March 5, 2025

Mentorship keeps newer nurses from scrubbing out

Starting a new job can be stressful for anyone, but nursing comes with a particular set of pressures. A 2024 survey of 6,000 nurses from the American Nurses Association (ANA), in partnership with McKinsey and Company, found that an astonishing 45% of early-tenure nurses reported they were somewhat likely to leave their roles in the next 6 months.

Cheryl Peterson, MSN, RN

“Nurses are caring for human beings,” says Cheryl Peterson, MSN, RN, senior vice president of nursing programs at ANA. “The room for error is really small, and that’s really scary.”

Working in the OR can amplify the pressure, and not just because of the high stakes. With widespread lack of viable, cost-effective pathways into perioperative services, a young nurse’s first exposure to this inherently stressful environment is often not in school, but on the job.

However, aspiring perioperative nurses have reason for optimism, as do their counterparts pursuing other specialties. Whatever direction a nurse’s career takes, the survey results show that a good mentor can make the difference between staying or calling it quits. Opportunities for expanding and investing in mentorship are becoming more diverse, ranging from new technology to advancing legislation.

To whatever extent healthcare organizations take advantage of these opportunities, the benefits of expanding mentorship are clear. “You don’t always know what you’re going to encounter early on as a nurse,” says

Adriane K. Griffen, MPH, DrPH, who oversees the ANA’s programmatic portfolio. “Sometimes, you’re eased into it. Other times, you’re thrown into the deep end. Early -tenure nurses are looking for more stability.”

 

Building stronger teams

Adriane K. Griffen, MPH, DrPH

More than 80% of new nurses indicated in the ANA survey that they consider mid- and most-tenured nurses to be “great resources to learn from.”

Focused on generational differences and similarities, the survey found that mentoring both improved work conditions and helped support career goals of millennial nurse mentees. Notably, the survey also showed benefits for the mentors. More experienced nurses reported becoming energized and hopeful when supporting their younger colleagues—provided there are the necessary institutional support structures in place.

“One of the strengths of the current nursing workforce is that we have multiple generations working shoulder to shoulder,” Griffen says. “Nurses want to learn from experienced colleagues. And older nurses feel energized and fulfilled by mentorship—they enjoy teaching. It’s a high stress environment—anything we can do to build joy in work and enliven the work environment is key.”

The ANA survey found that more than 75% of both mid-tenure and most-tenured nurses enjoyed working with less experienced peers—that it made them feel hopeful, and respected.

Another study from 2024 looking at Millennial nurses found that the most meaningful attributes of successful mentors were not professional accomplishments, but interpersonal skills such as understanding, empathy, and open communication. The study authors write: “They learned through their mentors by using them as milestones, found the meaningfulness of nursing, and felt proud of their nursing jobs. Through this process, the participants felt that they could comprehend the essence of nursing anew and that they could find their own care philosophy.”

In addition to connecting nurses across generations, mentorship can help bolster a more diverse workforce that is better equipped to meet the needs of specific patient populations. This was the driving force behind the ANA’s Minority Fellowship Program, which provides federal grants to increase the numbers of PhD-ready nurses, psychiatrists, psychologists, social workers, and therapists from underrepresented minority groups. Mentorship is one of many tools employed to nurture individuals who have the interest and potential to pursue these careers.

Peterson, who leads the program at the ANA, says fellows who participate as mentees in the virtual program often later support it as mentors. “As they move into alumni, they want to support it as mentors because they know the benefit they received,” she says. “It’s fulfilling to be in that relationship.”

 

Cultivating new leaders

In addition to smoothing the transition into the profession, nurse mentors play a key role in helping their early-career peers advance in leadership—a key concern for perioperative services.

One example of nurse leader mentoring in action comes courtesy of the Organization of Nurse Leaders in New Jersey (ONL NJ). The organization first instituted a mentorship program in 2010, and is now approaching its eighth cohort. Each cohort begins with an educational seminar on goals, objectives and best practices, and ends with a networking session in which potential mentors and mentees can indicate with whom they would like to work. This isn’t so much about helping to acclimate nurses to the profession, but rather helps to guide those who are new to leadership roles.

Susan Cholewka, MBA, executive director of ONL NJ

Since the program was instituted, ONL NJ has completed a number of related research studies, and the findings are clear: Mentorship opportunities pairing staff nurses with nurse managers, supervisors, directors, and chief nursing officers provide mentees with a valuable professional sounding board, help them to develop confidence, and give them courage to take professional steps—or reject offers that are not a fit.

“Whether nurses are looking for advancement, leadership opportunities, conflict resolution, or financial advice, mentorship really breaks down competition and barriers and levels the playing field,” says Susan Cholewka, MBA, executive director of ONL NJ.

Cornelia Gilpin, DNP, NEA-BC, CCSS

Cornelia Gilpin, DNP, NEA-BC, CCSS, who has served as a mentor in ONL NJ’s program, says newer nurse leaders can benefit from navigating challenges and making career decisions with advice from someone they trust. “Speaking to someone who is at a different stage in her career helps you narrow the scope,” she says. “There’s that flight of ideas—lots I want to accomplish. A mentor is like a ‘sage on the side’ to help you to refocus.”

Mary Rich, BSN, MSN, DNP

An online toolkit available for purchase brings the benefits of ONL NJ’s year-long mentorship program to a broader population (the guide is free for members). “We copyrighted some of the best practices,” says Mary Rich, BSN, MSN, DNP, adjunct nursing faculty at the College of St. Elizabeth in New Jersey. “It’s a really succinct and comprehensive guide for the mentor and mentee to navigate that relationship.” The toolkit helps them to set expectations, and provides benchmarks for meeting short-term goals and a sense of how they are progressing, she adds. And due to the success of the program, Rich says they have presented nationally, including at the American Association of Colleges of Nursing conference.

 

Bridging OR knowledge gaps

Lack of perioperative content in standard education curricula is a well-documented challenge in recruiting and acclimating new nurses to the field. As long as nursing programs provide limited or no exposure, preceptors will be critical to easing the transition from academia to the OR.

These experienced veterans serve as educators to early-career nurses, guide clinical decision-making in hospitals, and play a crucial role in helping new graduates transition and thrive. For a new perioperative nurse, a preceptor is likely to be the primary source of both theoretical knowledge and practical skills, ranging from sterile technique to handling complex equipment to anticipating surgeon needs in the midst of high-stress procedures.

Additionally, regular interaction with preceptors has been shown to significantly reduce stress among novice nurses and to enhance both satisfaction and retention rates. “We all need someone we can talk to,” said Peterson, who is responsible for guiding ANA’s Department of Nursing Practice and Work Environment, the Center for Ethics and Human Rights, and the Minority Fellowship Program. “If I need somebody to talk to about a patient, or a situation with a peer, or where I want to go as a professional, all of that is infinitely clearer when I have someone I can trust to have that discussion.”

However, serving as a preceptor also means additional workload and extensive training—often at a nurse’s own expense. Bipartisan legislation introduced in January 2025 called the PRECEPT Nurses Act would provide a $2,000 tax credit for nurses who serve as a clinical preceptor to nursing students, ensuring more nursing students can receive clinical training and enter the workforce—helping to combat shortages and burnout. “This legislation paves the way to increase patients’ access to care through the development of a growing pipeline for nurses, including CRNAs,” says American Association of Nurse Anesthesiology (AANA) President Janet Setnor, MSN, CRNA, Col. (Ret), USAFR, NC, in a related release.


5 steps to create an in-house nurse mentorship program

Although regional, national, and virtual nurse mentorship programs can be valuable resources, hospitals and health organizations can also benefit from setting up their own. With an in-house program, mentors and mentees have a shared experience, common resources, and greater opportunity for in-person meetings. Here are five evidence-informed steps for setting up a new program:

❶ Establish a task force with both experienced nurse leaders and new graduates to establish the details, which include:

    • a plan for the mentor-mentee matching system
    • program length and curriculum
    • benchmarks for measuring progress
    • reporting process and follow-up items.

