October 21, 2020

Most OR nurse leaders find jobs rewarding despite COVID-19

By: Cynthia Saver, MS, RN
Share

Results from the 2020 annual OR Manager Salary/Career Survey show that despite the turbulent times, most OR leaders view their work favorably; 77% are satisfied with their jobs, with nearly a third describing themselves as “completely satisfied.” This might seem surprising in light of COVID-19, but many nurse leaders are well compensated and are meeting the challenges related to the pandemic.

Nearly a third (30%) of respondents say they earn $150,000 or more annually as a salary, up from 19% in 2019, and 17% report total compensation of $200,000 or more, compared to 11% who reported that amount last year.

Other highlights from the 2020 survey include:

• Nearly half (49%) of OR leaders expect to be retired by 2029, with 24% planning retirement by 2024.

• OR leaders supervise an average of 96 full-time equivalent (FTE) employees, down from last year’s 139.

• Nearly two-thirds (63%) of respondents manage an annual operating budget in the $2.5 million to $49.9 million range, comparable to last year’s 65%.

• The percentage of those identifying themselves as male was 22%, unchanged from 2019.

Here is a closer look at more of the findings related to OR leaders, including some comparisons with findings from the past decade.

Compensation

Overall, 78% of OR leaders earn an annual salary of $100,000 or more, with 30% earning $150,000 or more and 2% earning less than $60,000.

The most frequently reported total compensation range again was $120,000 to $149,999 (25% vs 24% in 2019), followed by $150,000 to $174,999 (18%). Only 7% reported an annual total compensation of less than $80,000.

More than two-thirds (68% vs 70% in 2019) had received a raise in the past 12 months, with an average of 3.3% (compared to 3.06% last year, 3.27% in 2018, and 3.5% in 2010). However, when deleting outliers (those 10% or higher), the average falls to 2.9%, slightly higher than the 2.3% increase in the consumer price index in 2019.

 

Responsibilities

Of the options provided, the most common job title was director (57%, compared to 37% in 2019 and 46% in 2018), followed by nurse manager (24% vs 30% in 2019), and administrator/administrative director (17% vs 14% in 2019).

In those roles, OR leaders supervise an average of 83 clinical employees and 63 nonclinical employees (compared to 102 clinical and 42 nonclinical employees in 2019). A total of 41% of respondents oversee 1 to 5 ORs, with 21% in charge of 6 to 10 and 15% responsible for 11 to 15.

In addition to the OR, more than half of OR leaders oversee the postanesthesia care unit (PACU, 73%), central sterile processing (70%), preoperative area (65%), outpatient/same-day surgery (60%), preadmission services (56%), and GI/endoscopy (55%). Interestingly, these are the same departments reported by more than 50% of OR managers in 2010, with the addition of anesthesia support personnel (57% in 2010 vs 48% in 2020).

After declines last year, percentages for PACU, central sterile processing, the preoperative area, outpatient/same-day surgery, GI/endoscopy, and preadmission services rebounded significantly.

Budget responsibilities decreased slightly from last year, with some 44% of respondents overseeing an operating budget of $4.9 million or less and nearly half (49%) in charge of a capital budget of $499,999 or less.

Satisfaction

Compared to 2019, more OR leaders are satisfied with their total compensation (60% vs 51%); nearly two-thirds (65%) are satisfied with their benefits, comparable to 61% from 2019. Most leaders are satisfied with both the top leadership of the organization (57%) and their own boss (67%). Job satisfaction has had longevity among OR leaders. For example, in 2015, 75% were satisfied with their jobs, and 65% were satisfied with their own boss.

OR leaders report big gains in staff, patient, and physician satisfaction. For example, the favorable rating for staff engagement increased from 51% in 2019 to 70% this year (vs 63% in 2015), and physician engagement rose from 49% to 65%. It seems possible that the teamwork required to respond to the pandemic may have boosted these percentages. Reported patient satisfaction with OR services rose from 77% last year to 85% this year, compared to 82% in 2015.

Top of mind

What is the one thing about your job that keeps you up at night? In all, 214 OR leaders answered that question. Staffing concerns were cited by 37% of respondents, and staffing popped up in some of the comments related to the COVID-19 pandemic. For example, having to furlough staff was the second most common worry. Other COVID-19 concerns related to supplies and testing.

Sample comments that many OR leaders could likely identify with include:

• “Staffing is the single biggest issue that I have the most problems resolving”

• “Lack of experienced staff”

• “Trying to make sure staff, including surgeons and anesthesia providers, are happy, which reverts back to patient satisfaction outcomes.”

Sample comments concerning COVID-19 include:

• “Having enough PPE [personal protective equipment] to cover for COVID-19”

• “COVID-19 testing availability/viability/etc”

• “A large COVID spike”

• “Ramping back up for the backlog of surgical cases after COVID-19”

• “How do I keep my patients and staff safe during the pandemic?”

• “How to recover from COVID-19…what pieces will we be picking up, and can we survive as a business?”

One person summed up many others’ concerns as: “With the ever-increasing amount of change, will [we] be able to keep up and continue to keep patients safe? Will caregivers stay engaged? Will they stay with us? Will they be able to step up during this crisis? Can we help them so that they don’t burn out?”

The third most common group of worries were related to regulation and patient safety. One respondent said: “regulations and never-ending pressure of litigation or fines for infractions.”

Other areas of concern include finance, volume, physicians, and equipment. Some expressed concerns for their own future, such as: “Will I have a job tomorrow in this changing climate?” and “How long can I keep this up?”

Not everyone worries; 16 OR leaders said nothing keeps them up at night.

Demographics and work life

The average age of the OR leaders who responded to the survey is 54, just a year more than the average age of 53 for nurses overall, according to the 2017 National Nursing Workforce Survey. Interestingly, the average age in 2010 was 53.

In all, 41% of OR leaders have a master’s degree as their highest level of education, compared to 47% last year.

Most master’s degrees are in nursing (26%). Only 3% of respondents hold a doctorate in nursing, and 45% report their highest level of education as a baccalaureate in nursing.

A total of 52% of respondents work in a community hospital vs 23% based at teaching hospitals. The South had the highest percentage of respondents (42%), followed by the West (25%), Midwest (22%), and Northeast (11%).

OR leaders are an experienced group, with 66% having more than 10 years of experience as a perioperative manager; nearly a quarter (23%) have 26 years or more experience. Of course, this also means that succession planning should be a top priority.

Finding time for succession planning could prove to be challenging because of work commitments. Overall, 41% of respondents work more than 50 hours a week, and another 32% log between 46 and 50 hours. Only 5% work 40 hours or less.

OR leaders’ compensation and satisfaction levels are higher, but that could easily change given the uncertainty associated with the COVID-19 pandemic. The next year will bring increasing challenges; fortunately, OR leaders are known for their ability to lead teams through difficulties.

Furthermore, many have a positive outlook. As one respondent noted: “I work at a great organization, and our department has resources to support our needs. I have been in a leader role for greater than 20 years. This organization is the best I’ve ever worked at, and I have the resources to be successful. I LOVE my job.” ✥

Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat