• Many tools for measuring productivity do not reflect the complexity of the perioperative setting.
• Multidisciplinary teams can help establish productivity metrics and tools.
• Productivity measures vary across the perioperative continuum.
For most perioperative leaders, discussions about productivity do not top the list of enjoyable parts of the job. For many, productivity is not even a topic area where they have much experience.
Yet perioperative leaders must frequently answer questions from those in senior leadership positions who consistently look to boost productivity as a means for achieving financial goals. Too often, the answers these leaders provide are not well received by senior leadership.
Brian Dawson, MSN, RN-BC, CNOR, CSSM, points to one main reason for the disconnect: “Perioperative services is not like any other nursing location, so there are no national benchmarks for productivity in OR areas.” Dawson, who is system vice president for perioperative services at CommonSpirit Health in Chicago, adds that given this gap, senior leadership frequently turn to consultants for advice on benchmarks, but that advice might not be valid. In many cases, consultants do not have evidence-based data to back up recommendations, yet organizations often accept them as fact.
In response to a question in the 2023 OR Manager Salary/Career Survey that asked about productivity measurement, many leaders agreed with Dawson about the uniqueness of the perioperative setting, noting that productivity tools and performance indicators often do not reflect the setting’s complexity. (For more comments, see Survey: Surgical volumes surge in midst of staffing woes, pp 1, 18–21.)
So how can perioperative leaders make productivity measurement work for them? This two-part series is designed to help perioperative leaders measure productivity effectively, analyze results, and communicate with the C-suite so that productivity can be a tool and not a burden. Part 1 focuses on the value of measuring, challenges, and making decisions about what should be assessed. Part 2 will discuss analysis of productivity data, the role of technology, and communicating results to key stakeholders, such as staff and top leadership.
Productivity measurement has value because it impacts an organization’s bottom line. “Accurate productivity measurement helps us have the right staff in the right place at the right time to take care of our patients,” says Lydia Casteel, MSN, RN, CCRN, director of nursing for surgical services at Wellstar Paulding Medical Center in Hiram, Georgia.
Measuring productivity has value, but it also comes with an array of challenges, starting with the difficulty of accurately reflecting the work conducted in the perioperative setting. For example, a common measure of productivity is the number of trays processed by the sterile processing department (SPD), but this measure fails to account for the complexity of each tray.
Another example is OR staffing. “In any active OR, you need a nurse and a surgical tech,” says Edna Gilliam, DNP, MBA, RN, CNOR, assistant vice president for perioperative services and SPD for Nemours Children’s Hospital in Wilmington, Delaware. “Regardless if that room is running 10 minutes or if it’s an add-on room, you have to have staff on standby for urgent or emergent cases.” Gilliam oversees the Delaware Valley region of the system, including the main hospital.
Other challenges include productivity measurement tools that are cumbersome to use. When data are pulled from the electronic health record (EHR), it may be inaccurate—the EHR might not have the capability to generate a useable report, and clinicians who complain about the length of time it takes to document in the EHR may take shortcuts and not provide complete information.
Finally, Gilliam says the nature of the perioperative area makes it challenging to “tell our story” to those in the C-suite. Part 2 explores ways to overcome this challenge.
Who decides what productivity measures should be followed? Many organizations use multidisciplinary committees. For instance, Casteel says measures are established each year at the system level of Wellstar Paulding as part of the budgeting process. To develop the measures, each hospital’s chief financial officer (CFO), along with system workforce analytics staff, review data from the system’s operational benchmarking tool and obtain input from nurse leaders in person and through a questionnaire.
Requested input includes information about staff responsibilities and overall composition (such as the number of anesthesia technicians and surgical technologists) and a list of other departments that receive perioperative services, such as the cardiac catheterization laboratory. “The process gives us the opportunity to share that we have a new service line we are adding, or that we expect a higher level of acuity,” Casteel says. “We can then incorporate our needs into the budget.”
Dusty Clegg, MS, RN, operations officer for the Canyons and Desert Regions of Intermountain Health (based in Utah), says the surgical operations leadership for the regions determines key performance indicators. The group comprises Clegg, the senior medical director, the anesthesia medical director, and the nurse executive director. “We give broad goals, which they [perioperative leaders] implement in their own organizations,” she says.
Gilliam says Nemours also uses a multidisciplinary approach. The perioperative operations committee, which consists of OR, physician, and anesthesia leadership, meets to establish annual goals and metrics for the perioperative department. An example is compliance with preoperative chlorhexidine gluconate bathing within a specified time frame, which is part of the bundle for preventing surgical site infections.