❷ Set program goals reflecting outcomes that will benefit the organization and participants. These might include:

    • reduced turnover
    • identifying potential nurse leaders
    • improved patient outcomes
    • added skillsets and experience.

❸ Create a system for matching. Successful mentorship programs rely on mutually beneficial matches between mentor and mentee. Factors to consider include:

    • career level
    • specialty
    • professional challenges.

❹ Launch the program. As the mentors and mentees begin working toward their goals, they should collect data related to their progress and milestones. Nurse leadership, meanwhile, should provide opportunities for feedback to assess the success of the pairings.

❺ Measure the program’s success. Pulling together the collected data from the first program, nurse leaders can determine where the program is working and where they need to improve. Areas to measure can include:

    • extent of nurse call-outs
    • level of mentor-mentee participation
    • educational course attendance
    • adverse event rates among patient populations.

Reference

Cortney M, Wagenberg C, Loney E, et al. Creating and Implementing a Nurse Mentoring Program: A Team Approach. The Journal of Nursing Administration. June 2020.


Connecting virtually

With the latest technology, a preceptor or other mentor need not necessarily be on-site. Virtual nursing is already being widely implemented to help hospitals cover the gaps in their nursing workforce. As of 2024, 46% of hospital leaders were trying out or had already instituted virtual nursing—and 74% of hospital leaders see virtual nursing as an integral part of how care is provided moving forward. This includes “virtual sitting” (watching over patients with video and audio tools), but it can often extend into support for clinical decision-making, documentation, and even nurse mentorship as well.

With technology tools offered by companies like LookDeep, virtual nurses can provide real-time expertise to more novice nurses. A virtual nurse acts as a mentor supporting bedside staff, the company notes on its website. The virtual nurse can provide experienced input, support specific procedures, and serve as a “more senior colleague who is always available”—provided that video technology is available “quickly, easily, and everywhere in the hospital.”

To make mentorship more broadly accessible, there are also a number of virtual mentorship programs available to nurses looking for professional and personal guidance. This includes the ANA’s Virtual Mentorship program, founded in 2015. The program has evolved in response to surveys. Cohorts now meet over the course of 8 months, and there are weekly discussions hosted by community leaders, webinars for mentors and mentees, and additional online resources.

While there are advantages to face-to-face interactions, Peterson says virtual connection opens up additional avenues for mentorship and “a relationship can still be built—particularly if there’s a strong match.”

Whether in-person or virtual, nurse mentorship programs require support at the institutional level to succeed, she says. At larger institutions hiring thousands of nurses, establishing a nurse mentorship program is a major undertaking. “The C-suite has to buy in—they have to say, ‘This is important and we have to invest in it.’”

And that buy-in has to extend to leadership at all levels, adds Griffen. “Not just the chief nursing officer, but the unit nurse and the floor nurse.”

Ultimately, the nursing code of ethics “calls on us to support each other,” Peterson says. “None of us functions alone, and we all need support.”

 

—Brita Belli is an award-winning writer and PR professional with published stories in The New York Times, National Geographic, MSN.com, and Alternet.

 

References

American Nurses Foundation. New Survey: Different Career Stages in Nursing Mutually Agree Mentorship is Beneficial. March 28, 2024.

How Virtual Nursing Solutions Empower Patient Care. LookDeep. Accessed January 2025.

Jung S, Kim J. The experience of good mentoring focused on overcoming turnover intention among millennial nurses. Frontiers in Medicine. February 6, 2024.

Mentoring across the nursing profession: Lessons from the ANA. Wolters Kluwer. August 19, 2020.

Minority Fellowship Program. American Nurses Association.

Over one-third of Americans live in areas lacking mental health professionals. USAFacts. July 14, 2021.

Siwicki B. 74% of hospital leaders say virtual nursing will become integral to acute care. Healthcare IT News. December 10, 2024.

The Code of Ethics for Nurses with Interpretive Statements. American Nurses Association.

Wurmser T, Kowalski M O. The Gift of Mentorship A Qualitative Study of a Statewide Mentoring Program. Organization of Nurse Leaders NJ.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat