Perioperative staff complete a thorough orientation to ease their transition into a new job, but what about surgeons? How are they onboarded into a new OR? This isn’t an academic question—effective onboarding is key to the success, including financial success, of the OR.
“To have someone walk through the door ready to do surgery but not have what they need affects staff morale, patient care, scheduling, surgeon satisfaction, overall operations, and revenue,” says Jon Brickman, MS, CRCST, director of perioperative operations for University of Chicago Medicine (UCM) in Chicago. UCM developed an onboarding program that has helped integrate new surgeons into the team and launch expanded service lines.
Unfortunately, a negative first experience happens too often, says Michael Goldfarb, MD, FACS, a general surgeon in private practice in Long Branch, New Jersey, and chair of the Surgeon Workforce Subcommittee of the American College of Surgeons (ACS) Governors Surgical Care Delivery Workgroup. “I’ve seen what a terrible job many systems do with onboarding.”
Dr Goldfarb collaborated with the subcommittee to develop a checklist that can be used by employers and surgeons alike (sidebar below). “It’s particularly helpful for surgeons who are just starting their practice,” he says.
Dr Goldfarb and others say OR leaders are well positioned to make both new and experienced surgeons feel welcomed and productive from the first day in the OR by following a few key steps.
Too often, surgeon onboarding to the OR falls by the wayside because of time constraints, says Marie Paulson, MS, BSN, RN, CNOR, CSSM, CPPS, director of risk, patient safety, and accreditation, regulatory, and licensing for Kaiser Permanente San Rafael Medical Center in San Rafael, California. “Physicians are so involved in the privilege and credential processes that orientation either doesn’t get set up or the physician doesn’t take time to go through it.”
Well-intentioned OR leaders can also fail to meet with new surgeons, but it’s a mistake not to orient surgeons. “You should be putting the same diligence into onboarding of physicians that you do for staff,” Paulson says.
Onboarding should occur early on, notes Jennifer Schwartz, MSN, RN, CNOR, regional perioperative director for Kaiser Permanente Southern California. “It is critical for it to happen as soon as possible on the front end so we can prevent problems like scheduling issues,” she says.
Brickman adds that connecting with the surgeon early is easier because his or her clinical load is usually lighter then.
“We all come to a new job with certain expectations, and that’s true of physicians as well,” says Paulson. “They have an even greater challenge because they may go to different facilities, so there is a wide range of information they need to have and remember.”
Paulson is responsible for Kaiser’s system-level orientation for physicians. “They receive information and training on the electronic health record, consent process, lab standards, x-ray processing, and other areas,” she says. The system-level orientation lasts several days and is followed by regional-level orientation.
Ian O’Malley, MS, assistant director of strategic sourcing at UCM, recommends focusing on the goal of onboarding: “On day one, when the surgeon walks into the OR, you want the patient to get the best care and the surgeon to have a great experience in providing that care. The worst thing that can happen from a supply chain perspective is that the first case gets cancelled or delayed because devices aren’t available.”
Starting off on the right foot pays off down the road as well. “Because we’ve helped surgeons be successful, it makes for a smoother process downstream, like when we are doing capital budgeting,” Brickman says.
Dr Goldfarb recommends remembering basic courtesies. “They should be introduced to the people they are going to work with,” he says. That includes staff in the preoperative area, OR, and postanesthesia care unit.
At UCM, surgeon onboarding is a joint venture that includes perioperative services, the departmental service line, supply chain, and informatics (sidebar below). “Make sure you know who you need to partner with in your organization,” Brickman says. “Understand the recruitment process, so you know when it’s the right time for you to be notified.”
At UCM, the human resources department sends Brickman an email telling him the surgeon’s start date, which triggers a welcome email. “The email I send includes key processes and what the surgeon can expect during the first few months,” he says. “We also ask for a procedure list and preference cards, so we can check if we have the needed equipment.”
Any requests for new products that occur 45 days after the surgeon’s first case are considered part of the onboarding process; after that, requests go through the value analysis process.
Typically, surgeons do their first surgery within 45 days of their start date. Before the first case, surgeons meet with the project manager assigned to the onboarding process (an RN with certification in project management), representatives from supply chain and informatics, perioperative managers, and nurse team leaders, who are the surgeon’s main contacts. Sometimes scheduling staff attend this group meeting as well.
The meeting lasts about an hour. “It’s our discovery period,” O’Malley says. “We find out what they need and how those needs align with our contracts or standardized products to coordinate trials where needed.”
Surgeons are given a tour, and sometimes the sterile processing department will provide instrument trays for review.
Follow-up meetings occur as needed, for example, if the surgeon is part of establishing a new program, multiple meetings will be required, as when UCM was building a more robust program in oncology. “In that case, it’s not just what happens in surgery, it’s also what happens before and after surgery and on the unit,” Brickman says.
Ideally, OR leaders should meet with the surgeon before he or she is hired or brought onboard. “OR managers are very perceptive,” Dr Goldfarb says. “They know right away if the person is a good fit.”
Even if the leader wasn’t part of the selection process, Schwartz suggests a formal meeting with new surgeons to establish a good relationship from the start. “You can welcome them, answer their questions, and give information about initiatives such as an enhanced recovery after surgery program,” she says.
Other topics include how to request new equipment or products, how to schedule cases, cancellation policy, expectations of the surgical team, and metrics.
“They should see examples of what is tracked, such as on-time case starts, and reports, such as suite utilization,” Paulson says. “They need to know what data goes to the medical staff office or OR committees.”
Dr Goldfarb adds that surgeons need to know the overall perioperative workflow and the appropriate hospital committees. He recommends that OR leaders also learn:
• proctoring guidelines if a surgeon is doing a new procedure
• what procedures the surgeon has been credentialed for
• how often the surgeon plans to operate
• what type of staff the surgeon expects on his or her team.
OR leaders should be alert to potential practice differences when a physician is moving from another state. “The requirements for a history and physical in California aren’t necessarily the same as those in New York,” Paulson says. “Requirements for operative notes can also differ.”
Surgeons may be working with different equipment from what they are used to, so they should spend time with the specialty RN coordinator and the chief of the specialty to learn about departmental expectations, Paulson says.
“It’s really important for them to have something in writing,” Paulson says. Kaiser has a handbook with four major sections:
• surgical culture, which includes professionalism, safety expectations, a code of conduct, and the need to treat people with respect
• customers, which focuses on the patient and includes the use of AIDET for communication (acknowledge, introduce, duration, explanation, and thank you)
• quality, which includes information about pain management and core measurements
• patient and workplace safety, which covers protocols for marking the surgical site, conducting the preoperative time-out, ergonomics, and sharps safety.
Paulson adds that the handbook is tailored to the facility where the surgeon will be practicing because state requirements may vary.
Reviewing the ACS checklist with the surgeon is a proactive step that empowers OR leaders, Dr Goldfarb says. For example, if a surgeon complains that a piece of equipment isn’t available, the OR leader can note that the surgeon didn’t provide the requested list of items, so it will take time to obtain the equipment.
The OR director may also learn about any health accommodations the surgeon requires. “Having the list takes the emotion out of discussions,” he says.
Making the effort to correctly onboard surgeons pays off for an organization, including OR leaders. “It takes time to do this up front, but you’re going to save yourself time in the long run,” Paulson says. “The better oriented surgeons can be, the better partner they will be with you.”
O’Malley agrees: “It’s about establishing a long-term relationship.” ✥
Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.
Goldfarb M A. ACS surgeon workforce subcommittee develops onboarding checklist for surgeons. Bull Am Coll Surg. 2016;101(7):48-49.
Editor’s note: Jon Brickman and Ian O’Malley will discuss their onboarding process at the 2018 OR Business Management Conference, January 30-February 2 in San Antonio. To learn more about gaining efficiencies through optimal teamwork or to register for the conference, visit http://www.orbusinessmanagementconference.com/.