Those on a committee must contend with tools available to the organization. Jessica Gruendler, DNP, RN-BC, CPHQ, CNOR, senior director of nursing operations and perioperative services at Dignity Health in San Francisco, says productivity measures are partly driven by the metrics in the commercial software the organization uses. Metrics, which are related to volume and efficiency (such as first case on-time starts, block utilization, and turnover time), are sent to her and senior leadership.
Leaders must weigh several factors when choosing productivity measures. Selecting too many creates a burden on those responsible for analyzing the data and adjusting as needed.
In cases when manual data collection is necessary, care must be taken to not overburden staff. In addition, when patients are involved, Casteel says, “Some measure of acuity must be built into productivity so we can make it as accurate as possible.” That can be difficult because acuity tools are lacking for preoperative areas, although Casteel is able to access an acuity tool for postanesthesia care unit (PACU) patients though the EHR.
The most important consideration when choosing a productivity measure is why it is being measured—its impact on achieving overarching goals. “You have to decide why you have a metric,” Clegg says.
For example, many organizations measure first case on-time starts, but Clegg says this measure does not affect the bottom line unless delays are so long that reducing them allows the organization to add another case or reduce overtime, which is rarely the situation. That is not to say delays are not worth looking at. “If we take patients back to the OR 20 minutes later than when we said we would, we get complaints, so that’s a patient experience issue,” Clegg says. Therefore, if one of the 24 hospitals in the Canyons and Desert Regions of Intermountain Health falls below 60% for on-time starts, leaders at the facility are tasked with improving the metric.
When looking at improving on-time case starts, Clegg says the most value comes from examining cumulative tardiness over the course of a day, which incorporates the longer-term impact of on-time starts. For example, a surgeon who consistently schedules cases for shorter than they take will cause more and more delays as the day progresses. “In this case, reducing delays will save money and improve efficiency,” Clegg says.
Recently, the organization conducted a trial at a level 2 trauma hospital in Southern Utah; cumulative tardiness revealed that the OR was running late 64% of the time, with an average of 35 minutes per delay. Leaders used the average actual time related to scheduling several types of orthopedic cases (total hips, total shoulders, total knees, and unicompartmental knees) to improve accuracy with scheduled case time. The trial reduced delays in 50% of all cases, and the average amount of delay fell to 15 minutes. In fact, total hip cases went from 40 minutes late on average to 5 minutes late on average.
“Tracking what your average scheduled time is versus your actual time and then working with providers to help them understand that they’re scheduling an hour and a half for total hip, but their data show they take 2 hours helps get future cases scheduled correctly,” Clegg says.
Correct scheduling of procedures promotes downstream efficiency (eg, having appropriate PACU staff) and reduces bottlenecks in the preoperative area. Accurate scheduling “also helps make the end of the day more consistent so there is less call utilization and asking caregivers to stay late, which means less premium pay,” Clegg says.
Productivity measures include those specific to the process of the work setting (such as the OR vs SPD), those related to patients (such as patient satisfaction), and those related to staff (sidebar, Productivity and staff). Here is a closer look at variations in work settings across the perioperative continuum.
Measures of productivity related to staff typically include turnover and onboarding time. However, Edna Gilliam, DNP, MBA, RN, CNOR, assistant vice president for perioperative services and sterile processing department (SPD) for Nemours Children’s Hospital in Wilmington, Delaware, and Jodie Lockwood, MSN, RN, CNOR, perioperative nurse manager at Nemours Children’s Hospital, consider another aspect—effective utilization of each staff member’s role. For example, nurses in the preoperative area, rather than OR nurses, update families about surgery. PACU nurses focus on direct care of patients, while support staff clean PACU bays between patients.
“Each role is utilized to the fullest,” Lockwood says. “We view ourselves as one unit caring for the patient perioperatively.” Ensuring staff focus on their areas of expertise improves outcomes and efficiencies.
Jessica Gruendler, DNP, RN-BC, CPHQ, CNOR, senior director of nursing operations and perioperative services at Dignity Health in San Francisco, adds that perioperative leaders also must consider tasks that staff perform but are not usually included in productivity measures. Examples of these in the OR include morning huddles, room set up for the first case of the day, preference card updates, stocking rooms at the end of the day, and checking for expired supplies. These can add up to significant amounts of time: a 15-minute huddle and 30-minute first case room set up results in 45 minutes for each staff member that is not accounted for in minutes of service or volume of cases. “It’s unrealistic to try to quantify these tasks, but leaders should at least be aware of their impact,” Gruendler says.
