April 19, 2024

Managing challenging employees: When to let go

By: Cynthia Saver, MS, RN
Share

TAKEAWAYS

• HR should be involved early in the disciplinary process to help guide OR leaders’ decision-making throughout disciplinary and/or remediatoin processes.

• Timing, privacy, opportunities for employee feedback, and an empathetic approach are among the most important considerations for a final termination meeting.

• Whatever the process for communicating the change to the rest of the team, doing so promptly can help prevent rumors.


A key part of an OR leader’s responsibility is to help team members succeed. Leaders do that by setting expectations and providing support on a regular basis, particularly when an employee is not functioning effectively. However, a leader sometimes has no other option but to terminate a problem employee.

As detailed in the first part of this article (the previous cover story in this issue), employee competence and behavior problems cannot be left to fester. However, empathy is critical, even when the remediation strategies detailed in that article fail. Most employees are not prepared for this final stage even if they are aware of the problem. “You want to speak with them in a kind, respectful way,” says Tammy Straub, MSN, RN, APRN, CNOR. As administrator of perioperative services at Lehigh Valley Health Network, a 13-hospital system in Allentown, Pennsylvania, where she oversees ORs at 13 hospitals (including a level 1 trauma center) and three surgery centers, she takes care to recognize that an employee “is a human being. We’re affecting their livelihood.”

Other points of advice from OR leaders relate to the timing of the meeting, who needs to be there, and what needs to be documented. Additional considerations go beyond the nuts and bolts of the final meeting. Leaders must consider what to tell the rest of the staff as well as how and when to deliver the message. Throughout the process, HR personnel can be essential allies in adhering to the goals and policies of the broader organization—and in some cases, finding an alternative to complete separation.

 

HR support, OR initiative

HR should always be involved early in the process, well before the decision is made to terminate. At Tampa General Hospital, an organ transplant and level 1 trauma center, HR staff act as strategic consultants for OR leaders, says Tyler Carpenter, vice president of people and talent. For example, HR can help set key performance indicators for specific jobs, he says. Along with monthly check-ins, clearly defined expectations for a role ensure managers are backed by evidence when confronting problematic employees. Helping establish such expectations throughout an organization also can make HR ideally suited for evaluating a potential new beginning for a problem employee.

A bad fit for an OR does not necessarily equate to a bad fit for the organization. Although the employee is ultimately responsible for their own situation, life circumstances could make it impossible for them to meet expectations. If things don’t work out, “That doesn’t mean they’re not a good nurse, it just means it’s not the right fit for them,” says Beth Bozzelli, MBA, RN, CNOR, CSSM, vice president, surgical services for Lifepoint Health in Brentwood, Tennessee, which runs a diversified network of integrated care sites including more than 60 acute-care hospital campuses. “They might go to another department and be a rockstar.”

OR leaders need not rely entirely on help from HR in this matter. Denise Waslo, MSN, RN, CNOR, CSSM, is associate executive director for perioperative services at Long Island Jewish Valley Stream in Valley Stream, New York, a robotic center of excellence with The Joint Commission’s Gold Seal of Approval for five orthopedic specialties. She says she might offer to help find a better fit elsewhere in the industry, perhaps by assisting with the employee’s resume. This approach is particularly helpful for those in non-staff positions such as educators and managers, she says. In essence, these conversations provide the opportunity for the employee to make their own decision to leave.

In fact, Waslo makes that option explicit when it becomes clear that counseling, remediation, and performance improvement plan (PIP) strategies detailed in part 1 of this article are not working. “I don’t want you to terminate you, but I think you need to give your letter of resignation,” she tells the employee. This approach leaves the door open to finding a better fit elsewhere in the larger Northwell Health system.

 

The final meeting

Parting ways presents a difficult situation for both the employee and the manager. Handling the final meeting well can reduce stress and minimize the impact on the well-being of all involved. Even after deciding to part ways with an employee, Straub asks if there are any thoughts they want to share. “You want to be respectful and preserve their self-esteem and sense of pride as much as you can,” she says.

Experts also advise that formal termination conversations should be held in private and in a separate meeting, as opposed to a regularly planned check in (sidebar, Conducting a termination meeting). If possible, it is best to meet in a neutral location, such as a conference room, rather than the leader’s office.

