Tapping incoming or newly graduated OR nurses as champions and preceptors for initiatives works quite well, say some OR leaders. Though less experienced than their peers, these nurses bring to the table up-to-date knowledge, energy, a fresh set of eyes, and comfort with new technology. In turn, making them experts and giving them responsibility boosts their confidence, garners respect from colleagues, facilitates team building, and positions them for career advancement and leadership roles.
In 2015, the OR at Summa Akron City Hospital in Akron, Ohio, launched a catheter-associated urinary tract infection (CAUTI) competency initiative to address inconsistent catheter insertion techniques and to get staff up to speed on use of a new Foley catheter kit. The 490-bed facility is a Level 1 Trauma and Magnet-accredited hospital with 18 ORs where more than 15,800 surgical procedures are performed annually. Training consisted of an online educational session followed by a hands-on competency evaluation using simulation with a mannequin.
“We are busy and didn’t really have extra people. We have 75 RNs, and everyone had to go through this training in a 4-week period,“ says Valarie Grant, MSN, RN, CNOR, OR education coordinator and representative on the hospital’s CAUTI committee.
Her strategy was to tap three nurses who were transferring to the OR and going through orientation. They would be trained as CAUTI champions and would be part of a team conducting the hands-on competency evaluations. “These were med-surg nurses who had been in practice for 5 years or less. They came to us with no OR experience, so they went back to a novice level,” she explains.
Nurses in orientation have more flexible schedules than those of staff, and making them champions helps integrate them into the department. “It’s a bit of an icebreaker for everyone to get to know each other on a different level,” Grant says.
To prepare to be champions, the novice nurses underwent rigorous, comprehensive training on CAUTI prevention and evidence-based practice for catheter insertion technique. “I absolutely wanted to make sure their skills and their technique were perfect because they were extending that training to other nurses, so they had to be role models,” Grant says.
The training program included online education via HealthStream with a review of guidelines from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention as well as best practices for CAUTI reduction and Foley catheter insertion education, according to Grant. The RN champions then demonstrated the hands-on CAUTI and Foley insertion competency with the RN CAUTI trainer.
When it came to the hands-on sessions for the seasoned nurses, Grant helped the novice nurses overcome initial nervousness and anxiety by being present as much as possible and making introductions. She also helped the seasoned nurses get over some initial resistance by emphasizing the need for consistent, up-to-date technique and by noting the extra education and training the novices had completed.
The experienced nurses ultimately appreciated these novice nurse champions for taking on the responsibility. Feedback included comments such as, “It was a good idea to have our nurses in orientation do the education because there was no way we had extra staff that could have been available.”
Grant says using novice nurses as champions promoted team building and development of mutual respect. “It gave our novice nurses an opportunity to feel like they were really part of our department. Their comfort level improved, and they remain a support group to each other,” Grant says.
Weekly orientation meetings are ongoing and provide an opportunity to share the challenging experiences novice OR nurses face each day, Grant says. “We discuss the challenge of being that ‘expert nurse’ in their previous position and now being ‘the novice nurse’ in the OR,” Grant says. “The group of novice nurses who helped with the CAUTI initiative have since moved into staff roles but often recall their orientation meetings,” she says. “It’s not unusual for staff to ask if they can ‘come to the orientation meeting again.’
“After we had done all this work, we took it to the next level. I encouraged the novice nurses to apply for their clinical ladder, which our hospital uses to recognize department improvement projects that focus on evidence-based practice,” she says. “Our novice nurses attended an annual hospital-wide award luncheon with other leaders and me, where they were recognized for their achievements. So it was a win-win for everyone.” In addition, the team created a poster describing the initiative, which has been presented at professional meetings and is displayed in the OR hallway, giving the novice nurses something to be proud of.
Since serving as CAUTI champions, the novice nurses have taken on leadership roles in the OR, and are helping to develop competency initiatives of their own. For example, one is now a coordinator for the cardiothoracic service, and she and her team conducted a competency review with OR staff on sternal saw use.
“From my perspective, which is recruitment and retention of our nurses, the initial orientation—creating a sense of belonging, interaction, and integration into the department—is vital, and this project really facilitated that,” Grant says. “All of those nurses are still here and doing wonderfully. I’m delighted to see our novice nurses transition into a comfort level and develop expertise.”
As a part of its succession planning strategy for OR nursing, Sutter Medical Center in Sacramento, California, commonly uses its Sutter OR RN Training Periop 101 graduates to act as preceptors for students currently going through the program. This role helps reinforce the information they just learned. The graduates are also given some responsibilities aimed at cultivating leadership: helping to review policies, participating in selected calls that require surgical service participation, and representing the service at hospital meetings.
“Recently, we had a past Sutter Health OR RN Training Periop 101 program graduate represent the department in a hospital systemwide initiative. This empowered her by making her the department leader on this initiative,” says Renee Hildebrand (Dodge), MSN, RN, CNOR, RNFA, administrative director of surgical services.
“As another example, we needed a ‘fresh set of eyes’ on a new standardized procedure, and the new Sutter OR RN Training Periop 101 program graduate reviewed and edited the draft for input,” she adds.
“New OR RNs in your department can be your new process improvement ‘change masters.’ What have become comfortable workflows in your department may be seen from a different perspective with novice OR nurses,” Hildebrand says. She adds that nurses who have just finished orientation can often be very effective preceptors. “They can reference very recent ‘new nurse’ feelings, scenarios, and anxiety. Many times, these nurses can exhibit a different energy vibe and creativity level than what we are used to seeing.”
Millennials are more comfortable with some of the new technologies being used in the OR, Hildebrand notes. “This can actually be comforting to the tenured OR RN who may not be as comfortable with new technology,” she says. For example, a nurse new to the OR became a superuser when the hospital began using an electronic medical record. This superuser became a resource for the experienced nurses in the department and was quickly accepted by her peers.
“With new hires and new Periop 101 graduates, you can develop succession plans fairly quickly,” she notes. “Strengthening the new generation of OR nurses only strengthens surgical services long term. Building and developing leaders early in their careers builds depth in your department. Several of my Sutter Health OR RN Training Periop 101 program graduates have evolved into roles such as charge nurses, specialty service line coordinators, and members of specialized teams such as cardiac.”
Hildebrand believes there can be a paradigm shift from the orientee-preceptor dyad relationship to a trio consisting of orientee (new grad)-preceptor-mentor (reserved to an experienced tenured RN). A successful preceptor or mentor partnership helps less experienced OR nurses gain respect so they can work with their more experienced colleagues to improve OR processes, she says. “Capitalize on pairing the new grad/orientee with the right preceptor/mentor, and let them drive your change. It is a match made in heaven.” ✥
Agrell-Kann M. Improving quality outcomes using a champion model for ancillary nursing staff. J Contin Educ Nurs. 2015;46:539-541.
Grant V. CAUTI competency invades the operating room. Novice OR nurses to the rescue. Poster. OR Manager Conference. 2017.
Hildebrand R, Gardner Y. Leaving your legacy: Succession planning with you and your staff front of mind. OR Manager Conference. 2017.
Lane A J, Mitchell C G. Using a train-the-trainer model to prepare educators for simulation instruction. J Contin Educ Nurs. 2013;44:313-317.
Manoochehri H, Imani E, Atashzadeh-Shoorideh F, et al. Competence of novice nurses: Role of clinical work during studying. J Med Life. 2015;8(4):32-38.
Pellico L, Djukic M, Kovner C, et al. Moving on up, or out: Changing work needs of new RNs at different stages of their beginning nursing practice. OJIN: The Online Journal of Issues in Nursing. 2009;15(1).
Reicherter E A, Gordes K L, Glickman L B, et al. Creating disseminator champions for evidence-based practice in health professions education: An educational case report. Nurse Educ Today. 2013;33:751-756.
White C L. Nurse champions: A key role in bridging the gap between research and practice. J Emerg Nurs. 2011;37:386-387.
Woodfine P. Taking a novice nurse under your wing. Nursing. 2011;53-55.