Productivity measures should consider how to account for staff who do not deliver direct patient care. Brian Dawson, MSN, RN-BC, CNOR, CSSM, notes that the OR has several non-direct care staff, many of whom are not found in other hospital areas, such as schedulers, perioperative educators, specialty nurse coordinators, and charge nurses who run the schedule. Other non-clinical staff associated with the perioperative setting include environmental services personnel, directors, and nurse and business managers.
“If I take all those people who don’t touch patients and put them into the mix with the people who touch patients, I’ll never get to my productivity goals,” says Dawson, who is system vice president for perioperative services at CommonSpirit Health in Chicago. Yet all these staff are important. For example, no matter what the volume of cases in the OR on a particular day, schedulers are needed to schedule future ones. To address nonclinical staff, Dawson says, “I take those people out of the mix, and they become fixed labor.”
Dawson adds that determining the number of fixed labor staff needed should be based on the number of ORs and the number of cases per day. Finding the right number is something that OR leaders can use their expertise to determine. In addition, leaders can set standards, such as have a supervisor responsible for X number of employees. “If you don’t account for fixed labor, you will always run in the red (for productivity) and you will be short of the people you need to take care of patients,” Dawson says.
Lydia Casteel, MSN, RN, CCRN, director of nursing for surgical services at Wellstar Paulding Medical Center in Hiram, Georgia, agrees that productivity needs to be based on clinical staff. “We have a separate administrative department for (nonclinical) staff such as schedulers and data specialists,” she says. “Those non-variable staff are essential to keep ORs and PACUs highly productive but should not be counted with clinical staff.”
Preadmissions testing.“Preadmission testing (PAT) is often overlooked in productivity models,” Gruendler says, adding that an efficient PAT phone call takes an average of 45 minutes and longer for patients older than 60 years, who often have multiple medications and complex medical histories.
Rather than having nurses in the preoperative area make those calls, Gruendler set up a separate call center at Dignity Health, which improves efficiency. “If preadmission testing is functioning well, you can bring patients in an hour instead of 2 hours ahead and improve preoperative productivity,” she says. Dignity Health uses the number of patient encounters for the day as the productivity measure for this area.
Preoperative area. This area can be viewed as a clinic, so when determining productivity, Dawson and Gruendler look at the number of nurse-patient encounters and how many nurses are needed to manage those encounters. Timing is an important factor, with more staff needed early in the day to prepare patients for surgery, but fewer needed later in the shift.
Dawson says that although some staff can make preoperative and postoperative patient calls during the slower time, staff are also cross trained in the PACU, so they can work in that area as needed. At Wellstar Paulding, Casteel uses 2.3 hours of service needed per patient hour in the preoperative area.
Some hospitals are experimenting with different types of metrics in this area. For example, Clegg says Intermountain Health is starting to look at the time the patient arrives at the hospital, the time the patient is ready for surgery, and the time the patient is transported to the OR. “We want to manage the time to avoid bottlenecks but have enough time to safely prepare the patient for surgery, ” Clegg says.
Operating room. Dawson at CommonSpirit recommends minutes of service—how many minutes the patient is in the OR, from wheels in to wheels out—as the best tool for measuring productivity in the OR (sidebar, Productivity calculation). He adds that when managers and assistant managers regularly help with breaks and lunches (a practice more common in ORs of five rooms or less), fewer staff will be needed for these activities.
Brian Dawson, MSN, RN-BC, CNOR, CSSM, system vice president for perioperative services at CommonSpirit Health in Chicago, uses the following steps to calculate productivity for OR clinical staff based on minutes of service.
➊ Add up the minutes for the scheduled daytime shift (eg, one 7 am to 4 pm shift would be 540 minutes).
➋ Add in the minutes for after hours and weekend shifts.
➌ Add up the hours worked by nurses and surgical technologists.
➍ Divide the hours by the total minutes from steps 1 and 2 to determine productivity.
This gives you the number of full-time staff needed for 1 hour of service (usually.25 or.35). The next step is to determine how many staff are needed to cover lunches and breaks during the shift. For example, one nurse and one surgical technologist are needed to cover a 15-minute break in the morning. If there are 10 ORs, that means 1 hour.
Dawson says leaders need to consider what activities staff can do after providing coverage. One option is to bring the staff in later in the day, so they can be assigned to an OR at 4 PM, thereby creating a swing shift.