Leaders should consider timing: earlier in the day is better than late afternoon. Author Minda Zetlin writes that Wednesday is the best day of the week for a termination meeting. This gives employees time to start their job hunt, and they can contact HR with questions. Terminating someone earlier in the week may leave employees feeling the organization was trying to squeeze an extra day or two of work out of them before letting them go.

Bozzelli notes that leaders should follow their organization’s HR policy regarding how the meeting is handled. For example, what paperwork is required? Does an HR representative need to be present? Some organizations require HR be in attendance, while others leave the decision to the leader’s discretion.

When HR will be present, Straub says it’s important they are on the same page as the leader. “You want to consistent in the message that’s going to the employee during the conversation,” she says. “You don’t want to be manipulated by the employee.” If a strong negative reaction is expected, HR support can be helpful.

At the start of the meeting, Bozzelli suggests saying something like, “We’ve had several conversations about this issue. It has not improved over the past 6 months. [She then provides objective examples to support this statement.] This continues to be an issue; it is time to part ways.”

Kathleen Ulrich, MS, BSN, RN, NEA-BC, senior VP for perioperative services at Tampa General, first reviews what has happened to date. Then she says something like, “In review of your performance, we have made the decision to terminate your employment as of today.”

Carpenter recommends leaders provide the reason for the termination and follow-up contact information if the employee has questions after the conversation. “It’s hard for the employee to hear they are being terminated, so they aren’t going to absorb a lot of information in the moment,” he says. Employees should receive a checklist and FAQs with information such as key contacts in HR, when they can expect to receive their final paycheck, contact information for key benefit vendors, and how to update their contact information to receive additional updates after they leave the organization.

Depending on the reason for the separation and the organization’s policy, the employee may need to be accompanied by someone while they gather their belongings and leave the building. If the leader has a safety concern related to how the employee may react, security can be an excellent resource. In a career spanning more than 30 years, Ulrich has only had one seriously negative employee reaction, which did not occur at her current organization. “If you have set up progressive discipline and the employee is getting feedback on how they are meeting expectations, people aren’t going to be surprised,” she says.

“Our philosophy is that no matter the situation, it’s important for the employee to understand the decision that led to their termination, to always be treated as a person, and to leave the organization with the same respect as when they joined it,” Carpenter says.

 

What to tell others

Some organizations communicate the separation by email, while others do not. Straub sends an email to notify staff, which typically includes verbiage such as: “It’s been a mutual decision to part ways. At this point in time, we wish [name] the best in their future endeavors.” She notes that she is available to answer questions if she can do so without violating the former employee’s privacy. It is important to send the email promptly to reduce rumors.

Waslo says managers at her organization share the news during huddles and leadership meetings, saying something like, “Mr. Jones has transitioned from their current role and is no longer in their position. I’m available for any further information.” She says staff members have never asked for additional information, likely because they have seen the issue first-hand and realize that there have been many attempts at resolving it.

Ulrich says she and other leaders communicate to team members that the employee is no longer part of the organization, but never share that an employee has been terminated. If someone asks specifically, Ulrich says, “We always say that it’s a private matter.”

Bozzelli lets staff know that the employee has “chosen to look at outside opportunities” and that the position will be posted. She notes how staffing will be handled in the meantime (for example, using PRN staff), and asks that any questions be directed to her.

Carpenter says it is a good idea to support team members by making rounds to see how they are doing. Leaders should also identify which stakeholders within the department or organization should be notified and communicate with team members the support that will be provided to them to ensure they are able to continue normal operations. How much support and notification are needed partially depends on the employee’s role within the organization, and on understanding the support needed from those team members who remain within the department.

Termination can have a positive effect on remaining staff. “Managing a difficult employee out of the facility shines a strong light on the value we have for our productive and competent staff who are here for the right reasons,” Waslo says.

At the end of the day, leaders need to realize that they have done what they could to help the employee succeed. “Leaders put their whole heart and soul into trying to make the employee successful, so not succeeding is a letdown,” Ulrich says. “I try to help managers understand that they did everything they could.” And in some cases, such as when the job or organization was not a good fit, the employee may go on to be successful in another situation.

—Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.

 

References

O’Donnell R. When (and how) to fire an employee: 7 signs it’s time to terminate. Trakstar Hire. nd.

Wolters Kluwer. Conducting a termination meeting. Expert Insights. January 5, 2021.

Zetlin M. This is the best day of the week to fire an employee, according to HR experts. Inc. May 29, 2019.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat