Every day, I come across postings in the media suggesting that nurses are struggling with burnout. These accusations are tone deaf and misleading. In addition to my private coaching practice, I am the professional internal coach for a trauma center in the Greater New York area and several professional nursing organizations. These roles afford me the opportunities to listen to RNs across the country. Reflections on burnout are not what I am hearing from those I coach or interact with at conferences. When I ask what insights these RNs gained from their COVID-19 experience, the majority share that they now know they are stronger than they ever thought they could be.
This is the language of growth, not burnout. If our administrative and nursing leaders do not understand—if they do not appreciate and support their staff’s new sense of confidence and empowerment—they risk poor engagement and the loss of clinical and managerial talent.
In short, leading those experiencing what positive psychologists term “post-event growth” is the newest leadership challenge.
Post-event growth is a psychological term for positive change that can occur after a difficult or traumatic event. It can be achieved deliberately by leaning into bootcamp moments: Life’s way of offering opportunities to discover where you are strong and where you still need to develop your character. Bootcamp moments arise when what you wanted to happen didn’t, and when what you did not want to happen did. In other words, these events can test your limits and can trigger a sense of disappointment, betrayal, confusion, and anger.
Bootcamp moments humble you. They make you exquisitely aware of how hard it is to be an adult in the 21st century, let alone a healthcare professional or leader. Bootcamp moments provoke you into questioning your competence or worth. These introspective occasions bring you face to face with loss and the challenge of navigating the grief of that loss. It is a process akin to chewing on glass.
Leaning into the teachings of a bootcamp moment is optional. You can choose to take an incomplete grade in this real-life class. Still, if you dig deep and find the personal courage to lean in and process all that bubbles up, the return on your investment is life changing, and there is no going back. Successfully navigating a life event that challenged you in body, mind, and spirit remodels you in ways that may take months to discover. You are undeniably different, and things you may have tolerated before are now impossible to ignore.
Staff experiencing post-event growth begin to confront this discontent, start to simmer, and then engage in resignation ideations. While most are not considering leaving their profession, they are more than ready to try alternative employment venues and opportunities to practice differently.
For many leaders, supporting those experiencing post-event growth remains a significant blind spot. Pre-COVID, progress in adopting a more humanistic approach to leadership was ongoing. However, managing the pandemic mandated a full-on transactional leadership approach in order to appropriately respond, in real time, to something not only unknown but deadly. As 2020 and 2021 ticked by and the threat lessened, administration began to signal a desire to return to normal operations. While this desire was well intended, many organizations demonstrated a blind spot toward the sentiments and growth of their staff. The media began to report on something coined, The Great Resignation.
As nurses across the country shared their post-pandemic plans with me, the option of choosing travel nursing was a frequent topic of conversation. Ninety-nine percent of those I spoke with were physically spent but nonetheless energized by new possibilities.
Those who opted for travel nursing fell into three categories. The first were those who practiced less than 6 years, were not in committed relationships, and wanted to see the country before it shut down again. The second group were disillusioned by the perceived lack of support from administration during the pandemic and no longer wanted to be affiliated with an organization they felt abandoned them. They wanted to shop for an organization that supported their new sense of self.
The motivation of the third group is very unreported. While nurses were working very long hours during COVID-19, many of their significant others were furloughed, let go, or lost family businesses. They found it necessary to tap into college or retirement funds in order to make ends meet. When the opportunity to make more money than they ever dreamed of presented itself, they felt an obligation to their family to take advantage of that offer for as long as they could in order to replenish their savings.
Those who resigned but did not opt for travel opportunities explored unconventional ways to practice. Some were successful in their search, while others slowly found their way back to traditional settings. It was disappointing to hear many leaders respond sarcastically to their return. I hoped that curiosity would override their tendency to judge. These leaders may now be able to fill their empty staffing lines, but they risk huge dips in their engagement scores if the lack of a warm welcome reinforces the notion that things are going back to the way things were pre-COVID.
If there was ever a time for leaders and administrators to challenge their allegiance to top-down approaches and embrace a future of true inclusivity and shared governance, that time is now. Organizations have an opportunity to capitalize on the gift of having an interprofessional staff experiencing the sense of increased competence and confidence that is the byproduct of post-event growth. This is nothing to fear. Rather, it is something to embrace with both arms.
Embracing this opportunity is not easy. It does require those at the top of their departments and organizations to recognize this growth and level up their command of humanistic leadership skills. If this opportunity slips through their fingers, they could be facing years of unrelenting issues with recruitment and retention of talented clinicians and managers. Consider the following suggestions:
• Be open to and embrace changing perspectives. Be alert. Staff may experience a shift in priorities and expectations after transformative events. Bootcamp moments could have led them to reevaluate their work-life balance, career goals, and values. Leaders should recognize these shifts and stay open to creative ways of accommodating them.
• Invest in development. Support staff’s desire to test their professional boundaries. Providing opportunities for continuing education, mentoring, and leadership training can send a powerful signal that they are seen, and you understand their desire to take on new challenges.
• Anchor a sense of belonging. Publicly acknowledge individual and team accomplishments. Focus on the ripple effects of their contributions. This bolsters a sense of value and belonging.
• Understand that psychological safety and trust are the glue. Champion a workplace where staff feel comfortable sharing their opinions, voicing concerns, and asking for reasonable accommodation. This may require an ongoing conversation with administration and human resources to identify where flexibility is possible.
If you are to retain a resilient and talented staff, your leadership mandate becomes doing all you can to create and sustain a positive, healthy workplace that will support the staff’s new sense of self and promote further growth. Invite your staff to contribute by engaging them in your change management initiatives. Showcase their achievements at every opportunity. Ensure that every moment you recognize a staff member, it anchors that person’s sense of belonging.
Leadership is the most demanding path in any profession. Fortunately, your staff are now ready to share those challenges with you in a very new way.
—Phyllis S. Quinlan, PhD, RN, NPD-BC, has practiced nursing as a staff nurse, educator, nurse executive, and internal coach in a variety of clinical settings. Her full-service consulting firm, established in 1994, specializes in executive coaching, leadership development, and personal coaching. As a legal nurse consultant specializing in defense, she is a frequent keynote/plenary speaker, published author, and social media influencer on issues addressing nursing practice, nursing support staff, and risk management.