Many ORs also measure factors such as turnover time, first case on-time starts, cancellation rates, block time utilization, and delays (surgeons and patients)—all of which impact minutes of service. Casteel finds block utilization particularly helpful for building the staffing model in the preoperative, OR, and PACU areas. “You can look at what services you are offering on what days for how many hours for each surgeon,” she says. Block scheduling was the most common productivity measure mentioned in the OR Manager Survey.
At Intermountain Health, Clegg considers an average turnover time of 25 minutes to be a good target, with select specialties slightly higher or lower. “I don’t want turnover time to be too fast because that’s dangerous,” she says. Perioperative leaders can compare their metrics such as turnover time with other, similar hospitals in the system.
PACU. Dawson says the minutes of service approach used in the OR also applies to PACU. A challenge unique to PACU are extended stays for patients who are no longer Phase 1 but must remain in the PACU because no unit bed is available. “You need to look at the acuity level of those patients,” Dawson notes. If patients would have been transferred to a medical/surgical unit, the ratio can be one nurse to four to five patients. “You have to account for the time in extended stay,” he says.
Jodie Lockwood, MSN, RN, CNOR, perioperative nurse manager at Nemours Children’s Hospital, uses the average time a patient is in the PACU (from entry into Phase 1 to exit out of Phase 2) as a baseline measure. She compares this to an EHR data report that lists each patient (including procedures performed) that each nurse cared for, so individual productivity can be evaluated in the context of acuity. “Drilling down to individual nurse data allows us to benchmark mean times and identify outliers,” Lockwood says. “It also helps us identify nurses who do things really well, so they can be champions and help staff who may have challenges.”
Measuring PACU length of stay helped the hospital reduce it by almost 10% in the past year by implementing various strategies, such as improving the communication of discharge readiness from nurses to physicians. For example, nurses now use a timestamp to notify anesthesia when a patient is ready to be moved from Phase 1; the timestamp is visible on a status board in the OR. In addition, rounding by patient-flow supervisors (and later charge nurses, who were trained for the task) helps promptly identify a patient who is ready for a change in discharge status.
Gruendler says Dignity Health has found the number of patient encounters per day in the PACU to be a helpful productivity measure. Casteel at Wellstar Paulding uses the figure of 3.7 hours of service per patient hour, depending on acuity. PACU nurses document acuity via a scale in the EHR. Managers can share this information with the CFO to support variances. The 3.7 figure encompasses not only nurses, but others involved in caring for the patient, including transporters and nursing assistants.
Linking OR volume to PACU care is a productivity measure that can help with staffing. Gilliam says Nemours added an additional OR for ENT surgery to manage increased post-pandemic volume. By tracking timing through the process, she was able to justify additional full-time employees for the PACU.
SPD. Dawson says that minutes of service does not work for the SPD as a productivity measure because the length of time it takes to process instruments varies considerably among cases. In addition, the complexity of instrument processing is why counting number of trays processed also does not work. Instead, Dawson uses AAMI’s four levels of complexity related to what SPD staff members do. Each level has an associated time, and the levels include ancillary tasks such as setting up case carts.
Tracking these tasks would be burdensome for staff, which is where an instrument tracking system comes in. Staff scan a bar code on an instrument set when starting cleaning and when finished cleaning. The time can be linked to a level of complexity. “Now I can right-size SPD staffing,” Dawson says. That includes determining if a regular night shift or weekend shift is needed, or if having staff on call is a better option.
Clegg at Intermountain Health says another measure of productivity—and patient safety—relates to immediate use sterilization (IUSS). At one point, some OR sites had levels as high as 30%. One facility identified that the cataract instrument set had the highest IUSS rate; increasing the number of sets decreased the rate significantly. The SPD and OR leadership teams at each facility now meet monthly to review the IUSS rate and determine what instruments need to be purchased to reduce the rate. Currently, the rate for hospitals in the Canyons and Desert regions is less than 2%.
The plan for next year is to reduce the size of instrument sets. “About 30% to 60% of instruments in a set aren’t used, but they get processed over and over again,” Clegg says. Reducing the number could have a significant impact on productivity.
Gilliam adds that it is important to not only consider the support SPD provides the OR, but also the support provided to the entire organization, including, for example, endoscopes processed for various clinics.
Productivity measurement directly relates to asset management. “Ask how well you are managing the assets of the various departments,” Clegg says. In addition to answering that question, perioperative leaders must be able to analyze productivity reports and communicate key findings to staff and senior leaders. Part 2 focuses on these two areas and discusses how productivity measurement can be a tool for perioperative leaders to obtain needed resources.
—Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.