April 19, 2024

Managing challenging employees: How to help

TAKEAWAYS

• Addressing an employee with a competency or behavior issue is important for the well-being of staff and managers.

• Determining the reason for the issue is an important first step to resolving it.

• Sources of support for managers include colleagues, human resources, and educators.


In today’s perioperative environment, every staff member is precious. Even for ORs not facing personnel shortages already, the loss of even one person could significantly burden the remaining staff. This situation makes dealing with challenging employees difficult. When is investing time in resolving the issue worthwhile? At what point should a leader let go—and let the employee go?

Barring egregious behavior such as stealing or drug diversion, interviews with several OR leaders and an HR expert indicate that these decisions can be complicated. Besides knowing when to terminate an employee, OR leaders must consider the reasons for problematic behavior, provide support, and otherwise manage personnel challenges. Is the problem a competency issue or a behavioral issue? Can it be corrected—and is the employee interested in correcting it? What is the best remedy? Where can a leader find support?

Finding the right answers is critical to the well-being of everyone in the OR, including the staff, the patients, and the managers asking the questions.

 

Responsibility to patients, staff, and self

Tammy Straub, MSN, RN, APRN, CNOR

People are at the heart of competency and behavioral personnel matters. Throughout the remediation process, “It is important to understand that the employee is a human being,” says Tammy Straub, MSN, RN, APRN, CNOR, administrator of perioperative services at Lehigh Valley Health Network in Allentown, Pennsylvania. “We want to work with and help them succeed, if possible.” Straub oversees ORs at 13 hospitals (including a level 1 trauma center) and three surgery centers.

That said, the well-being of the problem employee must be balanced with the well-being of the staff. “People want to work in an environment where they feel safe, confident, welcome, and that they’re in a team environment,” Straub says. “Keeping people who are not competent or not emotionally intelligent affects vacancy rate and turnover.”

Kathleen Ulrich, MS, BSN, RN, NEA-BC

The well-being of the staff also directly impacts the well-being of the patients, points out Kathleen Ulrich, MS, BSN, RN, NEA-BC, senior VP for perioperative services at Tampa General Hospital. For example, toxic employees can make other staff fearful to speak up, which in turn can jeopardize patient safety. “Employees need to have psychological safety, so they can share concerns,” she explains.

The responsibility to act can be stressful to an OR leader, but letting problems fester can feel even worse. “If you’re not holding people accountable, you lose your credibility as a leader,” Straub says.

Beth Bozzelli, MBA, RN, CNOR, CSSM

Holding employees accountable does not have to mean letting them go, which Ulrich calls “one of the most difficult things a leader has to do.” However, sometimes termination is the best outcome for the well-being of the rest of the team and the patients, even if it would leave the OR short-staffed. “In my experience, staff would rather work a little bit harder and a little bit longer if it means they get rid of a toxic person,” says Beth Bozzelli, MBA, RN, CNOR, CSSM, vice president, surgical services for Lifepoint Health in Brentwood, Tennessee, which runs a network of integrated care sites including more than 60 acute-care hospital campuses.

Part two of this article (the next cover story in this issue) sheds more light on how to part ways respectfully. However, managers should exhaust other options first. When faced with difficult decisions about remediation and discipline—including the worst decision—Ulrich has found that colleagues can provide much needed support. In some cases, they also provide solutions.

 

Support structures

For Ulrich, weekly leadership team meetings at Tampa General, an organ transplant center and level 1 trauma center, provide a forum for discussing matters such as employee disciplinary actions. Rather than focusing on a particular employee, the group shares approaches that worked well in the past and options to try in different situations. “We bounce ideas off each other and make sure that what we’re doing as leaders is consistent,” she says.

Shari Bowen, LTC, LG(DM)

Leadership development teams provide a source of support for Shari Bowen, LTC, LG(DM), assistant professor in the department of behavioral sciences and leadership at the United States Military Academy in West Point, New York. Discussion often turns to topics such as resilience and the pressure of decision making. “The other members of the team act as mentors for you,” she says.

