Since July, when repeal and replacement of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) stalled, healthcare reform has been somewhat overshadowed by events such as natural disasters and concerns about national security. Now, with insurers due to announce rates for the coming year, Congress is working on a bill to stabilize the individual insurance market. We can’t predict those rates, but we can reflect on emerging trends in healthcare payment and delivery of care.
An August 29 report from Health and Human Services’ Office of Inspector General (OIG) cites cost savings and improved quality of care associated with accountable care organizations (ACOs) participating in the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ (CMS) shared-savings program. Healthcare providers coordinate care to reduce costs and improve quality, as measured against 33 individual quality targets, and if they succeed, they keep a share of the savings generated for Medicare.
The OIG report found that, although not all ACOs reduced spending, the overall net reduction in spending across all ACOs over the first 3 years of the program was $1 billion.
In addition, the report notes that 82% of the ACOs improved quality of care and outperformed fee-for-service providers in 81% of the quality measures. ACOs also performed better than 90% of all fee-for-service providers on lowering hospital readmissions.
The comment period recently ended for the CMS proposal to pay for total knee and hip replacement procedures in outpatient settings. Many orthopedic surgeons and ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) applaud the proposal, but for hospital leaders, the prospect spells potentially large revenue losses.
More than 200 ASCs are now doing outpatient joint replacements, compared with just 25 centers 3 years ago, according to Steve Miller, chief operating officer of the Ambulatory Surgery Center Association. There’s no question that outpatient joint procedures are cost-effective: Proposed knee replacement reimbursements for 2018 are $12,380.78 for inpatients without complications vs $9,912.69 for outpatients. However, it’s also true that not all patients meet the criteria for outpatient surgery.
Currently, almost 800 hospitals in the US are participating in a mandatory Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement (CJR) program for total knees and hips that started in April 2016. By implementing bundled payment for an episode of care, the program aims to encourage hospitals, physicians, and post-acute care providers to work together to improve the quality and coordination of care from initial hospitalization through recovery.
However, in mid-July, CMS issued a proposed rule to cancel the episode payment models and the cardiac rehabilitation incentive payment model that was supposed to start January 1, 2018.
In addition, certain hospitals would have a one-time option to choose whether to continue participating in the CJR model, among other proposed changes (https://innovation.cms.gov/initiatives/cjr). The current 67 geographic mandatory participation areas would be cut from 67 to 34, and the 800 participating hospitals could drop to 470. Comments on the proposed rule are due by October 15, 2017.
The shift away from mandatory bundled payments, along with changes to the Merit-based Incentive Payment System reporting requirements for 2018, may be “just the beginning of a campaign to re-advantage independent practitioners at the expense of hospitals,” says Jeff Goldsmith in a recent Modern Healthcare guest commentary.
Goldsmith, national adviser at Navigant healthcare and associate professor of public health sciences at the University of Virginia, envisions opportunities for independent specialty physician groups to take certain procedures and services out of the hospital and into new short-stay surgical facilities, where they would be cheaper. Indeed, this is already happening at some microhospitals, which are being built in an increasing number of areas across the US (see OR Manager, July 2017, pp 28-29).
Such competition would make it more important than ever for hospitals to right-size physicians and staff and rein in costs. Alternatively, Goldsmith suggests, hospitals might consider entering into joint ventures with independent specialty groups.
Another implication of voluntary vs mandatory bundled payments is the loss of impact on healthcare delivery nationwide, according to Michael Thompson, president and chief executive officer of the National Alliance of Healthcare Purchaser Coalitions, a nonprofit organization based in Washington, DC.
Thompson sees Medicare’s move to back away from bundled payments as loss of support, but he doesn’t see it as the end of coordinated care. “Health plans will continue down that path, but they won’t have the same impact on changing the industry as we would see if everyone, including the biggest player in the market [Medicare], was doing the same thing,” Thompson says.
We don’t see the end of coordinated care, either. We’ve reported many times on improved outcomes and cost savings seen with perioperative surgical homes and enhanced recovery after surgery. Those care models and how to implement them were among the topics addressed at our Bundled Payment Bootcamp in June. The next one is October 23 in Dallas: www.ormanager.com/bundled-payments-bootcamp. It’s an important opportunity to get some guidance on the future of healthcare delivery and changes you should consider making.
Freeman G A. Health plans keep focus on value as HHS backs off bundling, payment reform. HealthLeaders Media. August 30, 2017.
Goldsmith J. Guest commentary: Tilting back toward independent medical practice and what it might mean for hospitals. Modern Healthcare. August 29, 2017.
Livingston S. Medicare shared-savings ACOs cut $1 billion in costs over three years. Modern Healthcare. August 29, 2017.
Meyer H. Hospitals leery of CMS proposal to pay for joint replacements in ASCs. Modern Healthcare. August 5, 2017.