Becoming a perioperative nurse generally does not require certification. However, expectations can change quickly for those hoping to climb the career ladder. For some, expectations are also changing for how knowledge and skills should be assessed. Rather than taking an exam, this subset of specialty nurses earn certification by submitting curated showcases of real-world work experience.
This has been the case only since October 2024, when the certified registered nurse first assistant (CRNFA) credential became the first—and to date, the only—portfolio-based nursing certification to earn accreditation from the Accreditation Board for Specialty Nursing Certification (ABSNC). In a period of prolonged staff shortages, this is a welcome development. It validates the role of the registered nurse first assistant (RNFA), and it opens new career path for prospects seeking a more hands-on role in surgical procedures.
Longer term, this success paves a well-defined, portfolio-specific pathway to accreditation for new credentials for other specialized groups of healthcare professionals. From anesthesia techs to perioperative supply chain specialists, these groups could enjoy the same advantages now anticipated for CRNFAs, including enhanced status and prestige for the profession; improved prospects for certification holders to advance up the clinical ladder; increased potential for employers to reimburse fees for the newly accredited certification; and increased attention from entities such as the Magnet Recognition Program from the American Nurses Credentialing Center (ANCC). More fundamentally, certification validates the necessary knowledge, skills, and experience for a specialized role with a high degree of certainty.
The CRNFA certification was created more than 30 years ago for RNs involved in handling tissue, suturing incisions, and otherwise assisting surgeons directly during procedures. However, the number of CRNFAs has always been relatively low—less than 2,000—and smaller certification programs have more difficulty staffing the volunteers required to keep exam questions accurate and up-to-date. Over time, an aging CRNFA volunteer pool compounded the problem. Eventually, declining numbers put accreditation status at risk. Added pressure from high fixed costs (such as test development costs) meant keeping the certification viable would require not just a new approach to assessment, but also an infusion of resources.
Enter the National Assistant at Surgery Certification (NASC), which purchased the CRNFA certification program in 2018. A year later, the for-profit organization’s board of directors decided to retire the examination—losing accreditation status in the meantime—and build toward a new accreditation application for CRNFA as a portfolio-based credential.
This transition was not entirely smooth. The first step, a foundational job analysis, followed the same rigorous workflow as any examination-based certification. From there, multiple committees of volunteers worked with contracted psychometricians to develop the assessment while ensuring strict adherence to scientific principles (sidebar, Psychometrics explained). Even after attracting a sufficient volume of applicants to substantiate an accreditation application, the organization worked with SeaCrest Consulting on documentation. The accreditation approval process itself also took several months.
Nonetheless, lower startup costs make portfolio-based assessments advantageous for smaller groups or subsets of larger specialties who desire their own certification. As proven by the success of CRNFA, earning accreditation from ABSNC—and perhaps the other principle accrediting body for nursing certifications, the National Commission for Certifying Agencies (NCCA)—is feasible even without a strong, well-established member organization, the support of which often underlies examination-based certifications.
Portfolio-based certification also has advantages for those who earn it. Securing approval for other nursing-related scoring rubrics can position other specialties to benefit in the same way as the latest crop of CRNFAs, whose assessment experience is markedly different from virtually all other certified nurses.
A portfolio is not merely a collection of documents and artifacts. A portfolio requires the nurse to reflect on their practice. The nurse must learn to produce a written narrative that details their clinical practice and expertise.
CRNFA certification allows for 3 months of this reflective practice before submitting a portfolio for scoring. Whether a portfolio passes or fails (sidebar, Objective scoring) depends on a detailed scoring rubric completed individually by two raters (and potentially a third tiebreaker). Portfolios consist of three primary components:
Each section is broken down into “activities,” which are presented as essay questions (109 total, some with multiple parts). Each activity is carefully calibrated to allow assessment of specialized knowledge, skills, understanding, and application of professional nursing practice and theory in the RNFA role, as identified by the initial psychometric job analysis commissioned by NASC. For example, Activity No. 4 of the intraoperative section of the clinical case study focuses on patient positioning. Describing a procedure-specific patient position in writing proves a certification candidate’s specialized knowledge. Describing positioning methods proves their skills, while providing a rationale for both the position and the methods demonstrates their understanding.
With implications for certification candidates and patients, requiring the nurse to actively engage in reflective learning is one of the most important factors differentiating portfolio and examination-based assessments. Patel and Metersky inform us that, “Reflective practice is a cognitive skill that demands conscious effort to look at a situation with an awareness of one’s own beliefs, values, and practice, enabling nurses to learn from experiences and incorporate that learning in improving patient care outcomes.”
Influential nursing theorist Patricia Benner touts reflective practice as an essential element of experiential learning. In her seminal work “Educating Nurses: A Call for Radical Transformation,” she and her co-authors explain that experiential learning “depends on an environment where feedback on performance is rich and the opportunities for articulating and reflecting on the experiences are deliberately planned.” Portfolio-based assessment facilitates this.
Portfolio-based certifications cost less to develop and maintain, but the resource commitment is significant nonetheless. Support infrastructure is also limited because the volume of these programs is miniscule compared to the volume of standardized examinations. Companies that can be contracted to perform foundational job analysis, question development, administering and scoring functions, and even consulting may be difficult to find. The pool of psychometricians with portfolio-based assessment experience is also limited.
For NASC, these were not the only challenges. The cessation of the CRNFA certification examination caused considerable angst among some stakeholders, including nurses who had previously earned the certification by taking an examination. Nonetheless, the organization pressed ahead, embodying Renaissance diplomat and historian Niccolo Machiavelli’s advice: “There is nothing more difficult to take in hand, more perilous to conduct, or more uncertain in its success, than to take the lead in the introduction of a new order of things. Because the innovator has for enemies all those who have done well under the old conditions, and lukewarm defenders in those who may do well under the new.”
Specific steps taken to transition the credential are as follows:
❶ Job analysis. Describing the functions, responsibilities, and the knowledge and skills underlying proficiency, this report is the foundation of any certification. Calls for volunteers to all active and emeritus CRNFAs provided a pool of subject matter experts (SMEs) to update materials underlying the previous examination-based assessment. From there, the organization contracted with Manny Straehle, PhD, president of Assessment Education and Research Experts (AERE), who provided a psychometrically validated Test Specifications document listing and categorizing specific task and knowledge statements that qualify a CRNFA. Following AERE training, SMEs curated a final list of 104 task statements and 97 knowledge statements divided into seven weighted knowledge domains.
❷ Portfolio development. The work of developing a portfolio-based, psychometrically sound assessment was guided by Judith Hale, PhD, CPT, CACP, CIDD, CDT, of Hale Associates, a performance improvement and credentialing specialist (and co-author of this article) with expertise in portfolios and competency assessment. A call for volunteers (active and emeritus CRNFAs and qualified CRNFA certification candidates) provided a pool for selecting three committees of SMEs to develop the initial portfolio documents, as outlined in the table below.
❸ Pilot, beta testing. The Peer Review Committee worked with Dr Hale to rank the importance of every task, assigning point values to questions based on the rankings and developing the scoring rubric. NASC then issued yet another call for volunteers to pilot test the portfolio and validate the scoring rubric, culminating in 22 RNFAs completing test portfolios. Feedback from testers resulted in several changes, including consolidating and rewording questions and adding instructions to the scoring rubric to help the raters. From there, the organization conducted a larger beta test, involving 38 more completed, volunteer test portfolios as well as additional volunteer raters.
❹ Standard setting. Another committee of SME volunteers, The Standard Setting Committee, met with Dr Hale on April 18, 2021, to review the Beta test results and set the passing score. Based on the results of psychometric analysis, Dr Hale recommended a passing score of 73%, a change from the 75% agreed to for the initial pilot test. After further discussion, the committee voted to set the passing score at 80%, with one chance to revise failed portfolios.
Additionally, NASC contracted with SeaCrest Consulting to develop and implement policies and procedures in alignment with third-party accreditation standards and for consultation in applying for and achieving ABSNC accreditation. NASC was able to not only pursue its goal to attain ABSNC accreditation, but also to ensure its policies are in alignment with best practice guidelines for professional certification programs.
Significant challenges aside, the pioneering work of NASC and their dedicated volunteers demonstrates the opportunity of portfolio-based nursing certification. Their experience provides a blueprint for the professional development of American nurses and healthcare workers who can benefit from a legitimate, viable alternative to examination-based certifications.
—James X Stobinski, PhD, RN, CNOR, CNAMB(E), CSSM(E), is a professor at Central Michigan University’s Health Administration Department and director of hospital and ASC relations at NIFA. He has more than 40 years of perioperative nursing experience. Julia Johnson, MS, is executive director at National Assistant at Surgery Certification (NASC) and former admissions counselor at NIFA.
About the CRNFA Professional Portfolio. National Assistant at Surgery Certification. November 20, 2024.
American Association of Critical Care Nurses (AACN). Certification benefits patients, employers and nurses. nd.
Machiavelli N. The Prince (G. Bull, Trans.). Penguin Classics. 2003. (Original work published 1532)
Straehle M. Job Analysis of National Assistant at Surgery Certification’s Certified Registered Nurse First Assistant (CRNFA). 2019.