Tyler Carpenter

HR can also act as strategic consultants for OR leaders, says Tyler Carpenter, vice president of people and talent at Tampa General Hospital. At his organization, HR staff partner with leaders to help them identify key performance indicators for their teams and proactively support performance by setting clear expectations for their roles aligned with the goals and values of the organization. HR staff provide information related to best practices and resources for leaders to support people management, helping leaders in making data-driven decisions and mitigating possible risks to the organization related to disciplinary action.

Looking inward and focusing on personal development can also help navigate difficult situations. “If we can grasp emotional intelligence, it will help us make better decisions,” Bowen says. “[Emotional intelligence] begins with my self-awareness as a leader.”

For example, the emotionally intelligent leader avoids making a hasty decision by setting aside their frustrations with the situation and recognizing the employee’s emotional state. “You can then better understand how your decision will affect the employee and the organization, then decide what is best for both,” Bowen says.

 

Finding the ‘why’

Denise Waslo

Among the first steps toward remedying problematic behavior is understanding the reasons for it. “If I don’t find the ‘why,’ I can’t do the next step where I coach, mentor, and motivate,” says Denise Waslo, associate executive director for perioperative services at Long Island Jewish Valley Stream in Valley Stream, New York.

Janet Duran, DNP, MSN, MHA, LNC, ST, RN

If the problem behavior is sudden and out of character, it may be due to external forces such as a family illness. In addition to a more empathetic approach, employee assistance programs can help. One example is courtesy of Janet Duran, DNP, MSN, MHA, LNC, ST, RN. As director of surgical services for Fisher-Titus Medical Center in Norwalk, Ohio, her scope of responsibility includes eight ORs, two endoscopy rooms, the postanesthesia care unit (PACU), a hospital outpatient department, and an ambulatory surgery center (ASC). When an experienced nurse turned in a specimen with the wrong patient name, she pointed out that she knew he was good at his job and asked what was going on. Fortunately, the employee was distressed at the error and sought help through the employee assistance program.

Overall, problems tend to fall into two camps: those related to behavioral issues and those related to competency issues. For behavioral issues, general points of advice from OR leaders include:

• Start simple. Simply stating what a leader has observed can prompt the employee to provide a reason for the problematic behavior, Duran says. For example, she might say, “It seems you are angry with every decision we’re making,” and in response, the employee shares the reasons why. In fact, many employees will correct themselves once they’re aware of a problem.

• Consider the possibility that the employee does not recognize a problem. Straub advises making room for self-reflection to help solve it. “If they are willing to move forward with improvement, then that’s somebody you invest in.” Phrases such as “Help me understand…” or “Can you share your thoughts on…” can help draw people out and reveal the extent of their self-awareness.

• Tackle toxic behavior promptly—“in real time,” as Bozzelli puts it. However, she also emphasizes the importance of objective data to outline specific examples of what needs to be improved. If the manager did not witness the problem behavior, consulting those who did could reveal useful insights.

• Recognize that behavioral issues could be rooted in frustration about insufficient growth or boredom with routine. In that case, Bozzelli says it may be helpful to give the employee a project to work on. “If they have potential and their competency is good, maybe they need to see what an asset to the organization they are,” she says.

• Identify any “rewards” motivating problematic behavior to understand the situation better, Waslo says. For example, a nurse who is unwilling to help coworkers with new equipment may relish the feeling of being considered an expert.

• Remind employees that their behavior can set an example for others, Ulrich recommends. She might say, “We need you to be a positive role model because new employees seeing this behavior are going to ask themselves if they want to work here if people are so negative.”

Competency issues may seem easier to diagnose and treat than behavioral issues, but there are always exceptions. Even the most experienced OR nurses can encounter difficulties upon joining a new organization, Straub says. Perhaps the nurse was enticed by the organization’s weekend program and interviewed well, but lacks the necessary skillset. Or a surgical technologist may have difficultly working in a level 1 trauma center as opposed to a community hospital setting. Additional training may be effective in resolving these situations.

General advice for competency issues includes:

• Extend orientation for nurses who are entirely new to the OR, Straub recommends, as long as lack of competency does not create a safety issue and the employee has the right attitude. “If they’re willing to learn and have that fire in their belly to continue, then we go the extra length and continue investing in that person,” she says.

• Consider the possibility that problems are rooted in a dysfunctional nurse-preceptor relationship, Ulrich says. For example, the preceptor’s teaching style may not match with the employee’s learning style. Resolving the issue might be a matter of encouraging discussion between the parties or even changing preceptors. She adds that having someone other than the preceptor to meet with informally also can be helpful for new employees.

• Moving a staff member to a less complicated service line can help them “really grow in their confidence,” Bozzelli says.

 

Counseling strategies

With the problem diagnosed, leaders should focus on providing constructive feedback and resources to help address it, Ulrich says. For example, a surgical technologist who is struggling to learn the names of instruments might benefit from spending time in the sterile processing department. Someone who is often perceived as confrontational may need to complete a class on conflict management. She suggests asking, “Do you see any barriers that we need to take away to make you successful?”

The onus for action is on the manager, but Bowen prefers to let the employee take responsibility as well. As she sees it, giving people resources helps empower them to change, Bowen adds. “You’ve put the onus on them.”

If there is not improvement, leaders must progress to formal counseling, then written warnings laying out steps toward remediation or termination. A performance improvement plan (PIP) should state what you expect to be corrected and when, Duran says. For example, by 30 days, the employee must be able to independently serve as a circulator for a general surgery robotic case.

Other tips for counseling challenging employees include:

• Meet weekly to discuss progress, and work with an HR partner to make sure goals are achievable, Ulrich says. Such steps can combat the common view that PIP is a sign that an employee is going to be fired. “At the end of the day, we want employees to succeed.”

• Develop the action plan together with the employee, Duran suggests. She and Bozzelli also emphasize closing the loop with employees by regularly checking in and being available to talk. “If you recognize progress, give them a pat on the back to let them know; if it’s not working, provide them with feedback so they know their progress isn’t where is needs to be.” Duran says.

• Standardize a process for managing challenging employees, and stick to it. “Whatever the process is, it’s got to be fair and consistently followed,” Bozzelli says.

• Continually emphasize expectations. Straub suggests saying something like, “These are our expectations. If there isn’t sustained improvement, then this isn’t the work environment for you.”

• “Document early and often,” Carpenter says. In addition to detailing what has occurred and what has been shared with the employee, follow-up with the employee to ensure the employee understands the expectations and how to meet them. Even a simple email can provide an opportunity to identify any resources necessary to succeed. Performance issues need not be the only focus, he adds; documentation also can be a tool for positive reinforcement and performance evaluation feedback.

 

Focusing on success

Working with challenging employees is often a gamble despite careful decision-making. However, success stories illustrate the rewards of a positive outcome. At Long Island Jewish Valley Stream, a robotic center of excellence with The Joint Commission’s Gold Seal of Approval for five orthopedic specialties, Waslo recalls moving an assistant manager with dayshift struggles to the evening shift. With fewer staff, the manager could concentrate on her strengths of overseeing preparations for next day. Rather than exploring other employment options, “She is very happy,” Waslo says, adding “OR flow is much better.”

Ultimately, leaders need to do what is best for staff and patients. “We want to retain employees, but we want to make sure those we are retaining are part of the team,” Ulrich says. “We’re all here for the same reason: to take care of patients and to keep our patients safe.”

 

—Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications

 

References

Boyette M. Salvage the employee before you fire an employee. Rapid Learning. 2009.

Knight R. How to decide whether to fire someone. Harv Bus Rev. 2019.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat