October 21, 2020

Editorial

By: Elizabeth Wood
Share

Surveys this past year seem to have proliferated, many of them related to the COVID-19 pandemic. What has worked? What hasn’t? What are the next steps?

Resuming surgical procedures after the springtime hiatus has helped regain some lost ground. Even as cases of the virus surged in many parts of the US this past summer, some hospitals continued to perform procedures because they had enough personal protective equipment (PPE) and ventilators, and well-established safety protocols. Some even performed their own tests for COVID-19.

Others, however, struggled to get supplies. Susan Bailey, MD, president of the American Medical Association, told Kaiser Health News in mid-August that she was concerned about long-term PPE shortages and the need for less dependence on foreign manufacturers. Although US production of medical supplies has ramped up, factories are not expected to be able to meet demand until mid-2021.

 

Parsing the data

The Kaufman Hall National Hospital Flash Report for August, based on data from more than 800 US hospitals, shows a 10% drop in outpatient revenue for January through August compared with the same period in 2019, and a 4% decline in inpatient revenue. The corresponding decrease in OR minutes (14% year to date), interestingly enough, was less than 1% below budget expectations, the report says. But the ongoing rise in per-patient expenses is concerning. Both total expense and labor expense per adjusted discharge are up 17% year to date.

Slightly different data are offered in Strata Decision’s National Patient and Procedure Volume Tracker, published in September. These data, culled from 58 StrataSphere™ health systems and 275 short-term, acute care hospitals from January 1, 2019, to September 5, 2020, find inpatient procedures are down 18.6% from 2019. Outpatient procedures have fared better, the report says, with many rebounding to higher than 2019 levels. However, orthopedics, spine, vascular, and general surgery continue to lag while cancer care, breast care, nephrology, and cardiology are recovering.

A smaller but focused analysis of surgical services paints a more promising picture. A recent survey of the OR Manager database, administered by InforMedix, sought data on facilities that had returned to normal or near normal surgical volumes. Among the 70 respondents, trauma surgery and transplants led the “near normal volume” pack, at 72% and 70%, respectively. Orthopedics came in third, at 63%, and several other service lines ranged from 45% and 62%. Only bariatric surgery was still quite low, at 34%.

What has changed compared to a year ago, or is most likely to change? Leading trends, this survey finds, are new ways of managing patient scheduling and flow, cited by 73% of respondents, new case scheduling practices (64%), and new cleaning and disinfection procedures (60%). Other ongoing or anticipated changes include more use of information technology and innovations, new staff assignments, and different types of supplies, devices, or equipment. Just 3% said they did not expect anything to be different in the second half of 2020.

The COVID-19-related upheaval in the supply chain is likely to continue over the long term. When asked how to ensure adequate supplies and lower risks in the future, 67% of InforMedix survey respondents said having backup supplies and stockpiles is most important. Others cited diversification of geographic location of supplies (39%) and vendors (59%). A total of 41% said it was important to prioritize US-based manufacturing over imports.

COVID-19-specific changes noted by survey respondents include more rigorous protocols for cleaning, PPE use, and safety; outreach efforts to persuade patients that the hospital environment is safe; revamped schedules and increased workloads to catch up on backlogs; and implementation of testing programs and policies. But many things actually haven’t changed—they’ve just become more important since the start of the pandemic.

When asked about how to return to normal in the coming year or two, InforMedix survey respondents offered comments like these:

• “Include the staff in the information gathering as well as the protocols that are established. Overcommunicate the protocols, the why, and the daily status of volume of patients you have in house and why. Ensure regular opportunities for staff to voice their concerns and gather information.”

• “The more you share with staff the things that are to be changed, the better. Come up with changes they can live with. Respect and care for your staff.”

• “[Have] a solid plan in place, and [train] staff to that plan, as well as interdisciplinary cooperation from surgeons, infection control, quality, lab, and surgery.”

• “Use this unique opportunity to reinvent your operations out of necessity; aim to come back stronger than you started.”

The annual OR Manager Salary/Career Survey results reflect some of the same concerns expressed by respondents to other surveys (cover). Although COVID-19 has created sometimes daunting challenges, it’s worth remembering that basic communication and collaboration are vital resources for withstanding any crisis and positioning patients and caregivers for a better future. ✥

 

References

Informedix Marketing Research, Inc. Surgery Management Monitor 2020. September 2020.

 

Kaiser Health News. PPE shortage could last years without strategic plan, experts warn. August 17, 2020. https://khn.org/news/ppe-shortage-could-last-years-without-strategic-plan-experts-warn/.

 

Kaufman Hall. National Hospital Flash Report. September 2020. https://flashreports.kaufmanhall.com/margin-september-2020.

 

Livingston S. Some hospitals choose to continue providing elective procedures. Modern Healthcare. July 10, 2020. https://www.modernhealthcare.com/hospital-systems/some-hospitals-choose-continue-providing-elective-procedures?utm_source=modern-healthcare-covid-19-coverage&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=20200712&utm_content=article3-readmore.

 

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat