of respondents reported having a business manager (see details on p 10).
When it comes to annual operating budget, 21% manage $10.0 million to $24.9 million, with another 21% managing a budget of less than $2.5 million. Only 13% manage an annual operating budget of $75 million or more.
Of the respondents, 23% manage an annual capital budget of $2.0 million to $4.9 million, with 20% reporting $1.0 million to $1.9 million and 19% reporting less than $250,000. In all, 28% reported an annual personnel budget of less than $1.0 million, with 20% reporting $2.0 million to $4.9 million.
The survey revealed several interesting perspectives on OR leaders.
OR leaders view patients’ satisfaction with OR services most favorably (83%), followed by their current job or position (71%), and staff engagement (65%). Job satisfaction in other fields tends to range from the low to mid 70s percentage points.
On the other end of the spectrum, only 52% of respondents had a favorable view of top leadership of the organization; 55% had a favorable outlook about their total compensation, with a 56% satisfaction level for physician engagement.
The two highest unfavorable ratings were for top leadership of the organization (21%) and total compensation (20%). OR leaders aren’t alone in their dissatisfaction with compensation. A Gallup poll found that only 41% of employees were satisfied with the amount of money they earned in 2016.
Differences in satisfaction emerged based on work setting. Two-thirds (66%) of respondents in teaching hospitals were satisfied with their current job or position, but that percentage jumped to 75% for those in community hospitals. On the other hand, 75% of those in teaching hospitals were satisfied with their benefits, compared with only 57% of those in community hospitals. (Interestingly, the latter percentage equals a Gallup poll that asked nongovernment workers if they were satisfied with their benefits.)
Satisfaction was also higher in community hospitals vs teaching hospitals in terms of patient satisfaction (84% vs 79%, respectively), staff engagement (67% vs 59%), and physician engagement (57% vs 50%).
Respondents in teaching hospitals had the edge when it came to satisfaction with top leaders of the organization (57% vs 50%) and support provided by their boss (65% vs 62%).
Respondents in both settings had the same level of satisfaction with total compensation.
Only 9% expect to leave their current position within 2 years, and another 10% plan to stay 3 to 5 years. The most common reason for leaving within 2 years was concern with management, as shown by comments such as “new upper management has not earned my respect,” “lack of administrative support,” and “concerns about upper management.”
When asked about retirement, 20% said they plan to retire between 2021 and 2023, and another 20% cited the years 2024 to 2026. Slightly under half (42%) said 2026 or later.
Demographics. Overall demographics are listed in the infographic at right. The average age of an OR leader (53.82 years) is higher than the 48.8 years for nurses reported in the 2015 National Nursing Workforce Survey.
That same survey noted that the most common age cohorts for nurse executives were 55 to 59 and 60 to 64, with each having 14.8% of respondents with that title. Most nurse managers fell into the cohorts of 55 to 59 (16.6%) or 50 to 54 (12.4%).
Nearly half (46%) of OR Manager survey respondents had earned a master’s as their highest degree; 31% had an MS or MSN, 9% had an MBA, and 6% had another master’s degree.
More than a third (38%) had a baccalaureate as their highest degree. Only five had a doctorate degree in nursing as their highest level of education, and only six reported a diploma.
OR leaders in teaching hospitals were more likely than their community counterparts to have a master’s degree (55% vs 33%).
Those who were administrators or administrative directors had the highest level of education (44% had an MS or MSN), followed by directors (34% had an MS or MSN) and nurse managers (24% had an MS or MSN).
More than half of respondents (59%) work in a community hospital, and 31% call a teaching hospital their work home. Most OR leaders are satisfied with their jobs, but significant areas of dissatisfaction exist, notably financial compensation. It remains to be seen whether overall job satisfaction will keep leaders at work, despite continued challenges such as declining reimbursements, or whether dissatisfaction with compensation will prompt them to change jobs, retire, or change professions. ✥
Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.